Chapter Four: Past Loves and Second Chances
This chapter isn't very Finn friendly, don't get me wrong, I love Finn, but I needed him to be an asshole in this story, and I thought that he would sort of act this way if he found out Rachel chose a girl over him. So, if you're a big Finn fan, proceed with caution in this chapter.
It's been two weeks now, since the kissing incident and Faith had been trying to get a hold of Rachel ever since she told her off in the glee club classroom, she had been calling the brunette at least ten times or more a day, texting her almost twice as much, but it was futile.
It seems as though Quinn's plan worked like a charm, Rachel hadn't been anywhere near as enthusiastic as she had been two weeks prior, she barley even wants to sing in glee club anymore and when she does it lacks her usual spark of majesty.
Rachel's mood had been so sour lately; she wasn't as annoyingly talkative as she would usually be during glee rehearsals or even raised her hand once either. She has been feeling her phone buzz for the tenth time that day, Rachel was so flustered with Faith's constant texts, that she just turned her phone off, and put it back in her pocket and left for the lunch room.
On her way though, she run into Quinn and her cheerleader followers, who upon seeing Rachel, all threw slushies' at her. She was covered head to toe in slush, so she did the only thing she could think of, she run off crying, heading to her only sanctuary in the school, the choir room.
Finn had seen what his girlfriend Quinn had done to Rachel, and went to go comfort her. 'Rachel can be really sensitive; I'll make her feel better.' He thought to himself as he followed the brunette into the choir room.
When he enters the room, he hears her bawling her eyes out to someone, but can't hear the other person. 'Hmm, wonder who she's talking to?'
Rachel had heard someone come in, but ignored them, cause right now she really needed to hear her father's love and compassion.
She had called her dad Harim as soon as she had gotten in the glee room. "What happened honey?" Hiram asks worried. Hearing her father's worried tone of voice, Rachel decides to just tell him everything, from the constant calls and texts from Faith that she will never answer, to Quinn and her flunkies dumping cups full of slush all over her.
"Got to go, love you, see you when I get home, bye." Rachel told her father before hanging up.
After she hung up her cell, she realized it was Finn who had followed her. He was looking at her with a puzzled look on his dopey face. 'Good lord, I bet he thought I was talking to myself, he was never very bright, what did I ever see in him?' Rachel thinks to herself, inwardly sighing at having to deal with another ex.
"What are you doing here Finn; I'm really not in the mood to talk to someone, least of all you." Rachel tells him with a hint of anger in her voice.
"Hey Rachel, I just wanted to make sure you were ok." Finn says sincerely.
"Why should you care, it's your girlfriend who slushies' me almost every day, and you say nothing to her!" Rachel practically screams at him.
"Believe it or not, I do care Rach." She cringed when she heard that nickname, that's what Faith would call her and even though she knows it was all a lie, it feels odd to have someone else use Faith's nickname for her, almost wrong in a way.
Not getting an immediate response, Finn asks the question he really wants to know. "Who were you talking to, are you still dating Faith? You know she's just using you." He asks her with a hurt expression, his voice heavily laced with jealousy.
"What's it to you, we're not together and haven't been for quite some time, so you have no right to be jealous. I'm not yours Finn!"
After hearing that, Finn starts to get really pissed and storms towards Rachel with a look of pure rage etched into his features. He grabs Rachel by the arm. "What? Come on Rachel, you're not even gay! What are you doing, going for anyone who might love you, huh!? What did you do, fuck her just to keep her lying cheating ass!?" Finn screams at her.
Rachel looks at Finn flabbergasted, 'How dare he! He's just mad that he doesn't have a plan B girl when Quinn decides to cheat on him again.'
Rachel wrenches her arm from Finn's grip on her, rares back and slaps him as hard as she can, leaving an angry red hand print on his cheek. She was seething after that comment. "For your information, Finn, even though everything Faith said was a lie, she was a heck of a lot better to me than you ever were!" Rachel yells back at him. "She at least would listen to me and never seemed bored with what I had to say!" She added, folding her arms across her chest, but Finn wasn't going to accept that she didn't want him anymore.
Before Rachel could storm out, Finn grabbed her by the arm, yanking her back towards him, and pushes her against a wall. He looks into Rachel's frightened but angry eyes. "Don't scream Rach. I still love you, I made a big mistake breaking up with you, and you're the only one I want, not Quinn." Finn tells her softly in contradiction to the strong hold he has on her.
