Finn didn't want to completely admit that he actually felt something when the boys kissed. This was all happening way too fast and it was confusing the hell out of Finn right now. He stared back at Sam, a scared expression on his face. Sam looked at him just as scared which made Finn feel slightly more calm, only because he realized he wasn't the only one freaking out. Finn didn't reply though, he just stepped close to Sam and placed his hand on his cheek pulling him in for another kiss. He didn't know what came over him, but he wanted to feel it again, just to see. He closed his eyes tightly as the innocent peck turned into another make-out session between the two males. Sam brought both of his hands to Finn's waist pulling his body closer to his own. Finn was a few inches taller so in order to deepen the kiss, Sam had to practically stand on his tippy toes. Finn's other hand made its way to Sam's other cheek, now cupping the young blonde's face as the kiss was deepened as the seconds went by. Their tongues explored one another's mouths, but before anything further could happen, a familiar voice came into listening distance.
It was coming from the hallway, "Finn!", it was Kurt. Finn quickly pulled away from Sam and stepped back a good distance as Kurt finally made his way into the door frame. Why didn't Finn think to close his door? Oh right, maybe because he wasn't planning on making out with another boy in his bedroom. Finn's erection was long gone thanks to Kurt. Kurt placed one hand on the door frame and the other on his hip, "Oh, hi Sam.."he smiled sweetly. He then turned his attention to Finn, "Carol gave me money for groceries and Me and Blaine need your assistance. God knows I can't carry anything heavier than a milk carton, so come on."Kurt slowly turned to walk away then looked back with a curious expression, "No offense, Sam but why are you in my house? I didn't even know you two were friends since…well, you know…" he gave a light shrug and waited for an explanation. Finn thought quickly and saw the textbook on the bed, he immediately rushed past Sam to get it and handed it to Sam. "He was picking up his book," Finn said uneasily, "And…he was just leaving." Sam nodded awkwardly and looked at Finn, "Uh..yeah, thanks again, dude…see ya…both tomorrow," he headed towards the door and walked past Kurt. Kurt rose a brow but didn't question anything, Finn was always acting awkward, so it was nothing new. Plus, maybe it was just awkward because Finn had taken the guys girlfriend not too long ago? Finn followed Kurt out to his car to help he and Blaine with the groceries. He couldn't stop thinking about the kiss and what would have happened if Kurt hadn't interrupted or if Kurt would have walked in on it and saw them. Finn didn't know what to think, I mean, he did like it and he wouldn't mind doing it again. But no, he had a girlfriend. Holy crap, did he just cheat on Quinn? And with the guy he took her away from?
Finn couldn't sleep at all that night, he tossed and turned in his sheets, haunted by thoughts of Sam. What was happening to him? Did he like Sam? Was he… gay? How was it going to be at school? Would Sam tell anyone? So many questions were running through Finn's mind and he didn't know how to handle it. He considered skipping the school day, but that would just bring concern and questions from Quinn and would only delay his next encounter with Sam. Finn took a breath before exiting his car in the morning. He was parked in the school's parking lot just staring at all the students walking inside. He knew he had to act normal and just go with the flow of the day's events, at least for now.