Chapter Four
23rd December Part Two
"Finally, time to have some FUN"
Everyone walked into the bar thirty minutes later and Puck immediately went to the bar, while everyone else went to find some where to sit. Once they found a large enough booth at the back Rachel went to the bathroom already needing to pee and she hadn't even had a drink yet. Santana jumped up and followed her friend into the bathroom. Once there she waited outside the stall for her friend to come out.
"So, you still pissed at me for making out with your brother?" Santana asked bluntly once Rachel had come out of the stall.
"Yes, I am" Rachel replied, she washed her hands then moved past her friend to leave but Santana grabbed her arm and pulled her back.
"Come on Rachel it was just a bit of fun"
"A bit of fun, Santana I told you what it was like for me being back here and you're here three hours and you're just pilling on top of it" Rachel snipped.
"Rachel I'm sorry okay. I didn't mean to pile on top but maybe you need to loosen up a little bit"
"And maybe you need to stop kissing my siblings"
"Well given that ones married and the other kissed Kurt I think your safe" Santana quipped, Rachel gave her a questioning look "Kurt told me, he was worried you were going to kill him. I promise not to say anything"
"Good that's the last thing my brother needs"
"So, are we good? You know what I'm like" Santana smiled at her friend moving closer to her before eventually pulling her into a quick hug. "I promise not to do it again, you know unless he wears that leather jacket again"
"Now you are pushing it"
Rachel and Santana hugged again then went back to the booth where Puck was passing them all tequila shots.
"You ladies kissed and make up? Good now drink this" Puck said handing them both a shot. As everyone, even Quinn and Sam, downed their shot Rachel threw hers over her shoulder without anyone but Finn noticing. She sat down on his lap and kissed his cheek as everyone grimaced at the after taste of tequila.
"My god, I feel sick already that's strong stuff" Artie grimaced.
"No, you're just getting old" Blaine joked smiling at his brother. Rachel smiled at them both and she couldn't help but notice how close Blaine and Kurt were sitting. She wanted her brother to be happy she really did but she wasn't sure this would be it. She didn't want Kurt or Santana mixing with her siblings not because she didn't think they were good enough, but her friends didn't deserve to have to put up with what she did with her mother, Rachel was protecting them.
"Okay how about another?" Puck asked before any of them replied he was already at the bar getting another round.
He came back to the table with another round of shots and beers for everyone, he passed them around and everyone quickly clicked glasses and smiled at one another.
"Here's to a night of no drama just drunken fun"
Another hour passed and for the most part Rachel actually had a good time, she was able to sneak her drinks to Finn, so no one would notice and for once Rachel was getting along with all of her siblings. Well Rachel wasn't speaking directly to Quinn, but she reasoned that was the same thing. The group all got to know Santana and Kurt better and Rachel did her best to ignore the flirting between Santana and Puck.
Eventually her brothers, Quinn and herself decided to play pool, while the others continued to talk at the booth.
They used to play pool at the Club when they were kids but eventually they all became too different to be able to put up with each other for the length of a game but given that all of them besides Rachel were a little buzzed they didn't see the harm.
Puck and Artie racked them up while Blaine got them all a drink.
"So, Rachel, you're friends are very colourful" Quinn remarked as the girls waited by the table.
"Not really a word I would use to describe them but sure fine" Rachel answered.
"So, when do you plan on telling our parents you're having a baby out of wedlock" Quinn asked smirking at her sister, Rachel just stared wide eyed at her.
"How did you know?" Rachel asked looking around to make sure no one else could hear them.
"Really it's obvious; we are not all as stupid as you seem to be"
"Excuse me" Rachel snapped eying her sister.
"Your not even married Rachel and you're family have only just meet him how could you let this happen" Quinn complained.
Rachel sighed heavily then looked back at her sister disgusted "You're unbelievable"
Rachel stormed quickly out of the club with Quinn following behind and once they noticed so did Puck, Artie, and Blaine.
XoXoXoXoXo
"Leave them Finn, they need to talk" Tina said lightly grabbing Finn's hand to stop him from leaving. He reluctantly sat back down. He knew in situations like this Tina would know best as she had been with this family since she was a teenager, in a way she knew them all better, even Rachel to an extent.
"Trust me I've dealt with this family since I was 16, they just need to get it out and they will all be fine in five minutes" Tina reasoned "Congratulations by the way, I guessed when we went to the mall, but I didn't get a chance to say anything to you"
"Thank you" Finn smiled sheepishly, although he wasn't sure why, a small part of him still couldn't believe he was going to be a father.
