Author's Note: I just want to say thank to all the people who responded and gave me your opinions.

thecatchisdeadliest: I don't know if Hunter and Randy could share her…they both are a little too possessive of her.

I am going to be honest with you guys…I don't know who Amber is going to choose and I am the one writing it! LOL I find myself always changing my mind because in the long run neither guy is 100% evil yet neither of them is 100% good. There just regular guys that love Amber in their own special ways.


Chapter Four

Randy and I stood silent until we heard Hunter's footsteps get quite; knowing that he has continued down the hall and away from the room I was trapped in with my ex-lover.

I looked at Randy and pleaded with him to let me leave, "Please Randy," I whispered, "I have to go to Hunter."

"No you don't," Randy responds with cold dark eyes staring into mine.

I have to admit I started to feel a little frightened, "Randy…"

"No! Amber I want you back…it's no secret…but you are the one that lets me get this closer to you," Randy steps closer and pins me to the wall again. While he dips his head down my breath becomes shallow. He presses his lips to my ear and I feel his hot breath against it as he continues to talk,

"You let me touch you…kiss you…Amber can't you see? You still love me."

This is getting to be too much. I feel my body trembling as Randy cradles my face in his hands tenderly and stares into my eyes.

Damn those eyes, those icy blue gorgeous eyes.

//What the hell am I saying? Amber you need to leave now. Don't let Randy undo what you are trying to build with Hunter. //

As much as I was telling myself to leave and shove Randy away I couldn't. His warm toned body pressed against mine was bringing back so many memories, so many emotions that I started teary up. I wanted to leave but yet I also didn't want to leave.

Randy began stroking my jawline and the apple of my cheek. His eyes looked down to my lips which caused me to lick them. I heard Randy shutter a breath that warmed my entire body.

//I have to go. I have to leave. //

Randy's gaze meets my eyes again, "God Amber I want you so bad."

"Randy please," I plead again as tears fall from my eyes.

"Amber I need you," Randy whispered as he lowers his head again.

I knew what was going to happen and I couldn't stop it. I didn't know how. All of the fight in me was drained out the second Randy's lips connected with mine in a soft passionate kiss. I felt the electricity surge up in me that I thought was dead and gone a long time ago.

Randy's lips were as soft and warm as I remembered. He sucked gently on my bottom lip and bit it which caused me to gasp and arch my body into him. Randy took that invitation and plunged his tongue deep into my mouth. We both let out deep moans at the familiar and delicious taste of each other's mouths. We stood there caressing our tongues together and meshing our lips as one for so long that when we finally came up for air we were both panting and had swollen lips.

Randy stroked the side of my face while having that infamous smirk on his but I was too turned on and too confused to smack him for it. Randy looked me in my eyes and smiled at seeing the conflicting emotions on display. He leaned down and kissed me gently on the lips before whispering against them, "Now you can go to him,"

//What the hell is he talking about? Oh yea…Hunter! //

I shove Randy out of the way as I run out the door. I vaguely remember hearing Randy's laughter as I sprinted down the hallway.

"Have to get to Hunter…have to get to Hunter," I kept saying to myself softly as I run passed WWE superstars and crew to get to Hunter's locker room.

Once I stood in front of the door I swung it open so hard it shocked Hunter as he was getting dressed in his DX ring gear.

"Baby what's wrong? Why are you crying?" Hunter said as he walked over to me and started wiping away my tears.

I didn't even realize I was crying, I tried to shake out of Hunter's grip but he quickly gathered me up in his arms and rocked me, "Baby what happened? Is it Randy?"

As I wrapped my arms around Hunter I could feel his muscles tensing up under his tight black DX t-shirt. I pulled my head away from his chest to look him in the eyes. I could see the anger boiling inside. I panicked; I knew that Hunter's temper was something you should never mess with. I use to think Randy had an evil streak but his is child's play compared to Hunter's. I had to think quickly before something bad was going to happen,

"Hunter please leave it alone please. I don't want any trouble; I just want to have a nice night with the man I love please."

"No Amber," Hunter started going for the door and I run to try and block his path, "Get out of the way,"

"Why can't you just leave this alone?" I yell out of frustration.

