Disclaimer: I do not own Criminal Minds

A/N: Shout out to Hippichic81, OhSnapItsMadison, Chermayne for reviewing chapter 2. Also a huge thank you to Fashionista7 for those song suggestions.


Previously in chapter 2.

Spencer was sitting next to Alex, and they were both reading books when Alex looked at Morgan and JJ.

"Hey, what's wrong? For two people who made a big arrest, you look pretty unsettled." said Alex, causing Spencer to look at JJ and Morgan.

"Something was off about Wallace. The-the restaurant shooting was so chaotic and disorganized." said JJ.

"Yeah, it was. But when we arrested him... He was controlled. He was together." said Morgan.

"Well, Richard Farley was like that after his rampage." said Rossi.

"Yeah, so was Edward Tallaway." said Alex.

"Everyone has a different reaction to being caught. You guys did good." said Spencer.

At that moment Hotch's phone rang.

"Hotchner. Yes. I'm sorry? Thank you." said Hotch before hanging up and looking at his team. "We got the wrong guy."

"What?" asked JJ.

Spencer looked up behind him to look at Hotch.

"The fingerprints at the restaurant don't match." said Hotch.

"Hotch, how is that possible?" asked Morgan.

"Then Wallace must have an identical twin brother that we don't know about." said Spencer.

Hotch went to talk to the pilot and a few minutes later the jet turned around.


Spencer pulled out his cellphone and called Olivia, who answered on the second ring.

"I thought you're on your way home?" asked Olivia.

"Apparently our unsub has an identical twin, and now we have to fly back to Glendale." said Spencer.

Everything clicked in Olivia's mind.

"So the guy you guys arrested was the unsub's twin?" asked Olivia.

"Yes, but are you and dad going to be fine with me being gone a bit longer?" asked Spencer.

"Your dad and I will be fine with Piper, Albert, and Ava." said Olivia as Ava cooed.

"Are you feeding one of the twins right now?" asked Spencer.

"I'm nursing Ava, and she's aware that I am talking to you." said Olivia.

"Well, I will let you get back to feeding my little birdie." said Spencer.

"I love the nickname you have for Ava." said Olivia.

"Well, Ava does mean bird." said Spencer.

"I love you Spencer, and please stay safe." said Olivia.

"I love you too, and I promise to try to come home safe." said Spencer before hanging up.


Spencer was in an SUV with Hotch, Morgan, and JJ heading back to the police department as they listened to the press conference that Morgan was watching on his tablet.

"Let me say it again for the cheap seats. My client is innocent of these charges. He's been wrongfully arrested for crimes he did not commit. This is a case of the Glendale police department, and especially the FBI, jumping the gun." said Mark Anderson.

"Why?" said Mark

"Because profiling doesn't work, people. Racial profiling, behavioral profiling, whatever. When you rely on a set of assumptions instead of facts, you arrest the wrong people." said Mark Anderson.

Spencer entered the police station with his teammates and Sergeant Johnson approached them.

"You let him go?" asked Morgan.

"We didn't have a choice. He's a paralegal at a law firm. Jesse called the lead partner and within minutes the whole firm was here with employment records." said Sergeant Johnson.

Morgan's cellphone rang.

"Excuse us." said Morgan as he and everyone else walked into another room where he put the call on speaker, "Hey, make it good, mama. We are stuck on our own 20." said Morgan as a few teammates crossed their arms.

"I don't know if this is the penalty kick you need, but here's what I got Jesse Gentry. He was put up for adoption a smidge before he and his brother turned 3. His adoptive parents kept his first name, raised him in Phoenix, and he came to Glendale 5 years ago for work." said Garcia.

"Any contact between him, Wallace, and their mother?" asked JJ.

"Sort of-ellipses- and about a year ago he unsealed his adoption record." said Garcia.

"So, he knew he had a twin." said Rossi.

"He could have inserted himself into the investigation as a decoy to help his brother out." said Spencer as he wondered what type of mischief Albert and Ava would get into together in the future since they are pretty much close for three month old twins.

"Hold your handsome horses, boy wonder. His cell phone is clean, there's no credit card overlap. So just looking at the- pardon the dirty word-metadata, he hasn't had any contact with his family here." said Garcia.

"Go through all that work and not make contact? Come on." said JJ.

"At this point, everything's on the table. Dave and I will help coordinate the manhunt for Wallace. Reid, you and Blake talk to Carla Hines. She was the last person to see her son. JJ, you and Morgan keep tabs on Jesse. Even though he wasn't part of the original investigation, he is now." said Hotch.