"I take it you two already knew" Tina assumed pointing to Kurt and Santana who just nodded happily, both excited at the thought they would soon be an Aunt and Uncle.
"They were with us when Rachel told me, she couldn't hold it in, it was like she was going to burst" Finn smiled fondly remembering the day Rachel had burst into their apartment telling him she was pregnant throwing herself at him without even realising Kurt and Santana were there.
"I can tell your going to be an amazing father Finn with the way you been with my two, they love you and the way you've been with this family you can handle anything" Tina acknowledged to which Sam nodded in agreement although once again didn't say anything.
"Thank you that means a lot" Finn smiled shyly he'd never been used to receiving compliments especially about something he was so unsure about himself.
"It's the truth! I'm also glad to have another one on our team" Tina amused nudging Sam lightly, who actually smiled at her.
"Team?"
"Yeah the in-law team against Shelby I know you hope it will get better with everyone else and it will but trust me she gets worse the longer you've been together" Tina lightly joked as Sam nodded in eager agreement which made Santana and Kurt snicker at Finn's misfortune.
"Then I'm glad I'm on the team with you" Finn agreed then clicked his beer bottle with Sam's and Tina's.
"You're all screwed!"
"Ha true Santana, I think we've given them long enough let's see what damage is done" Tina said, so they all made their way outside.
XoXoXoXoXo
Rachel stormed out of the club knowing her siblings were following behind. She knew it was a mistake to come here and all she wanted to do was go home. She tried hailing a cab but when she realised she was in Lima not New York she threw her hand down, cursed, then reached into her bag to find her phone to ring one instead.
"Why do you always do this Rachel, why do you always run when things don't go the way you want" Quinn argued as soon as she stepped outside the bar.
"I'm not running I've just had enough of listening to you, your becoming more and more like mom everyday and its sickening to watch" Rachel argued back as their brothers, who had just come out, looked on.
"Yes, you do you did it six years ago and you're doing it now, we don't all have to agree with your choices Rachel" Quinn barked.
"You've never agreed with anything I do, you always felt like you had to take mom's side in everything" Rachel shouted. The guys stayed still watching them, all unsure what to do.
"Someone had to! You guys could never see that she was only trying to look out for you!" Quinn reasoned throwing up her arms.
"Well we aren't the only ones who can't see things!" Rachel snapped back.
"What's that so supposed to mean"
"You say I'm wrong for having a baby out of wedlock but at least I know Finn loves me and I love him, You're so far up mom's bum that you can't see how miserable your husband is, when was the last time you two did anything that you wanted to and not just because you thought you had to" Rachel shouted back
"Come one guys let's call it a night" Blaine tried to reason finally coming in between his sisters. Quinn was by the curb facing the bar with all her siblings looking at her shocked and sad face.
"You have no idea about my marriage or anyone's for that matter, I mean you didn't even go through with yours" Quinn snipped, Rachel gasped at Quinn as Artie and Puck came closer to their siblings.
"Quinn..." Puck warned coming between Rachel and Quinn as he could see the anger in both their eyes.
"I mean how can you judge my relationship when you're lying to Finn about being engaged to Jesse" Quinn smiled evilly and Rachel knew why when she turned around to see a very shocked Finn stood by the Club's door along with Kurt, Santana, Tina, and Sam.
"You were engaged to Jesse?" Finn asked in disbelief.
"Finn please let me explain..."
"I asked you after we saw him if there was anything else with you two and you said no... You lied to me" Finn croaked looking at Rachel and no one else, although they were all listening.
"I just didn't think it was the right time to explain... "Rachel answered, she moved closer to Finn, but he backed away a little.
"When?"
"What?"
"When were you engaged to him?"
"Finn, I need you to know... "
"Answer the question Rachel!" Finn demanded raising his voice a little. Everyone else looked on as Rachel walked closer to Finn trying to grab his hand but he just pulled away again, the hurt and betrayal was clear in his eyes. None of them knew what to do so they continued to watch the scene unfold.
"Six years ago," Rachel finally answered looking down instead of at Finn.
"Six years... Six years! We're you engaged to him when you met him?"
"Finn please..."
"We're you engaged to him when you met me?" Finn asked again.
"Yes" Rachel answered finally looking at him as she started to cry.
"I have to get out of here" Finn declared as he began to walk away.
"Finn please! Let's talk about this" Rachel shouted to his retreating body. Finn just ignored Rachel and continued to walk away.
