The Raw afterwards featured Melina defending her newly won Divas Championship against the former champ, Natalya. However, due to the incident at the Royal Rumble, the anonymous Raw GM announced just prior to the match that if any one person not involved in the match interfered, they would be suspended on the spot. The match itself was a relatively fast paced, back and forth match. Melina was preparing to hit the Last Call and retain her championship, but made a very costly mistake as she didn't gain enough momentum when she attempted to drive Natalya down into the ground. This would cause her to land on her neck during the powerbomb, leaving Natalya hooking her legs, and Melina with her shoulders on the mat.
The ref counted the 1, the 2, and the 3, the crowd getting to their feet and cheerling loudly, as Natalya had regained the Divas Championship. Immediately after, a replay was shown of the last seconds of the match, this time at a different angle. This angle showed that Melina's shoulders may not have both been on the mat, and Michael Cole was quick to point it out. Natalya held her title up high triumphantly, before being cut off by a loud, shrill "Excuse me!". Vickie Guerrero, her signature scowl stuck on her face as the audience immediately began showing her more and more hatred.
"I said excuse me!" she screamed into the microphone, only provoking louder boos. "I have two pieces of information that you, Natalya, and every other diva should know about."
"I think that 'news' can wait a bit, I'm a little busy right now," Natalya, having just grabbed a microphone, told her off. "Now, I don't wanna see your big porky butt during my celebration."
"I'd watch my mouth if I were you, missy."
"And just why would I do that?"
"Because you're speaking to the new Commissioner of the entire WWE Divas Division," Vickie informed her and the crowd, eliciting a loud chorus of boos, and an incredibly angry look from the third generation Diva. "That covers one piece of news, the other, I think, will surely interest you, Natalya," Vickie said as she began her walk down to the ring. Suddenly, Natalya was attacked by Kelly Kelly, having emerged from the crowd, and was soon joined in the beatdown by Melina. With Natalya on all fours, Kelly hit the springboard K2 on the new Divas Champion as Vickie entered the ring and Melina stared on, holding her neck and laughing at the same time.
"After reviewing the replay, I can confirm that Melina's shoulder was not on the mat during the pinfall." She showed a replay of the situation, and the camera that was not shown on television did indeed show that Melina's shoulder was off the mat. "Because of this, I am nulling the championship change and restarting this match." The ref waited for Natalya to get back to her feet, and after a few moments of stumbling, she managed to stand up, though with aid from the ropes. The ref rang the bell, and Melina immediately ran after Natalya, taking her down with a hard boot to the face. With an evil grin on her face, Melina slowly picked her back, and turned her around. With Natalya locked in a reverse headlock, Melina let loose a loud scream that could be heard throughout the arena, and hit Natalya with a Sunset Split, covering her in the same split-legged position.
Melina got the 1, 2, 3, and with her hand raised, was announced by Justin Roberts, "Still the Divas Champion, Melina!" Kelly stood at the top of the ramp along with Vickie, both smiling and clapping at Melina's title "defense", though Kelly left before Melina could join them.
It was announced that major news regarding the entire divas division would be announced the next morning by Vickie. Time passed, and it was Tuesday morning. The news was announced on , with credit going to Vickie, that all divas would be able to compete on both shows, fitting with the idea that the Divas Championship is interpromotional. This would go into effect on the following SmackDown, as Kelly Kelly, Maryse, and Alicia Fox would take on the team of Kaitlyn, Eve, and SmackDown's newest unannounced Diva. Kelly made her way out first, with both Maryse and Alicia by her side, the audience still not used to her new entrance music. Kaitlyn and Eve were next out to the ring, but they both stopped at the bottom of the ramp, waiting for their mystery partner. To the surprise of Kelly, her partners, and the audience too, the third partner, and SmackDown's newest Diva, was revealed to be Naomi, Kelly's former Rookie on NXT.
Kelly and Naomi started it out in the ring, Kelly staring her former protege down angrily, before taking a slap to the face from Naomi. Kelly, fuming from the blow, tagged in Maryse, and the match began, though it ended soon after, with the debut of her new finisher, Naomi slammed Alicia down with a Michinoku Slam and got the pin. In the lead up to all this, the other divas had taken each other out in usual 6-person tag match fashion. Kelly slipped back in the ring immediately after the match and began attacking Naomi, though she would soon be halted by the screeching of a guitar. Natalya ran down to the ring and took Kelly out with a spear, and soon after locked in the Sharpshooter, making Kelly tap almost immediately. After a few more moments of pain, Natalya let go of her legs and after interacting with some fans, returned backstage. Kaitlyn slipped in and looking down at Kelly, shurgged and mouthed, "Sorry," with a smile.