Sergeant Johnson entered the room.

"Agent Hotchner, his lawyer wants to talk." said Sergeant Johnson.

Hotch came back into the room a few minutes later and looked at his team.

"We might as well go to the hotel and catch a few hours of sleep before we get to work." said Hotch.


Alex pulled up at Carla Hines house, and she and Spencer got out of the SUV.

"I'm just saying it's the kind of mistake that can end careers." said Alex.

"So Hotch doesn't get the section chief job." said Spencer.

"Spencer, Jesse Gentry is threatening a multi-million-dollar lawsuit against the Bureau. It's not just Hotch, it could be all of us." said Alex before recognizing the car that Wallace was driving, "That's the car Wallace stole from the shootout."

Spencer pulled out his cellphone.

"This is SSA Spencer Reid, requesting backup at 505 Palmetto Street." said Spencer into his phone as he and Alex sprinted towards the house before pulling out his revolver.

"FBI! Carla Hines! Anybody home?" shouted Alex.

Alex looked at Spencer before she opened the door, and she and Spencer started clearing the house.

As soon as Spencer cleared the upstairs, he shouted to Alex.

"Clear!" shouted Spencer.

"Clear." said Alex.

A few minutes later Spencer was donning his latex free gloves when he met up with Alex in the living room.

"Jewelry's still in the bedroom. This wasn't a robbery." said Spencer.

"Maybe Wallace or Jesse came for their mother." said Alex.

"Maybe, but if either twin did this, they'd have a lot of questions. Whoever did this was trying to hide something." said Spencer as he crouched down by the fireplace.

"Carla?" asked Alex.

"Let's see." said Spencer as he pulled out burnt papers. "It looks like documents from the delivery. Pages from a baby book." said Spencer as he thought about the documents he and Olivia have on Piper, Albert, and Ava.

"Things a mother would keep." said Alex.

"And destroy if she had to. All the evidence of a 30-year secret." said Spencer.

"Except we know about the twins. They know about each other. What's left for her to hide?" asked Alex.


Spencer pulled out another document out of the fireplace and read it the best he could as he headed over to Alex.

"She also tried to destroy a birth certificate." said Spencer as he laid it down on a table that he laid other documents he found.

"It still looks like mom was trying to burn everything that mentioned Jesse, right?" asked Alex.

"Mm-hmm. Based on what I'm salvaging." said Spencer.

Alex walked over to him.

"Then why didn't she burn the APGAR scores?" asked Alex as she passed the document to Spencer.

"This identifies both twins by name. How did she miss this?" asked Spencer.

"She didn't. She burned other sections of the box." said Alex.

"So this isn't about Jesse at all. She's trying to hide something else." said Spencer as he and Alex glanced at the burnt documents.

"If we work deductively based on what survived and eliminate from that, we know her hospital, her O. B., even what drugs she took. But not who the father is." asked Alex.

"So who's dad?" asked Spencer.


Spencer and JJ were at the crime scene, and a crime scene tech was taking a picture of the body.

"Wallace's M. O.-the rape, the bullet through the heart. He even tried to pose her." said Spencer.

"He didn't try to force-feed her, which is his signature. And this crime scene..." said JJ.

"Organized, skilled, got in and out without detection." said Spencer.

"Exactly. If Wallace is losing it, he wouldn't be capable of this." said JJ.

"Maybe he re-evolved." said Spencer.

"Or we have a copycat who's a literal copy." said JJ.

"Jesse? But why start now? Why this victim?" asked Spencer.

A few minutes later Spencer and JJ were in the room where Morgan was interviewing Mr. Randall.

"Yeah. How did you know?" asked Mr. Randall.

"It was Jesse." said Morgan as he looked at Spencer and JJ.


Spencer, Hotch, and Morgan were conferencing in with Garcia.

"So, that super helpful law firm gave me some curious Intel regarding Jesse and his mom." said Garcia.

"How far back does the relationship go?" asked Hotch.

"According to some legally binding documents, 3 months. See, Carla was doing a little planning for the future and she utilized said law firm to set up a trust, with two trustees. Can you guess their names? Can you?" asked Garcia.

"Wallace and Jesse?" asked Spencer.

"Wrong. Well, half wrong. Jesse is named, but the other mysterious trustee is Bill Robbins." said Garcia.

"And who's that, mama?" asked Morgan.

"Mm-hmm. You haven't heard that name yet, have you? Bill Robbins went to college with Carla 30 years ago." said Garcia.

"Thanks, baby girl." said Morgan.

