Casey heard the doorbell ring at least half a dozen times before she made it to the door and answered it. "That was one hour and five minutes," she snapped. "Ever hear of punctuality?"

"Like you've never been late before," Olivia snapped.

"I have," Casey agreed. "But…you know what? Shut up. Don't blame me for this." She turned and walked inside, leaving the door open.

"And if I don't?" Olivia challenged as she leaned down and kissed Casey gently, unzipping Casey's skirt at the same time.

Casey kissed her passionately. "Not here. I'm not going to lose my virginity in my living room. Are you nuts?" She pulled back and walked upstairs knowing Olivia was close behind. Pausing in the doorway, she turned to her girlfriend. "Is it gonna hurt?" she asked, her voice barely audible.

"I'm going to be really gentle, okay honey? I'll be slow and gentle." Olivia held Casey's gaze. "Are you sure you're ready?" She closed and locked the bedroom door. "Lay down."

Casey did as she was told, biting her bottom lip in anticipation. There was still time to stop this if she wanted to, but she knew that she was ready. "I know I'm ready," she said out loud.

Olivia began by slowly unbuttoning Casey's shirt, then unhooked her bra. "Are you sure you want to do this? We don't have to have sex. I'll still love you even if-"

Casey was getting really tired of hearing Olivia lecture her. Biting Olivia's lip as hard as she could, Casey looked into her eyes. "I know I'm ready, okay? I'm ready."

"Okay. Just tell me if I hurt you." Olivia walked her fingers slowly down Casey's body and tickled her inner thigh. After asking Casey to lay on her back, she gently slid one finger between her legs and inside of her.

Casey watched her and smiled softly. True to her word, Olivia was being gentle and slow, and Casey appreciated that. "Olivia? I heard somewhere that if you use a condom it doesn't hurt so much. Not that you're hurting me," she quickly added.

"That's if you're having sex with a guy. Or if you're using a strap-on, which I'm not going to use on you until at least our tenth time. But for now, I am not going to use a condom." Olivia kissed her gently.

Casey kissed back and laid back down. "Oh. Okay. You can continue now."

Olivia chuckled and resumed what she had been doing. After a couple of minutes, she added another finger.

Casey squirmed underneath her after another ten minutes. It didn't hurt; it was more of a tingly feeling that she felt in her lower belly downwards. "Olivia," was the only thing she could whimper.

"I know," Olivia whispered. "You're doing really well baby. Don't hold back. Cum for me."

It only took one more stroke of Olivia's fingers to drive Casey to breaking point. Closing her eyes, she buried her face into the pillow and tried not to scream. She could have never imagined that anything could feel that wonderful.

Once she caught her breath and her body stopped shaking, she pulled Olivia closer to her and wrapped her arms around her neck. "I love you," she murmured against Olivia's lips. "That was just…wonderful. And it didn't hurt."

"Well I'm glad it didn't hurt. You know that I would never hurt you on purpose. Not verbally, physically, or any other way."

Casey smiled and hugged her. Hugging was romantic to Casey; she didn't know why she felt that way, but she did know that it was comforting. "Are you staying the night?" She paused. "Will your mom let you?"

"I need to go home and get some things. My mom has a new boyfriend, and I bet she's at his place. I'll be back as soon as I can."

Casey watched Olivia get dressed and smiled. Tonight would definitely be fun.