I own nothing except my OC's Valerie and Jess
cgi/set?id=164682481
To Kill a Mocking Girl
"Whose idea was this, again?" Hanna muttered as the five girls trudged through the woods, trying to find their old special spot. Valerie slapped her thigh where she assumed a bug had been as she tugged the bottom of her dress down.
"Emily's mom," Spencer answered, following after Emily who was leading the way.
"The shed was me," Emily explained, "My mom just said we should do something for us."
"Well, couldn't we do something without mosquitoes?" Hanna complained.
"They're not mosquitoes," Valerie said swatting the air as she walked by Hanna, "they're gnats."
"Whatever!" Hanna shot her a look, "They're small and annoying, and they're flying up my nose."
"Well, they're attracted to your perfume," Spencer turned back to glance at them.
"And your hair product and your lip gloss…" Valerie listed and Hanna turned to the other blonde to give her a mocking look.
"So, what are you saying, I attract flies?" She tested with a perfectly raised eyebrow.
"Gnats," Valerie returned the look.
"Why do I feel like this is the wrong way?" Emily asked as Hanna continued to swipe at the air, accidently hitting Valerie's forehead. Valerie stopped to give the girl a glare as the other shrugged innocently. The five stopped at the giant tree that was planted in the middle of the forest.
"No, this is it," Spencer pointed out as she moved ahead, "I remember that tree. It's the halfway point. There's 136 steps left to the shed."
"Have you been out here since...Alison?" Emily asked cautiously.
"Me?" Spencer gave her an incredulous look before shaking her head furiously, "No. No way."
"But you remember that tree," Aria pointed out suspiciously.
"You guys, it's not that weird," Hanna defended, "I mean, we came out here in eighth grade like, every day... even after."
"Well for one thing I think this is a really bad idea to put up whatever you call it… a shrine in the middle of the woods," Valerie said crossing her arms.
"It's not a shrine," Emily corrected with a bit of edge, "It's just a place to remember Alison. What's wrong with that?"
"Doing it way out here makes it look like we have something to hide," Spencer explained.
"You guys are worried what other people think?" Emily asked.
"Not really," Valerie shook her head before responding, "But do you really want to give that creepy Detective more reasons to question us?" Emily turned her attention away from the two before turning to Hanna who started to walk away from the group to continue through the woods.
"Hanna, why are you so quiet?" She questioned.
"I'm trying to keep the bugs in my nose and out of my mouth," She said, completely avoiding the topic.
"You're allowed to have an opinion on this," Emily tried.
"You want my opinion?" Hanna abruptly stopped and turned to the other four, "I say we hold off and not remember her 'til we know for sure she's not still here."
"What?" The four gave her a bewildered look.
"What are you talking about?" Aria asked her in confusion.
"You think she's still alive?" Emily asked.
"Hanna, they found her body," Spencer pointed out.
"Stop," Aria said, "I'm officially scared. Can we just not..."
"You know, you asked for my opinion. I don't believe she's really gone," Hanna said earning more looks from her friends.
"We went to her funeral Han," Valerie frowned at her blonde friend who walked away from the conversation.
"Yeah, and when we left we all got a text from her," Hanna continued as the others followed behind.
"It wasn't her," Emily denied immediately, "Someone is messing with us."
"How do you know?" Hanna turned on her "And what about all those nasty messages? I mean, how does this "A" person know stuff only Ali knew?"
"Okay, I'm starting to agree with Aria," Valerie said as she rubbed her arms with her hands, "This conversation is starting to give me creeps."
"That's a bite," Hanna said as Valerie shot her a look before she shrugged innocently again, "Mosquito."
"Spencer, have you gotten any more messages?" Emily said, averting her eyes from the two feisty blondes back Spencer to continue the conversation.
"Haven't you?" Spencer asked before a distant rustling of branches was heard. Hanna and Valerie quieted down immediately before grabbing onto each other, their eyes wide. Valerie's green eyes surveyed the area and she noted that the others noticed the sound too.
"What was that? Did you hear that?" Emily asked, her voice laced with panic as she turned her head from left to right to find the source of it.
"Yes, I heard that. I'm standing right next to you," Aria whispered back.
"Hello? Is anybody out there?" Hanna called out.
"It's probably a rabbit," Spencer dismissed.
"Hello?" Hanna tried again, ignoring Spencer's comment.
