School is now out for the summer so that means for the whole summer Sarah would have to accompany her brother and Seth to the gym everyday she also knew that both Seth and Dean have been keeping something from her and she wanted to know what. Once the two men were dressed for work they saw Sarah eating some cereal for breakfast so the decided to make some coffee, Sarah then wanted to know what was going on so she spoke up.
"Guys is everything ok?" Sarah asked.
"Yeah everything's fine". Dean said.
"Dean, you and Uncle Seth have been acting very different the last couple of weeks. What's wrong i think i can handle it". Sarah said.
Dean looked at his friend with a questionable look, Seth shrugged his shoulders and nodded.
"Sarah, sweetheart as much as we don't want to tell you this i think we should". Seth said.
"Tell me what?" Sarah asked a bit scared.
Dean then moved by his sister and threw an arm around her shoulders bringing her close.
"Sarah right before i came and got you from school a couple weeks ago someone stopped by". Dean started.
"Who was it". Sarah asked.
This is the moment of truth for Dean once he tells her that's it, he wasn't ready to see the outcome of what he's about to reveal.
"It was your father, it was Andrew". Dean admitted.
Sarah looked wide eyes with fear in them hoping that he was lying and that this was some kind of sick cruel joke.
"Y-you're joking aren't you? I mean he's in jail. De please please please tell me that this is a joke or something". Sarah said with her voice cracking.
"I'm sorry baby girl it's not a joke". Dean said.
"No". Sarah cried.
She then ran from her brother's arm to her secret hideaway place in the house, Seth then went to go after her but Dean stopped him he'll talk to his sister. He knew where his sister always hid when she was scared, he opened his closet and there she was curled up in a tight ball hugging her knees close to her chest crying her eyes out he then sat down beside her and brought her close and held her as she cried, Seth then came in the room to see his niece clinging to Dean as if her life depended on it.
"De, Uncle Sethie don't let him get me please after last time...i was really scared. He said if i didn't do what he said he'd kill you guys and Uncle Roman i didn't want to but he said he'd kill you and i didn't want him to". Sarah cried.
She then ran to Seth crying in his chest as he held her in a tight hold, after a full ten minutes of crying Sarah felt drowsy and she wanted to rest so Seth went to go put her in her room but she didn't wanna be alone in her room so Seth put her in Dean's bed and they covered her up and waited and soon as she was in a deep enough sleep they left the room leaving the door cracked open some Dean then got two beer out of the refrigerator for him and Seth thinking back to that day it was their worst nightmare.
*Flashback*
Dean and Seth are a bit worried because Sarah was suppose to be home from school by now but she hasn't came home yet or hasn't called either one of them.
"Where is she this isn't like her to be late". Dean said.
"She could be at the library with a friend". Seth suggested.
"She would have told one of us, i got a feeling something isn't right". Dean said.
"Gut instinct?" Seth asked.
"That and big brother instinct i can't shake this feeling". Dean said.
Dean's phone rang and it was Sarah calling him so he answers it.
-Sarah where are you? Dean asked.
-De? Sarah cried.
-Sarah, sweetheart what's wrong. Dean replied.
This made Seth get up and made Dean put his phone on speaker.
-De i'm scared please help me, i wanna go home. Sarah cried.
-Where are you Sarah can you tell me where you're at baby girl. Dean said.
-I'm at-hmm hmm. Sarah said being cut off.
-Sarah? Sarah? Seth called into the phone.
-I'm afraid she can't tell you anything right now she's a bit...tied up at the moment. Andrew said.
-Andrew you son of a bitch, give me back my sister or i swear to god i will kill you. Dean said angrily.
The phone is silent for a minute till a piercing scream comes through the phone making both men look panicked and worried.
-Sarah, sweetheart are you ok? Seth said quickly.
-Uncle Seth i wanna go home please help me. Sarah cried.
-Either of you make one threat little Sarah will get it. You should have just given me a chance Dean now this is on you. Andrew said.
-Andrew let my sister go right now dammit. Dean said.
-No she's my daughter and i'm taking her so she can live with me she'll be happier with me. Andrew said.
-You stupid delusional son of a bitch wait till i get my hands on you. Dean said.
-Goodbye Dean i'll make sure you never see Sarah again. Andrew said coldly.
-De, Uncle Seth help me. Sarah cried.