"Why can't I leave this alone?" Hunter mocked as he pointed to himself, "Like I am the one in the wrong? No! Randy needs to learn that he can't have you. You're mine!"

"I'm not your fucking property Paul! I am not some cattle you could brand as your own!" I screamed.

//Where the hell did that come from? Damn you Randy! //

I stood there and watched the shock flash over Hunter's face before it was replaced with anger again, "Is that what you think? Are you DEFENDING him to me?"

I opened my mouth to speak but then quickly closed it. I didn't know what to say, I was standing in front of my new love actually defending the conduct of my old. I didn't know how to redeem myself at that point. So I just looked down at my feet, too afraid to look Hunter in the eyes.

"I see, so that's how it is huh?" Hunter's tone was cold but I could hear the disappointment and sadness in his voice, "Well then Amber I think you should go back to your place."

I looked at Hunter in disbelieve, he has never sent me away before, "Hunter…" I reply softly.

He holds his hand up to me, signally me to stop talking, "I don't want to hear it right now. Just go back home ok? I will talk to you later about this but right now…I can't even look at you."

And with that Hunter pushed me gently out of the way to get to the door. Once Hunter left and the door slammed behind me I broke down in tears. I couldn't take it; what the hell is wrong with me? I am suppose to hate Randy not defend him. Why am I letting this asshole ruin my relationship with Hunter?

As I feel the hot tears running down my face I think back to the last time Hunter was this mad at me for defending Randy…

*Flashback**

April 5, 2009 – Houston, Texas

Wrestlemania 25

//The ego of Stephanie McMahon is unbelievable. //

I say to myself. The whole angle of Hunter coming to the rescue of the McMahon family was nothing more than a vanity storyline for Stephanie to have her ex-husband play her knight in shining armor. It's no secret Stephanie doesn't like me; part of me knows she came up with the whole Randy kissing her with Triple H handcuffed to the ring post was a way to piss me off.

//Whatever Stephanie. Booking Hunter to still care about you and your fucked-up family is laughable. //

I am backstage right now in Hunter's locker room watching the match between Hunter and Randy continues on the plasma screen. I have to admit I am a nervous wreck about this match. When Hunter first told me that he would be facing Randy at Wrestlemania I flipped.

This entire Wrestlemania weekend is the most I have seen Randy since the break-up. Usually I would just see Randy from afar in some random location backstage at a pay-per-view and then spend the remainder of time in Hunter's locker room until he and I would leave. But this weekend has been nothing but stressful for me. The worst was at the Hall of Fame ceremony when Randy came with Kelly Kelly as his date. I would never admit it to Hunter but that really pissed me off for reasons I don't even want to explore.

But Randy did look delicious in his tux.

//What the hell am I saying? //

I quickly brush the thought away and looked back at the screen. Things are really starting to heat up in the match as I see the referee down and Hunter picking up his sledgehammer. Hunter rears back and hits Randy square on the side of the head as the crowd goes nuts. Hunter throws the sledgehammer out of the ring while Randy looks dazed and confused. Hunter then measures Randy up for the Pedigree. The audience is standing as am I just waiting for Hunter to deliver the move. Hunter hooks Randy's arms up and plants him straight into the mat face first. The referee finally comes to when Hunter rolls Randy over to get the pin.

1-2-3

It's over. Motorhead is playing in the background as it is announced that Triple H is still the WWE Champion. I couldn't hide my excitement as I jump up and down at the sight on the screen. I was happy for Hunter because nobody deserves to be champion more than him. However a part of me wanted to see Randy win only for the storyline aspect. Just to see someone stick it to the McMahon family.

I sit back down on the plush leather couch waiting patiently for my baby to come back into the room. I didn't have to wait long when I saw the door swing open and a sweating and panting Hunter walks into the room.

I smile brightly at him as he closes the door behind him. Hunter stares at me with intense eyes and drops the WWE title to his feet. He marches straight towards me and grabs my face to bring me in for a hot kiss. I moan at the taste of Hunter's salted lips. I stand up wrapping my arms around his waist and pressing myself against him not caring about getting covered in his sweat. Hunter shoves his tongue in my mouth and growls as he deepens the kiss. I whimper and moan as I rub my body up and down his just begging for him to take me right here and now.

