An: Words that are Italicised and Bolded are Spencer's memories.
Words that are just Italicised are Spencer's thoughts.
Recap:
Instead of answering back the girl hissed, "Who are you?"
Spencer was surprised when the girl smiled softly. "I'm Emma."
Spencer burst out laughing, Emma in Neverland. She let out a snort. What a joke.
It took Spencer a while to actually remember a time when Emma believed in Fairytales. The two girls had to be the age of four when Emma was obsessed with Snow White. It was after the Swans had given them away when Emma had a strange dream. Emma had told Spencer she had a dream where Snow White and Prince Charming were their parents and a man with snake-like skin had kidnapped them. When they got older and Spencer mention the dream to Emma, Emma looked at her weirdly and said she never had a dream liked that.
Spencer gasped for air and she quickly apologised, "I'm sorry, but the Emma I know wold never be in Neverland. She always told me Fairytales weren't real."
The woman looked down in shame and quietly said, "We'll meet under the peach tree in Garrison Park and we'll run away together." She let out a sigh, " I told you this before I ran away from the orphanage without you."
Spencer's eyes widen in shock. She couldn't have made that up, it's really Emma. She looked at Emma and slowly began to see her when she was 11 years old. Emma has grown so much and I've stayed the same girl from back then.
The woman with short black hair stepped forward and asked, "Emma who is this?"
Spencer looked Emma and when she saw her hesitation she felt a spark of anger in her chest. Spencer decided to speak for herself, "I'm Emma twin sister, Spencer. Who are you?"
The woman's jaw dropped and everyone seemed shocked with Spencer's announcement.
Hook was the first to recover and he said, "Well uh, this is Regina."
The woman had brown eyes and was looking at Spencer as if she had grown a head.
Hook turned to the other woman, "The women next to David is Mary Margret."
An awkward silence filled the air and Emma turned to Spencer, "How are you here? Why are you still 12 years old?"
"Well look what we have here, looks like there are two family reunions in Neverland."
Spencer felt a shiver run up her spine when she recognized the voice, "Peter I-"
Peter narrowed his eyes at Spencer, "I'm quiet disappointed in you Spencer, I expected more from you."
Emma looked betrayed, "You're with him?!"
"Did you really think you were the first lost girl?" Peter mocked them as he walked around them in a circle. He let out a laugh and smirked, "Who knew Emma Swan had a twin sister?"
Out of nowhere a ball of fire went hurling at Peter, but he quickly dodged it. Regina growled in anger, "Enough of your games Pan! Where is my son?!"
"As much as I like to play games I have something to tell you all." Peter dragged out the silence until he turned to Emma, "The father of your boy is alive. We kidnapped him from this very camp"
Emma stormed towards him with a sword pointed at his face, "You're lying."
Peter moved the sword and said,"I never lie, you can ask your sister and she'll confirm what I'm saying is true. Though it seems she has a lying problem of her own."
He turned to Spence and glared, "Aren't I correct Spencer."
Spencer looked away from him, Please let this be some twisted dream.
Peter waved at them "Until next time."
David tried to follow him, but as soon as Peter disappeared behind the tree he was gone.
Mary Margret looked around, "look over there it looks like someone was struggling to get away."
The other adults looked at the trail while Regina laughed, "You can't be serious. Pan is obviously tricking us to keep us away from Henry. How do we even know your so called twin sister isn't a spy of his."
Spencer looked offended and said, "Peter doesn't lie, Henry's dad is alive. If he wanted to keep you away from Henry he would have sent his shadow on us."
"Are you one his spies?"
Spencer was shocked by Emma's accusation. "Are you seriously asking me that?"
Mary Marget quickly tried to defuse the tension, "Let's not figh-"
Emma snapped, "He called you a lost girl."
"Well news flash Emma you're one too and the only reason I'm in Neverland is because Captain Pee Brain can't tell a boy and a girl apart."
"Everybody shut up." Everybody looked shocked at Mary Margret and she smiled, "Thank you, now whatever problems we have can wait for later. Let's follow the trail so we can rescue Neal and Henry."
Everyone nodded in agreement when David asked, "Where's Regina?"
Regina was nowhere to be found and Emma sighed, "We're supposed to stick together."
Hook pointed at the trail, "Let's just follow the clues and see where it takes us. Regina can handle herself."
Hook took one more look at the ground before pointing at a cave. "The trail ends here."
Spencer took a step back in fright, "The Echo cave. Once a person is trapped in the Echo cave they never escape. Let's just go save Henry, this is a lost cause."
David stopped her before she could move any further. "Have some hope, Spencer. We can defeat anything in there."