The phone then went out making Dean go crazy mad and Seth to sit and panic, they then called the police and had a Amber Alert issued. It was only three days since the two men heard Sarah's voice and they were pissed off, Seth called Roman and he is flying out from Florida once he got there Seth had filled him in on what was going on with Sarah, he was ready to kill Andrew with his bare hands. It was another couple of days when Dean had finally gotten a call about his sister Andrew had taken her across state lines into Arizona and she is being brought back to the police station in Nevada, she finally arrived at the station with a blanket covering her with her eyes widen in fear with unshed tears in them with a bandage on her arm where she got cut and a bandage on her wrist where the handcuff was placed too tight cutting her wrist some. Dean, Seth, and Roman ran into the station to see Sarah, Dean sees his little sister sitting on a bench covering herself with the blanket with tears streaming down her face silently crying.
"Sarah!" Dean called out.
Sarah heard a voice she would recognize anywhere when she brought her head up and saw her big brother with her two uncles she ran into Dean's arm hugging his waist tightly while burying her face in his chest soaking his shirt.
"Oh my god Sarah, i thought i lost you. It's alright now baby it's alright baby girl shh i'm here now i'm right here shh. Everything is alright now shh it's ok now. He won't ever hurt you again". Dean said.
Sarah held onto her brother for a few more minutes till she pulled away then she saw over her brother's shoulder Seth and Roman standing there with a relief look on their faces.
"Come here sweetheart". Seth said gently.
She then ran straight into his arms crying in relief.
"Uncle Sethie". Sarah cried.
"It's alright sweetheart it's alright now shh sweetie shh everything is alright". Seth soothed her.
She stayed in his arms for a couple more minutes till she pulled away and she saw Roman with his arms open and she hugged her other uncle gripping the back of his shirt as he soothed her, once she has calmed down enough she went back to Dean gripping his left arm tightly burying her face in his neck as they made their way out once they were outside they saw two officers bringing Andrew in custody and he saw Dean, Seth, and Roman standing there so he smirked at them and Dean gave his sister to Seth so he can kick Andrew's ass if not kill him for doing this to his sister just as he was about to make a move Roman held him back until they brought Andrew inside once he was in the station Roman still had to hold Dean back some but his thoughts are interrupted by Sarah's cries for her brother. Once they got to the car Seth drove while Roman was in the passenger seat then Dean sat in the back with his sister hugging her to his chest as she slowly fell asleep.
*Back to reality*
Dean was so pissed off he had to go blow some steam off before he did something seriously stupid so he took his car keys and left to go to the gym so he can blow some steam leaving Seth to care for his niece. It's been a few hours since Dean left and Sarah had woken up from her nap so she silently went in the kitchen to grab a soda so she didn't notice Seth come in from the patio and he goes to her and when he gently touches her shoulder she jumps.
"Sorry sweetheart". Seth said.
"It's ok, where's Dean?" Sarah asked.
"Probably at the gym blowing some steam off. Listen i gotta go to the store to grab a few things for dinner wanna come or do you wanna stay?" Seth replied.
Sarah didn't wanna be alone because she thought Andrew can come while they were gone and take her again, but if she was with Seth she would feel protected because she knows that if Dean isn't around Seth or Roman will make damn sure nothing happens to her. Seth notices that she is daydreaming about something.
"Sweetheart you alright?" Seth asked.
"I'm fine". She lied.
Seth then decided to let it go since she didn't wanna talk about it so while she got her shoes on he got his car keys, once they had all their stuff they went out to Seth's car and Sarah put her headphones in turn her IPod on cranking it up he then started the car and went to the grocery store after he finds a parking spot they get out grabbing a cart heading inside. Seth then had a mental list of stuff he needs to cook for dinner so he gets chicken breast, angel hair pasta, alfredo sauce, and some vegetables he then let Sarah go pick something for dessert and after she gets there she's looking for dessert and she was so lost in her thoughts she didn't even hear someone come up behind her.
"Hello Sarah. Miss me". The voice said.
This made Sarah's eyes widen and made her turn around slowly looking at Andrew with a fearful look in her eyes.
"Andrew". Sarah said with fear.
"I prefer dad". Andrew said.
"What are you doing here?" Sarah asked.
"I wanted to see you i mean after all you are my daughter". Andrew said moving some hair out her face.