However, Hunter pulls away and smiles, "We can do that later baby. We are supposed to go to the Wrestlemania after party to celebrate."

I move closer to Hunter, "I don't care about any after party. I just want to be with my champion."

Hunter leans down and kisses me softly on the lips. I reach my hands up trying to pull him in to deepen the kiss but Hunter pulls away again and laughs, "Come on my little princess people want us there and besides we have all night for those other activities," Hunter replies seductively.

I watch as Hunter picks up a towel while walking over to the showers. He laughs at the pathetic pouting I am doing right before he shuts the door.

Hunter and I arrive at the night club about an hour later. Almost everyone from the WWE roster was there celebrating another successful Wrestlemania. Hunter and I took a booth in the back with Alicia and Paul Wright (Big Show).

"I am surprised to see you here Paul," I saw over the loud music. Hunter has he arm around me and is rubbing the small of my back.

"Why is that Amber?" Paul replies while taking a sip of his beer.

I take a sip of mine before answering with a smile on my face, "Because only winners should be out celebrating."

I hear Hunter chuckle as Paul shakes his head, "Oh but Amber I am a winner. You should see the fat check the WWE paid me for tonight."

"Oh then I am guessing the drinks are on you then?" Alicia chimes in.

Paul scoffed, "In your dreams."

We laugh before Hunter replies, "Don't worry Alicia I got you."

Alicia smiles at Hunter, "Thank you Hunter," then turns toward Paul, "It's nice to know there are still gentlemen around here."

Paul scoffed again as he went back to his beer. We all continue to talk about what Monday Night Raw was going to be like tomorrow and how much fun this weekend has been. Alicia and I started talking about all the clothes we bought while Hunter and Paul just rolled their eyes.

Mark Henry came over to the table and asked Alicia to dance. She said yes and proceeded to leave the table and hit the dance floor. I looked over at the other side of the room and saw Beth Phoenix and Cody Rhodes sitting together. I asked Hunter to let me up so I could say hi.

Hunter moves and I walk over to their booth, "Hey you guys!"

Beth looks up and smiles at me, "Hey Amber. How are you doing?" Beth stands and gives me a big hug. Beth and I have been friends even since Randy and I use to go on double dates with her and Cody. After the break-up Beth and I remained friends. Cody however is on Team Randy.

As Beth released me she waved her hand towards the other seat in the booth. I take the invitation and sat down while ignoring the disapproving look that Cody was giving me.

"I am doing well. How are you? That Diva Battle Royal was some bullshit!"

"You damn right it was. I mean they really embarrassed us out there."

I nodded my head in agreement while my eyes landed on Cody who was still giving me the stink eye. I rolled my eyes at him as I looked back over to Beth,

"So do you know what they have planned for this 'Santina' character or what?"

"I have no idea but it's stupid if you ask me. I can't believe Santino has agreed to do that."

"Neither do I,"

"So how's Hunter?" Cody asked with a slight attitude.

I was a little put off by his tone but I decided to play nice in front of Beth.

"Hunter is great. He is still the WWE Champion."

Cody huffed, "Well Randy isn't doing too good."

I smiled, "Well I honestly don't care how Randy is doing."

"Obviously,"

"Cody stop it," Beth said as she placed a hand on Cody's shoulder to calm him down.

"What? I am just saying you saw what Randy looked like after the match! What Hunter did…"

"Stop it!"

"Wait! What did Hunter do?" I asked.

//Did Hunter hurt Randy? //

"Don't worry about it. Randy is fine. Come on Cody lets go to the bar," Beth says as she pulls Cody out of the booth. Cody gives me one more evil glare and leaves.

I shrug it off and start to walk back over to my booth with Hunter when something grabs my arm and pulls me into the darkest. I start to panic as I am pulled to another booth so far in the back of the club that it is practically invisible. I am guided into someone's lap as they sit in the booth with their back against the wall and their feet facing out.

I start to scream but a hand quickly reaches up and covers my mouth while an arm wraps firmly around my waist. My body goes into shock when I feel a pair of lips brush against neck up to my ear. I was going to fight until the familiar scent of cologne calms my nerves and hot breath is felt on the back of my neck.