"We'll go after him Rachie" Santana hugged her friend and then her and Kurt began to run after Finn. Rachel wiped her eyes and turned to face her sister, anger suddenly radiating her.
"You knew he was there didn't you, you did that on purpose!" Rachel accused angrily.
"I don't know what you're talking about" Quinn lied, Rachel ran to her sister ready to punch her but was quickly pulled away by Puck who kept a hold of her waist as Rachel tried to fight back.
"If Finn doesn't forgive me, I'm never going to speak to you again Quinn I mean it!" Rachel started to cry again into her brother's arms. "You did this, and I'll never forgive you!"
"Come on Rachel, Finn just needs time to cool down let go back to mum and dads" Puck put his arms around Rachel's shoulders as he set her back down on the floor.
"I think you should stay away Quinn" Puck warned as he began walking away with Rachel with Artie, Tina and Blaine following behind, leaving just Sam and Quinn.
Quinn turned to her husband. "She should have told him"
"Yeah she should have but you should have" Sam answered. "Did you know he was there?"
When Quinn didn't answer, Sam shook his head at her "When did you become this person? When did I become the kind of person who just put up with it"
"What are you talking about Sam?"
"This! me and you. When did we change so much that I don't even recognise us anymore. This isn't a marriage, it a legal agreement to raise our children and share our money"
"Sam where is this coming from?"
"You have to fix this Quinn" Sam demanded looking at his wife seriously, ignoring her question "Or I want a divorce"
"Excuse me" Quinn gasped.
"You heard me, prove to me you are still the person I fell in love with or I want a divorce"
XoXoXoXoXo
Quinn sighed as she faced the door before knocking. This was the only hotel in Lima and according to the reception the only room in use tonight, so she knew this had to be the place. A few seconds later she came face to face with Santana, who immediately scowled when she saw who it was.
"What are you doing here?" Santana barked, as Kurt came to the door to see who it was.
"I was hoping I could talk to Finn" she answered, she tried to look inside to see if he was there and sure enough he was laid on one of the beds looking towards the ceiling.
"Don't you think you've done enough?" Kurt remarked as him and Santana gave her dirty looks.
"Its fine guys, let her in" Finn said. Santana slowly opened the door further and let Quinn inside. She sat on the chair next to the vanity then looked at Kurt and Santana.
"Will you give us a minute" Finn asked, without saying anything else Kurt and Santana left the hotel room closing the door behind them. Finn sat up and faced Quinn.
"Why are you here Quinn?"
"I wanted to say sorry for what I did outside the club. I was fighting with Rachel and I ended up hurting you and I'm sorry for that" Quinn apologised. Finn frowned at Quinn almost like he didn't believe her.
"Then why say it. You knew I was there, you knew Rachel hadn't told me"
"I really have no idea, when my siblings and I are together we go back to being immature teenagers, no holds bar and apparently no tact. It was rude of me and I'm sorry" Quinn acknowledged.
"What happened between you and Rachel that would create such loathing between you?" Finn asked. He moved closer to Quinn looking at her patiently waiting for her answer.
"I got pregnant with Stacey my junior year at college, I was so scared about what my mom would say after what she went through with Puck, so I pressured Sam into marriage so that I could save face with her. She was happy with that and had Sam and I marry quickly so she could tell her church friends that I got pregnant with Stacey on our wedding night or something. I was so concerned with what my mother thought after the mistake I made that I couldn't see I was slowly losing my sister because of how much I was changing to please my mother" Quinn explained.
"If you know this then why not try and fix it"
"Because in the meantime I did change… permanently, I became about my children and I was okay with that. I lived my life the way I always thought I was supposed to. Rachel and I were always different it just took me getting married and having Stacey to finally see that and we've never been able to fix it" Quinn answered.
"That's not just you Quinn, Rachel changed as well. I'm sure leaving Jesse had something to do with that" Finn admitted. "Will you tell me what happened with them?"
"Rachel and Jesse were together all though High School and it was clear to both families that once they finished college they would get married. So, before Rachel left for New York Jesse proposed. She said yes, and everyone thought she was happy with it, she said she wanted to wait until she had graduated from college and Jesse was just happy that they were together he agreed but by senior year our mother got impatience. I think she could see New York was changing Rachel and she didn't like what she was seeing" Quinn explained, she looked at Finn and he slowly nodded his head for her to continue. "So, Jesse and Rachel started planning their wedding but when Rachel came home after winter break her senior year something was different. Rachel called off the engagement and told Jesse they couldn't be together anymore. Nobody knew what had pushed her over the edge. She packed up everything at our parent's house and said she wasn't coming back. It's not until we meet you that we realised what had changed… Rachel had fallen for you. She knew what real love was and knew she wanted it"
Neither of them spoke for a while as Quinn watched Finn absorb her words. Rachel might not have wanted her to tell Finn what she had but she knew she had to.