Hook shook his head at David's optimism, "The girl is right, I've lost men because of this cave. The only way to save someone from this cave is to reveal a secret."
Emma snorted, "A secret? Really?"
"Not just any secret, a dark secret. One you never thought about telling anyone in your life."
Hook took in a deep breath, "Well let's go."
Spencer watched as the adults walked bravely into the cave when she felt a hand on her back. Mary Margret smiled down at her and said, "It will be alright, let's go before we get left behind." The girl took a deep breath and nodded her head. I'm not ready for this. She watched as David and Mary Margret grabbed each other hand. If what Peter told me is true they're supposed to be my parents. Why haven't they said anything? Spencer's heart felt heavy as she followed the couple into the cave.
When they had finally reached the end of a cave, a man inside a cage yelled, "Emma!"
Hook looked around and said, "I guess I'll go first."
He paused for a moment until he said, "I kissed Emma."
Nothing happened and Emma sighed, "That's not a secret. I already told Mary Margret."
Spencer realized what he was going to say and quietly said, "Don't do it, Killian. I lied, okay? I forgive you."
Hook smiled softly and turned to Emma, "You gave me hope of finding love and I haven't thought about love since my first love died, but the truth is I probably don't deserve your love. I've done a lot of wrong to your family."
He turned to me and said, "I made a bargain with Pan that if he released Baelfire from Neverland I would find him a lost boy to replace him. So I went to the world without magic and I saw Spencer. She had a huge jacket on and she tried to cover her face as these kids tried to spray her with something called silly string. The children bullying her called her Spencer so I assumed she was a boy."
"That night I saw her at the docks wishing on a star to go to Neverland so I told her I was there to take to Neverland and she believed me. When morning came I realized she was a girl so I tricked Spencer into pretending to act like a boy for Pan. All I did was for nothing when we got to Neverland Pan told me Baelfire had escaped long ago. Pan hadn't realized Spencer was a girl and once he realized she was I knew it was likely that Pan was going to rip out her shadow. I was a coward, I ran and left Spencer to face Pan's wrath."
The ground suddenly shook and a rock path came into their view.
Spencer gave Hook a sad smile and to her surprise, David punched him in the jaw before anyone said anything.
The girl quickly placed herself between the angry man and the pirate, "Stop it! If we continue like this we'll never save Neal."
Emma exclaimed, "You don't a shadow Spencer?"
Spencer shook her head, "I'm still here. You die without your shadow. I convinced Peter to let me stay."
The other adults were relieved at her statement and Mary Margaret blurted out, "Spencer we're your parents."
Spencer quickly shut her eyes. Emma was always the one who wanted to find our real parents. I'm not ready to admit that they're my parents.
No shaking occurred like last time and they all looked at Spencer.
She admitted, "I knew that. Peter told me Henry's moms and grandparents were here. Regina and Emma were the moms so I figured out who you were on my own. You need to confess something bigger."
The adults were shocked with the girls confession.
Mary Margret sighed and said, "I love our girls David, but we didn't get to experience anything with them. We missed it all and I want another go. I want another baby."
The ground shook and the rocky path grew more. David smiled sadly at Mary Margret, "I would love to have another baby, but you can't have one with me. One of the lost boys hit me with NightShade."
Mary Margret glared at him, "When you blocked me.'
"I was hit. Hook and I found a cure, but if I leave Neverland I will die."
The Rocky path finally finished and Emma took her sword out. Just as she stepped forward something threw her back. Hook caught her before she fell and she quickly thanked him.
Spencer stepped forward, "I guess it's my turn."
They all turned her ready to hear her confession when she finally spoke, "When I first arrived in Neverland Peter tested me. He said if I wanted to stay I need to think and act like a lost boy. They made me do a lot of crazy things and I did them all exactly how they wanted me to but Peter said it wasn't enough."
Spencer couldn't look them in the eye, for all the years she lived in Neverland this was the one thing she regretted more than anything. The girls lip began to shake and tears filled her eyes. "I didn't want to do it but I couldn't go back. I wanted to stay with them."
The girl couldn't breathe and she clenched her fist so hard that her fingers were turning white.
Green confused eyes looked back at her. "I thought you said we were friends forever. Please, I don't want to be alone anymore."
Spencer tried to speak but no words came out. "I-"
"Don't Go! Spencer! SPENCER!"
The screaming pierced her skull and she could feel tears roll down her cheeks.
"I left her. I left Wendy."
So Spencer has met Wendy before but of course, there is always more to the story. Thank you guys for all the follows and please leave a review on how you feel about this chapter.