Chapter 4

Lying Is The Most Fun A Girl Can Have Without Taking Her Clothes Off

A/N: I know it has been ages but before you stab me to death with anger I have a kind of excuse involving a lot of school work soo please forgive. Also I come with thanks and happiness because even though the last chapter sucked I still got 6 reviews soo really thanks! Soo I am hoping this chapter will be a lot better but I am not garneting it because these are just the build up chapters and I always seem to have writers block because I write better with drama though something a little dramatic will happen in this chapter but I am not sure if all of you will like it, it might be a little over kill!! Read and Review as always. Please and Thank you!! Song by Panic at the disco!

The music blurred as the squeals and laughter sound took over the room. Haley had been hiding in the corner afraid to even show herself. She was never the confident one out of the three. Peyton never really cared much about trying to impress people or so she said but behind it all she hid herself with protective walls. Brooke she knew she was hot and used it to her advantage but Haley knew how her sister always wanted more then a meaningless fuck with a boy but she just pretended other wise. Both them could always get naked physically but never emotionally. Maybe Haley was the better out of the two at least she was up front about her fears and doubts she never hid who she was. She was just Haley smart, sweet and sensitive Haley. Sure she had secrets that she hid but she never hid who she was, her personality. She stood there starring at the worthless people drinking and groping each other. She was glad she wasn't just another drunken whore though sometime she wondered otherwise. She wasn't a virgin even though she promised she would wait till she was married or sure that it was true love but she did think she was in love but then again she had her doubts and what if she was right. Not only that she was a bit on the side but did it matter when she knew what they had was love, he could see him, the real him not that guy he pretended to be. He opened up to her even though he disguised himself as an ignorant jerk.

Flashback

"Hey" she whispered with a saddened tone as she walked through the empty mansion.

"Hey" He greeted her with a hug as he leant in to smell the sweet fruit sensation from her hair. He was hooked and whipped. He was always himself when around her knowing that she wouldn't judge him or would pressure him into being some one he wasn't. He loved that about her. Though he would never dump Peyton for her because then he would just become that jack ass to Haley so the boys wouldn't think he was whipped and he couldn't live with that thought that he could hurt Haley.

Haley bowed her head avoiding the brown eyes that she could easily get lost in. "Nathan" she muttered forcing herself to look up only to find her self caught into those eyes. Her heart skipped a beat as she swallowed a large lump in her throat and continued it. "I can't. This isn't me! Peyton is my sister." She blinked as she blocked the tears. She wanted him to think she didn't care maybe it would make goodbye easier but it didn't it made it harder for her to walk away thinking, knowing that he would never know how she felt. "I'm Sorry" she quickly added.

"Haley" He begged pathetically. "Please. I love y…"

"No you don't. You just love the idea of me. I'm probably just another conquest of yours. You just want to have sex with me and then you'll leave me for some other stupid girl who will fall for your charm." Haley muttered bitterly as the tears streamed down her cheeks.

"No! I love you. I love the way your smart and care about your grade. The way you don't get drunk and throw yourself at every guy you see and I just love you! That sounds cheesy I know but if that's what I need to say to keep you with me then I'll say again and again because I do. You make me want to be a better person."

She smiled a little but how did she know he wasn't just smart and just knew what she wanted to say and not to mention the fact that Peyton was still involved in the equation. "But Peyton" she whispered oddly regretting it. Why couldn't she just enjoy the moment for once. Why couldn't she just be the girl that guy wanted for once.

"She's great but she's not you! I told you Haley there is no girl for me but you and I know when you see with me Peyton I'm just some ass but that's not me its just it's the way I'm expected to act and I'm guess I'm just scared to show me" Nathan nodded speaking the truth. He had never been so honest in his life.

Haley stood there as she looked him in the eye she knew he was telling the truth. It wasn't just some lie to trick her into bed. "I love you soo much" She found herself blurting out finding herself blushing and lowering her head.

"I love you too" He smiled and kissed her softly on the lips. "I promise once I sort things out I'll break up with Peyton."

Haley felt heart beat speeding up she threw off her top and stood there standing in her bra.

"Haley you don't have to do this" Nathan reassured.