"Thank you for telling me that Quinn, I understand now"
"Rachel didn't tell you Finn because she's not proud of what she was willing to do just to keep our mother happy. She could have turned into me or Blaine who's too afraid to tell our mother who he really is" Quinn informed.
"You know?"
"I do, I once saw him kissing a boy behind the gym at school. He never saw me, so I never said anything" Quinn smiled. Finn smiled back as if he was seeing a different side of her. "For what it's worth Finn I'm happy for you and Rachel. Having a child is a wonderful thing"
"Thank you, Quinn, and for what its worth I think you and Rachel can get better, maybe to the point where you can be nice to each other for more than an hour at a time" Finn joked.
"So, you're an optimist… anyway I didn't come for that I came for you and Rachel. I was hoping you would come back to the house with me and talk to Rachel" Quinn suggested, she got up from the chair and straightened her coat. "You will never find anyone like my sister. We have flaws us Berry's, but we are one of a kind"
"I'm coming to realise that" Finn mused as he got off the bed and grabbed his own coat.
"So, you'll come with me?"
"I will… and it has nothing to do with fact that these beds look like they have bugs"
XoXoXoXoXo
Rachel was listening to Barbara sing the last line of My Man when her father walked into the living room. Rachel had been back at her parents over an hour and everyone else had gone to bed, so she decided to watch Funny Girl hoping Finn would eventually come back.
"Hey Rachie, what you doing up?" Will asked as he sat down next to Rachel on the couch. He found himself smiling when he saw what Rachel was watching. His daughter had always loved musicals and he knew she always watched Funny Girl when she needed cheering up.
"I couldn't sleep what about you?" She replied, pausing the film, and facing her father.
"Just getting a glass of water, now why couldn't you sleep?" Will had heard somewhat of happened early from listening to Artie and Tina in their room. From what he got Finn and Rachel had had a fight and somehow his eldest daughter was to blame.
"I was waiting for Finn to come back" Rachel confessed, he knew there was no point her lying to him; he always managed to find out anyway.
"What happened with you two?" Will was never really one for comforting his children they usually went to each other for that, but he could tell Rachel was upset and needed someone right now.
"Quinn was shouting her mouth off about me and Jesse and Finn heard, and I hadn't really told him about it in fact I had out right lied when he asked after the meal yesterday" Rachel explained feeling her anger for her sister come back but also for herself as she knew she shouldn't have lied to the man she loved.
"That sister of yours! More like her mother everyday... Why didn't you tell him yourself?"
"I didn't want him to know about that part of my life. We all know that's the reason I never come back. I don't to be reminded of what my life might have been if I hadn't left him. I'd be just like Quinn and Sam" Rachel answered. Will wrapped his arm around his daughter and held her close.
"Now Rachel it's not the same and you know it. I'm not excusing what your sister did, but you should have never have lied to him. This is the man you say you're going to spend your life with, so you need to be honest with him about everything" Will hugged his daughter tightly. Will reasoned sometimes all your children need is hug.
"Have I ruined it dad?" Rachel asked as she pulled away from her father.
"Of course not, sweetie you and Finn have only been here two days and Finn's already had a lot to deal with especially with your mother, but he never ran. He's still here! Besides you're the kind of girl a guy sticks around for"
"Thanks daddy" Rachel hugged her father tightly once again just as the front door opened and closed to reveal Quinn and Finn. Parent and daughter separated at the noise to see them both standing in the door way. Rachel jumped up and crossed over to Finn unsure of what to say.
"Well I'm going to go back to bed night all" The three of them just nodded their head in acknowledgement as Will made his way back upstairs. They were silent for a few moments before Rachel finally spoke.
"I'm so sorry Finn I should have never lied to you about Jesse I never..."
"I know Rachel" Finn said stopping her mid sentence "We will talk tomorrow but right now I think you should talk to Quinn"
"What! Why?" Rachel asked sending a mucky look to her sister, who Rachel had to admit looked a little ashamed.
"Just talk okay, I'm going to bed" Finn kissed Rachel's head and quickly made his way upstairs before Rachel could protest.
