Hey! Thanks so much for reading. It means a lot to me. I'm not crazy about this chapter. I'm still not sure what im doing with this story yet. I have the main climax part planned out but not sure how to get there. I don't want to make it to short or to long. So please stick with me. Well, I hope you enjoy :)

I do not own Pretty Little Liars.

All I Want

Chapter 3: Round and Round

Spencer Hastings sat at a table in The Apple Rose Grille. She had just gotten of the phone with her annoying mother. Apparently Melissa had another new boyfriend who is amazing and other crap. She was already having a really crappy day and she was not going to some dinner with Ms. Prissy. So she hung up the phone and went to an empty nearby table.

What she really needed was a drink. But she wasn't going down that road again. Just because Toby was back, didn't mean she was going to have an emotional break down again. Never again.

She decided to just have a late lunch, then go home and do homework. When will she finish this homework?

Spencer was engrossed into her thoughts, when she felt someone tap on her shoulder, scaring her.

"I'm sorry I didn't mean to scare you." Toby said sitting down across from Spencer.

"Well, you did! Let me guess, you heard my little phone conversation?" Spencer said annoyed at the presence of Toby.

"Well you were pretty loud."

"You know the only way my mother understands stuff is if it's done by screaming."

"Oh of course. Are you okay?"

"Yeah, why wouldn't I be?"

"You seemed pretty upset on the phone."

"I just haven't had a very good day. And I didn't want to have dinner with Melissa and some stupid guy."

"Does this bad day have anything to do with me?"

"Not everything has to do with you! Why don't you just go back to your table and be annoying there."

"Spencer, whether you like it or not, we need to talk."

"We don't need to do anything! I'm done with this conversation. Ok? So leave."

"I will, but I have one question. Why didn't you tell the girls what actually happened?"

"I didn't tell them because it wouldn't change anything. Or make it better."

"I understand. Can we please try to fix what happened? I miss you and the fun we use to have."

"I don't think it can be fixed. Listen, Toby, I do miss you to. But you need to understand that yesterday at this time; I thought I was never going to see you again. Now all of sudden your back. This is a lot to think about Toby. So please give me time to think and process what has happened before I decide what's going to happen in the future. Give me time."

"Ok, ill give you time. Goodbye Spencer." Toby said getting up from the table and going to his.

"Goodbye Toby." Spencer whispered, putting her head down.

After Toby paid the bill, he looked over at Spencer's table one last time, admiring the way she ate her salad. Then walked out the door.

As Toby walked to his truck, he saw the same guy that stood outside Spencer's house last night. He was walking his way, probably to meet up with Spencer. The guy stopped out side of the window that looks into The Grille, staring at Spencer. Spencer notices him and Groans. Maybe she doesn't like him. He knows who would know: Hanna.

Toby drives over to Hanna's house and knocks on the door. Hanna comes to the door a few moments later, surprised at her visitor.

"Toby! What a surprise." Hanna said letting Toby in.

"Yeah, I came to ask you something." Toby said sitting down in the kitchen.

"What is it?"

"So I was at The Grille earlier today and Spencer showed up. I'm going to skip this part. Then when I was leaving I saw the same guy that was at Spencer's house last night. He saw Spencer through the windows and Spencer saw him to. Then she groaned. What is up between them?"

"He's positive that they belong together. His name is Wren. They met at a bar in Philadelphia. Spencer gave him her number; well he thought that she was asking him to marry her. He has called her and texted her everyday since then. He's become stalkerish. It's kind of scary."

"So, he just is obsessed with her? That's better than what I thought."

"Yep. She hasn't really dated anyone. Sure she meets them then goes out with them, but then she realizes how creepy they are. The one was obsessed with cats. He had a whole shrine dedicated to them."

"Well thanks for answering my question." Toby said, getting ready to leave.

"No problem. Look, Spencer will come around. I know her and she will." Hanna said before Toby left.

Spencer had just left The Grille, when she got a text from Aria.

Hey Spence. I just wanted to say im sorry about this morning. Please come meet me and Emily at the Brew.

Spencer chooses not to reply, but does head to The Brew. It's still Saturday which means she has another day until school. When she gets into her car to meet Aria and Emily, she remembers something. The day she first met Toby.

It was a warm June day when Spencer was lounging at the country club pool with Hanna. They had just finished sophomore year and were excited to be juniors. Spencer decided to go get each of them a smoothie from the drink bar.

When she was on her way there, she accidentally ran in to someone. That person spilling strawberry banana smoothie all over her.

"Watch where you're going! Now I have smoothie all over me!" Spencer screamed at the man.

"I'm so sorry miss! It's my first day working here and I was just trying to take these drinks over to table 4. I didn't see you there because I was worried about spilling these drinks. Which I still did. I'm sorry!" the man with gorgeous blue-eyes said.

"It's ok. It's my fault to. Do you have any towels to help me clean this up?" Spencer said, obviously wanting to know this new waiter.

"Yeah, back this way."

Spencer followed him to the waiting station, looking for paper towels.

"My names Spencer Hastings, by the way." Spencer said after they found the paper towels.

"Toby Cavanaugh. I'm new to town."

"Of all jobs you choose to be a waiter at the country club?"

"Yeah, it pays well. And I would never be able to go to a country club anyway."

"Well, Toby Cavanaugh, I now have a reason to come every day."

"That would be nice, Spencer Hastings."

