Disclaimer:

I do not own Pretty Little Liars

Chapter 3

For the next week or so, Hanna, Alison and Spencer grew a lot closer. They hung out numerous times, and even though they only knew each other for a week, they felt like sisters.

So, one day they were all sitting in Alison's apartment, Alison was painting Hanna's toes a vibrant red color and Spencer was painting her own a deep plum, and Alison suggested something.

"So Hanna, my boyfriend's best friends with this guy named Caleb. He is single and-"

"I'm so in!" She cut her off excitedly.

"Uh Hanna, are you sure? You don't even know the guy…" Spencer asked trying to understand why she said yes so quickly.

"Your right Spence! I have one question." She turned to Alison and put on a serious face. "Is he hot?"

Alison and Spencer giggled. "Yes Hanna he is hot!"

"Okay now I'm totally in!" Hanna squealed. "Just tell me when and where and I will be there."

"It's going to be a triple date, don't think I forgot about you Spence! I know a guy named Andrew and he's a total catch!"

Spencer looked at Hanna and Alison's pleading faces and finally gave in, as if they were children begging their mother for candy.

"Yay!" Alison screeched happily and clapped her hands. "I'll just call Andrew and tell Toby to call Caleb and we'll set it up for tonight!"

A few hours later, Spencer and Hanna left Alison's to get ready for their triple date. Hanna was incredibly excited because she was finally going back on the market after her last boyfriend, Sean Ackard dumped her for some size zero cheerleader. Spencer on the other hand, was not as thrilled. The last time she was a part of a setup, the guy ended up being a handsy British guy who still lived with his mom.

Also, there was the blue-eyed mystery man. You know what Spencer? He has a girlfriend. And you talked to him for like two seconds. So just get him out of your head. Maybe this guy will be a good one. She thought to herself.

Spencer Hastings was very skilled at suppressing her feelings and right now was one of those times where she did a great job. Mystery Man, who?

She chuckled to herself, he was already gone.

All of a sudden, Hanna came running in wearing her fuzzy purple bathrobe and huge curlers in her blonde hair, holding a few different dresses in her hands.

"Spence, pick for me!" She shook the dresses in her hands, sounding like a three year old.

"Uh, the pink one." She pointed to a pink peplum dress on her left hand.

"That's the one that I wanted to!" She squealed and ran off to go get dressed.

Alison told them to dress formal because they were going to a new restaurant on Madison called, Eleven Madison Park. She has been there once with her parents and some clients. The food was great but it was very elegant. So Spencer decided on a navy dress and some nude pumps.

When they arrived the restaurant, they asked the hostess to take them to their table. Sitting down were two men. One with shaggy brown hair and olive skin, and the other with short but shaggy golden hair and muscles Hercules would be envious of.

They both got up and introduced themselves, and then sat down with their date.

"I don't know where Alison and Toby are. They said they wou-" Caleb looked over Hanna's shoulder and saw Alison. "There's Alison." Caleb waved her over.

"Hey guys, Toby just had to park the car he'll be in in a minute." She took off her pea coat to reveal a gorgeous laced dress, then sat down. "So Spence, Hanna?" She looked at her friends.

Hanna gave a thumb up and Spencer smiled. He was really cute. She thought while staring into his deep blue eyes.

After about five minutes of small talk, Alison's face brightened as she saw a man walk in to the restaurant.

"Toby! Come over here!" She gestured for him to join the table.

Spencer and Hanna turned simultaneously to see what their friend's boyfriend looked like.

You have got to be kidding. They both thought.

Hanna was surprised because this was the couple that made her lose her appetite, and Spencer was surprised becasue, well you know why…

He came over and looked at Spencer. "Hey I bumped into you!"

Spencer feigned a smile, "Oh really that was you?" She tried to act natural but on the inside, she was screaming. And rather loud.

"Yeah it was." He stared at her for a bit too long, but then looked away and sat down next to his girlfriend.

After they all ordered, Spencer noticed that Hanna was having a great time with Caleb. That makes one of us. Andrew was a total snob. Sure he was cute but he didn't have an off switch. All he talked about was his parents and how 'oh so rich they are'. Spencer may come from a very wealthy family but she was not that flashy…

But what she didn't notice was the looks she was getting from Toby the whole time. He couldn't put his finger on it, but something about her fascinated him. He knew that he should be paying attention to Alison because well he loved her.

Didn't he?

Of course he did!

Maybe…

But he couldn't tear his eyes away from the brunette beauty.

The rest of the dinner went very well. Hanna and Caleb planned a second date already, while Spencer tried to avoid Andrew so he wouldn't ask her, which worked very well.

Once Hanna and Spencer got into Spencer's car, Hanna said what Spencer has been dying to say all night.

"So the girl was Alison? Who knew-" Suddenly she understood why Spencer was so uncomfortable at that dinner.

"THE GUY YOU BUMPED INTO WAS TOBY?" her big blue eyes bulged out of her head like a pug and her mouth hung open.

Spencer slowly nodded.

"So the guy that you like is dating Alison, our friend? Oh lord." Hanna was Spencer's best friend but sometimes she wishes she would just shut up.

Okay so this wasn't really my best but I tried so I hope that you liked it (:

-Glitterintheairr