"When did you kiss Stefan?" Caroline asked, turning sideways on Klaus's lap to watch his reaction.
"In the 1920's," Stefan answered for him. He raised his face from his hands as he added, "We were both beyond drunk."
"Don't exaggerate, you were only slightly drunker than usual," Rebekah interrupted.
"We were more than a few drinks past not being able to walk without falling down," Klaus argued. "He threw up on my shoes afterwards."
"Hey, I'm still proud that I didn't throw up in your mouth," Stefan told him.
"Okay, whatever," Rebekah said. "You were drunk. Now stop dodging and answer the question."
Klaus sighed, and then answered, "Stefan… He actually kissed back, Damon just resisted…" Klaus wanted to distract from that conversation as soon as possible so he quickly asked, "Bonnie, truth or dare?"
"Dare," She chose.
"I dare you to make out with Damon until someone tells you to stop," A slight smirk found its way back onto Klaus's lips. He figured that one of the Gilberts would get jealous and stop them; the fun part would be seeing which cracked first.
"Yes, I get to kiss a girl for once," Damon said happily as Bonnie stood up.
The pair had been kissing for about forty-five seconds when Jeremy couldn't stand it any longer and had to call stop. To him it had felt like an eternity.
"Kol, truth or dare?" Bonnie asked when she had sat back down.
"Dare," Kol answered with a childish grin on his face.
"I dare you to do a striptease," Bonnie told him before casually adding, "… And I guess you could leave your clothes off after."
Kol looked like a little kid on Christmas as he excitedly jumped up from the couch.
Once his clothes were off and he had stopped gesturing towards his genitals with over-exaggerated Vanna White hand gestures, Kol sat back down and asked, "Caroline, truth or dare?"
"Dare," Caroline chose.
"I dare you to make out with me until someone who isn't Nik tells you to stop," Kol said with a smirk.
Caroline remained sitting on Klaus's lap as she made out with Kol.
A long three minutes later, Matt finally called stop while everyone else was enjoying the payback at both Caroline and Klaus.
"Klaus, truth or dare?" Caroline asked, turning to face back towards him.
"Dare," Klaus chose.
A cunning smirk formed on Caroline's face as she said, "I dare you to call Tyler from my phone and make sex noises with me until he hangs up."
A grin formed on Klaus's face; he was suddenly very glad that he had chosen dare.
"Get your phone," Klaus said in response.
Caroline bent down to grab her phone out of the pocket of her skirt that was lying in the middle of the floor, and then handed it to him.
As Klaus dialled the number, he watched Caroline's face for signs of hesitation. He found none.
The phone rang twice and then was replaced with Tyler's voice, "Hey."
Instead of answering him, Caroline began to breathe heavily. Her eyes locked onto Klaus's as he followed suit and soon Caroline began to moan.
"Care?" Tyler's voice came loudly through the phone.
Although there may not have been any real sex going on, there was certainly eye sex going on. Every few seconds one of their sets of eyes would flick down to stare at the other's mouth and then flick back up.
Klaus's lips were twitched up into the arrogant smirk that Caroline hated to admit that she was attracted to. The seductive smirk that Klaus had seen a glimpse of while she had been taking his boxer's off was back and it wasn't going away as they continued to moan and pant. That time Caroline didn't mind the poking sensation against her leg nearly as much.
The eye sex escalated until it was obvious enough that even Elijah had picked up on it from the opposite side of the room.
Just when it was beginning to seem like Tyler was planning on listening to the entire thing, Klaus moaned out, "Oh, Caroline!"
Their faces were so close that Caroline could feel his breath hot on her lips.
"You've got to be fucking kidding me!" Tyler's voice came angrily from the other end of the phone as he realized who the guy was; there was the sound of something smashing, and then the tone that signified that Tyler had hung up.
Caroline and Klaus hardly noticed as they continued their eye sex. Caroline suddenly felt a strong urge to close the small distance between their lips and her eyes involuntarily flickered to stare at his slightly parted lips as she thought it.
