Spencer and Ashley are still at the empty park in front of the statue. Unexpectedly, the girls simultaneously experience flashbacks. Ashley as Spencer sees Spencer the night of the party, after Ashley left. Spencer slammed her door. She's crying uncontrollably. Ashley can once again feel Spencer's pain as deeply as if everything Spencer felt in these moments is happening to her.
Spencer throws herself on her bed her arms flailing about punching her pillows. Then she screamed loudly into one. That's when she noticed her pillows as well as everything in the bed smelled like Ashley and that slut Megan. The smell must have been burned into Spencer's mind because Ashley can smell the two distinct scents of herself and Megan. Next, Ashley could feel Spencer's white hot rage in that moment, as Spencer got up from her bed and began furiously throwing her bedding all over her room and to the floor, where her heart might as well been. Ashley's heart feels like it is literally sinking Ashley's flashback ends with her struggling to stand under the weight of her guilt and self loathing.
Meanwhile, Spencer as Ashley is flashing back to the same night. Spencer sees Ashley after she got home from the party; she can hear Ashley contemplating suicide. Ashley thought "Without Spencer, who would really care if I wasn't here? Dad and Ky would have each other. They're strong enough to make it without me. Without me here they'll grow closer! I don't give a fuck about Christine. Spencer was my reason for living. I don't deserve to live anymore." Then, Spencer sees Ashley as she tries to commit suicide by taking an entire bottle of her anti depressants at once, and washing them down with bourbon, just when Ashley's anguish is about to consume her, Spencer sees Ashley decides she doesn't want to give up on her and Spencer just yet.
She runs to her bathroom and forces herself to through the pills up. Seeing this as Ashley makes Spencer very sad. In that moment, Spencer feels every bit of Ashley's depression. These feelings make her empathetic to Ashley's want to die. The flashbacks are over. The time in each other's bodies, and the ability for them to see what their actions and reactions have done to the other person, have finally driven them through the last road block to their hearts. They now realize how fragile life is. They know the pain being apart has caused. Both girls stand at a distance sobbing, trying to compose themselves before addressing each other.
It doesn't work. So, without coordinating it they run to each other, outstretching their arms for an embrace. Both keep talking at the exact same time. "I'm Sorry!" It's okay!" I understand now!" "I love you" They kiss, but what should be a great feeling accompany the end of their fighting, feels weird. They pull away from the kiss, open their eyes, and are taken aback. Spencer as Ashley "That was weird for you too right" She says hoping Ashley will agree. Ashley as Spencer does agree.
"Kinda like kissing myself." They laugh it off Then, Ashley continues. "We'll try again when we're back in our own bodies." Spencer nods. The girl's turn their attention to the statue. Ashley as Spencer says in a confused tone to the statue. "Why the hell haven't you switched us back?" Spencer interrupts her out of concern. "Be nice we don't want to make it mad…It might turn us into frogs next. Who knows?" Ashley laughs, and proceeds to question the statue without swearing at it. "I thought the way this worked was you make us switch lives so we could see things from each other's perspective? Isn't that the idea? We switch so we can find our way back right?" Not surprisingly the statue didn't respond. Spencer as Ashley decides to take a turn talking to the statue. "She's right. We're back together please switch us back? She said nicely." Ashley as Spencer to her girlfriend, it probably knows everything. If it can show us each other's memories and thoughts it probably has the power to see them for itself." Spencer as Ashley "Maybe we need to go do some research?" Ashley nods then her face lights up as she gets an idea. "We should call Aiden!" Spencer as Ashley is skeptical. "That's your big idea?" Ashley as Spencer "Uh huh, he's a big supernatural buff." Spencer looks at her girlfriend with an intrigued look on her face. "Whatever works!" They leave the park holding hands.