"Doesn't your man know it's dangerous for a pretty girl like you to go off on her own? I mean, a big bad wolf could come and eat you up."

I shiver as the deep treble of this voice raises goose bumps along my neck and shoulders. I make an audible moan that causes the other person to drop their hand from my mouth and chuckle softly.

"Don't you mean a big bad viper," I shakily reply.

Randy laughed, "Maybe," I sat in silence while Randy brushes his lips over my ear and lightly sticks his tongue in the canal.

I moan but quickly shove Randy in the chest with my elbow, "Quit it," I yell as I slap my hand up and hit the side of Randy's head. As I climb off Randy's lap I hear him say 'ouch' and then reach up to rub the side of his head.

I look back just before storming off but stop dead in my tracks when I see this huge bruise on the side of Randy's face.

"What the hell happened?" I ask as I sit back down in the booth next to Randy.

"Nothing. Since when do you care?" Randy says as he massages the area where the bruise was located. I could see he was in physical pain and before I could think I reached my hand up and moved Randy's hand out of the way. I lightly brush my fingertips over the purple and red area while watching Randy's face contort from the pain.

"What happened?" I ask again with a whisper.

"It seems your boyfriend got a little stiff with me when he used the sledgehammer."

I brought my hand down, "Hunter did that tonight?"

Randy looked over at me with those blue eyes and before I realized it he leaned over and kissed my nose. I was in shock, "What was that for?"

Randy smirked, "Nothing, you just look so cute when you're thinking. It makes your nose wrinkle up."

I bend my head down to hide the blush that was creeping up to my cheeks.

// He has always been such a charmer. //

Randy reaches over and grips my chin in his hand; bring my face up to meet his. Randy gazes into my eyes one more time before he leans his head down and captures my lips in a soul searing kiss. I gasped as Randy's tongue parted my lips and entered my mouth. My head is swimming; I know what we're doing is wrong but I couldn't stop myself from reaching up and cupping his face in my hands. Randy slid his arms around my waist and pulled me down as his shifted his body so I was lying down in the booth and he was on top of me.

I felt my heart racing as Randy caressed my bare thigh and groaned, "I love these legs so much."

I felt him slid his hand up my black skirt until he was touching the hem of my panties. This is getting too intense so I turn my head away from Randy's as I bit back a moan. But Randy took that as a cue to assault my neck with kisses. Randy licked the pulse of my neck before sucking gently so there will be no mark left later. His lips traveled down to the slope of my exposed cleavage and licked between my breasts. I moan and arch my body closer to Randy while sliding my hands from his face down to the hem of his shirt.

//I need to feel it. I need to feel his perfect body pressed up against mine again. //

Randy slips his hand down the front of my panties and looks up at me. It is as if he is asking me for permission to touch me. Just before I was about to say yay or nay I felt my arm almost ripped out of my socket as I am pulled out of the booth and from underneath Randy.

I looked up in horror as I stared into the wild eyes of Hunter looking down at me. I tremble in fright as Hunter's grip on my arm tightens and I wince from the pain.

"What the hell are you doing in the back with him?" Hunter barked as he pointed to Randy still never taking his eyes off me.

I try to answer but the pain in my arm hurts too much so instead I start to silently cry.

Randy rushes over and tries to snatch me out of Hunter's grip, "Get your damn hands off her! You're hurting her!"

Hunter pulls me back towards him as Randy still has a firm grip of my other arm; although his grip is less hurtful then Hunter's.

"Mind your own business Orton! You should consider yourself lucky! Because I should be bashing in your face right now!"

Randy got nose to nose with Hunter, "Try me Hunter just try me!"

Things were getting hot as I tried to stick my hands in between them so they could stop, "Stop it you two! Please! Paul can we just go!"

Hunter looked back at me and proceeded to shove me back against the wall as he stared daggers in me, "Why were you letting him put his hands all over you? You are with me! Why are you laid up in the back of a club with him were the whole roster could see what you're doing? Don't you realize how embarrassing that is for me? Don't you realize how that makes YOU look?"

I was crying now; I never wanted to embarrass Hunter like the way Stephanie did. But I can't help the attraction I still had towards Randy.

I try to open my mouth to answer but all that came out was loud sobs that I tried to choke back. I covered my face with my hands because it hurt too much to see the disappointment in Hunter's eyes.

