Madison and Skyler arrived back at the pizzeria for Night 3. Markiplier arrived with them.
Ryan: Hello, Star Warriors, and welcome back to Freddy Fazbear's pizza. I had time this morning to recollect my thoughts and come up with what was necessary to win.
Skyler: And that would be?
Other Ryan: We should just check Mangle's Kids Cove, and checking the lights for the other two. Considering they can just jump right next to your door. Cause it doesn't even matter. My time spent finding them is just gonna be power wasted. I just need to very quickly check everything, and we will win.
They walked to the office, got settled in, and the phone rang.
Message: ''Hello, hello? Hey you're doing great! Most people don't last this long.
Ryan: What?
Message: I mean, you know, they usually move on to other things by now. I'm not implying that they died. Th-th-that's not what I meant.
Other Ryan: Of course.
Message: Uh, anyway I better not take up too much of your time. Things start getting real tonight. Uh... Hey, listen, I had an idea: if you happen to get caught and want to avoid getting stuffed into a Toy Golden Freddy suit, uhh, try playing dead! You know, go limp. Then there's a chance that, uh, maybe they'll think that you're an empty costume instead. Then again if they think you're an empty costume, they might try to... stuff a metal skeleton into you. I wonder how that would work. Yeah, never mind, scratch that. It's best just not to get caught.
Madison: Was that his attempt at being competent?
Message: Oh yeah, one more thing. Uh, they just informed me of your experience at the last location. I-I don't remember any specific details, other than...a puppet that was a dark spirit tried to imitate my voice and body, to try and kill you. I want to reassure you, I'm no puppet. My name is Lewis Dawkins, and I hope you have no negative feelings towards the company. Last thing, it was around this time Toy Golden Freddy would start moving. He usually stays in the darker areas of the restaurant, so keep a close eye on any dark spaces in the camera views. Y-you know he's moving if you hear a really low laugh. He'll usually wait by the East Hall Corner before he gets into your office, and then he'll evade the door light. Just keep an eye out for him. Um...Ok, I'll leave you to it. See you on the flip side.
Ryan checked the camera, and when he pulled it down, Nightmare Fredbear was sitting across from the room.
Ryan: AH! FUCK YOU! OH GOD!
Nightmare Fredbear disappeared.
Ryan: WHAT THE FUCK?! WHAT THE FUCK, OK?! NOT OK!
Madison smacked him in the face.
Ryan: Ow. What was that, Madison?
Madison: You were panicking. I had to calm you down.
Other Ryan: What'd you see?
Ryan: I don't even know. It looked like Freddy, but it was gold and Nightmarish.
Skyler: Wait. Nightmare Fredbear?
Ryan: Y-yeah. I guess. Wait. How do you know what it was? Did it have something to do with that thing with the plushtrap?
Madison: Yes. It's nothing to worry about. He won't hurt us.
Ryan: Yay!
The Star Warriors continued their shift, until a deep laughing was heard.
Other Ryan: What is that?
Ryan checked the show stage and saw Toy Golden Freddy was gone.
Ryan: Woah woah. What the fuck?! No! No! No, Toy Golden Freddy's gone! He left! He flippidy do da left!
The bell gong was heard, and ended the shift.
Ryan: Yes! We did it! Thank you so much for coming, and as always, I will see you, in the next shift. Bye bye!
At the hospital, in Susan's room, something began to occur in her mind. A certain dark energy began to swirl through her conscience.
Deep voice: I have returned...
The Star Warriors arrived back for Night 4.
Ryan: Welcome back. Let's continue our shift, shall we? Now I think I have a way we can get rid of Toy Golden Freddy this time.
Madison: How?
Ryan: When he's right outside the door, shut it, and wait for him to leave.
Other Ryan: Thanks for the sage advice, Captain Obvious.
They got to the office, settled in, and Lewis called.