When Andrew touched her hair she flinched and whimpered.
"You are not my father you never were my father, all you are and will ever be is a sperm donor that's it". Sarah spat.
Andrew then backhanded her leaving a bruise on her cheek.
"Look Sarah i am your father whether you like it or not so you will talk and show me respect or something can easily happen to that pathetic brother of yours along with those two dumbasses you call uncles. You wouldn't want that would you". Andrew said.
She looked at him in fear because that is what he threatened her with last time so she slowly nodded.
"See you later honey oh tell your brother and Seth i said hi". Andrew said.
Andrew then left leaving Sarah fearing not only for her life but the lives of Dean, Seth, and Roman, Seth then notices his niece has been gone too long so he goes to look for her and when he finds her he goes into protective mode because he sees her shaking while holding her cheek he forgets the cart and runs to his niece.
"Sarah, sweetheart look at me". Seth said gently.
She looks up and sees him and she immediately hugs him burying her face in his chest trying not to sob, he then tries to calm her down enough not to draw attention so he brings her outside and they head home hopefully Dean is there by now, Once they are there Sarah runs in running to her room shutting her door crying in her pillow. Seth then goes in wondering what upset his niece so bad so he goes to her room knocking on the door first.
"Sarah, sweetheart are you ok". Seth called through the door.
She didn't respond except crying harder in her pillow so he decides to go in and sits on her bed carefully removing the pillow and bringing her in his arms trying to calm her down but fails.
"Sweetie what happened at the store?" Seth asked wiping her tears.
"I-i was l-looking for a dessert when someone came up behind me". Sarah started.
"Who was it?" Seth asked.
Sarah took a deep breath and gulped hard before answering.
"It was Andrew". Sarah said.
Seth's eyes widen but gets pissed off he then hold her tighter, just then they hear something from the living room.
"I'm home". Dean announced.
Sarah then let go of Seth just as he brushed some hair away from her face, she looked towards her door silently asking Seth if she can go see her brother and he nods so she kisses his cheek and she runs down the stairs to her brother catching him off guard a little.
"Hey kiddo". Dean said.
Sarah just clinged to him as if he was her lifeline at that point, Dean was highly confused with his sister's behavior he looks back at Seth wondering what's wrong.
"Sarah why don't you go to your room so i can talk to your brother i'll call you when dinner's ready". Seth suggested.
Sarah nodded she then kissed her brother's cheek and he kissed her head in return she then moved going towards her room but before she went Seth kissed her up, she then ran to her room closing the door.
"What the hell was that about?" Dean asked.
"If i tell you don't get mad". Seth said.
This made Dean get very suspicious now.
"What happened Seth". Dean demanded.
"While me and Sarah were at the store i sent her to get something and when she was by herself someone came up behind her, it was Andrew". Seth said.
Dean looked like he was about to explode and rip Andrew's off right off his shoulders.
"What did he say or do it her?" Dean asked.
"He slapped her and must have said something to her because she looked terrified and the last time i seen her like that was what happened before". Seth continued.
"I'm going to kill that son of a bitch". Dean said.
Sarah's room
Sarah is trying to calm herself down but then her phone dings signaling a text message but she has a curious look on her face she didn't have friends to text the only people who had her number were her brother, Seth, and Roman so if it wasn't them who could be texting her, she unlocks her phone opening the text and when she reads it her blood runs cold and looks at it with fear in her eyes.
-I will get you Sarah if it's the last thing i do. Andrew.
Sarah then dropped the phone but picks it back up running back downstairs to her brother and uncle, when they hear her they look on the steps and when they see tears coming down her face they jump up immediately and Sarah runs to her brother sobbing.
"Sarah, honey what's wrong?" Seth asked gently.
She then handed her uncle the phone and he read the text message making his blood boil getting him pissed off.
"What's wrong?" Dean asked.
Sarah pulled away from her brother and went to Seth hiding her face in his chest as he gave Dean the phone, when he read the message he was now so pissed off it wasn't a joke he now wants to kill Andrew.
"That's it i'm gonna hunt this stupid son of a bitch down". Dean hissed.
"Dean can we deal with that later right now she needs us". Seth tried to negotiate.
