"How did he find us?" Caleb asked his little brother after they faded back to their apartment.
"But it wasn't him. Do you think he still may be injured?" James asked. Caleb shrugged as he paced the floor in their two bedroom apartment.
"Caleb."
"Yeah?"
"Stop pacing or you'll put a hole in the floor."
Caleb stopped and kept thinking. "We can't keep running from him, James."
"Yes we can. We've been doing that for the last how many years."
"James, at some point, he's going to catch up to us."
"Maybe we should just tell Leo who we really are."
"No!" Caleb told James.
"And why not? That's our best hope right now!" James told him.
"So you're suggesting we go in there, tell him who we really are, and expect him to be all happy?" Caleb asked.
James frowned and shrugged. "I was happy when I saw him."
Caleb sighed and went and sat by his little brother. "I know you were bub. I'm just afraid of us getting close with him again, only for him to break his promise again."
Piper hadn't even tried to go to bed since the boys left. She was in the kitchen cleaning anything that she could. Pots, pans, dishes, chairs. Nothing was off limits.
"You still up?" she heard James ask.
She looked around and he soon faded in behind her.
He tapped her on her shoulder, causing her to jump. "Don't scare me like that!"
"Sorry. Are you alright? I know that everything we told you was a lot to take in."
She brushed back her hair and nodded her head.
"Um, yeah. Where's Caleb?" she asked.
"He went to talk to the Elders about our little friend. He should be here soon."
"Well, since your here, you should at least stay for breakfast." she offered. "Um, sure." he said.
He sat down at the small kitchen table while Piper went over to the coffee pot.
"Where were you and Caleb born? If you don't mind me asking."
"It's alright. We were born here in San Francisco."
Piper nodded and walked back over with two cups of coffee.
"James, I wanna know how you and Caleb know Leo." Piper told him. James looked up at her with begging eyes.
He couldn't tell her. He couldn't face the loss again. He was perfectly fine with acting like strangers with Leo.
"Pi-" "Morning Piper. Oh, hey James. What are you doing here?" Paige asked as she entered the kitchen. She was wearing a pink top and black pants.
"I'm...uh...I'm here to see if you would like to go have breakfast with me." he said.
Paige smiled and nodded. "I would love to. Just let me go grab my purse." she said before leaving.
"Thanks for the coffee Piper." James said and stood up.
Caleb sat in his old Chevy truck, looking at a letter. It was an old letter, but it was worth keeping track of. Caleb seemed to read it whenever he felt lost. After reading it over a few times, he hopped out of the truck and up the steps of the Halliwell manor.
The Elders had told him to go talk to the sisters, that they could help him.
He took a deep breath and raised his hand to knock on the door. But, before his hand ever touched the door, it opened wide open.
He saw his little brother and Paige.
"James?" Caleb questioned.
"Oh, hey Caleb. What are you doing here?" James asked.
"I came to talk to the sisters. What are you doing?"
"I'm going to go get breakfast with Paige." he smiled before the two walked past Caleb and to Paige's light green Volkswagon beetle.
"What do you mean you saw me in your premonition?" Leo asked his sister in law.
"I don't know. I just did. You were in a cemetery with James and Caleb. Some guy shot you with lightning."
"That doesn't explain why you saw us?" Leo told her.
"Leo, what does the song Buffalo Girls mean to you?" Phoebe asked.
Leo froze. "W-why do you ask?" he asked her, trying to act cool.
"Just answer the question."
"Phoebe! Leo!" they heard Piper yell.
Leo grabbed Phoebe and orbed downstairs.
They orbed right into the living room, right in front of Caleb and Piper.
"So you're a whitelighter?" Caleb asked Leo.
Phoebe gave Piper a confused glance.
"Caleb, what's your last name?" Leo asked him.
"It doesn't matter." Caleb told him.
"Actually it does. I mean, is it Robert? That's what James claims as his last name." Piper told him.
Phoebe wanted to protect Caleb. To tell Piper and Leo to leave him alone, but it didn't seem like he needed protecting. He stood there, unaffected by how intimidating Piper and Leo tried to be.
"Robert is James middle name." Caleb told them.
"What's his real name then?" Piper asked.
"His name is James. My name is Caleb. We've already been over this." He smirked.
Leo walked over to Caleb and pointed at him. "Listen here buddy, we need to know why you've lied to us."
"Easy man, no need for pointing."
"Caleb..." Phoebe said softly.
"My name is Caleb Joseph Wyatt."
Piper and Phoebe looked over at Leo who stood there in shock.
"No, it can't be." Leo said.
"It is. How's it going big brother?"
