When Puck got home that night Lily was the only thing going through his mind. He couldn't get her out of his head. He knew this was strange, as he'd never thought about a girl constantly before, he'd only been with girls before for one thing, and then when he got bored he'd leave them. Lily was different, he felt like he had a connection with her, even though he'd only just met her.
He paced up and down his room, trying to think of a song to sing to her tomorrow. He didn't want to sing a romantic ballad, she'd probably get put off by that, plus she didn't seem like the kind of girl to appreciate that. However, he didn't wanna just sing any random song that didn't have any meaning. He needed to find a rock song that expressed how he felt and that would make Lily want to sing with him. He got out his iPod and started flicking through songs, not one would impress Lily. He was just about to give up, when the perfect song started playing. 'Yes!' he thought 'I'll sing this to her tomorrow and she'll most definitely want to duet with me'. He smiled to himself, turned off his iPod and settled down to go to sleep, with Lily still on his mind.
The following day, Puck walked into Glee rehearsals smiling to himself, he was very confident that he'd get Lily. He saw her sitting next to Brittany, he looked at her and she caught his gaze, and he swore he could see her smiling a little bit. His stomach done flips and knotted, which was strange, he'd never got that feeling before. He smiled at the thought. He saw a chair that was free near her; he was just about to walk over to it when Rachel blocked his way.
'Rachel, what do you want?' He asked, slightly annoyed.
'Don't think I don't know what you're trying to do Puckerman' she said, in that annoying voice of hers.
'What's that then?' He said, folding his arms.
'You're trying to get with Lily, and I bet I know what your intentions are. I know you Noah, you want to get with every girl in this school' Rachel looked up at him, glaring.
'Rachel, you don't know me at all. She's a good looking girl, yes. But I don't want her for that. I've changed for the better'
'I don't believe you, so back off' Rachel warned him.
'No, I won't Rachel; you're just jealous' He then walked off and sat down at that time Mr Schu walked in.
'Hey guys, I hope you've started work on your duets, remember you have two weeks until you perform them infront of everyone' He said, smiling.
Puck raised his hand, it was now or never.
'Yes Puck?' Mr Schu asked.
'I know this isn't part of the duets theme, but I've been working on something and I'd like to show everyone' He said, his stomach knotting again.
'Sure, go for it' Mr Schu smiled.
Puck got out of his seat and went into the centre of the room. He took a deep breath, signalled to the band that he was ready and started to sing.
Let me know that I've done wrong
When I've known this all along
I go around a time or two
Just to waste my time with you
Tell me all that you've thrown away
Find out games you don't wanna play
You are the only one that needs to know
I'll keep you my dirty little secret (dirty little secret)
Don't tell anyone
Or you'll be just another regret (just another regret)
Hope that you can keep it
My dirty little secret
Who has to know?
When we live such fragile lives
It's the best way we survive
I go around a time or two
Just to waste my time with you
Tell me all that you've thrown away
Find out games you don't wanna play
You are the only one that needs to know
I'll keep you my dirty little secret (dirty little secret)
Don't tell anyone
Or you'll be just another regret (just another regret)
Hope that you can keep it
My dirty little secret
Who has to know?
The way she feels inside (inside)
Those thoughts I can't deny (deny)
These sleeping dogs won't lie (won't lie)
And now I tried to but it's eating me apart
Trace this nightmare
I'll keep you my dirty little secret (dirty little secret)
Don't tell anyone
Or you'll be just another regret (just another regret)
I'll keep you my dirty little secret (dirty little secret)
Don't tell anyone
Or you'll be just another regret (just another regret)
Hope that you can keep it
My dirty little secret
My dirty little secret
My dirty little secret
Who has to know?
Who has to know?
As he was singing, Lily couldn't stop staring at him. He was singing one of her favourite songs and his voice was amazing. Maybe there was more to Noah Puckerman, then she first thought, plus he was sorta cute. As he stopped singing, she got to her feet and applauded him. Puck saw this and smiled right at her.
'Wow, well done Puck, that was great' Mr Schu said, clapping. Puck smiled and went to sit down next to Lily.
'That was amazing, I would love to duet with you. Meet me in the auditorium after school' Lily whispered in his ear.
Puck smiled, he'd done it.