Disclaimer- I don't own warriors. Erin hunter Owns warriors.
Okay, I'm going to be doing Darkstripe, and then Hawkfrost. Because I don't think Mapleshade is considered evil, I think she's just wants revenge.
Darkstripe.
You are the least authoritive in the Dark Forest. You have minimum power, and are content to do whatever any other Dark Foresters tell you to do. You spend most of your time in the shadows, and when you ARE out of the shadows, you are slinking. Always. Because you have no major crimes.
You still treated Fireheart harshly, calling him a kittypet whenever possible, thinking he should never have been accepted into the Clan.
When you were on guard duty over ThunderClan's prisoner, Brokentail, you made no effort to stop Cloudkit and some other kits when they attacked the helpless prisoner. Fireheart is therefore left to break up the fight. You, however, take Cloudkit's side, insisting that the white tom is not doing anything wrong. Then you calls Cloudkit a kittypet and are the first one to inform Fireheart's kin of his kittypet heritage.
After Tigerclaw rebels against the Clan and tries to kill Bluestar, she exiles the tabby warrior. When Bluestar and Fireheart begin to explain Tigerclaw's treachery, you calls out that it was impossible, and challenge Fireheart several times throughout the explanation. Before he leaves, Tigerclaw asks Longtail, you, and Dustpelt to join him in exile. You decline, seeming to be hurt that Tigerclaw didn't tell you what he was planning, and for plotting with Brokentail.
When Fireheart is made deputy, you comment that you won't be taking orders from a kittypet. You also don't trust Graystripe very well either.
You brought Tawnypaw and Bramblepaw to meet their father, but you failed. And Tigerstar has never forgiven you for that; has he?
You passed information of ThunderClan to Tigerstar.
You went to meet secretly with Blackfoot. When Sorrelkit followed you there, you shoved death berries down her throat. If it weren't for Cinderpelt, Sorrelkit would have died.
These are your crimes; while most aren't major, there are several. You think up the stars should have placed you in StarClan? Think again, look at this list again, and you will find you should stay in the Dark Forest forever.
Darkstripe, you have a killer's mind.