Caroline didn't allow herself to kiss him though. She couldn't be the one to initiate the kiss, but if he initiated it, then she couldn't possibly be to blame…
Klaus felt that same urge, but he also noticed the way that Caroline was hesitating to grab her phone back and instead staring at his lips waiting.
Klaus's smirk grew as he turned away from her and hit the end button before handing her cell phone back.
After seeing that look, Klaus knew that Caroline wanted him to kiss her, but he wasn't going to let it be that easy so that he could get pushed away afterwards. If she wanted to kiss him, she was going to have to either admit so out loud or kiss him herself.
Caroline didn't let on that she was bothered by the fact that Klaus hadn't kissed her. Instead she leaned back against the arm of the couch, leaving her arm just barely touching his as she decided that two could play at the tease game and it was a game that Caroline Forbes was very skilled at.
"Kol, truth or dare?" Klaus asked, his smirk falling as he turned to face his little brother.
"Dare," Kol immediately chose.
"I dare you to stab yourself in the leg and leave the knife there until your next turn," Klaus told his brother with a serious facial expression.
"Nik, you can't just-" Elijah began, but was cut off by Kol.
"This wouldn't happen to have to do with a certain two dares that Caroline had involving me, would it?" Kol asked with a beaming smile despite the fact that he had just been dared to stab himself.
Klaus didn't respond to his brother, just gave him a bitch face.
"That's what I thought," Kol said, smirking as he left the room to find a knife.
When he came back a few seconds later, he had a steak knife in his hand and a smile still on his face.
Kol sat down and dug the knife into his right leg before he turned to Klaus with an even bigger smirk and said, "It was definitely worth it. You don't know the half of the things that she can do with her mouth."
If Caroline hadn't been sitting on his lap, Klaus would have tackled Kol on the spot. Instead he gritted his teeth and didn't dignify his brother with a response.
Kol's grin remained intact as he asked, "Bonnie, truth or dare?"
"Dare," Bonnie chose.
"I dare you to sit in my lap for the rest of the game," Kol told her. "Both of my brothers have girls in their laps, I'm feeling a little left out."
Bonnie rolled her eyes and then walked over and sat on Kol's lap, dodging both his crotch and the knife that was sticking out of his leg as she did so.
"Elena, truth or dare?" Bonnie asked.
"Truth," Elena chose. Thanks to Caroline she'd had more than enough dares to last her for a while.
"Which Salvatore do you think is a better kisser?" Bonnie asked her.
Elena suddenly remembered why she had been dodging truth as she felt Stefan and Damon's eyes on her.
Kissing Damon and kissing Stefan were too completely different things. Stefan's kisses were familiar and made her feel safe and warm while Damon's were exciting and wild as if she were skydiving out of a plane.
After a few more seconds of eyes scrutinizing her, Elena finally admitted, "Damon."
Judging by Rebekah's reaction, she completely disagreed. Possibly because she brought out the wild side in Stefan more than Elena ever had.
"Matt, truth or dare?" Elena asked.
"Dare," Matt chose.
"I dare you to-" A grin formed on Elena's face as she spotted the look on Caroline's face and decided to change her dare to the one that Caroline's look had silently communicated to her. "-do the milk challenge."
"How many times do you guys have to watch me throw up all over myself before it stops being funny?" Matt asked.
"This'll be the third time," Bonnie said with a grin.
"You guys are terrible," Matt complained.
"What is the milk challenge?" Elijah asked.
"He has to try to drink a gallon of milk within an hour without throwing up before time runs out," Caroline explained. "It's practically impossible."
A/N: Please read and review! You guys have been absolutely amazing with all of the reviews and suggestions! Thanks so much for reading and if you have any more suggestions feel free to tell me in a review :)
An extra-big, extra-special thanks goes out to all of the incredible reviewers of the last chapter: glevez25, Look At My Comment, bunnykay, TVDstories, justine, BiancaR, DrawingMyHeartOut, Rachel, chasing after stars, Archangel2011, Jackie Damon, Lily, vampiremoivelove, imaddictedtocarrots, VampireKissesx, Lola, bubbl3gum97, and the 3 anonymous guest reviewers :D