She was in the TARDIS, but it was dark. There was just a small dim light coming from a room down the hall. Amy walked to the room and opened the door. Inside sat Rory crying. He was crying over an empty cradle where a baby should be fast asleep, but the cradle was empty. There was no baby. There was no sign of a baby. There was only Amy, an empty cradle, and a crying Rory.
"Rory, what's wrong?" Amy asked.
"You should have kept it. We could have raised it together. You thought you'd be on your own, but you wrong. You were wrong Amy! YOU WOULD HAVE HAD ME!" Rory yelled.
"I'm sorry. I'm so sorry. We were young. I wasn't thinking," Amy cried. "I know now that I would have had you, but I didn't think about it then. I'm sorry!" She was sobbing now, and she couldn't stop.
"How can you expect me to love you when you just sat there and pretended like I didn't even exist back then? You treated me like nothing. Why would love you?"
"Rory, don't leave me. Don't leave. Come back," Amy sobbed as Rory left her alone with the haunting cradle.
Amy woke up in a cold sweat. She had just had the worst nightmare of her entire life. She kept trying to tell herself that Rory did love her and would never leave her, but it was hard. The nightmare felt so real that she thought that it was. Amy needed to hear this from Rory.
"Rory, wake up. I need you," Amy said as she shook Rory awake. "Wake up. It's important. I need you to tell me something."
"What do you need me to tell you?" Rory asked as he sat up in bed. "What is it?"
"I need you to tell me that if I had kept the baby that we'd still be together. I thought that we wouldn't, but I need to hear what you think. Tell me that you'd never leave me and that I'll never be on my own," Amy said as she cried quietly. Rory took her in his arms. He assumed that she had had a nightmare because nothing else could have caused this kind of distress for her at a time like this.
"Amelia Williams, I promise that I'll never leave you for anything. We'll be together forever. You'll never be on your own and by yourself," Rory said.
"And…"
"And if you had kept it, I would still love you and would still be your husband because I have and always will love you. I promise. And nothing will ever change that. I love you," Rory said as he placed a kiss on Amy's cheek.
"I love you too."
"Now get some sleep. I don't think you've had much lately. Am I right?" Rory asked.
"You are. I'll try to go back to sleep. It's going to take a while for my mind to calm down," Amy said.
"Then I'll stay awake until you go to sleep, so you won't be awake all by yourself. Sound good?"
But Amy didn't answer. Rory looked over to see that she'd somehow managed to fall asleep that quickly. It amazed Rory that she'd done that. Usually it takes her at least an hour to go back to sleep after a nightmare, but this wasn't any ordinary nightmare. It was a horrifying idea that had built up in Amy's mind for many years but had finally been squashed by Rory's love of his beautiful wife, Amy.