A/N: My deepest apologies regarding a late update. Stupid writer's block :)
Nick and Kat found Catherine sitting on a bench in local park, reading newspapers, wearing white T-shirt, blue jeans and brown sandals.
"Catherine Walker?", Nick called.
She raised her head and glanced at them.
"That's me. Who are you?"
"We are from the police. We need to talk with you about Jenny and Amy Smith."
She widened her eyes. "Really? Didn't they solve those cases? I thought those were tragic accidents."
"Yes", Kat confirmed, "but some new leads came up and we are re-investigating the cases."
"How did you even found me?"
"We looked up for you at home and saw that you are not there. One of your neighbours told us that you are usually here this time of day."
"Oh. I didn't know any of them very well. I only lived close to Amy..."
"And you were hitting on her", Katie reminded her.
Catherine took a big breath.
"I tried to make a move on her", she confessed.
Both Kat and Nick glared at her.
"OK, it was more than one move", she admitted. "She was... attractive young woman. But she... wasn't playing for my team, if you know what I am trying to say.."
Music: "Moneygrabber" by Fitz and The Tantrums
Amy was standing near a park, at a bus station, holding can of Coca Cola in her hand. Catherine walked toward her.
"Hi", she said.
"Hi", Amy replied without turning her back.
"You are... waitinh for a bus?"
"Yes. My car is broken."
Catherine looked around, trying to think of what to say.
"It will be a long wait... Maybe we could... you know... go out for a coffee or somethinhg... there is one nice cafe near by."
Amy sighed before turning around, facing toward Catherine.
"Catherine... we... don't have the same "preferences" when it comes to certain thinga. Realize that already, will you?"
"What preferences?", Catherine asked, trying to sound surprised and innocent. "I'm just inviting you to have nice little cup of coffee with me. No more or less than that."
"I know what are you trying to do. I'm not falling for that."
"Really?", Catherine smirked. "It never hurts to try new things", she smiled before gently stroking Amy's hair. "That's what I always say."
"Well, you can say that to somebody else", Amy said and walked away, but not before spilling content of the Cola can all over Catherine's shoes. "I'm going to take a walk. Alone!"
"And I stayed away from her ever since. I know how to stop before I cross the line."
"Where were you on 20th September 2009 between two and four pm?", Katie asked her.
"Uhm... I don't remember."
"And on 20th September 2010 between two and four pm?"
"Home alone. Finishing my latest job project."
"Do you know did she had any enemies?", Nick asked.
"No. I didn't get a chance to know her that well."
#
Lilly and Scotty walked toward Richard Grey, who was fixing a car in his car garage, wearing some dirty old work clothes and dirty work gloves. It was pretty messy garage, Richard and seemed entirely focused on his work, barely noticing them.
"Are you Richard Grey?", Nick asked him.
Richard finally stopped with whatever he was doing and turned around, facing them.
"Yes", he confirmed. "Who's asking?"
"We are from the Philadelphia police department", Lilly said while she and Scotty were flashing their badges. "We need to ask you few questions about Jenny Smith and Amy Smith."
"Yes... I think I read about their deaths. Accidents, right?"
"That was an initial conclusion", Scotty explained, "but now we are re-investigating the cases. We need to talk with all possible suspects."
"And... why am I a suspect? They lived close to me, I think I was seeing them sometimes, but I didn't know them personaly or anything."
Richard smirked. "Look, I know what you think about me, but I'm not the same man anymore. And even if I still am, I won't do it by staging car accident. That is not my style."
"Where were you on 20th September 2009 between two and four pm?"
He glared at them.
"Do you honestly expect me to remember that?", he smirked.
"And on 20th September 2010 between two and four pm?"
"Working. You can ask my boss.
#
Whole team met in the office again.
"Well, interrogating suspects wasn't very usefull. All of them deny any involvement and hardly have any alibies!", Nick said.
"Well, we know that Jenny was having a fight with someone shortly before the accident", Lilly said. "And that she was reading something on her laptop and frowned when Howard approached her. Did they ever checked her laptop?"
"It was found on the passenger seat in her car after the accident", Scotty said, studying the case file. "Badly damaged. They were planning to send it in FBI laboratory on repair, but couldn't do it right away because they were very busy at that time, and they didn't send it at all after they found so many evidences pointing on accident. Same thing with her cellphone. They are still in evidence storage."
"We'll send it in that lab, maybe they can re-pair it, check a hard drive", Jon decided. "If Howard is telling the truth, that could be only usefull lead we have so far."
"New family moved in Jenny's apartment two months after her death", Lilly read. "They probably cleaned it dozens of times since they moved in. I don't think we will found any signs of that person, and Mac can't tell who was he."
"Well, they did check her phone records", Kat read. "In days after her death she was only calling her father, Amy, Howard and few of her friends."
"What about GPS records from their cars?", Lilly asked.
"The one from Jenny's car prooved that she was driving home from work", Nick read. "That from Amy's car was too damaged for any informations to be recovered."
"Well, fight was pretty loud", Jonny said. "Mac can't identifei the man, but maybe neighbours can. Talk with them, maybe they heard something."
All team members silently agreed and went to do what they were assigned for, while John remained in the office, sorting through some paperwork.