He then proceeds to forcibly kiss Rachel, shoving his tongue into her mouth. Rachel was caught off guard by the unwanted kiss, but as soon as she felt his tongue forcibly enter her mouth, she kneed him in the groin as hard as she could…_
Faith was tired of getting ignored, so when this all first began, she put in for a transfer to William McKinley High, so that Rachel would have to talk to her, well eventually. The transfer went through, so Faith was now the new high school student at McKinley. 'Took long enough, but what if she's already found someone else or gotten back together with that Flinn guy?' She thinks as she enters the school.
'Hmm, I wonder if I will have any classes with Rachel?' Faith thinks as she gets her class schedule from the school secretary.
Faith had been to four classes and had not seen hide nor hair of Rachel anywhere. As soon as the bell rang, signaling it was lunch time, she smiled a little. 'Rachel has to be in the cafeteria, hopefully she'll let me explain everything, like the fact I'd never seen that whore before.' As Faith's heading towards the lunch room after putting her stuff in her locker, she hears a muffled scream come from the choir room.
What she sees when she enters the room, was a sight she never wanted to see. Finn had Rachel pinned to the wall, sloppily kissing her, but Rachel didn't look like she was into it at all. She looked way beyond pissed and kneed him in the groin, hard.
"Oh God Rachel, why'd you do that!?" Finn asks, gasping for air from the immense pain in his groin. Neither Rachel or Finn had heard Faith come in, he was too busy trying to kiss Rachel and she was too busy kneeing him as hard as she could, glowering at him.
After Finn got his breath back, he got up and shoved Rachel roughly against the wall. "You know, you should be happy that someone like me would even want to be with an annoying loser like you! Quinn was right; you think you're better than everyone else! Well here's a reality check, you're not anything special, your dreams of becoming a singer on Broadway is never gonna come true and you'll just be another Lima loser, while I'm a pro quarterback in the NFL." Finn tells her in a cocky tone, softly slapping her cheek, like she was an ignorant child.
Upon hearing Finn's degrading remarks towards her Rachel, Faith saw red and attacked him. She pulled him away from Rachel, threw him as hard as she could to the floor and started kicking the shit out of him, yelling the entire time. "HOW DARE YOU TALK TO HER LIKE THAT, I OUGHT TA CUT OUT YOUR FUCKING TONGUE, YOU WORTHLESS SACK A SHIT!" Faith screams at the top of her lungs as she continues to beat Finn to death.
Mr. Schue was not that far from the choir room, so he was the first to hear Faith's enraged screams. He ran into the room as fast as he could, and saw a bruised and battered Finn lying in a heap on the floor.
"What's going on in here?!" Mr. Schue yells, rushing over to restrain Faith. When he had Faith restrained, he looked to his left and saw Rachel huddled in the corner, sobbing uncontrollably with finger mark bruises on her arm.
Finn groaned and tried to get up only to fall flat. "That worthless excuse for a football player just totally degraded Rachel, and then patted her cheek like she was a damn child!" Faith spat in Finn's direction. "Probably more, but I didn't get here fast enough!" She adds.
Mr. Schue turned towards Rachel and asks her if what Faith said was true, she just nodded her head, and then tucked her legs underneath her chin, her body shaking from the sting of Finn's mean words.
The glee teacher let go of Faith and walked over to Finn, picking him up by the collar of his shirt, dragging him to the nurse, and then turned his head back in the girl's direction and yelled. "Detention all of you!"
Rachel stands up extremely upset with Mr. Schue's verdict. "What!?, I was the one backed into a corner to have Finn shove his tongue down my throat, then insulted me after I kneed him effectively telling him where he stood with me. I was just defending myself!" Rachel huffs, not wanting to be stuck in detention with both her ex's.
"I'm sorry Rachel, but there is a no tolerance policy for violence here, you know that." Mr. Schue told Rachel.
"Fine, but I still think I'm innocent." Rachel pouted, folding her arms across her chest.
When Mr. Schue left, Faith slowly walks towards Rachel, as not to upset her any more than she is now. She gets over to the wall, casually leaning against it. "So… guess we got detention after school today." Faith says with faux nonchalance, but her heart was beating frantically in her chest.
As soon as Rachel registered that Faith was beside her, she stiffened. "Yeah, no thanks to you going all Xena on Finn. For your information, I can take care of myself you know!" Rachel replied hotly.