The sisters don't say anything for a long time, Rachel didn't really want to talk to Quinn right now and Quinn wasn't really sure where to start.
"Should we sit?" Quinn finally asked, they both made their way into the living room and sat down on the opposite couches. Rachel decided she would wait for Quinn to speak again as she was in no mood to.
"I know you're really mad at me but there's something I need to say, and I hope you will listen" Quinn finally spoke, when Rachel didn't say anything Quinn took that as a sign to continue.
"You were 13 when you starting repelling against mom. Nothing major but you would want to see plays about aids and sex in the sixteenth century when mom just didn't know who to deal with you. She'd had problems with Puck, but you were her little girl and you were changing before her very eyes. At this time, I was 21 and pregnant with Stacey. I was learning how to be an adult and mother before I even finished college and it was very overwhelming I didn't know what to do and then my little sister is coming to me hoping I'll stick up for her with mom and I just couldn't do it. I thought mom was just acting like a parent and that's how I needed to be. So, I didn't help, and I made it worse by siding with mom." Quinn looked up from her hands to see Rachel was really listening so decided to continue. "I just kept thinking this is who I needed to be and in the meantime, I didn't realise I was losing my sister. She had no respect for me anymore and I finally see why. I should have defended her. I should have always defended her even when I didn't agree because that's what sisters are supposed to do" Quinn didn't say anything else as she let her words sink in. She knew Rachel wouldn't instantly forgive her, but she knew she had to at least try.
"Why now? Why have you suddenly come to this realisation now" Rachel finally asked.
"I don't know I guess talking to Finn about it all made me realise that neither of us are prefect and I should stop pretending that I am. You have a good one there Rachel"
"I know I do! You almost ruined that!" Rachel snapped, although she quickly regretted it as they were trying to sort things out.
"I know I did and I'm sorry, I shouldn't have said anything, but you should have, and you know it!" Quinn reasoned which made Rachel roll her eyes.
"I thought you wanted my forgiveness!" Rachel argued back at Quinn's last comment.
"I do but I think we both need to look at how we were acting. Just because we think something should be a certain doesn't mean everyone has to. That goes for both of us!"
Rachel had to admit in a way Quinn was right. She had always had one way of doing something and Quinn always had another and that's what had made them drift apart because they never understood that just because they did things differently didn't mean that one of them was wrong.
"I guess you have a point" Rachel eventually admitted.
"See we finally agree on something" Quinn joked lightly; Rachel just smiled at her big sister.
"So, what happens now, I don't think we can just decide to be best friends" Rachel wondered. Quinn moved to the sofa Rachel was on and looked at her sister almost hopeful.
"We talk, get to know who each other really is… and not judge each other" Quinn answered.
"I guess we could do that… want to start now?" Rachel asked. She felt now was a good time as ever as no one else was around and they could talk openly.
"Sure, why not?"
"Okay me first, where's Sam?" Rachel asked staring at her sister wondering if she would be honest about why her husband wasn't with her.
"He decided to stay at his parents, after he told me that he would divorce me if I didn't fix things with you" Quinn replied bluntly, Rachel stared at her sister shocked not only at what had happened but the fact that she had told her.
"Is that why you went to talk to Finn?"
"No, I went to talk to Finn because I realised that if Sam did divorce I wouldn't care, not really because we weren't the same people anymore and I felt sick about that. Then I realised if you have someone to love you're lucky and I definitely shouldn't stand in the way of that" Quinn answered honestly, tears came to her eyes and she quickly wiped them away as Rachel squeezed her hand.
"Quinn Sam loves you"
"Rachel my husband utters two words a day max… and I know that's because of me" Quinn admitted.
"Your strong-willed Quinn, there is nothing wrong with that. Sam knew that about you when he married you. Its just you've both just forgotten what made you fall in love with each other but there's still time to change that" Rachel asserted
"Do you really think so?"
"Of course, it's a Berry trait, we always get what we want" Rachel mused earning a small laugh from Quinn "If you really want to fight for Sam then I don't doubt that you'll be able to"
"I guess that's something we have in common"
"It was bound to happen sometimes" Rachel laughed "You know its still early, go see him"
"What?"
"Go see Sam, put things right, if you can do it with me you can do it with him" Rachel reasoned. She pulled Quinn off the sofa and handed her, her coat. "Go get your husband"
Quinn walked to the door with Rachel; she opened the door then turned back to her sister.
"Thank you, Rachel,"
"For what?"