"But I want too" Haley smirked teasingly as she pushed him onto his bed and jumped on top to him kissing him. "I'm glad it's you. That I'm losing my virginity with. I always promised it would be some one who loved me and I loved them."

End of Flashback

"Haley?" Peyton questioned as she walked towards the dazed looking girl hiding in the corner. "Hello?" Peyton perked an eyebrow as she took a sip of her jack daniels and coke.

"Huh?" Haley answered as she fell back into reality. "Oh hi" she muttered sheepishly.

"Were playing 'I Never' and I thought since you looked so bored you might want to join?" Peyton smiled hoping her little sister would join and maybe socialise for once. She was always trying to make Haley come out of her shell but she wasn't much for parties and silly games. Either was Peyton but with a lot of drink it wasn't as bad. Peyton grabbed a cup full of drink. "Here come on" Peyton walked into the living room that was filled with a group of people that was waiting for both of them to join so they could start the game. Haley walked behind Peyton un sure if this was really her idea of a game.

"Lucas! Come join" Brooke smirked as she seen Lucas passing the group. "I'm sure Rachel will move over her fat ass and let you fit in." She pressed her lips together before she left a huge smile widen across her face showing off her million dollar smile and of course her irresistible dimples. "Move Rachel" she hissed.

Rachel eventually moved over pushing Tim of the three seater couch so she would be beside Lucas too. "Okay Lucas grab a drink and you can join the game. I guess it's your lucky night getting to sit beside two hot girls. Well one hot girl. Brooke is a tranny but she doesn't like to talk about it." Rachel smirked cheekily glancing evilly at Brooke.

"Okay I'll start." Brooke chirped in with obvious anger in her voice. She eyed Rachel up she was no competition to Brooke Davis everything Rachel could do, Brooke could do in her sleep. She waited for Lucas to sit down and then smirked as she raised her cup and continued. "I've never done anything sexual with a girl." Brooke said while starring at Rachel making it obvious.

Rachel drank without a moment of feeling embarrassed. "Is that the best you've got Davis" she muttered and continued. "Cause if soo this is going to be the easiest 50 bucks I'll ever make."

"Bring it" Brooke muttered back before smiling sweetly at Lucas. "This game is kind of lame! Do you want to walk with me?"

Lucas immediately looked at Haley. He had known her for most of his life and they were practically sisters and brother but never once had Brooke even acknowledged him never mind invited to him to walk with her. Haley answered his non-verbal question with a shrug not sure to what was going on herself but she didn't seem to mind her sister all over he best friend if anything she found it humorous if anything.

"Uhh sure!" Lucas said not even convincing himself when he had answered the question.

"I'll come with" Rachel quickly chirped in. "I mean if we leave you alone with Brooke, Lucas. She might rape you" She glared at Brooke before standing up and dragging Lucas to his feet as well so she could link arms with him. Brooke quickly jumped up as the two began to walk off. While Lucas looked back at Haley with a wary face.

"That was interesting usually I'm the one that happens to me!" Nathan smirked as he collided his hands with all the boy's hands and laughed only to turn round to meet a death glare from his girlfriend Peyton. "Nathan would like another drink?"

"Yeah sure babe." He smiled a little confused to the fact that Peyton was soo nice to him considering the comment he just made.

"Here you go" she threw it her drink onto his face. "Sorry did you want a cup with that?" Peyton hissed and walked off.

"Come on Peyton it was only a joke." He rolled his eyes as she left his sight. "Some one is a little PMS" He joked as the boys laughed.

Haley stood up she hated watching him be this way. She understood he was scared to show himself. Most people were in the world but to treat her sister like crap was sickening. She wish just once he would just take of his mask and treat every one like he treated her. She began to turn and walk off too find Peyton till he heard Nathan slur her name.

"Nathan?" Haley questioned pretending as if it was a rare occasion him talking to her.

"Why don't we go to a room and you can do that thing you did to me last week." He smirked as the boys jaws dropped whilst Haley stormed off in disgust not daring to cry.

"Dude two out of three Davis. That's hot." Tim raised his hand as it smacked Nathan's.

Nathan stood there for a second feeling almost guilty for being an ass to Haley. It was the thing he wanted least but he always found away to mess things up. "Yeah soon three." He smirked as he turned to the boys and downing another shot to wash away this guilty feeling.