"Mm-hmm." said Garcia before Morgan hung up.

"30 years ago is when she conceived the twins. Bill Robbins must be the father." said Morgan.

"And this trust is why she burned any mention of him. If we found out who Bill Robbins was, we find the paper trail that connected Carla to Jesse." said Spencer.

"Not to mention that he could know where Wallace and Jesse are." said Morgan.

"All right, you two talk to Bill Robbins. I'm going to have another shot at the lawyer. It he's representing the whole family, he knows more than he's telling us." said Hotch before he, Morgan, and Spencer split up.


Spencer and Morgan walked through the apartment building, and heard a baby crying and a dog barking before Morgan knocked on the door and Bill Robbins opened it.

"How you doing? FBI. We're looking for a Mr. Bill Robbins." said Morgan.

"The sun and the moon have arrived. I'm ready to join you in your golden chariot." said Bill.

"We'd like to ask you a few questions, if you have a moment." said Spencer.

"Yes. Yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes!" said Bill as he closed the door to unlock the security chain before letting Spencer and Morgan in, "My life is the answer to your questions. Come in. Come in. Uh, sit." said Bill as he led Spencer and Morgan inside.

"Full-scale psychotic break when he turned 25, right after Jesse was put up for adoption." said Spencer quietly.

"Well, no wonder his sons turned out the way they did." said Morgan as he closed the door.

"Schizophrenics are rarely psychopathic. If the twins are predisposed genetically to kill, they didn't get it from their father." said Spencer.

Bill came into the room with a chair.

"Where are my manners? Have a seat. Have a seat." said Bill as he sat down.

Spencer sat on the bed while Morgan stayed standing.

Bill decided to point out his artwork.

"Do you like my artwork?" asked Bill.

Spencer took a look and realized what Bill used for his artwork.

"Yeah, I do. Is that your feces?" asked Spencer.

"Maybe." said Bill.

Spencer gave Bill a wary smile, while he realized that he was glad he had his mother institutionalized since she has the supervision she needs.

As Morgan talked to everyone else, Spencer stayed with Bill.

"You have to understand, eggs are the devil's cholesterol." said Bill.

Spencer nodded as Morgan looked back at him.

"It's hit or miss." said Morgan before speaking again after hearing Hotch and Rossi talk to him. "We'll do what we can, but we might need a plan B." said Morgan before he hung up and approached Spencer and Bill.

"Mr. Robbins, have you seen your sons lately?" asked Morgan.

"Yes, Wallace and Jesse. Wallace is the older one. He's teachable. I can teach him things. But Jesse looks more like me." said Bill.

"When was the last time that you saw them?" asked Morgan.

"Not long ago. One was potty-trained, but the other wasn't." said Bill.

Morgan looked at Spencer.

"They were toddlers." said Morgan.

"And they were crying because Carla was crying. And a magical woman took Jesse away." said Bill.

Spencer looked at Morgan.

"He's describing the adoption." whispered Spencer.

"She was a Saint, letting her son die like that." said Bill.

"Who do you mean? You mean Carla?" asked Morgan.

"No, no, no, no, no, no, no. Not her. The woman that took Jesse away. She was a Saint. She made the ultimate sacrifice. She let her son die." said Bill.

"I know who he's talking about." said Morgan as he looked at Spencer.

A few minutes later Spencer and Morgan were driving back to the station, and they called the others.

"St. Mary's. The church St. Mary's?" asked Rossi.

"We think that's what the dad was describing to us." said Spencer.

"Yeah, JJ and I dug it up when we were researching Jesse. It's the church he was adopted through." said Morgan.

"It's also how Carla would see herself, as the most revered mother of all time." said Rossi.

"Have Sergeant Johnson notify SWAT." said Hotch.


JJ looked at Spencer.

"Did you let Olivia that your on your way home?" asked JJ.

"I've decided to surprise them." said Spencer as he pulled out a book from his messenger bag and started reading it.

A few minutes later Hotch and Rossi approached Spencer, Alex, Morgan, and JJ.

"My name got withdrawn from the list, so I am still your unit chief." said Hotch

Everyone smiled in relief since they didn't want to lose Hotch as their Unit Chief, and Spencer looked at his teammates and thought about the concerned looks he received all day.

"I know that you guys were concerned about me during this case since it has been been a bit personal for me in some ways when it came to being a parent of twins, and having a schizophrenic parent." said Spencer.

"But you didn't end up like your mom, and you and Olivia are no way like Carla and Bill." said Morgan.

