The rest of dinner consisted of casual conversation. I loved that John and I could always pick up where we left off, no matter how long we had been apart. After the third glass of champagne, he finally let out a huge sigh, pushed back his chair, and shot me a mischievous grin.

"Are you ready for the next part of the evening?" He asked.

I giggled. The alcohol was starting to take effect, but I wasn't about to let him catch on to that. I fought back my laugh and flashed him what I hoped could pass as a sober smile. "You bet I am. Where are we going?"

"You should know by now it does no good to ask." He teased me. "It's a surprise!"

"Darn." I grumbled. "You sure know how to keep a girl in suspense."

He just winked at me and offered his arm. We walked outside, and instead of heading back to the car, he lead me in the opposite direction. I looked at him, confused.

"Where in the world are you taking me?" I asked him.

He said nothing, only pointed. I looked, and there across the street was a skating rink. I didn't even know those places still existed, let alone that there was one in my city. I was maybe 9 the last time I set foot in one, and I doubted I would be a very graceful picture on skates at this point.

"Seriously? That's where we're going? Are you trying to torture me here?" I shot at him, as he pulled me across the street.

"Yep, that's my plan. Come on, just roll with it."

I sighed. "What about my dress? I can't go skating in this thing!"

"Did I ask you too?" He pointed to a figure standing just outside the entrance. As we approached, I realized it was Anna…with a guy. My eyes widened as I recognized John's good friend and also wrestler, Randy Orton.

"Hey you two…there you are!" Anna exclaimed.

"Seriously dude, I thought we were going to have to send a search party for you." Randy teased as he slapped John on the back.

"Sorry guys." John apologized. "I sort of lost track of time."

Anna grabbed my arm and handed me a bag. "I brought you a change of clothes." She stated. "John told me about the plan when he picked you up. He wanted it to be a surprise. Come on, let's go in and we can talk while you change."

I glanced back at the guys, who were deep in conversation. "All right, let's go."

As we walked in the door, I saw a girl out of the corner of my eye who looked strangely familiar, but I couldn't place her. She disappeared around a corner before I could get a better look at her.

Anna noticed my hesitation. "What's wrong?" She asked.

"Nothing, I just thought I saw someone I knew."

"Oh, okay." She shrugged and practically dragged me into the bathroom. I knew she wanted a complete dish session and I was happy to oblige.