After some time, Jennifer and the Calientes decided they wanted to be wed. And yet, it was impossible for the three of them to be married. Not only were there three of them, but two of them were sisters. They tried to find some loopholes, but unfortunately there seemed to be none. Soon after, they all drowned in the pool, and nobody could really tell if it was an odd, coincidental accident or if they had decided that death was the only way the three of them could truly be together.

Brandi freaked out when she heard about the incident with the pool. Remember her ex-husband, Skip, who similarly drowned in a pool? She believed it to be a conspiracy, and she decided she needed to protect herself and her remaining family from it. Somehow, she managed to mess with some pretty dark stuff, and she, Kaylynn, and Beau all had satellites crash down on them.

Daniel, being the only person who even knew Kaylynn and was alive at this point, was going through some of her things. He discovered a journal she had kept hidden. It had things from both before the Tabula Rasa and after. She had known almost all along, then, that she and Brandi's relationship was a lie, but she had played along with it out of fear for her personal safety. If something as minor as snooping got her entire memory erased, she wasn't sure what they would do if it was discovered she had effectively gotten her memory back. In this journal, though, she had written about Michelle. She had all her discoveries in there, with the exception of the very final one. However, what had happened to her proved that she had been correct.

Daniel was furious. Not even remotely thinking, he stormed over to the Goths' house and started a fire, burning it down. Michelle, Cassandra, Alexander, and Kyle Goth all died in the fire and he ran before it burned him too.

Back at the Pleasant-Dreamer-Burb household, Dirk was not happy when he found out what Daniel had done. It wasn't just that his boyfriend had committed arson – "Dude, my mom died in a fire!" In fact, this argument carried on for so long and was so intense that they were both struck by lightning and died.

Darren was then grieving, especially for the loss of his son. He ended up becoming so wrapped up in his grief, in fact, that he forgot to clean the house. He also didn't call a maid because, with everybody dying, he had a feeling the maid would either try to murder somebody or die on their property, now just the Dreamer-Burb household. This turned out to be a grave mistake. One day he made a just ever so slightly wrong step upon a plate and flies engulfed him. When John returned from work, he found Darren's grave sitting next to a gross plate.

This was the final straw for John. He and his daughter were the only ones left in all of Pleasantview. Somehow, he obtained a cow plant. He honestly had no idea how it worked, but had heard that its milk would extend a person's lifespan. If it would keep him and, more importantly, his daughter, safe, he was willing to give it a try. Of course, knowing so little about the plant, he didn't know that he had to feed it, nor did he know how it produced the substance that would prolong their lives. He figured he would just wait and figure it out along the way – it wasn't like it could hurt anything, after all. It was just a plant. Or so he thought.

Lucy saw the cow plant. But she didn't really see it – she saw the piece of cake it seemed to be offering her. How nice! She loved cake. So, she reached out to take it, and she was eaten.

Not long after, John began to worry. It was getting late. Lucy had just gone out to the yard to make a snowman – she should be back in the house by now. He scolded himself for letting his little girl go outside alone as he began to search for her. Wasn't that plant supposed to protect her or something? Like a guard dog, except a cow plant. He tried to tell himself that the plant would protect her and he had nothing to worry about, but somehow he wasn't finding himself very successful in that endeavor. Suddenly, he felt something behind him and when he turned… a ghost. The ghost of Lucy. The last living person in Pleasantview died from the shock.