Faith shuffles even closer to Rachel, nudging her with her elbow. "Come on, ya can't give me the cold shoulder forever babe."
Moving to get away from the heat and feelings that Faith still invoked in her and wanting to ignore all those feelings and give Faith a piece of her mind, Rachel tares into her. "Yes I can, and I will as long as I want. Didn't you get enough out of humiliating me by tricking me into loving you!?" Rachel yelled, tears streaming down her face.
Faith pulls a struggling Rachel, who's beating her chest, towards her and whispers "Shhh, everything's going to be ok now, I'm here, and I ain't leavin, not now not ever. It wasn't a prank, if it was, then why would I be doin everythin in my power ta get a hold a ya?" Faith soothes. "I fucking transferred schools ta be with ya." She adds, whispering to Rachel reassuringly. 'I hope she believes me, I've been going nuts without her.' Faith thinks smiling faintly, feeling Rachel relent, burrowing her head further into Faith's ample chest, continuing to sob.
Once the other girl stops crying, she turns until her eyes meet Faith's and what she sees in the other girl's caramel colored watery eyes is nothing but pure love with a hint of protectiveness. Seeing Faith looking at her with silent tears running down her cheeks, showing her vulnerability, Rachel was slowly starting to believe that Faith truly cared for her, and maybe she was telling the truth.
"I'd like to believe you, but I don't know if I can trust you. I'm still not sure if this is just another prank." She tells her honestly, pulling out of the embrace.
Faith didn't know what to say, so she just nodded her head, accepting the fact that it's going to take some work to get her beloved back. "Alright, then can we start again as friends?" she asks grasping for straws at this point.
"Ok, friends it is, for now." Rachel agrees, sticking her hand out for Faith to shake.
Shaking her head, Faith grabbed Rachel's offered hand and gave it a firm shake, sealing their friendship. "So, does this friendship come with benefits?" Faith asks wiggling her eyebrows, and then laughs at the glare Rachel sent her way.
"No, just friends, nothing else, I probably shouldn't even give you a second chance to be anything to me sine you've been dating Santana for three months!" Rachel growls out towards the end.
Putting her hands up surrender. "Hey, no need ta get flustered and here's a piece of information ta think about, I didn't know who Santana was till ya pointed her out ta me in that restaurant in Columbus. Since you seem ta be so smart how does that add up if I'd only known about her till only a few weeks ago?" Faith throws back.
Rachel had never really stopped to think that the time frame didn't really add up at all, too heartbroken to even think. "Oh my God! Santana was on a date with Brittany that day, I'm so stupid!" Rachel exclaims just as they heard the bell ring for their next class.
"Yeah, well while ya stew in your stupidity, I'll be in Biology class, see ya whenever." Faith sneers as she leaves a contemplative Rachel behind. 'Even if she does finally realize I was tellin the truth, I ain't letting her off that easily, let her stew in her guilt fer awhile.' thinks Faith, getting her books from her locker for her next class.
Rachel was sitting in History class thinking over the events of the last few weeks, realizing she was too quick to shut Faith out. 'I should have known Quinn would do something evil like this to get back at me for taking Finn from her last year! I broke up with the only person that truly cared for me; I have to make things right no matter what it takes!' Rachel thinks to herself, she was brought from her thoughts when the bell rang, meaning detention, and then glee practice afterwards.
Rachel, Faith, and Finn were all sitting in detention together, Faith and Rachel glaring hard at Finn, while in turn he glares hard at both of them. "I can't believe you would pick this slut over me Rachel!" Finn snarls.
"Hey dick wad, why don't ya shut your cocksuckin mouth, fors I beat the shit outta you again!" Faith grits out, flipping Finn off.
"Fuck you, slut!" Finn screams his face red with embarrassment at being beaten by a girl.
"No thanks, I don't fuck dumbass jocks like you who think they're better than they really are and I'd rather gouge my own eyes out fer I'd ever think of fucking a guy with a baby dick like yours." Faith calmly replies, which enrages Finn even more.
"You know what you filthy little lesbian whore, my dick is huge and it'd turn you straight if I gave you the pleasure of fucking you." Was Finn's cocky reply.
Faith had seen Mr. Schue coming in the classroom out of the corner of her eye before Finn made his very vulgar remark, so she played it up to get the bastard into even more trouble. Faith starts sobbing really hard. "I can't believe you would say something like that, just because I said I didn't want to go out with you." Faith says continuing to sob.