"It's a rabbit, Hanna. It's not gonna answer you," Spencer said as the girls moved closer to each other.
"Can we just get to the shed?" Emily asked her eyes wide in fear. A branch snapped and Valerie clutched onto Hanna's arm even tighter.
"That is definitely not a rabbit. Someone's out there," Valerie whispered causing a chill of terror to run through the five girls.
"Let's turn around," Emily said and just as they were making a leave, a sound wave of cellphones went off. Valerie pulled out her phone from her bag with a shaky hands before reading the message that popped up.
Unknown
Heads up, BFFs. It's open season on liars and I'm hunting…
-A
.
Valerie took another bite out of her apple as she rushed around her room, trying to slip on her other boot before grabbing her school bag and field hockey bag. Before she could leave, a framed picture on her night stand caught her attention. In a blue and white sharks cheerleading uniform was fifteen year old Valerie Sommers sporting a blonde high pony tail. Her green eyes shined with happiness. Valerie pulled the apple out of her mouth before the sound of the doorbell rang. She took one last glance at the picture before running down stairs. That girl in the picture was gone, and she was never coming back.
The blonde slipped on her bag and passed Jess, who was busy trying to pull up her wild strawberry blonde curls.
"Could you please get the door?" Jess begged with a bobby pin sticking out of her mouth. Valerie snorted into her apple before heading towards the door with a smile. The smile quickly slipped off her face when she realized who was on the other side.
"Morning," Wilden greeted in full uniform. Valerie narrowed her eyes at him when she noticed his eyes were roaming everywhere else that wasn't her eyes before they returned to her face.
"What do you want?" She said straight to the point. Wilden smirked.
"I offered to give your aunt a ride to the police station," Wilden said before moving towards the door where Valerie's body blocked the entrance, "You mind?" He feigned politeness but the blonde could see right through it. She frowned at him for a moment before slowly moving out of the way to let him in. As he made his way into her home, she dropped her bag onto a table nearby.
"Just give me a sec," Valerie muttered before making her way back to her aunt who was trying to slip on her shoes.
"What the hell is detective Wilden dong here?" Valerie hissed and Jess's brown eyes widened in disapproval.
"Language," She chastised, when she noticed the younger of the two wasn't going to drop the question she sighed, "Remember the cop I was telling you about?" Valerie scoffed in disgust.
"I didn't think you were talking about this creep," she mumbled before Jess pushed her niece into the kitchen where Wilden was waiting.
"Sorry, I didn't realize you coming in so early," Jess's voice brightened up immediately. Valerie went to go pick up her bag and watched the two with a cautious eye.
"It's no problem," Wilden smiled and Valerie wrinkled her nose as she grabbed her keys, still keeping her eyes on the two.
"Did you have something to eat before you got here Darren?" Jess asked. Valerie felt her jaw drop slightly before wrinkling her nose in disgust at her. What the hell? Darren? Are they on first name bases now?
"No, don't worry about it, we should get going now," Wilden said placing a hand on the lower back of her aunt. Jess went to open the door and she held it out as the two passed Valerie.
"Tell your friend Hanna her mother's hospitality was very much appreciated," Wilden whispered to her so Jess couldn't hear before they left. Valerie's eyebrows furrowed at what he meant before she checked the time on her clock and left.
.
"Look, I get it! You're upset and I feel for you, but don't dump it all on me. Maybe you should be asking yourself why Wren felt the need to... I'm sorry. Okay? I'm not perfect, but I don't want to be accused of something that I didn't do!" Valerie heard Spencer yell the minute she walked into the Hasting's home. As the door shut, three pairs of eyes were moved to her.
"Sorry," Valerie apologized sheepishly, "Is this a bad time?" Melissa scoffed at her before marching into her room and Mrs. Hastings rubbed her forehead.
"Hello Valerie, I wasn't expecting you this morning, your turn to drive right?" Valerie nodded her head. She and Spencer switch on and off driving each other seeing it was easier to save on gas money this way. As Spencer's father put it, there was more important things money could be spent on and gas wasn't one of them. Veronica turned back to her daughter, who gave Valerie a desperate look through her eyes.
"You can take your muffin to go, Spencer." She said in a tired tone before leaving the room. Spencer grabbed her bag and dumped her muffin in the trash can as she walked towards the door with Valerie who gave her a sympathetic smile.