"I know, but the only genes that I passed down to my kids are the higher chance of twins since multiples run in my mom's side of the family, Asperger's syndrome, and the chances of my kids being a genius like me." said Spencer.

"Piper is already a genius like her father." said Rossi.

"And Albert and Ava are pretty much ahead of schedule with their milestones." said Spencer before he flashed back to a prior case, causing him to grin.

"What's with the grin?" asked Hotch.

"I am thinking about getting Ava a onesie that says 'Evil Twin' and Albert a onesie that says 'Eviler Twin." said Spencer with a huge grin on his face.

"Now why does your wording seem familiar?" asked Morgan.

"I had to think of a creative way to tell you guys I told you so based on my evil twin and eviler twin theory that I made during the Angel Maker case back in 2008." grinned Spencer.

Hotch, Rossi, JJ, and Morgan burst out laughing when they realized that Spencer finally found proof of an evil twin and its eviler twin while working on a case.

Alex looked at Spencer, confused.

"It was when Emily was back on the team, and everyone thought I was crazy when I mentioned my evil twin and eviler twin theory." said Spencer.

A few minutes later Spencer looked at his teammates.

"Livy and I were talking about having a date night since we haven't had one since our belated Valentines Day celebration." said Spencer.

"That long?" asked a bewildered Morgan.

"Olivia and I have been very busy, and we were also talking about my dad getting a night off too." said Spencer.

"So you guys are going to be needing some sitters." said JJ.

"Yes." said Spencer.

Alex, JJ, Morgan, Hotch, and Rossi were all chiming in that they would be glad to babysit.

"Piper, Albert, and Ava are going to need more than one sitter." said Spencer.

"How about Will and I babysit the kids, and Henry would have fun playing with Piper." said JJ.

"What about Savannah and me since I am the twins godfather?" asked Morgan.

"Well I am Piper's godmother." said JJ.

"I'm Piper's godfather." said Hotch.

Spencer groaned, realizing that he would have to deal with his teammates arguing about who gets to babysit the kids, but at that moment his cellphone rang and he grinned when he saw it was his uncle Gordon.

"Hi, uncle Gordon." said Spencer.

"Ethel and I are bringing your mom to DC this weekend so Diana can see her grandchildren while Ethel and I get to spend time with our great nieces and nephew." said Gordon.

Spencer grinned at the thought of his aunt and uncle being babysitters.

"I guess you helped solved a problem that I have been dealing with." said Spencer as he smirked at his teammates.

"What's the problem your dealing with Spencer?" asked Gordon.

"Olivia and I were talking about having a much needed date night, and my teammates are arguing about who gets to babysit the kids so dad could have a night off, and I think that Piper, Albert, and Ava would love to spend time with their great uncle Gordon." said Spencer as he watched his teammates jaws drop.

"You want Ethel, your mom, and I to babysit the kids?" asked Gordon.

"Exactly. So when are you guys arriving?" asked Spencer.

"This Friday, and Dr. Norman gave Ethel and I the all clear to take Diana to DC." said Gordon.

"I guess I will see you, mom, and Aunt Ethel on Friday then." said Spencer before exchanging goodbyes with his uncle and hanging up.

"You are evil." said Morgan.

"Well I can be an evil genius when I want to be." smirked Spencer.


Spencer quietly entered the master bedroom and smiled when he saw his wife sleeping as he quietly crept towards the bathroom when Olivia opened her eyes and smiled when she realized that her husband was home. She turned on the lamp.

"I thought that you would be home tonight since I heard that the BAU is currently trending on Twitter." said Olivia.

"Well I am about to take a quick shower before joining you in bed, and I have today off." said Spencer.

"How about a bubble bath." said Olivia as she started to get out of bed.

"You're planning on joining me?" asked a smirking Spencer.

"Yes, and I was just up with Albert 30 minutes ago." said Olivia.


A few hours later Spencer entered Piper's nursery while his dad and Olivia tended to the twins, and he smiled at the sight of his still sleeping daughter before he stroked Piper's cheek causing her to open her eyes and she grinned when she realized that it was her daddy waking her up, causing her to quickly scramble to her feet.

"Daddy home." said Piper.

"Yes I'm home, and I get to play all day with you, your brother, and your sister." said Spencer as he lifted Piper out of her crib and groaned, "What has mommy been feeding you when I was gone?"

"Food." giggled Piper.

20 minutes later Spencer, Olivia, William, and Piper were eating breakfast as Albert and Ava were sitting in their baby seats, babbling to each other as the adults talked about upcoming weekend plans.