He knew that Seth was right but he was going to have a 'talk' with Andrew the next time he saw him, they ordered take out for dinner and they ate quietly after dinner Sarah went straight to her room staying in there the rest of the night. Dean and Seth then clean up the few dishes then puts the food away Seth notices something wrong with his friend and got curious.
"What's up man?" Seth asked.
"It's that son of a bitch Andrew, he's really getting to her i just don't want her to end up like the last time". Dean said.
"What do you wanna do man, she's not gonna feel safe with him around and we both can't take him on by ourselves he's dangerous". Seth said.
"Then we call in reinforcements". Dean said.
Seth had a smirk on his face because he knew that he was calling Roman so he dials him putting the phone on speaker.
-Hello. Roman said.
-Rome it's Dean and Seth, we gotta big problem brother we need help. Dean said.
-What's going on? Roman asked.
-Sarah's no good stupid son of a bitch father is back. Seth answered.
-WHAT? Roman screamed.
-He threatened Dean then he showed up at the grocery store said something to Sarah and hit her, he then texted her not to long ago. Seth continued on.
-Oh hell no that son of a bitch asked for it. I'll be on the next plane out. Roman said.
-Thanks Rome. Seth said.
-Yeah thanks man it means a lot. Dean said.
-I'll do anything for you guys and Sarah. Roman said.
-Listen man we gotta go now but let us know when you get here. Dean said.
-Alright. Peace. Roman said.
Dean then hung the phone up then got two beers from the fridge so he and Seth can watch a match. After a while Seth went to bed leaving Dean in his own thoughts, he then soon went to bed after that.
3 am
Sarah is tossing and turning violently in her bed with tears coming down her face.
*Nightmare*
Sarah is running and running from Andrew who had blood all over his face and clothes because he just killed Dean, Seth, and Roman.
"Come out come out wherever you are Sarah, you can't run from daddy forever". Andrew called out.
Sarah kept her hands over her mouth firmly so she won't make a noise and continued running until she tripped and when she went to go get up she saw her father with an evil smirk on his face and she screamed.
"I told you i'd get you Sarah if it's the last thing i do". Andrew said coldly.
Sarah then screamed.
*Reality*
Sarah screamed in her sleep making both Dean and Seth jolt out of bed running to her room watching her trash and cry in her sleep, they then moved to her bed and Dean leaned her up as she continued to thrash and cry.
"Sarah, wake up your dreaming wake up sweetheart wake up. Come on wake up". Dean said shaking her.
Seth then began to shake her to till her eyes finally snapped open and she looked around to see her room with her brother and Seth there alive and well so she threw her arms around her brother first crying in his chest, after a few minutes she then threw her arms around Seth burying her face in his neck sobbing a bit.
"You wanna talk about it sweetheart?" Seth asked.
She then pulled away from her uncle looking down so she wouldn't face them.
"Andrew was chasing me and was covered in b-blood, he killed you, Dean, and Uncle Roman then said he'd get me if it's the last thing he did". Sarah said with her voice cracking.
"It's alright now sweetheart me and your brother are right here he won't hurt you without going through us first". Seth assured her.
"That's part of what he said at the store the other part was, that he was my father so i better talk and show him respect or something can easily happen to you guys and Uncle Roman". Sarah continued.
The two men were now pissed they were so pissed they want Andrew's head on a silver platter, Seth sees it's going on 3:30 so Sarah tried to go back to sleep.
"Alright sweetheart why don't you try and go back to sleep now". Seth said.
Sarah then shot her hand out grabbing her brother wanting him to stay with her for the night.
"Please don't go please i'm still a bit scared". Sarah said.
Dean knew if his sister had a nightmare and was scared she wouldn't want to be alone so he climbs in getting comfortable and Sarah lays her head on her brother's chest gripping some of his tank top like she did when she was little he then stroked her hair which always calmed her down and after a few minutes she was fast asleep.
"Were gonna get this asshole if it's the last thing i do". Dean said seriously.
"Whatever you guys need i'll help you 100%". Seth said.
Seth then kissed his niece's head before going back to his room knowing Sarah is in great hands with Dean, he continued to stroke her hair and began humming an old song to her.
"Don't worry Sarah i will always protect you no matter what". Dean muttered.
He then started to doze off going into a deep sleep with his sister curled up next to him as if she were a little girl all over again he was going to do anything and everything in his power to protect his sister at all cost even if it mean drastic measures.