I'm a little sad that only two people have reviewed my fanfiction, but it's to be expected since it's my first fanfiction… Thank you to those people (and you know who you are!)

DISCLAIMER: I don't own any part of this story except for Nyako Hima and Shimo Hikari.

Chapter 3: Another New Face

Previously on Thief in Ouran:

"Yo, how's it going?" Nyako looked at the boy who just walked in and her face fell.

"You…"

End re-cap


The Host club members all looked at the stranger looming on the doorway. It was a boy who looked tall and lean. He was wearing a backwards baseball cap, a grey hooded sweatshirt, and baggy jeans. The mysterious person smirked.

"I haven't seen you in a long time… Nyako-chan…"

Nyako looked annoyed. She sighed. "Hello… Shimo…"

Kyouya cleared his throat. "Do you know this person?"

"Yeah, he was my ex-boyfriend…"

This brought gasps from every Host club member except for Kyouya. Kyouya was cool and composed. He coughed. "So," Kyouya said. "What are you doing here?"

Shimo smiled an evil smile. "I'm transferring here starting tomorrow."

"WHAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAT?!?" yelled everybody except for Kyouya and Shimo.

Nyako cursed under her breath. "Of all the luck…" She sighed. Shimo walked over to the Host Club and chuckled.

"There's no need to sound so surprised Host Club, after all I'm joining the Host Club starting today too!" More gasps were heard from everyone (except for Kyouya). Kyouya sighed deeply and glared at Tamaki.

"In case you've forgotten, I told you this morning during class that we were getting a new host…" Tamaki looked thoughtful for a moment or two…


Flashback:

The blond king of the Host Club was currently engaging in a conversation with some fellow male students about the soccer game that had apparently aired last night. Kyouya walks on over and whispers in Tamaki's ear. "We're getting a new host today and his name is Shimo Hikari. He's a scholarship student."

Tamaki shrugs the Ootori prodigy off. "Yeah, yeah, whatever…"

End Flashback


Tamaki grimaced at the memory. "Oops, hehe, sorry Kyouya, it must've slipped my mind…" Every Host Club member (including Nyako) glared at him. Nyako put on a false smile and walked over to Shimo, eyebrow twitching the entire time.

"So, why are you here in Ouran?" Shimo smiled and laughed maniacally.

"Why to ask us to make up! It was silly of me to cheat on you and laugh at you and pull your hair and… Well, the list goes on and on!" The rest of the Host Club members' sweatdropped while looking at Nyako, who was currently getting more and more pissed by the second. Hikaru and Kaoru shake their heads.

"So, since you're here on scholarship, what's your special talent?"

"Why, that's a brilliant question, Sherlock! Quite frankly I'm here for my skills in sports, dumbass!"

Hikaru looked like he was about to rip Shimo's bloody head off.

Hunny looked questioningly at Shimo "But, why would you choose to join the Host Club when you're so good at sports? I'm sure a lot of sport clubs would want you if you were really that good."

Nyako sighed and glared at Shimo. "The thing is... He IS that good... I too, wonder why he chose to join the Host Club. Except…" Nyako glanced at Shimo who was currently looking at her in an evil way. "… I think I know why…"

"I joined the Host Club, because I heard you joined this club! But as to why you joined this club I can't imagine as you're not a boy (except in personality)." replied Shimo, who grinned like the Cheshire cat from Alice in Wonderland. Everyone looked at him and thought to themselves, great, another weirdo, and this one's a stalker!


The next day in the first years' class, the teacher clapped his hands and cleared his throat. "Class, today we have another new student joining us! His name is Shimo Hikari and he came here on a sports scholarship! Let's make him feel welcome! Why don't you say a few words Hikari-Kun!" Nyako, Haruhi, and the twins each exchanged glances with each other. They all looked dejectedly up at the front of the class.

"Hello there, my name is Shimo Hikari and I'm here on a sports scholarship as you all know. I may not know a lot so please bear with me," Shimo winked at the girls during this part. Almost all the females in the class swooned. Shimo cleared his throat and continued. "… And I hope we'll have a fun year together!" Everyone clapped (except for Nyako, Haruhi, and the twins, of course!) and some even whistled. When Shimo went to his seat he blew a few kisses to several girls and they swooned. Shimo sat in front of Nyako and winked at her. Nyako grimaced in return. Meanwhile, a lot of the boys in the class walked up to Shimo and began to talk to him about sports. Nyako sighed. Five minutes into class and already Shimo was an idol, just like at their old school… She stared at the window with a melancholy look on her face, while Haruhi gloomily buried her face into her book. This was going to be a long day…


All day long, Shimo was followed around by either a group of girls or a group of boys. Nyako and Haruhi felt annoyed about this, because the two of them shared almost every class with him which meant the followers were EVERYWHERE. At the end of the day the threesome met up with Hikaru and Kaoru and ran to the Host Club. Today, the Host Club was open for once. The five students walked in to find the Host Club getting ready for their gig. "Ah," Tamaki said after he saw them "It's almost time for the customers to come so all you guys should get dressed, except for Nyako."

"Hai!" They all scattered to the changing rooms while Nyako sat down on a couch near Kyouya. Nyako looked up at Kyouya questioningly.

"Aren't you going to change into today's costume?" Kyouya looked up at the time.

"Yeah… Might as well go change now…" Kyouya closed his laptop and walked to the changing rooms with his laptop under his arm.

"…Stupid…" murmured Nyako.


A group of girls were swarming the door to enter the third music room. A melodious group of voices called out to them. "Enter beautiful maidens…" When the girls entered they were in an Artic paradise. The music room was changed into a snowy place with even a few live penguins here and there. The Host Club members were dressed in Eskimo outfits.

A few minutes later, Tamaki was entertaining a customer. "Tamaki, aren't you chilly?"

"I was, but then your presence melted all the cold away from my cold heart, my beautiful hime…" Giggles and swoons were heard.

Nyako grimaced while watching this.

In another corner of the room the Twins were doing their brotherly love routine. "Hikaru, Kaoru, are we allowed to play with the penguins? They're so cute!"

Hikaru smiled "Of course, but they're not as cute as someone else I know…" Kaoru gasped.

"Are you cheating on me, Hikaru Hitachiin?!?" Hikaru smiled a sly smile. He embraced his brother and held him close.

"Hush, that person is you, Kaoru. No need for jealousy…" The girls all screamed in bliss.

Nyako watched this intently too and felt like puking.

In another part of the room Mori was watching as Hunny laughed and giggled while playing with the penguins. Their fans watched and screamed "KAWAII!!!"

Nyako smiled a little bit.

Close by, Shimo was entertaining girls with his different animal impressions. The girls all laughed.

Nyako groaned.

Haruhi was entertaining customers by saying what came naturally to her. They all swooned.

Nyako chuckled. If only they knew their Fujioka Haruhi was actually a girl! Kyouya walked casually over to her. "I take it you think this is all very strange isn't it? After all, this is the first time you've ever seen our club in action." Nyako grinned.

"Actually, this is my second time." Kyouya eyed her suspiciously. All of a sudden, a snap and crack were heard. The lights went out and all the customers screamed. They ran to the door only to find the door was locked. All of a sudden, one spotlight was turned on and there was a figure with a clown mask, black sweatshirt, black cargo pants, and black shoes (but those were required at Ouran, sooooo… No dif.). The person laughed.

"Hello, Host Club. Prepare for your doom! NYAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!"

Everyone gasped.


Ooh! Another cliffy! This chapter was a bit longer than usual, because I haven't updated in a while (Thanks to homework, projects, tests, and yada yada yada…) I hope it was worth the wait!