We are once again in the hospital where Burns remembers who had shot him. "The one who shot me was.." He looks through the crowd of people when he sees the person who shot him. "Bart Simpson!" The crowd is shocked and all look at Bart. "What? You're honestly going to believe what this old coot says?" asks Bart before Quimby responds with "Yes." And handcuffs him but Marge tries to stop him, "What proof does he have? You can't just arrest someone without proof!" "Well ya see…" Quimby can't think of response to Marge and just lightly pushes her out of the way.

At the police station the Simpsons visit Bart and Lisa asks if he did it. "What? Are you really asking me that here?" "Wel-" before she can respond Bart snaps with "Since when where you apart of the police?!" he turns his back towards them and quietly says to himself "I can't believe it, my own sister is accusing me of attempted murder." He quickly turns around and asks both Homer and Marge if they believe he did it, both answer no which (with Homer at lest) surprises Bart. "See Lease, mom and dad believe me! Why don't you?" He said with a sadden face, "Bart I-I wanna believe you but…" "But what?" "I…" She turns from him and starts tearing up. "I-I-I don't know! I-I just can't put it right….I'm sorry." She hugs him and apologizes and starts crying.

A day later Lisa revisits the crime scene where she looks for anything to prove Bart's innocence but has a hard time finding anything since her last time there. She's about to give up but then notices a black glove in a bush she picks it up and takes it. "Well these can't prove Bart did it! Although they are small enough for a kid." She looks around some more and enters through the backdoor when she sees a security camera, "Of course the security cam footage! All I have to do is get the footage and see if Bart went through this door before Burns was shot!" She manages to find a security guard and she politely asks if she could see the security cam footage but the guard won't let her. "Please?" She says with a adorable expression on her face which melts the guard's heart and he takes her to the room where a bunch of monitors and a control board. "Alright don't do nothing funny to the tape or you'll be in the slammer!" He leaves saying that something important has come and Lisa goes to the footage of the night Burns was shot. "Ok, here's Burns leaving."She says to herself before she fast fowards the footage until she notices a small blurry figure moving towards the door. Lisa reverses it and sees her brother's spiky hair. "Oh. My. God…" She lets the footage continue and sees Bart throw a black glove in a trash can, she goes back to the door and opens the lid and after some digging she finds the other glove.

She goes to bed that night and dreams about what will happen if the evidence is found. She finds herself in a courtroom where the judge reviews the evidence and sentences Bart to the electric chair. "No! Please don't kill my big brother!" She cries out but it's too late Bart is dragged to the chair and Lisa sees him locked to it, she begs again but they don't pay attention and fry him. Lisa cries as she sees her brother's corpse sitting in the chair with smoke admitting from him, suddenly Burns appears and thanks her for providing the evidence that led to Bart's execution which she tries to deny but suddenly sees her grief stricken mother grabbing a gun and shoots her waking her up from the nightmare.

After breakfast Lisa goes to her room where she takes the baggy with the gloves she found in it and takes it to the Springfield tire fire where she throws it in destroying the evidence. "And now for the tape and Bart will be homefree!" Suddenly she hears Wiggum's voice and her heart starts pounding fearing he saw her destroy the evidence but Wiggum makes no mention of her tossing the evidence into the fire and seems like he didn't even see it. "Hey your brother is wanting to see you!" "Re-Really?" "Yeah. I guess he's wanting to talk to you." And so Lisa gets in the cop car which takes her to the police station where Bart smiles at her and kisses her on the cheek. "Hey Lisa, what have you been doing?" "Well nothing really, I-I want to apologize for no-" "I know Lisa, that's what you did the last time you were here. I forgive you, to be fair I'd doubt me too if I were you." She looks at him with a worried look and Bart reassures her that he's just joking. "I'm just glad you're here." He brushes her hair while she talks to him, "Bart I'm pretty sure there's no evidence that you did it and maybe we can all forget about this." He then motions for Lisa to listen as he whispers to her "I'm just going to give up and admit I did it." Lisa is shocked, "What? No! Don't do that please!" "Lisa it doesn't matter if there is any evidence proving me to be innocent or guilty, Burns won't stop until I'm dead or imprisoned." Lisa starts tearing up but Bart shushes her and hugs her as she tries to stop crying. "B-Bart I don't mean to be rude b-b-but when d-d-did you become so grown up?" "Awaiting trial for attempted murder can change a guy Lease." Eventually Lisa has to leave but before she kisses Bart on the cheek and is sent home.

Bart's trail is a hard time for The Simpsons, reporters harass the family almost all the time until a court order. Finally after weeks and weeks of hearings the jury finally made their decision, "Guilty." Marge and Lisa burst into tears as Bart is hauled away into a police car and sent to juvenile hall. They visit Bart in juvie whenever they can and Bart is always happy to see them even Homer. 3 months later Bart is released and Lisa hugs her brother when she got home from school with tears in her eyes, Bart would be more nice to his sister following his time in juvie but would occasionally prank her (which would be harmless), Homer is still employed by Burns due to the fact the old man keeps forgetting who he is, and Marge is as happy as she ever was with her special little guy home.