Brooke glared viciously as she watched Rachel dance intimately with Lucas. "This sucks!" She muttered.

"You too!" she heard a bitter voice replied. It was Haley that stood there with her un-drunken drink that she still had from the game of 'I Never' or that game that was meant to happen but never did. She took all in her will power not to down it but she knew if she did she would just turn into one of those people she hated.

Brooke quickly hugged her tightly. "What happened?"

"What do you mean what happened? How do you even know anything happened?" Haley questioned curiously. Everything persuasive Brooke as this dumb girl yet she knew more then most people. Even Haley some times.

"Well your eyes are puffy. Obviously crying involved. Your hair is now tied back so you don't seem to care what any one thinks of you nor do you want to impress any one and also you are clenching onto that drink for you dear life and Haley you never even look at a drink never mind hold it."

Haley stood there as she felt the tears building up. She promised herself she would never cry over some boy because they were never worth it and the one that was would never even make her cry in the first place but yet here she was bursting into tears for the second time. She felt Brooke's arms wrap around her once again. It was comforting and she found herself sobbing onto her shoulder.

"Now you going to tell me what happened so I can kill who ever made you cry or do I have to beat it out of you first?" Brooke asked as she made a joke trying to lighten the mood a little. She got a few chuckles from Haley but then she crying for a few seconds till she finally wiped away the final fallen tears and breathed deeply pondering on whether tell Brooke about Nathan or not. "I'm so stupid" she found herself blurting out. "I thought that he loved me and I know loved him but once again I was proved wrong. I knew it was just sex and yet I just gave it away." She rambled.

Brooke looked at her confused and shocked. Haley was always the girl who wanted to save herself for some one who deserved her and yet here she was talking about having sex with some name less person who by the sounds of it used her. "Haley who is it?"

"Nathan" she muttered as she closed her eyes afraid to see the look of disgust and disappointment in Brooke's eye.

"Nathan!" Brooke shrieked repeating what Haley said only louder. "Sorry" she whispered when she looked at the death glare Haley was giving her. "You know he's a jack ass and not only is he that but he is your sister's boyfriend. Your meant to be the smart sensible one." He turned her direction a little only to see Rachel and Lucas kissing. She sighed at this moment of time she didn't care about Rachel and the bet. "How could you doing something like this?" she said bitterly.

"I'm stupid. I fell for his charm and I know it was stupid but he seemed so genuine around me I thought he was actually a good person yet I knew deep down he was just using me for sex. I wish I listened to my inner voice. Please don't tell Peyton."

Brooke sighed telling Peyton would just make the situation worse. She nodded in agreement. "This is officially the weirdest night ever. Rachel wins the boy and you're a slut! I need a drink or 10"

"Brooke" Haley hissed a little but it was too late she was away of to search for any type of drink available.

10 or so shot of vodka later. Brooke started there trying to get her balance as she watched some more of the guest leave. Now there was only Peyton who had officially disappeared. Haley who must have been in her room. Some of the guys and Nathan. Brooke stumbled into the living room were the boys were still seated.

"You're an ass" She slurred making it hard for the guys to make out what she was saying.

"Brooke nice to see you too! Still jealous that Peyton gets to have sex with me and you don't." Nathan joked but Brooke ignored as seated herself onto the couch.

"I hate this night!" she hissed bitterly. "Every one is having sex but me. Rachel and Lucas. You Haley and Peyton. Possibly at the same time which would be really creepy." She cringed at her one thought. She was drunk and horny why weren't guys taking advantage of her she pretty much begging for sex. She walked into the kitchen to get another drink there was no better way to numb your pain then alcohol.

"I guess it's soon going to be 3 out of 3 Davis's soon" he smirked and exited the living room and following Brooke into the kitchen.

Peyton sat her sketchpad placed it beside her as she sighed. She started to question while she was up here hiding out while all the fun and drink were down stairs. She didn't really have a reason to be angry it was just a comment it was not like he was kissing some other girl or fucking other people, well there was one time she had caught him in bed with another girl but of course she came back to him. Was it his charm? His looks? She never knew why but she hated the person she was with him and the person he was full stop but it was never always like that once upon time he treated her with respect and loved her maybe that was why she stayed with him in hope that Nathan she knew and fell in love with would come back. She stood ready to forgive Nathan or pretend that nothing had happened and everything was okay! As she entered the hallway she heard Haley singing. It must have been a song she had written because she had never heard it before.

