AUTHOR'S NOTE: Hello readers! So we left off at a little cliffhanger in Central Park with Finn and a mysterious guest, let's see who he ran into. Please like, reblog or even comment when you're done, I love to read the thoughts and suggestions about the story. Enjoy chapter three!

'The One That Got Away'

I can't believe who I just ran into, why is she here? How is she here? This can't be happening at all, this is truly a disaster. He doesn't understand how this is all happening, why is this all happening.

'Finn how long as it been; a few years?' He wishes he can just blink his eyes and count to three, hoping this is all a dream but unfortunately it's not. She grabs him and pulls him into a giant hug, and let me tell you that was probably the worst hug of Finn Hudson's life, and that is no understatement.

'Hi..umm…Quinn what are you doing in New York?' Why is she here? This confused Finn more than anything or anyone he hopes for that matter, he left her the day high school ended. And, that was the last time he wished he would ever see her again.

'I came to see you and New Directions, I heard from Burt down at the shop where you used to work that you guys are here touring so I came to see you, I really miss you Finn.' She started to rub his arm seducing him into her old ways but he wasn't going for it at all, in fact Finn had that feeling that someone had punched him really hard in the stomach, the kind that makes you want to throw up but you can't find the nerve to actually do it? Yeah, that was the feeling that he had right now, and it wasn't a good feeling at all.

'Quinn stop, you hurt me more than anyone in my entire life! You can't just expect me to come crawling back to you, it's not going to happen, and I shut out everyone in my life because of you! I don't even know how you can come here and show your face to me, it disgusts me at the thought you want me back and came all this way you are one disappointed and messed up girl. I am not taking you back Quinn, I think it's best if you just leave and never come back.' He was mad, but he was more than mad all the feelings, hurt and disappointment came back into his mind when he spent countless years trying to forget about her, forget the horrible memories. The memories that made him do stupid things in high school. The memories that he wished were all a nightmare, the ones that he wanted to forget for the rest of his life and now they're all flooding back into his mind, just like they happened yesterday but in reality they happened over twelve years ago.

'I hurt you? You hurt me Finn! You never loved me; you just used me as your little door-hanger! I saw the way you looked at girls like Santana, Brittany, and even Mercedes! I was never pretty or skinny enough for you, I had to do something to make myself feel wanted Finn, I needed someone and you weren't there, I did what I had to feel loved, and wanted in that god damn town and that's what I did while you were off getting drunk with Jared and the rest of those junkies!' Is she serious? Yeah Santana, Britt, and Mercedes are smokin' hot but I loved Quinn for her down to earth personality, the way she never pounded on her makeup like all those other girls, and she was the head cheerio so that was a big plus. But, she has the right to come here and accuse me of not loving her? She doesn't realize that he only drank because of how depressed he was, and how he could've changed the way things were but he can't and he never could.

'I never loved you? You're pathetic! Everyone loved you Quinn! You were pretty the natural way; you had a down to earth personality! So don't come here and follow me to say that I never loved you when you were the only girl I have EVER loved in my entire life! I won't stand for this, you need to leave now, I can't even bear to look at you right now, being popular in a small town got to your head and made you think that you were going to leave one day and that everything was just going to disappear from your life but it never will! Those memories will always be there, you can't change what happened and you can't change where you are from. Leave now Quinn before I call the cops for harassment, and if you think I'm kidding, I'm not. I need you to leave from my life, forever.' Truth is I would never call the cops on her I just used it against her for her crazy criminal record, she hates the word police or anything that has to do with the law. Her past has gotten her into some serious trouble, and if she gets into any more trouble, that could be the end of her life.

'Fine I'll leave but you will regret letting me go again Finn Hudson oh yes you will, and let me tell you one thing, I am not finished with you, just for now I am, but I will be back. You will want me back, they always do.' Having she again? This girl is seriously needs to be put into a nut house, but she is wrong about one thing, I will never ever want her back, no matter what happens, Quinn is in my past and I plan to keep it that way.