"Melissa still not over the whole Wren thing?" Valerie asked as they sat in her car. Spencer groaned.
"How could she? As she eloquently put it I was and I quote 'sitting there like a throw pillow with my tongue down his throat'." Spencer said before hitting her head against the window. Valerie hissed.
"Harsh," She said, "If you think that's bad wait till I tell you who showed up at my door this morning." Spencer's head snapped up in interest.
"Who?" Spencer asked as Valerie's hands clenched around the wheel.
"Wilden," She rolled her eyes and Spencer gasped, "I guess he's going after Jess now." She purposely left out the little comment about Hanna. She figured no one needed to know about it till she talked to said girl herself.
"You don't think she's actually into him do you?" Spencer asked in shock as she leaned back into her seat.
"God I hope not," Valerie prayed as she pulled into the parking lot. The two left her car and walked towards school and Spencer couldn't help but notice the attention her blonde friend was receiving from the guys at the school.
"Tell me again why you're single?" Spencer asked as they walked side by side, walking through the school entrance.
"Because the guys at this school think I'm just another bottle headed pretty face looking for an easy screw between class periods," Valerie inhaled as they stopped by Spencer's locker.
"That why you quit the cheer-leading squad to be president of the science club," Spencer teased with a smile as she put in her locker combination. Valerie pulled on a smile.
"What are you doing?" Valerie snapped as she entered her room. Alison stood by her dresser in all her glory with a hand behind her back.
"The real question is what are you doing?" Alison asked with a raised eyebrow and smile as she pulled her hand into plain view with a bag of white substance, "What is it this time? Coke?" Valerie went to grab it but Alison held it out of her reach. "Careful, it might spill on your precious little uniform." Valerie glared at her.
"It's not mine," She said through clenched teeth. Alison's eyes twinkled.
"Jason's right?" Alison scoffed when her friend didn't answer, "My brother's already a loser, I don't need him dragging you down too."
"Ali, just give it back." Valerie tried as panic arouse in her. If anyone found out… Jason would be beyond pissed that she let Ali get to his stuff again. Her parents would burn her like a witch if they knew what she was doing behind their backs.
"It would be such a shame if your parents found out what their perfect daughter was doing with my brother in his room," Alison said noticing the panic behind her friend's green eyes.
"Please Ali," Valerie begged.
"It'll be our little secret," Alison smiled before placing the bag down, "If you do me a favor."
"Yeah of course, anything." Valerie breathed, willing to do almost anything.
"Quit the squad," Alison demanded. Her heart dropped. She was the youngest on the varsity squad, in line for captain next year.
"Wha- why?" She stuttered.
"I don't need people thinking your some stupid blonde on the cheer-leading squad. Don't you want people so see you more than just an easy slut?" Alison ran a 'comforting' hand down Valerie's arm, "You're so much smarter than you're given credit for and being on that squad with all those bimbos isn't going to help you don't you get it. You could be up there with Spencer, be known as the one with beauty and brains."
In all honesty, Alison just didn't want her to be her competition anymore. She was tired having to compete for attention against someone who could care less about it. People liked Valerie more than they liked Ali. She was the pretty mean one. Valerie was the pretty nice one and people leaned more towards nice than mean. Boys fawned over her and with Valerie off the squad and in the library she would be seen like Spencer was. Unapproachable.
Valerie bit her lip. She knew Alison too well. The girl had perfected the art of manipulation by the time she was four. If she didn't do what she said, then not only would Valerie go down but Jason as well. And she knew he'd never forgive her if Alison managed to twist the truth to make it seem like she turned him in instead of his sister.
"Fine."
"That's half of it," She muttered before catching the book that fell out of her friend's locker. She noticed the cramped space in the locker.
"Geez Spence, you need any more AP classes?" Valerie retorted sarcastically before handing the textbook back.
"I'm already drowning in there," Spencer sighed, "First paper's due Monday and I've written two words: my name." Valerie frowned. That didn't sound like the Spencer she knew.
"You okay?" Valerie asked in concern when she just noticed the dark circles under her eyes.
"No," Spencer paused, "Yeah, I don't know. Is there any chance Jess is willing to adopt me?" Valerie let out a laugh. The two walked down the hall only to be stopped by Jenna and Toby. Valerie and Spencer both exchanged a look when Hanna and Aria joined their side as Jenna and Toby passed them. Valerie could almost hear the alarms of the fire truck and the smell of smoke from the day of the incident, almost like it was yesterday.