Lewis message: Hello, hello? Hey! Hey, wow, day 4. I knew you could do , hey, listen, I may not be around to send you a message tomorrow. *banging sound* It's-It's been a bad night here for me. Um, I-I'm kinda glad that I recorded my messages for you *clears throat* uh, when I , hey, do me a favor. *bang bang* Maybe sometime, uh, you could check inside those suits in the back room? *bang bang* I'm gonna to try to hold out until someone checks. Maybe it won't be so bad. *bang bang* Uh, I-I-I-I always wondered what was in all those empty heads back there. *chime plays*. You know...*moan* oh,no-*noises followed by an animatronic screech and static*.
Funtime Foxy leapt into the room and screamed
Ryan: Ah! Fuck you!
Skyler knocked her away.
Markiplier: Oh, oh oh! I didn't check Mangle's Kids Cove. I was worried about that guy. He died!
Madison: We know.
At the hospital, the darkness in Susan's mind grew stronger and stronger. Suddenly, Susan's eyes opened. They were dark black with small white pupils in the middle like pinpricks. She stumbled out of her bed, looking around the hospital, crashing into the walls. She saw the doctor and slowly approached her.
Doctor: Susanna? How are you walking?
Susan held up his hand, and the doctor began grabbing his throat, as he was lifted into the air. Susan spoke in a deep, low voice.
Susan: Where are the Star Warriors?
Doctor: They're at the new Fazbear and Friend's pizza!
Susan: Thank you. They will be my next victims.
Doctor: Next?
Susan twisted her hand, breaking the Doctor's neck.
At the pizza place, the Star Warriors, Other Ryan, and Ryan had finished their shift. As they were departing the pizzeria. A darkness tornado began swirling around them. They saw the dark-eyed Susan float down and land in front of them, dressed in her clothes again.
Madison: Susanna! You're ok!
Madison ran towards her daughter, only for a sonic wave to knock her back.
Skyler: Susan?
Susan: Susan's gone. Do you remember me? I'm back!
Other Ryan: What is going on?! What is happening?!
Amethyst: Susan! What are you talking about?!
Madison: Do you not remember me? The very being destroyed by my brother made of light?
Skyler: Brother made of...
Madison and Skyler gasped.
Skyler: It's Plushtrap!
Susan: There you go-o-o...
Susan's eyes reverted to normal.
Susann: Mom! Help me! Please!
They reverted back to dark black.
Plushtrap: Silence! This body is mine!
Ryan: Why?! Can somebody explain this to me?!
Susan shot darkness into Ryan and Other Ryan's mind, giving him the information.
Ryan: Oh, we get it.
Madison: Susan! Fight back! Don't let Plushtrap take over!
Susan lifted her hand, and shadow creatures began to form, before morphing into dark copies of the Star Warriors.
Skyler: ryan and other ryan. Stay back. We'll handle this.
Ryan: No problem!
Madison and Skyler drew their weapons, and the darkness copies did the same.
Madison: Ruh-oh.
Madison: Stand together. Don't let them separate us.
Shadow Madison slammed its Sword into Madison, crashing through the street. She pulled herself up. The two of them leapt towards each other, clashing sword. Madison punched through Shadow Madison's head, but it reformed around her fist, and Shadow Garnet kicked her into a wall.
Skyler and her Shadow copy clashed spears, and Skyler soon bisected her copy.
Skyler: Ha ha!
The copy then morphed into two Shadow Skyler. Skyler drew another sword.
Skyler: I hate fighting me.
Susan slowly approached the hiding Ryan, who rose from his hiding place, standing to face Susan.
Ryan: Plushtrap. Let Susan go.
Susan formed a dark energy ball in her hand.
Ryan: I said...
Susan threw the dark energy ball.
Ryan: LET HER GO!
Two blades extended from his elbows across his arms, creating two forearm blades. He blocked the dark blast, and deflected it towards the shadow copies. This caused them to all be destroyed and broken apart.
Skyler: Huh?
The blades retracted into Ryan's elbows.
Madison: What did...how did you...huh?