"Finn Hudson! Principal's office now!" Mr. Schue yells upon hearing Finn's extremely vulgar remark towards a seemingly distraught Faith.
Rachel turns towards Faith, giving her a curious look. "He never asked you out."
Faith just chuckles. "Yeah, I know, but I saw the teacher comin, so I played it ta my advantage. Got his cocky ass in trouble, no guy should ever talk ta a girl like that."
"Yes, but you started it and he's the one to get expelled probably, I don't think it's right even if he may have deserved it."
"What the hell you talkin about, I meant he shouldn't a talked ta you like he did, not me. Hell, I know I deserved those crude remarks, but that jackass needs to get it through his thick fuckin skull, that you're my girlfriend, not his."
"I never said I was your girlfriend, remember?, We agreed we were going to just be friends for now, but with a convincing act like that, I should probably rethink that. I thought I was the only person able to produce crocodile tears at will."
"Fine, whatever, let's just get through the rest of detention, then we'll be outta each other's hair ok?"
"Faith, I didn't mean to hurt your feelings…" Rachel starts, but gets cut off mid-sentence by Faith.
"I don't have feelings, I'm a cold heartless bitch that coned ya into loving me remember?" Was her cold reply.
After that, they just sat there in an uncomfortable silence until the bell rang signaling it was time for Rachel to get to glee practice, but what she didn't know was that Faith had signed up with Mr. Schue earlier that day, in hopes of getting to see her.
When everyone was seated and Mr. Schue came in, and Rachel noticed Faith walking in behind him. 'What is she doing here?' "Hello everyone, I'd like you all to meet our new member of the glee club, Faith Lehane." He announced, motioning to Faith to take a seat. She chose to sit in the back, far away from Rachel, folding her arms over her chest.
Faith was pissed that it took her transferring schools to get Rachel to finally believe that she didn't kiss Santana willingly, nor had she been dating her behind Rachel's back and she was still upset with their argument in detention.
Disheartened by Faith's obvious choice to ignore her by sitting in the back opposed to sitting beside her, Rachel decided that she probably should give Faith some space to let her anger dissipate.
Faith has always had issues with entrusting her heart to someone, because in her experience people will always let you down and right now she wasn't sure if she was willing to put her heart out there for Rachel to possibly break again.
Faith's life had never been easy, her mom was a drug addict who would always beat her in her inebriated state, she was very young, but old enough to remember, and she was twelve when one of her mom's dealers tried to rape her. She barely got out without anything happening.
Her parents slit up when she was three, so she didn't remember her father, turned out he was a really nice guy, who married someone he thought was perfect, turned out he was wrong. Faith had always thought that he never wanted her, but the truth was, he'd been looking for her ever since her mother had in a since kidnapped her.
When she went to the cops after the attempted rape, they found out that she was the missing daughter of a cop in Lima Ohio, so they called him, telling him that his long lost daughter was alive and in Boston.
David Lehane showed up in Boston and as soon as he saw his daughter, he wrapped her in a bear hug and started crying, he had thought he would have never seen her again and was so happy to be holding his precious daughter in his arms. Faith stiffened as soon as he hugged her to him, in her experience living with her mom, never trust anyone especially men, and she did not trust this strange man, so, she shoved him off her.
"Who the fuck do you think you are, get your fucking mitts off me perv!" She yelled.
Flabbergasted at his daughter's crude language, "I'm your father Faith, and I've been searching for you ever since your mom kidnapped you." He told her, hugging her again.
"Faith, FAITH!" Mr. Schue yelled trying to get her attention.
She looks up suddenly, asking "Huh?"
Mr. Schue just shook his head looking in her direction. "I asked you if you would please pick a song to sing for everyone, we need to know how well you can sing, to know where to place you in our competitions." He asked Faith again.
Everyone was looking at her, intrigued to see if she could actually sing, she also noticed the heartbroken look on Rachel's face, and decided to pick a song that might win her back. 'I'm tired of living safe behind this damn wall, I'm gonna show her that I can truly love someone and let em love me back.'
Faith walked up to Mr. Schue after he addressed her. 'I hope he lets me do this.' She thought. Faith motioned for him to lean in closer so she could whisper her request, so no one would hear her plan "Mr. Schue, would you mind if I sang a song to Rachel, she broke up with me cause of a misunderstanding and I was hopin this would be a good way to win her back, but I was also thinking it could be like my audition for glee also, is that cool?" She whispers.