"Leave her alone man! Stop berating her like a child in front of everyone!" Randy yelled as he got closer to us.

I looked through my fingers and witnessed damn near the entire roster crowded around watching my humiliating moment.

//This is almost as bad as the night I caught Randy cheating on me! //

Hunter turns away from me and back at Randy, "Didn't I tell you to stay out of it! Since you want me to address you so bad Randy how about you tell me why did you have your hands all over my girlfriend?"

Randy smirked, "Maybe because she knows that I am a better lover than you."

That was it; that was all it took before Hunter tackled Randy to the ground and started punching him in the face. I screamed as I saw blood spurt out of Randy's mouth. I tried to rush over and save Randy but I was snatched up by Paul Wright before I got the chance.

"Let me go Paul! Hunter is going to kill Randy!"

Paul whispers in my ear, "This has to be done Amber. Randy needs to learn to leave you alone,"

I wasn't hearing that, I didn't understand nor did I care. I screamed for Hunter to get off of Randy but he wasn't listening as I watched him beat Randy senseless. Randy blocked as much as he could but finally he reared his knees up to his chest and kicked Hunter off of him. Hunter's back smacked up against the table for the booth as he shuffled to the ground. Randy slithered up and started stomping on Hunter's ribs and head. I screamed for Randy to stop but just like Hunter he isn't listening to me. Randy was coming down again with another boot to the gut until Hunter reached up and grabbed his foot and pulled into out from under Randy. Randy came crashing down to the ground again and before he could get back up Hunter was on him again just landing punch after punch.

I finally worked my way out of Paul Wright's grip and ran over to the two men fighting. I grabbed Hunter by his arms and tried to pull him off. Hunter shakes me off easily as he goes back to hitting Randy. Hunter then wraps his hands around Randy's neck and starts to choke him. I leap on to Hunter's back and start to pull his hands away from Randy's neck as I watch Randy's face turn from red to purple and those beautiful clear blue eyes of his turn bloodshot.

"Paul stop! Paul let go! You're going to kill him! Somebody help!" I screamed.

And thank God Ted DiBiase and John Cena came and helped me pull Hunter off him. Hunter looked like a wild animal as he panted and wiped the drool coming down from his mouth with the back of his blood soaked hand.

I stood there is shock as I looked at the man I love in horror and then at the man I use to love with sympathy. Hunter reaches out and grabs my hand firmly, "Come on. Let's go."

Hunter pulls me to the exit of the club as I look back and watch Ted and John pull Randy off the ground. The last thing I see as I am dragged out into the night air is Randy staring at me with pity written on his face.

*End of Flashback**


That night was one of the most gruesome things I have ever witnessed. The second we got back to the hotel Hunter screamed and yelled at me about how I looked like a whore and he wasn't going to look like a fool again. He stormed out of the room and went to a bar while I spent the night crying myself to sleep. I awoke the next morning to Hunter making love to me and apologizing for his actions and that he was just afraid of losing me and didn't mean a word he said to me last night. I showed Hunter the bruise he left on my arm from grabbing me and he nearly broke down into tears as he repeatedly said he was sorry.

We all assumed that after the beating Hunter gave Randy that it meant Randy would back off. Wrong! The following week after Hunter was drafted from Smackdown to Raw and then what proceeded was nine months of Randy's constant touching, grabbing, and mini kidnappings backstage to try and win me back.

//I don't know why he is so persistent. //

I had followed Hunter's orders and left the arena. I went back to the apartment and watched the rest of Raw with tears in my eyes. After it was over I tried to stay up and wait for Hunter but it is now 4am and I had no idea where Hunter was. I tried calling his cell phone but he won't answer. I tried calling Shawn and he told me that Hunter will come to me when he was ready.

I am lying in my king-sized bed trying to get some sleep but I can't. I am worried about Hunter and worried that he might leave me after this. I can't deal with that; I love him too much.

Just then I heard the front door of my apartment open and then close. I sit up in bed and watch Hunter drag himself into the room.

"Paul," I said softly but all he did was hold his hand up signally me to keep quiet. So I did what I was told.

