MBAV Fanfic

True Identity

A/N: I do not own My Babysitter's a Vampire… or any references to games, shows, books, songs, etc. However, I do own my character, Casey. Please Read and Review.

Casey's POV

"Good, she's gone, I can finally do this and not get my head bit off" I say as I grab Benny's collar and pull him on top of me. I see his eyes widen before I wrap my arms around his neck and push my lips onto his. I feel his tongue brush my lower lip. Soon our tongues are in an epic battle and I'm running my fingers through his brown hair.

I smile to myself as he lifts himself up some. He looks down at me with a big, dorky grin. I laugh as he pushes himself up to a seated position, because I can see Sarah's face. It's a mix of shock and horror.

"Sarah, don't give me that look. I know you wish that was you and Ethan." I say with a snicker

She and Ethan both painfully blush. Score! Benny and I laugh at this. To think we still have an hour.

Sarah's POV

Casey is so right. I just realized, I'm probably as red as a tomato.

"Let's play truth or dare" suggests Benny with an evil smirk.

Oh lord, save me.

I go first. "Casey truth or dare," I ask her as Ethan turns on the radio.

"Dare please" she says happily.

Taylor Swift's, 'You Belong With Me' comes on the radio. "Sing along with this" I say.

"I'm not the greatest singer, but okay" she says as she stands up. She begins to sing.

We're all gaping by the time she's done. She had put on a whole performance for us. She had one of the prettiest voices I've ever heard! Benny's eyes seem almost glazed over as he stares into space. I wave a hand in front of his face. Nothing. Casey plops down onto his lap. Wrapping her arms around his neck, she kisses his cheek delicately.

Benny shakes his head, causing his messy brown hair to flip back and forth. He turns and looks at Casey. "You're an amazing singer" he tells her as he lays his hands lightly on her hips.

We all nod in agreement. She blushes and giggles. "Thanks" she says with a smile. Turning back to Benny she says "It's your turn to ask someone."

He nods, "Sarah, truth or dare?"

Crap. I'm screwed either way. "Truth..." I say nervously.

"Describe the boy that you currently like" he says with a devious smile.

Casey's POV

Sarah is freaking out. Still, she begins slowly. "Brown hair, brown eyes, taller than me..." she pauses for a moment, "has an adorable smile; I can't help but feel alive around him..." she trails off.

Before the awkwardness can set in, I pipe up, "Ethan, truth or dare?"

"Well Benny always tells me to be more daring..." he shoots Benny daggers, "so dare."

"Text the girl that you love, the following: The sun shines and you sizzle. The moon beams and you shine. I'll love you forever, and with you, that's a long time."

I watch as Ethan types what I said. He sighs. He's about to press send when Sarah sniffles. "Excuse me for a moment" she says quietly. She gets up and heads to the kitchen.

Ethan gets up and follows her.

Ethan's POV

I walk into the kitchen. Sarah is sobbing. I walk over to her slowly. She looks up, "I hate this vampire thing... no one can love a cold blooded, blood-sucker of the night... I'm stupid to think that someone possibly could." Tears run down her cheeks. "I just want to be somewhat normal. I am never going to have a family; I am never going to have a love life, period. I have always dreamt of living 'happily ever after'. But that's never going to happen now… I'm a freak!" She pulls herself together somewhat and says to me, "I'm sorry that you had to hear all of this Ethan..." she turns away from me as more tears threaten to break.

I look down at my phone. Should I send it? I have to, it was a dare. I sigh as I press send and slide my phone back in my pocket. My life is about to be ruined forever.

I hear Sarah mumble to herself "Benny and Casey are happy, why can't I be happy with someone special...?"

All of a sudden her phone vibrates. She checks to see who it is. Looking up at me she says, "Ethan, we're a foot away, you could've told me whatever it was in person." She smiles at me. I can see the tear stains that run down her cheeks.

Opening the message her smile becomes shock. I take in a breath anticipating what she's going to say.

"Do you really mean that?" asks Sarah as she stands up from her chair. I blush, nodding my head. Her eyes lock on mine she says to me "I could say that I don't feel the same about you, but I would be lying." As she finishes, I find that she has pressed herself up against my chest. I smile as I realize that she has wrapped her hands in mine. Our faces are only a few inches apart at the moment. Of course, this is until our lips actually meet. I feel as if I'm in heaven.

"It's about time!"

We break apart abruptly. Blushing, we both are looking at our feet.

"Benny! You just ruined their moment" I hear Casey exclaim as she appears in the doorway. "Leave them be" she says to him sweetly as she runs her hand down his arm and grasps his hand when she reaches it. She drags him off.

I turn back to Sarah. "So are we like boyfriend and girlfriend now?" I ask her cautiously.

"I haven't been asked anything of the sort" she states with a playful smirk on her face.

I look her straight in the eye. "Sarah, will you be my girlfriend?"

She nods. Once again we find ourselves kissing. Thank you Lord for answering my prayers!

Casey's POV

Well perfect timing for Sarah and Ethan to walk in. Not. My shorts are pulled down slightly; nothing is showing, but still! Benny's hands are up my shirt and my hair is a mess. Benny's hair is even messier than normal. His striped polo is unbuttoned and the collar... I don't know what exactly happened to it. All the while, are tongues are being very inquisitive and exploring each others' mouths. We break apart because we hear Sarah gasp.

"Intense canoodling?" a smirking Ethan asks Benny as 'Baby I Like It' by Enrique Iglesias comes on the radio.

I start laughing at the irony of the situation. Continuing to laugh I point to Ethan's ruffled hair and crooked shirt, "You two love birds aren't that innocent either."

"Touché" says Sarah as she straightens Ethan's hair and shirt; Ethan blushing all the while.

"Ethan will you grab my bag right there?" I ask pointing to a small blue purse with a purple peace sign on it.

He grabs it and hands me it, accidently touching my hand in the process, sending him into a vision. I grab a brush out of my purse and brush my hair out quickly. I stand up straightening my clothes. Ethan is out of his vision and before he can say anything I say "I got to go. See you later." I kiss Benny on the cheek and hurry out the door. I am so screwed tomorrow...

Benny' POV

Best night of my freaking life! However, these lovely thoughts are cut short by Sarah asking what Ethan had seen in his vision.

"I'm not positive, to be honest" says Ethan, flustered. "I think she was… but that's impossible…"

"What" Sarah asks Ethan somewhat agitated.

"Casey is hiding something from all of us. The way she is now is not her true identity" Ethan tries to explain.

A/N: I hope you guys liked it. A little longer than the first two chapters. Again, please, R&R.

Thanks :)