Mr. Schue nods his head and addresses the glee club. "Alright everyone, Faith will be singing for us today." He motions to Faith to get ready. "Whenever your ready Faith."
Faith motioned to the band to start the music, she picked:
"I Don't Believe You" by P!nk"
I don't mind it
I don't mind at all
It's like you're the swing set
And I'm the kid that falls
It's like the way we fight
The times I've cried
Faith looks into Rachel's eyes as she sings this part, letting her know she's actually cried over her.
We come to blows
And every night
The passion's there
So it's got to be right,
Right?
(Chorus)
No I don't believe
When you say don't come around here no more
I won't remind you
You said we wouldn't be apart
Faith walks over to where Rachel is sitting and kneels in front of her, holding her hand out for Rachel to grab, and smiles, showing off her dimples when Rachel accepts her hand.
No I don't believe you
When you say you don't need me anymore
So don't pretend to
Not love me at all
I don't mind it
I still don't mind at all
It's like one of those bad dreams
When you can't wake up
It looks like you've given up
Looking into Rachel's eyes again, she lets her see that she won't give up on them that easily, that she wants more, want's to get back what they had.
You've had enough
But I want more
No I won't stop
Because I just know
You'll come around
Right?
(Chorus)
No I don't believe you
When you say don't come around here no more
I won't remind you
You said we wouldn't be apart
No I don't believe you
When you say you don't need me anymore
So don't pretend to
Not love me at all
Just don't stand there and watch me fall
Because I, because I still don't mind at all
It's like the way we fight
The times I've cried
We come to blows
And every night
The passion's there
So it's got to be right,
Right?
(Chorus)
No I don't believe you
When you say don't come around here no more
I won't remind you,
You said we wouldn't be apart
No I don't believe you
When you say you don't need me anymore
So don't pretend to
Not love me at all
I don't believe you_
When Faith finishes her song, Rachel is holding her hand against her chest in a death grip, crying. "I love you Faith, I never stopped. Ever since we broke up, I've felt as though there has been a huge hole in my heart. I've cried myself to sleep every night feeling so lost without you, thinking it was all an act, but now I know it wasn't, you love me, I can feel it, I can see it. Please, can you ever forgive me?" Rachel asks pouring her heart out with tears streaming down her face.
Hugging the brunette close to her, Faith leans up and plants a light kiss on Rachel's lips. "Yeah, I forgive ya." Faith tells her, then moves off the floor to sit next to her girl.
After Faith's performance, Mr. Schue proceeded to talk about this weeks new lesson, but Rachel was to absorbed with Faith to listen. "Why didn't you tell me you could sing like that?" Rachel whispers.
The other girl shrugs her shoulders. "Never thought I was any good."
"Not any good? You could almost pass for Lzzy Hale, the voice and the clothes!" Rachel whisper screams.
That made Faith laugh. "Nah, I ain't that good, but thanks for the compliment." Faith says, kissing Rachel's temple, but their quiet conversation was cut short when everyone started making comments about Rachel.
"Whoa, how did Rachel freakin Berry of all people land a babe like Faith anyway?" Puck questioned, shaking his head in disbelief.
"I couldn't believe a hottie like that would even go for someone as repulsive as Berry when I first saw them like a month ago." snarked Santana, still pissed about being punched by the raven haired beauty.
"Yeah I know, RuPaul must be paying her to be her girlfriend or something, like a man-handed Hobbit would really be with someone as beautiful as Faith." Quinn said, her voice dripping with distain.
"If only she would a played into your plan, but no she has to go all stalker, and transfer here, somehow save her and Berry's relationship, and will probably become the schools new power couple or something." Santana says.
"No, Finn and I will always be McKinley's power couple, I won't let Treasure Trail take my status with out a fight, preferably one where she ends up in a coma, so I won't have to hear her annoying voice ever again." Quinn threatens.
"I think they look cute together. Why don't you like them Quinn, Faith has been really nice, except for when she punched my Sany, but she shouldn't have kissed her against her will." Brittany chirps, lightly glaring at her girlfriend for going along with Quinn's plan to break them up.
At that point, Faith was trying her hardest to keep her rage in check, but her control was quickly waning with each new degrading comment directed at her girlfriend, but it was the last one that went right through her. 'Those evil little bitches, I can't believe they intentionally tried ta break Rachel and me up!'