"Im not sure really just thank and I'm sorry"
Rachel hugged her sister tightly. She knew they had a long way to go but tonight was a start "I'm sorry too"
XoXoXoXoXoXo
Once Rachel had watched Quinn leave, pretty sure that she wouldn't come back for the rest of the night she locked up then decided to go to bed. It had been a long day and night and all she wanted was to sleep. She also wanted to talk to Finn, but she knew he would need the night to cool off, so she turned all the lights off and made her way to her old room. When she opened the door, she was surprised to see Finn there lying on Beth's bed, obviously waiting for her.
"Where's Beth?" Rachel asked as she closed the door behind her. She knew that shouldn't be the first thing she said but she wasn't sure what else to say.
"Puck had her bunk with Stacey, so that we could talk... I think he's grown to like me" Finn replied with a slight smile. Rachel was surprised to see he wasn't as angry as she thought he was going to be, which made her wonder what him and Quinn had talked about.
"They all love you. They are probably hoping I haven't ruined things because of what I've done" Rachel admitted as she sat down on her own bed, looking at him hopeful.
"You haven't ruined anything Rachel, I'm just wondering why lied to me"
"Finn the night we met changed everything for me. After one conversation, I felt closer to you than I ever had with Jesse. So, I knew I had to end it with him and when I did, then came back to New York I couldn't tell you because I didn't want to ruin for what we had because it started with lie" Rachel explained. She moved closer to Finn but remained on her own bed, Finn swung his legs off the bed and leaned closer to her as well.
"Rachel, we've been together six years and I understand not telling me in the beginning, but you've had plenty of time since then especially when you knew we were coming down here and that we might bump into him..."
"Or that my sister might have told you in spite" Rachel added.
"Don't blame her for this Rachel, I should have never been in position where I had to find out that in front our friends and your siblings" Finn argued.
"I know" Rachel admitted, she wasn't sure what else to add. She had no argument, she was in the wrong and she was finding it strange Finn wasn't yelling at her more for it.
"How did your talk with Quinn go?" Finn asked her.
"It was okay I guess. We understand each other better now but we still have a long way to go" Rachel explained. She looked at Finn and gently took his hands in her own. "Are we going to be okay?"
"I'm still upset you didn't tell me but I'm not leaving you if that's what you think" Finn remarked "Did Kurt and Santana know?"
"Just Santana, she knew I was engaged because we lived together, and Jesse would visit me but after I met you and called it off I begged her not to say anything and she clearly saw the difference in me because she agreed. Kurt never knew, none of my other friends did... I guess that tells you something right there" Rachel answered. She moved off her bed and sat next to Finn on the other. He leaned back on the headboard and wrapped his arm around her and she snuggled into his side.
"I guess I can live with that"
"Finn I'm so sorry, I never met to betray you and I never wanted you to find out that way..."
"You never wanted me to find out" Finn remarked.
"True I didn't plan on ever telling you because it didn't matter to me. The night I met you changed me for the better and I don't like being reminded of the person I was or what I was willing to do just to keep other people happy and that's why I don't like coming back here because it brings all those old feelings up again" Rachel acknowledged.
Neither of them said anything for a while after Rachel's admission. She could see that for the most part Finn really was okay and was really only mad about how he had found out, but she reasoned his talk with Quinn had lessened that in some way. She wanted to ask him what they had talked about, but she had a feeling Finn wouldn't tell her. Just like her own talk with Quinn, his was private and just for them to understand each other better, which Rachel was certain they had. She knew from personal experiences how easy it was to fall for Finn Hudson's charm.
After five minutes of comfortable silence Finn eventually spoke "So is there anything else I should know and this time I want a really answer"
Rachel smiled up at Finn and kissed his jaw "My brothers were teasing me so much about Brody at church because I lost my virginity to him"
"Yeah, I kind of figured that one out on my own" Finn teased bringing her closer to him, he laid his hand gently on her stomach, which always gave her a thrill.
"Anything else?"
"Nope that's it. I went from Brody straight to Jesse my sophomore year of High School... oh wait I did shoplift when I was twelve because my mom wouldn't buy me lipstick... oh, and I stunk into an r-rated movie once" Rachel listed off. Finn chuckled slightly then kissed her head.
"Okay I get it... and you already told me about the shop lifting"
"Oh, I also never liked olives, I know I told you on I first date that I loved them but that was only because you said you loved them, personally I don't care for them"
Finn looked at Rachel in disbelief "You don't like olives"
"Not really"
"You know it's like I don't even know you"