'That's where you're wrong Quinn, I never let you go, and you let me go.' With that I walked away proud of myself getting all that anger and frustration out of me.

Middle of Central Park

I continue walking around Central Park trying to forget about Finn, why can't I let him go? I'm Rachel Barbra Berry after all, big Broadway star that is independent and doesn't let people interfere with my life. What is so different about this guy? This one guy that smiles crookedly that makes me want to melt into his arms? Or the way he gels his hair into a little spike at the top? Maybe it's the fact that he's a drummer in a band that is pretty good and can sing; after all I need a man that can keep up with me mentally and vocally. Oh my gosh and to top this all off I see him sitting on the benches, he looks really sad.

I decided to go over and see if he was alright he looked like he was crying after all 'Are you okay? I saw you sitting over here and you look like you needed some company.'

'Oh hi Rachel, yeah I'm okay just had an interaction with a girl that kind of made my life hell back there, so things are kind of flooding back to me that I had intended to never come back.' I want him to tell me what happened he had tear marks running down his face, I don't want this moment to end, I just want to wipe off his tears and pull him into my arms.

'Do you want to talk about it?' I have always been the kind of girl that someone can talk to, someone to comfort you when something is wrong. I'm a very good listener.

'Well when I was in high school before I dropped out I had a girlfriend her name was Quinn she was amazing, and she had a down to earth personality. Head cheerleader, I thought I was in love Rachel, I really thought I was but it turned out I was wrong, major wrong. She cheated on me with one of my best friends Puck. I thought my life was over, I pushed everyone away and tried to forget but the memories just kept coming back. I did some things that I shouldn't have, I went out partying, and I drank a lot, experimented with drugs trying to forget about the horrible thing that had just happened to me. I thought I had done something that couldn't be a good boyfriend to her so she had to go cheat on me I really don't know, and the worst part was after I found out, Puck continued to fool around with her and later they started dating. But I just saw her and she accused me of staring at other girls who yeah we're pretty hot but they weren't her. So I kind of yelled at her telling how I got hurt from all she did but then she said that I was bad and she needed someone to 'comfort' her so that's why she did what she did.' I can't believe that I just told her all of this, I just met this girl but it feels like I have known her forever.

'Awe Finn I am really sorry but trust me this girl is not worth anything in your life. If she had the feeling that she needed to cheat on you then she is just messed up in the head. You're a great guy, any girl would be lucky to be with you, and if she had the need to be wanted then you were obviously not meant to be together.' It's true any girl would be great to have him as a boyfriend, including me. What are you saying Rachel? Stop! No boys no matter how cute they are, I can't be sucked into the paparazzi life but who I am kidding I can't get this guy out of my head.

'Thank you Rachel, you're right I am a pretty great guy not to sound conceited or anything but I don't need some girl who ruined my life back in the teenage years make me unhappy now.'

'Yes! That's the spirit Finn, I would love to stay and talk but I really need to get back at work.' I started to walk away when I felt someone grab my arm holding me back.

'Wait, I would really love to see you again maybe we can give each other a call sometime and set up a little date for coffee?' He hands me his number it has a little winking face at the end! He is so cute!

'I would really love that, here's mine. I'll see you soon hopefully Finn.' I held the number in my hand, I can't believe this. His actual phone number, all seven digits with the area code, it wasn't a New York area code, which just proves that he is telling the truth and he is not some guy trying to get with me just for my fame.

'You too Rachel, don't be afraid to just give me a call anytime I could even hook you and some friends up with concert tickets to our next show maybe?' I knew that she could want to do that; she couldn't take her eyes off me at the first concert.

'That's so chivalrous of you, I'm sure they would like that. Goodbye.' I watched as she walked away her beautiful hair in the wind.

'Goodbye.' With that I walked away, Jesse is going to be so mad at me for being so distracted and for being gone so long, my fifteen minute walk in the park turned into an hour long walk, and now that I have his number in my cell phone, I am going to be even more concentrated on him then my work. What am I going to do?