"I'll see you around. My friend will kill me if im not back." Spencer said about to walk back to Hanna.

"I better see you around!" Toby said as Spencer walked away.

"And you will!" Spencer said turning back around, then walking back to Hanna.

When Spencer got back to Hanna, she had a smile plastered to her face. Hanna of course noticed. She also noticed the smell of strawberry banana.

"Spencer, did you spray the smoothie on you instead of drinking it?"

"I ran into someone."

"Is this person some one you want to see more of?"

"Hopefully."

Spencer smiles to herself. That was a pretty good day.

Spencer parks her car, waking into The Brew. She spots Emily and Aria over by the window.

"Hey guys." Spencer said sitting down beside Aria.

"Thanks for coming." Emily said.

"No problem."

"We wanted to ask you a question. Did Toby cheat on you?" Aria said thinking she solved Spencer's secret.

"What? No! Toby did not cheat on me!" Spencer said shocked that they would think that.

"Then what happened?" Aria said frustrated.

"Nothing happened! Now if that's all you wanted, im leaving." Spencer said walking from her seat and out the door.

"Great. Now what do we do?" Emily said after Spencer left.

"I don't know. What else could've happened?" Aria said confused.

"Do you think Toby would tell us?"

"No. I asked him and he told me to ask Spencer."

"I don't know what to do. I want to help them."

They fell in silence for a few moments, thinking of what to do, when someone came up to them. Wren.

"Hello ladies. Aren't you friends of Spencer's?" Wren said sitting down where Spencer was previously.

"Yes, why?" Emily said eyeing the man up and down.

"Well, I wanted to know what was wrong will her. She's been distant lately, telling me she wants to be on her own."

"Wren she does not like you!" Aria said loudly.

"Yes she does. I know she does."

"No she doesn't!"

"She has a boyfriend!" Emily blurted out.

Aria eyed her curiously.

"What? No she doesn't. Who is this person?"

"His name is Toby. They had broken up, but there back together now. So please leave Spencer alone." Emily said.

"Ok. Well, please tell Spencer that I would love to meet this Toby guy." Wren said obviously hurt.

"Will do. Bye bye." Emily said getting Wren to go away.

"Emily Fields. What did you just do?" Aria said shocked.

"I got rid of Wren." Emily said quietly.

"Spencer's going to kill you." Aria said matter of factly,

"I know."

Spencer decided to go home after The Brew incident. When she got home, she went straight up stairs to her bedroom. If someone was at the door, she was going to ignore them. She needed some Spencer time. When she reached her bedroom, there was a bouquet of flowers waiting on her table.

She walks over to them, reaching for the card.

Spencer, I heard about your boyfriend. I'm very hurt. But I would love if we could have dinner sometime. Including the guy. I will always love you.

Wren.

What boyfriend? Spencer thought to her self. She never told Wren she had a boyfriend. So where did he get this idea? Either way he should leave her alone, which is good.

Spencer hears her phone buzz from her purse and goes over to get it.

Spencer, call me. We kind of told Wren you had a boyfriend.

Emily

So that's why he thinks that she has a boy friend. Should she kill them or thank them?

But wait who is this boyfriend?

Her phone buzzes again.

Spencer, please don't kill us. We said your boyfriend was Toby.

Yeah she is going to kill them.

After Spencer got the text, she called Emily.

"Emily! What did you do?" Spencer screeched over the phone.

"It was an accident! Wren was being annoying and I figured saying you had a boyfriend would help." Emily said softly.

"Well it didn't work. When I got home, flowers were waiting for me. From Wren. He said he was hurt and that he wanted to have dinner with me an the boy friend. There is no boyfriend!"

"Yes there is! Toby! I'm sure if you asked him, he would pretend to be your boyfriend, for a dinner."

"Well, I don't want that. That would be moving 2 steps back ward. I'm not doing that! So forget that!"

"Spencer, please? I think that it would be good for you!"

"No! I'm finally close to moving on, not moving back."

"Think about it, please."

"Fine, I will. Goodbye Emily." Spencer said before hanging up the phone.

Toby sat on the porch, looking up at the stars. Thinking about his life. And how he screwed it up so badly. He remembers when he asked Spencer out on a date for the first time. He was so nervous, he felt like throwing up.

It was the last week of June and Spencer and Toby had been getting pretty close. Everyday she was free and Toby worked, she would go to The Country Club. And on his breaks they would meet up and talk. They talked about everything. From her annoying family to his new motorcycle. Her friends say that they just need to date already. But Spencer doesn't want to ruin a new-found friend.

Toby was having the same feelings. But he decided to just ask her out.

So on the day he had off he called her and told her to meet him at the park.

When she got their, Toby was waiting by the pond.

"Why did you want to meet here?" Spencer asked curiously.

"I wanted to ask you something." Toby said walking towards her with flowers.

"Ok. Why do you have flowers?"

"They are for you. Open the card." Toby said handing her the flowers.

"Spencer, I have thought about you ever since I spilled smoothie all over you. You are incredibly beautiful. Please give me the honor of going out on a date with me? Toby." Spencer read.

Instead of answering with words, she grabs his face and kisses him.

Toby was so happy that day. He couldn't get the feeling of Spencer's lips off his lips for 2 days. He wants that back.

Spencer sat on her bed that night, thinking about every thing. She's finally decided to forget about Wren and Toby. She needs a break. Maybe a break is what will help decide what she wants.