" I always said that I would make mistakes
I'm only human and that's my saving grace
I fall as hard as I try
So don't be blinded
See me as I really am
I have flaws sometimes, I even sin
So pull me from my pedestal, I don't belong there"

Peyton listened intently as the melody of the keyboard flowed softly in the air and some way she understood and could relate to the lyrics. Haley's voice was so sweet and gentle yet was strong and rough.

"One thing is clear
I wear a halo
I wear a halo and you look at me but
Standing from here… you wouldn't say so...
You wouldn't say so if you were me
And I.. I just wanna love you
Oh oh oh I.. I just wanna love you"

"That was amazing Haley" Peyton said as she entered her room. Haley jumped a little she didn't think any one was upstairs. Haley quickly buried her head embarrassed.

"You weren't meant to hear that" She sheepishly said before pulling her duvet covers over her.

Peyton rolled her eyes. "It was great. Would it make you happy if I changed the subject instead about talking about your hidden talents?" And with a nod from Haley as she ripped the duvet sheets from her, Peyton did so. "Okay well have you seen Nathan?"

Haley shrugged not really wanting to talk about that subject either especially to Peyton.

"Come on you can help me find him." Peyton replied and before Haley could refuse or argue with her, Peyton had pulled her out of the bed and lead her to down stairs.

Some how after a few more drinks and a lot of sweet talking and hint of kinky suggestions Nathan had persuaded Brooke to join him in the bedroom. Their lips collided roughly as they both fell on top the bed tearing of each other clothes. Nothing was passionate there wasn't even a spark it was just lust mixed with being horny and a tiny bit of loneliness drove these two lovers together. As the ripped off their clothes Nathan began to kiss softly down Brooke's neck and onto her body and slowly down her chest. Sweet moans of pleasure escaped Brooke's mouth.

Haley and Peyton had made there way down stairs spotting Tim and few of the guys still there but no Nathan made Peyton feel a little suspicious. "Tim where the hell is Nathan?" Peyton questioned with an annoyed tone and a hint of anger.

Tim's eyes widened as he though of a plausible excuse. "There was a racoon and it stole Nathan's beer so Nathan chased it."

Peyton and Haley looked at each wondering how some one could be so stupid. Peyton rolled her eyes she was tired of these stupid games and lies. A second ago she just wanted to make up with her boyfriend but now she was fighting the urge to kill him. "I never told a stupid lie!" Peyton grabbed a drink from a table and handed it to Tim. "Now that's try it again where is Nathan?" Peyton asked more pissed off this time.

"I don't know?" Peyton looked at him again making him panic "I have to go" he added and ran out of the room.

Peyton squinted her eyes obviously Nathan was doing something he didn't want her to know about or else his moron of a best friend wouldn't have lied to her.

Peyton wandered upstairs since it was the only place she hadn't cheeked yet. If he was upstairs that only meant one thing he was sleeping with another girl. Why did she always give him the benefit of the doubt and assume that he will change. She started to climb the stairs as Haley hesitantly followed. Haley wasn't sure if she wanted to know what Nathan was doing but yet she did to know if he really was an ass. They reached the first room which was Brooke's room but no-one was there. Next room was the guest room but still no-one. The next room was their dad's room but it was rarely used but still she liked to hope out of all the rooms he wouldn't be stupid enough to use that room. She opened the door only to see two familiar people lying side by side naked under the sheets. Haley peeked her head around the door only for her jaw to drop and let out a small gasp.

Please tell what you think I'm not really sure what I thought of it myself. I know there is more swear words in it but I tried to make the sex sense not too graphic. This is officially my longest chapter lols. I don't know if the rest will be this long they might shorten. Please R&R

Next chapter- How will Haley and Peyton react to finding out Nathan and Brooke in bed?

Will Peyton ever find out Haley was also having an affair?

Some one is planning on leaving! Will they actually leave?

Will Nathan feel guilty? And who does he really love Peyton? Haley? Brooke?