"He's back, too? When did that happen?" Aria questioned, breaking the blonde from her train of thought.
"Maybe she needs help sending radioactive e-mails," Hanna suggested.
"Yeah, or he may be sending a few of his own," Spencer added before Wilden came up to the girls. Valerie felt an involuntary glare already forming at the older man.
"Hanna," He called.
"Looks like cops on campus too," Valerie said quietly for only them to hear.
"I just spoke with your principal, asked him if we could have a chat," Wilden said before Valerie stepped up.
"She has to get to class," Valerie said with narrowed eyes.
"Don't worry. She's been excused," Wilden smirked at the small girl before turning to the other blonde, "Let's go." The girls watched helplessly as their friend walked off with him.
"What is going on? Why just her?" Aria started.
"Probably thinks she's the easiest to crack," Valerie tried as Emily joined them.
"She is," Spencer stressed. Valerie heard the familiar clacking sound getting closer.
"Whisper, whisper, whisper. Almost feels like Alison's still here," Jenna sneered as she passed them.
"Hey Val," Noel greeted with a smile before nodding at Spencer, "Hi Spencer." Spencer gave him a small smile before his attention was directed back to the blonde.
"What is it that you want Noel?" Valerie asked with a smile as she unlocked her locker. Across the hall was Emily and Aria trying to get in contact with Hanna via cellphone.
"Well word spreads like wild fire; I'm surprised you haven't heard about my party tonight," Noel started and Valerie shot him a look to continue, "Just wondering if you plan to show up."
"I don't do parties anymore," Valerie drawled as she slammed her locker shut. She ignored the look Spencer had shot her.
"One party's not gonna kill you Val," Noel frowned, "What happened to the girl who knew how to have fun?"
"She'll be there," Spencer cut in earning a glare from the green eyed beauty. Noel smiled.
"Great, see you there," He gave her a teasing tap on the nose before leaving.
"Are you crazy?" Valerie hissed at her tall friend.
"It's just a party, I'll be there to make sure you don't touch one drink," Spencer assured her, "Besides, I think Noel might have a thing for you." Valerie scowled.
"Noel has a thing for anyone with boobs," She said rolling her eyes as they joined the other two.
"What are you doing? Is that a new phone?" Spencer asked, observing the phone in Aria's hand.
"Yeah, I'm checking my Kin. I'll just write on Hanna's wall from here," Aria said, typing away.
"If she's not answering texts, what makes you think she's checking Facebook" Valerie asked skeptically.
"It's worth a try," Emily shrugged, not hiding her panic very well like the others.
"What's going on?" Hanna asked as she appeared behind them. The girls turned around with wide eyes.
"We've been trying to get a hold of you. What happened in there?" Aria asked immediately.
"Nothing," She shrugged, "just the same old stupid questions."
"You were in there for an hour, Hanna. What else did he ask?" Spencer added.
"Nothing. He just took a couple calls, and I just sat there, waiting for him to shut up," Hanna said casually
"Well, is he gonna question all of us alone now?" Aria continued to question as she looked at the others.
"Who knows? Look, let's do this at lunch, okay? I have to hit the ladies' before my next class," Hanna brushed them off as she left to walk away from them.
"Is she being weird?" Valerie asked, reminding herself to talk to Hanna later at the party.
"She's being weird," Emily confirmed, "I'll see you guys at lunch."
.
"No drinking remember," Jess reminded as Valerie fixed her golden curls in the mirror.
"Noted," She smiled. She'd be lying if she said she wasn't nervous about tonight. It was the first time in a long time she was going to a party since she'd dropped the alcohol and drugs. Jess showed up behind her as she stood in front of the mirror. Her aunt brushed out any wrinkles in her olive colored top.
"You look good in green," Jess complimented. The doorbell rang.
"That'll be Spence," Valerie said before grabbing her bag and running to the door. It was the second time she'd been disappointed.
"What, are you here to question me too?" Valerie snapped as Wilden stood at the doorway for the second time today. She suddenly noticed the pizza box in his hands.
"Valerie," Jess chided as she opened the door wider, "Darren please come in."
"Ew," Valerie complained as he made his way into her home again.