Faith turned around glowering at Quinn and Santana. "I'd advise ya two ta shut yer fuckin mouths fors I kick your bitchy bottled blonde ass!" She spat through gritted teeth.
Rachel couldn't tell who was more surprised at Faith's outburst, Quinn, or Santana. No one in this school has ever defended her honor much less threaten the top two of the "The Unholy Trinity" and put them in their places.
Santana and Quinn were both beyond stunned and thoroughly pissed that someone would even dare to talk to them like that, but Santana was smart enough to know to not further anger someone like Faith; you might end up face down in a ditch, Quinn, not so much.
"You'd best know your place, before I have Santana go all Lima Height's on your ass!" Quinn yells, getting ready to attack Faith herself.
Santana raises her hands. "Ahh hells nah, you can fight your own battles Q, I ain't gonna go up against someone who could fuckin kill me."
"Fine, I'll do it myself!" Quinn snarls, getting up and pushing Faith out of her chair. "No one and I mean no one can talk to me that way, I'm Quinn Fabray, this schools HBIC!"
Faith gets up off the floor within seconds of being shoved. "Come on then you Barbie bimbo reject, let's see what ya got." Smirks Faith, getting into her fighting position.
Rachel was panicking; she remembered Faith telling her she was a black belt in Tae kwon do on their first date, so she knew Quinn didn't even stand a chance, and was going to get her ass severely kicked, unless someone intervened. Faith can look even more intimidating when she chooses to. Especially when it has to do with someone being mean to a person she loves wholeheartedly. 'I should stomp the shit out of her, but I don't wanna get kicked out, it'd kinda defeat the purpose a transferring, but, ah what the hell, I'll take my chances.'
Quinn lunges at Faith, but she dodges the attack with ease, and grabs Quinn's outstretched arm, and pulled it behind her back, kneeing her in the back of the legs, causing her to fall hard to the ground.
"You got somethin else ta say… Barbie wanna be?" Faith mocks, pulling Quinn's head back by her hair.
"Ow, ow, ow. Ok, shit I give, now let go super bitch!"
Faith lets Quinn go, throwing her flat on her face in the middle of the class, but not before pulling her up by the hair again, "From now on ya better keep that fucking mouth a yours shut, cause next time, ya might be leavin here with your damn mouth sewn shut, and I don't think your boyfriend like ya much without it, if ya catch my drift." Faith whispers menacingly into Quinn's ear.
Mr. Schue watched the altercation, and was glad it was over before he had to personally intervene. "Quinn, Faith, that was severely uncalled for, detention, tomorrow!" "Now everyone let's get back to today's lesson." Mr. Schue says.
Faith sits back down beside Rachel, and puts her arm around the brunette's shoulders. "Thank you for taking up for me." Rachel whispers. "But you might want to tone it down a little, Two detentions in your first day isn't very good." She added.
"No prob, I wasn't just gonna sit back an let them talk shit bout ya, and I promise ta tone it done, well at least in the open, cause if either of em do or say somethin else that hurts yer feelins, I'll catch em alone and take care of em." Faith whispered back, leaning down to kiss her girlfriend's cheek.
"Well, just as long as you don't get caught." Rachel smiled. The two love birds stayed like that throughout the rest of glee club, when Mr. Schue tells them they can leave; Rachel pulls Faith up and out of her chair, dragging her towards her locker, a huge smile plastered on her face.
"Damn Rach, I think I can walk on my own." Laughs Faith at Rachel's enthusiasm.
When they get to Rachel's locker she gets her stuff then grabs Faith's hand again, so they can leave in Faith's black truck. They get in, but before Faith can start it up, Rachel asks her a question "Faith, is there any way we can start over, get back what we had?" She asks hopefully.
Cupping the other girl's face in her hands, Faith gives Rachel a deep probing kiss that leaves her breathless. "I don't really wanna start over…" She starts, but gets interrupted by Rachel.
"Why, you love me I know it, you haven't stopped calling or texting since Santana kissed you and I stupidly broke up with you. Which was the worst decision I've ever made, please don't hate me, please give us another… Mph."
Faith cut Rachel's rant short by kissing her, wrapping her tongue around the diva's then sucking the muscle into her mouth, making the other girl moan loudly.
"I was gonna say I don't wanna start from the beginning, cause even though the last couple a weeks have been real shitty, I would like ta just continue this, us. Like ya said, we never stopped lovin each other." Faith explained, kissing Rachel again.