Ryan: I suppose it's time I revealed our true identity. Our name ain't really Ryan and Other Ryan. My name...
His entire body glowed blue, and Ryan and Other Ryan fusion into one. His hair changed to a dark blue, his skin became turquoise, and he wore dark blue sweatpants, and a bright blue tank top.
Ryan:...is Aquamarine.
Madison: He's a Star Warrior?
Aquamarine: Yeah, I have an Aquamarine on the back of my neck. Never mind that. We have to figure out how to get that Puppet out of Steven.
The three star warriors turned to face the possessed Susan. Skyler pulled out her Sword, Madison drew her stinger, and Aquamarine drew his arm blades.
Plushtrap: It is time for your demise.
All three leapt forward, but all got blasted back by a sonic wave. Madison jumped forward with a Sword strike, where as Susan evaded it, and delivered quick blows to her stomach, blasting her away with a darkness shockwave. Skyler tried to swing a sword at her, but she grabbed the sword and elbowed her away. Aquamarine attacked with his arm-blades, and Susan dodged the attacks and swept him off his feet. He walked over Skyler, pinned her to the floor and charged up darkness in her hand.
Plushtrap: It's over!
Plushtrap forced it towards Skyler, but her own hand suddenly stopped him.
Skyler: What?
Susan: I won't...let you...hurt...My Aunt!
Susan began attacking herself, punching herself in the gut and face, beating herself up.
Susan: Get out of my body!
Plushtrap: Never! You're mine!
Susan screamed as a large amount of light built up from within her. Plushtrap was expelled from her body, and Nightmare Fredbear appeared from Susan's stomach as the teenage girl fell unconscious.
Plushtrap: Nightmare Fredbear! But how why?
Nightmare Fredbear: I guess neither of us were entirely dead.
Plushtrap and Nightmare Fredbear began to fight, firing energy at each other, and wrestling along the ground. The Star Warriors grabbed the unconscious Susan.
Aquamarine: She's unconscious, but she'll live.
Plushtrap and Nightmare Fredbear began to infuse with each other, swirling around each other, creating a yin-yang symbol as the two fired light and dark symbols different directions. Nightmare Fredbear gained the advantage, infusing light into the Plushtrap.
Nightmare Fredbear: In the words of a powerful warrior...
Nightmare Fredbear took Plushtrap into a dark-light energy ball, aiming it at the rising sun.
Nightmare Fredbear: Skadoosh.
He threw Plushtrap and the light energy into the sun, destroying him and burning him down.
Plushtrap: AAAAAHHHHHH!
Nightmare Fredbear: It's finished.
Nightmare Fredbear saw Susan's body, and realized something.
Nightmare Fredbear: She's not unconscious.
Aquamarine: What?
Nightmare Fredbear: She's entered a death-like sleep. From which she will never awaken. Only my life force can reawaken her.
Skyler: We can't ask you to do this.
Nightmare Fredbear: I can. Goodbye.
Nightmare Fredbear infused his essence into Susan leaving a yellow husk with the head slouched over. Susan suddenly awoke from her death sleep, and saw everything around her.
Susan: Where am I?
Madison: Susanna!
Susan: You're back!
Madison, and Skyler all embraced Susan in a massive hug.
Madison: You get in here too, Ryan and Other Ryan!
Aquamarine: Naw, come on! This is a you thing and...
Madison shapeshifted her arm and drew Aquamarine into the hug as well.
Aquamarine: Well, guess we're hugging.
After the hug was over, the Star Warriors had a talk with Aquamarine.
Skyler: We can't thank you enough for your help.
Madison: What'll you do now?
Aquamarine: Probably go back to my original job.
He shifted back into Ryan and Other Ryan.
Ryan: Entertaining youtubers for our life span.
Ryan and Other Ryan then slowly warped away.
Madison: They're mimicking humans now.
Skyler: How will we know who to trust?
Madison: We will just know.
Susan: So, what do we do now?
Madison: Anyone want lunch?
Everyone started laughing. Even Madison.
THE END