"Darren was nice enough to bring me dinner while you went out tonight," Jess explained. The tension in the room was thick.
"Party?" He asked.
"None of your business," Valerie quipped, "Unless you plan on questioning me on why my pants are too tight. No? Then goodnight." Valerie left with a slam on the door before making her way to Spencer's.
.
Spencer, Valerie and Aria stood outside watching as everyone entered and exited Noel's cabin with either a drink in hand or a person to look for a quiet place to hook up. Valerie couldn't help but feel antsy when she smelled the alcohol in the air.
"Hey," Emily greeted them as she walked out from Noel's cabin.
"Hey Em, you okay?" Valerie asked, noticing her friend's nervous mood, "Where's Ben?" She shifted on both of her feet.
"I need to tell you guys something," Emily whispered, pulling them away from any stray ears. Emily explained to them what had gone down in the swim locker room with Ben and Toby and the three girls couldn't believe their ears.
"He tackled Ben?" Aria gasped.
"Wait, what was Toby even doing in the girls' locker room?" Valerie voiced in confusion.
"Why are you shocked?" Spencer quipped, turning to the blonde, "Toby's a perv. We caught him peeping through the windows, watching us undress."
"Alison's the one who saw him do that. We never did," Emily defended quickly.
"What's up?" Hanna asked, joining them.
"Toby Cavanaugh got into a fight with Ben over Emily," Aria elaborated.
"It wasn't over me. God. Look, he just... saved me," Emily added with a blush.
"For what, himself?" Spencer retorted back sarcastically.
"Ew," Hanna and Valerie shared a look of revulsion. Valerie glanced behind Emily and noticed Noel staring at her through the window. He brought up a red cup with a smile before leaving the window. She narrowed her eyes. Maybe one drink wouldn't hurt.
"If we hadn't asked you about Ben, would you have told us about this?" Aria asked, breaking Valerie's attention away from the cabin window.
"Toby is not a good guy, Emily. He could be seriously dangerous," Spencer warned.
"If he's such a bad guy, why'd he take the fall for us?" Emily countered, making Valerie rethink back to the incident. She did have a point. Valerie also noticed how Spencer faltered at the question which raised her suspicion.
"Is this another secret? Do you know something that we don't?" Valerie interrogated. She really need that drink right now. These damn secrets keep coming back to bite them in the ass.
"Guys, why don't we just, like chill, and talk about this somewhere else? When we're alone," Hanna suggested, glancing at the people around them.
"I... don't even know what "just us" means anymore," Aria murmured.
"Yeah, uh... Let's talk about it tomorrow, okay?" Hanna said, sounding a bit distracted, "Are we still meeting up at the shed?" Before anyone could answer she had gone up and left to go back to the cabin.
"Yeah. Yeah, sure. Why not?" Aria watched her walk away in bemusement before moving to leave as well.
"Where are you going?" Valerie asked her with a frown.
"The gallery," She explained, "I promised my mom." As she leaves, Maya approached the three remaining girls.
"Have you checked out the photo booth they've got in there?" Maya pointed back to the cabin.
"No. Show me the booth," Emily smiled at her friends in goodbye before leaving with Maya and Valerie turned to Spencer.
"I need to use the restroom," She lied.
"Wait you're gonna leave me here alone?" Spencer cried and Valerie gave her a smile, "Val, I don't even want to be here."
"Then I'll get a ride back with Hanna or Emily," When she noticed Spencer's hesitant look she added, "I'll be fine." Spencer finally gave in before waving good bye. Valerie took in a huge gulp of air before exhaling and entering the cabin.
"Finally," Noel cheered before wrapping in arm around her shoulders, in his hand was another red cup, "Now the party can officially start."
"Noel," Valerie warned in a teasing tone, "You know I don't drink anymore."
"You also said you don't go to parties anymore," Noel pointed out before handing her the cup with a knowing smile, "You can make this last exception for me right?" Valerie felt herself get flustered under his stare before giving in.
"Sure, why not."
.
Hanna walked away from the car wreck, still in tears and still fuming from what happened when she heard someone calling her name.
"HANNA," Valerie slurred out loudly as she stumbled towards the familiar blonde. Everything in her eyesight was a haze as she squinted at Hanna's face before patting her wet cheek, "Yeah y-you're her."
"Valerie?" Hanna gasped before wiping away her tears and looked at her friend in concern, "Are you drunk?"