Rachel looks at her a little unfocused, due to the kisses. "Ok, so we just go on like the last two weeks never happened?" she asks a little uncertain.
Pulling out of the parking lot and heading to Rachel's place, Faith replies. " Yeah, you know forgive an forget, so we can move on. I love you Rach, and I was goin crazy without ya."
After hearing that, Rachel slides in close to Faith, snuggling into the other girl, laying her head on Faith's shoulder and moving her hand up and down her thigh. "Rach, don't start nothin ya can't finish." Faith breaths in the other girl's ear making her shiver.
Rachel just walks her fingers up and down Faith's thigh, then moves to making circles on her inner thigh, walking them up higher and higher. Faith about wrecks when Rachel cups her hard through her jeans.
Hands gripping the steering wheel tight, Faith pulls over into an empty parking lot, turning curious brown eyes on her girlfriend. "What the hell, you coulda made me w-wreck…" Her rant gets cut short when Rachel applies even more pressure between her thighs. "Mmm… Rach… P-please don't start somethin ya can't f-finish… Eeep!" Faith squeals when Rachel's runs her middle fingers up and down the inseam of her jean covered sex.
"You know how turned on I got when you took up for me in glee and knocked Quinn off her high horse? No one has ever done anything like that for me, and I always finish what I start… Faithy." She purrs in Faith's ear, moving to straddle Faith so she can have easier access to her sweet pussy. Rachel leans in and gives Faith a languid kiss, twisting her tongue around Faith's, making her moan, as she pulls the zipper of Faith's jeans down.
After Rachel has the zipper down, she slowly slips her hand under Faith's thong. "Mmm, your soaked and it's all for me, right?" Rachel asks cockily as she withdraws her fingers, waiting until Faith is looking her in the eyes and slowly sucks each finger into her mouth, groaning at the salty flavor on her tongue.
"Mmm, you taste… Heavenly." Rachel moans.
"S-shit babe, that's wicked hot." Faith replies unsteadily, as the other girl moves her hand back under her thong, running her fingers up and down Faith's dripping wet pussy, then back up, lightly circling her clit. Faith's moving her hips up into Rachel's hand, groaning, trying to get more friction against her achingly hard clit.
"Please Rach, inside." Faith pleads.
Rachel hesitantly slides her fingers down to Faith's opening, circling her, unsure of what to do now. Feeling the other girl's hand stalling. "Rach… you ok?" Faith pants out.
"Yeah, I… I've never… you know?" Rachel stutters, feeling stupid now for her earlier boldness.
Faith cups Rachel's face in her hands, and plants a reassuring kiss on her lips. "It's ok babe, just do what ya think is right, I'll guide ya through if ya need it, alright?" She asks, getting an affirmative nod in response.
After mustering up the confidence, Rachel moves a single finger inside Faith, the feeling of being inside someone else, so foreign, but so unbelievable good. "Oh Faith, you're so velvety soft, your inner muscles keep clutching at my finger, it feels absolutely amazing." Rachel says, awe lacing her words.
Feeling Faith move against her finger, Rachel starts thrusting it in and out slowly. "More Rach, please?" She hears Faith beg, as she adds another finger, picking up the pace, pumping her fingers in and out of her girlfriend at a hard fast pace, per Faith's request.
"Oh yeah, harder. Babe… I'm gonna... Ung!" Faith exclaims, grunting as she cums around Rachel's fingers, her inner walls holding them in a death grip.
"Rachel!" Faith groans. When Rachel feels Faiths release, she gasps and moans at the feel of her fingers being pulled further inside her girlfriends hot slick channel, when she feels Faith slacken, she slowly pulls her fingers out, hearing Faith groan as another aftershock runs through her sated body.
"Damn Rach, I don't know if I got enough energy ta get ya home er not." Faith chuckles, feeling beyond euphoric.
Rachel licks her fingers clean, zips Faith's jeans back up, and crawls off her lap. "Take your time, I'm enjoying the view." Rachel giggles.
After she gets her breathing back under control, she starts the truck back up, and resumes the trek to her girlfriend's house. "Good thing I found an empty outta the way place fer our sexcapades ta continue, could ya imagine if ya'd a jumped me in your driveway? Your dads probably woulda killed the both a us." Laughs Faith, she laughs even harder when she sees the look of horror on Rachel's face.