Hunter sighed and dropped his hand, "I don't want to talk about it right now. I just want to sleep Amber ok?"

Hunter removes his shirt and unbuckles his jeans before sliding them down. Hunter undresses everything until he is only wearing boxer briefs. He lifts up the covers and slides into bed without even looking at me as he turns his back to me.

I sit there in silence for a while wondering what I could do to make Hunter forgive me for siding with Randy.

"Paul I'm sorry," I say softly as I feel the new hot tears fall down my face.

Hunter sighs but doesn't say anything. I reached over and touched Hunter's shoulder. I felt the muscles tense up but he didn't brush me away. I take that as a sign that it was ok to continue. I moved closer to Hunter and pressed my breasts against his back. I slide my hand down Hunter's massive pecs while gently caressing his nipples until they became hard like diamonds. I heard Hunter shutter and I sighed in response.

"I'm sorry," I whisper as I leaned down and kissed the side of Hunter's neck. I licked the pulse of his neck before sucking hard on the flesh. Hunter groans as I licked the already redden spot softly before leaving a wet trail of kisses up to Hunter's ear. I lick around his ear before dipping my tongue into his canal and then sucking gently on the lobe. Hunter groans again which is causing my pussy to become wet.

"Have I ever told you how hot your moans sound? God if you keep this up I'm going to cum," I whispered seductively in Hunter's ear.

I heard Hunter start to struggle for breathe when I moved my hand further down until I rubbed my hands up and down his toned abs.

"Your body is so sexy baby. I love how protected I feel under all this muscle."

I slid my hand further until I got to the prize between Hunter's legs. I slide my hand under Hunter's underwear until I grabbed his hardened cock firmly in my hand and smile when I heard Hunter grunt and then thrust himself into my hand. I begin to rub Hunter's cock in long hard strokes while collecting the pre-cum at the tip to make my hand slicker against his hardened meat. Hunter's breathing becomes heavier and more ragged as I stroke him faster and faster.

"Slide on your back sweetie," I say and without coasting Hunter quickly moved to lie flat on his back. Still stroking Hunter's dick I leaned down and swirled my tongue around his nipples and suckled gently. I feel Hunter start to tremble as I lick and bite all around his pecs until I get to those glorious nipples and nibble and suck them.

"Amber…Amber please," Hunter panted as I continued to lick down his chest to his abs.

"Please what Hunter…what do you want?" I asked breathlessly. I wanted to do it just as much as Hunter wanted it.

"Please suck my dick," Hunter replied desperately.

I smiled, "Of course,"

And with that I leaned down further and took Hunter's thick length into my mouth. I moaned around the cock from the exquisite taste and the sounds of Hunter moaning. I lick all around the head and suck hard until my cheeks cave in. I flatten my tongue under Hunter's cock as I bob my head up and down suctioning my hot mouth around his length.

"Oh God…so good baby…so good…this hot little mouth," Hunter groans as he grips the back of my neck and thrusts his hips forward to shove more of his cock down my throat. I deep throat Hunter's entire length as I reach over and massage his thick balls in my hand.

Hunter grunts, "Yes…yes…baby…so good…keep it up…so good."

Hunter grunts and groans while thrusting more and more as I continue to suck his delicious cock. I feel Hunter's balls tighten and I know what is about to happen.

"I'm cumming baby…I'm cumming Amber," Hunter growls.

Just then I feel hot cum shot into my mouth with such velocity I thought my head would explode. Hunter grunts and groans as the last of his seed spills into my mouth and I drink it all down.

Once Hunter was done he collapses against the bed in exhaustion as he removes his wore out dick from my mouth. I lied back in bed and snuggle myself into Hunter's chest.

"Do you forgive me?" I say.

Hunter sighs as he reaches over and wraps his arm around my shoulder and kisses the top of my head, "Yes I forgive you. But let that be the last time you defend that asshole to me."

Hunter was serious; so I didn't bother to respond. I just kissed his chest before drifting off to sleep...

A/N: I want to make this clear to guys that I am NOT turning Hunter into a woman beater…he won't be that guy in this story and neither is Hunter. Hunter was mad and wasn't thinking. I just wanted to clarify that in case you were wonder…anyway you know the drill please review…because like I said when you don't I assume you don't like it!