"No of course not!" She shrieked before almost tripping over her own feet to get closer to Hanna, "Okay maybe I'm a little drunk."
"You're totally wasted! Where the hell is Spencer?" Hanna yelled as she grabbed her friend's arm and started towards the street. Her house wasn't too far from here.
"Spencer left," Valerie swung her free arm around towards the sky, "You smell awesome."
"Thanks," Hanna let out a small smile as she kept a steady hold on her drunk friend.
"Like seriously I would jump you right now because you smell so good," Valerie slurred as she leaned on Hanna, "Mmmh, my lesbian lover."
"Yeah definitely wasted," Hanna whispered to herself as she quietly opened the Sommers' home door. If Jess found the two of them, they were dead. She managed to drag Valerie hallway up the stairs when she heard a female giggling. Hanna tilted her head to look into the living room and was more than surprised to see Jess sitting way too close to Detective Wilden. She managed to conceal her gasp before lugging her friend up the stairs.
"What's detective Wilden dong at your house Val?" Hanna asked when they were safe up her room. Valerie snuggled up close to her blankets before she looked at her fingers to inspect them
"When did these guys get here?" She giggled as Hanna sat down beside her.
"Val answer the question, what's the creep doing in your house with Jess," Hanna questioned as she grabbed her shoulders.
"I don't know," She hiccuped, "If we're on that topic now, he said something about your mom and how she has great hospitality or something what does that mean?" Valerie played with the stray curls on Hanna's head as her friend stared at her in shock.
"Nothing," She muttered, "It means nothing." She tucked Valerie into bed and turned out the lights before getting up to leave when she heard her sniffle into her pillow.
"Val?" Hanna asked.
"I loved him," She whispered into her pillow, "I really did love him." Hanna didn't push any further questions, thinking she probably meant her father or some guy at a party. But as she left, the only person that ever drifted into Valerie's mind was Jason.
.
"Alison wanted us across the street so she could have it out with Toby," Spencer explained the next day as they were walking in the woods, "Ali had something on him." Valerie cringed behind her sunglasses. It felt like nails were being hammered into her brain every time someone so much as stepped on a branch.
"Besides being a total perv who peeped in our windows?" Hanna asked, glancing at Valerie out of the corner of her eyes.
"Yeah, something way bigger, and she was threatening to tell everybody. That's why he took the fall for us," Spencer added before Valerie let out a groan and shushed them. Spencer sent her an odd look as the other three looked at her in concern.
"Why are you waiting until now to tell us?" Aria asked, still looking at the pale blonde.
"I don't know. Ali made me promise, and... I guess I was scared. I thought if we never talked about that night again, it would just go away," Spencer shrugged before turning to her friend, "What is wrong with you?"
"Nothing," Valerie exclaimed before groaning and clutching her head with one hand, "Can you guys just stop talking so loud?" Spencer gaped at her before grabbing her chin.
"Are you hung over?" she hissed. Valerie shoved her hands away.
"It's a migraine and unlike this, that night is never going away. Not unless we toss our phones and join the freaking Navy," Valerie rolled her eyes and cringed. Spencer sent her a look that obviously told her that this conversation was going to be dealt with later.
"Look, there's four of us and one freak sending messages. If we just talk to each other like this, I feel like it makes it easier to deal with everything," Emily said pulling her attention away from Valerie.
"I think Emily's right. There's way too many secrets," Aria said, "We shouldn't do this in the middle of nowhere. We should do it where we can see it every day."
"You mean, like, somewhere in school?" Hanna asked skeptically.
"No, like in town," Valerie grumbled.
"Exactly, we should ask if we can put a bench somewhere," Aria agreed before thinking of something else, "Wait, and you know what? Whoever did this to her, if they're still in Rosewood, we should make them look at it every day, too." Valerie noticed the look on Hanna's face and she wasn't the only one.
"What, you hate the idea?" Spencer asked.
"No. No, I just... I had a rough night," Hanna brushed off before casting a look at Valerie. There was a rustling sound just behind them and in panic, they ran.
"Wait stop," Valerie breathed, her headache slightly clearing up as she stare at the forest ground, "What is that?"
"Is that yours?" Spencer asked, noticing the small bracelet too as thy all circled around it. Aria looked at them with wide eyes, terror filled them.
"Alison's."