Rachel slaps Faith's arm playfully, giggling. "No, that would be beyond embarrassing, not to mention my dads would never let me see you again, there not to fond of you right now anyway. I told them your actions were false, that you were a part of a horrendous prank with Quinn and Santana."
"Well, I guess we got some splainin ta do." Faith chuckles throatily at her corny joke, as she pulls up into Rachel's driveway, turning the motor off.
Rachel slaps her again, laughing. "You're a goof, but using an I Love Lucy phrase in a situation like this won't help, this is very serious, it was hard enough to get them to believe that someone as gorgeous as you would date a loser like me the first time around."
Leaning over to give Rachel a peck on the lips "And as much as I loved that song at Regional's, ya ain't no loser, your wicked talented and hopefully they'll understand. I mean they gotta know you're a total drama queen by now." Faith laughs.
Rachel glares at her girlfriend, smacking her hard on her thigh. "I can't believe you said that, I'm extremely hurt, I am so not a drama queen." She says, placing her hand over her heart in faux hurt.
Faith pushes Rachel lightly, doubling over she's laughing so hard at her girlfriend's dramatics. "Ahaha, that's classic, if I didn't know ya, I might a thought ya was being truthful, but when ya started battin yer eye lashes and clutching yer chest, ya totally blew it. You're the goof, but ya my overly dramatic goof."
Opening the truck door and getting out, Faith walks over to Rachel's side to open her door for her, ushering her out of the truck. "Why thank you dear sir." Rachel laughs as she hooks her arm with Faith's.
"So ya sayin I'm the dude in this relationship?"
Rachel just laughs at the mock glare the other girl sends her way. "Well, no. But I couldn't resist the pun, you opened the door for me and helped me out like a gentleman."
Faith relents, not wanting Rachel's dads to think they're arguing. "Alright, here goes nothin." She whispers into her girlfriend's ear as they enter the house. The first thing greeting them as soon as they get through the door, are two very displeased looking men.
"Rachel what is she doing here?" Leroy asks his daughter a little harsh.
"Dad, Daddy, can we discuss this in the family room, please?" Rachel begs her fathers, hoping they won't immediately hate Faith due to a total misunderstanding on Rachel's part.
"Ok, but it better be good." Hiram says sternly looking between the two girls.
They all go to the family room and sit down, Rachel notices her dad (Leroy) grit his teeth when he sees Faith casually put her arm across his daughter's shoulders as they sat down. Clearing his throat, Leroy signals to Rachel for an explanation.
"Dad, Daddy, I was so wrong about Faith, she had nothing to do with the prank, Quinn had made Santana kiss Faith in the lunchroom in retaliation against me for taking Finn away from her last year and because he recently cornered me in the choir room and forcibly kissed me. Faith had nothing to do with it." Rachel explains to them hoping they will let her and Faith date again.
Giving them both a weary look, Rachel's dads accept her explanation. "Ok, honey, but if another misunderstanding like that happens again, you're not allowed to date or even see Faith, alright?" Hiram tells his daughter, giving Faith a hard glare.
"I promise I'll never hurt Rachel, I love her. I'd been going nuts for the two worst weeks of my life thinking she hated my guts." Faith tells them all with glassy eyes, pulling Rachel tighter to her body and kissing the top of her head in response to her revelation.
"Alright, well, your father and I am going to fix dinner, to which you welcome to stay and eat Faith." Leroy tells them before exiting to start said dinner, "You two can go on upstairs and finish whatever homework you may have, before dinner. Oh, Rachel, same rules as before, Ok?"
"Yes dad, I remember." Rachel grumbles.
"Thanks for giving me a second chance Mr. and Mr. Berry, and for inviting me to dinner, I know it will be as great as last time." Faith gushes.
Rachel grabs Faith by the elbow, and drags her upstairs. "Quit laying it on thick, they'll think it's an act!" She grits out, whispering as they enter her bedroom.
"Would ya rather me be my usual crude self round em? Cause I think that'd get my ass tossed outta here a hell a lot faster." Faith grits back.
Dinner was served and Faith tried to not suck up as much, and everything was going great. Faith helped with the clean up like before, then Rachel asked her dads if Faith could spend the night, to which they both agreed, so both Rachel and Faith readied themselves for bed. Rachel loaning her an oversized night shirt to sleep in.
They got into bed, and Rachel snuggled into Faith's side, her hand draped across Faith's stomach, and her head tucked into her shoulder. Faith kissed the top of her head before they both fell into a peaceful night's sleep, cuddled into the other.