Summary: Dean takes Castiel to a strip club/brothel all-in-one to try and rid the angel of his virginity for a second time, but gets a nasty shock when he discovers the identity of the club's main dancer, Temptation. When she heads out on the road with the Winchesters and Castiel, she grows a lot closer with one of them.

Disclaimer: I don't own Supernatural or its characters *Screams at God and curls up on the floor*.


More Than I Appear

Chapter Four – Guess Who's Back

Things had been a little awkward between Castiel and the two hunters since he saw their intimate encounter a few nights previous. They were just carrying on in their usual way, the occasional flirt here and there, but then again this was Dean Winchester, and Jennifer was a damn stunning woman. The angel still couldn't get the image of Jennifer when she climaxed out of his head. As much as he tried, and whenever it happened, he felt something stiffen between his vessel's legs. He'd feel uncomfortable for a few hours and then it would go away…until the thought came again.

Now, Jennifer wasn't an idiot. She was pretty intuitive and she could tell that there was something wrong with Castiel. He wouldn't look her in the eye, he'd blush around her and the entire atmosphere was awkward. It was just her and him in Bobby's study, trying to find possible leads on the Devil while Bobby and Dean were checking out possible hunts in the area. Jennifer looked up from her book to see Castiel sat, shuffling uncomfortably.

"You alright, Cas?" She asked, wincing a little when she saw how much the poor guy was blushing and fidgeting.

He glanced over at her with almost guilty eyes and looked to his lap, unable to meet her gaze again. He rubbed the back of his neck and pushed his book further over his lap as though he was hiding so-…

No…no way…

"Hey, if there's something wrong you can tell me, Honey…" Jennifer assured him as she moved closer, "It's okay…"

She took his hand tentatively, not letting go when he flinched a little. She pulled a chair up and sat right beside him.

"Talk to me, Cassie…"

That was an affectionate name she'd given him when she was trying to reassure him about something, only used when they were alone. When Dean and Bobby were around it was always 'Cas' or 'Castiel'.

"I don't…" Castiel began, looking away from Jennifer who cupped his cheek to try and get him to look at her.

"What's the matter?" She asked, trying desperately to meet his gaze.

The book had been sliding from his lap slowly for the whole time and suddenly dropped to the floor. Castiel looked horrified and Jennifer saw the problem.

"Is that all?" She asked, earning a confused look from the angel, "Cassie, that's okay. That's actually a bodily function…it happens sometimes to guys, alright?"

Castiel blushed and looked up at Jennifer, feeling more relaxed around her, tightening his grip on her hand. He turned in his seat and then looked to his lap.

"It's uncomfortable." He whispered, almost silently, "I…wish it would go away…"

Jennifer rested the hand that had rested on Castiel's cheek now supported her head as she smiled softly.

"Well, I doubt you want to deal with it the human way, so I guess you're gonna have to just ignore it for now, okay?"

The young woman was so sweet and caring about delicate things, she always had been. Unbeknownst to her, Dean and Bobby were stood either side of the door, listening to the conversation.

"Thank you." Castiel whispered, closing his eyes when Jennifer kissed his forehead.

"Anytime," Jennifer replied, "If you want to talk about anything else you know where I am, Sweetie."

Castiel nodded, smiling softly as the girl squeezed his hand one more time before returning to her book. She looked back at the angel who sighed and stood.

"I must return to search for my Father." He said softly.

"Alright, see you later, Cassie."

"Goodbye, Jen."

Jennifer smiled to herself. He'd used her nickname for the first time after such an awkward conversation too. Shaking her head she went to leave the room, only to be grabbed by someone.

"DEAN!" She yelled, smacking Dean's arm repeatedly, "You fucking idjit!"

"Sorry for scaring you," Dean laughed, "What was that about?"

"That was personal, Dean. I'm not gonna talk about it because it's private to Cas, okay?" Jennifer protested, "I'm getting a beer."

With that the young woman headed into the kitchen, grabbed a beer and headed out to the salvage yard. Climbing on one of the trucks, she sat taking a swig of her beer before closing her eyes and lying down, going deep into thought.


She had no idea how long she'd been sleeping atop that truck until she heard a sound beside her. Opening her eyes she saw two familiar brown eyes and she sat up, smiling at the person by her side.

"Sammy!" She cried, hugging the youngest Winchester.

"Hey, Jen…you missed me?" Sam asked, holding the girl tight to him.

"Sweetheart, we've all been worried sick!" Jennifer replied, kissing Sam on the cheek, "How you doin'?"

"I'm good thanks. What about you?" Sam replied.

"I'm great thanks, Sam." Jennifer replied, noticing a glint in the younger boy's eye.

"I heard about the night with Dean." Sam said, smiling at Jennifer.

"Oh did he tell you?" She asked with a laugh, "It was great…we both needed release so we helped each other out."

Sam nodded.

"I'm coming out on the road with you guys." He said, "We gotta keep finding ways to put Lucifer back."

"Yeah, 'cause I don't wanna lose either of you to an Archangel or the Devil…" Jennifer said, moving closer to Sam, "Promise me I won't lose you guys."

Sam wrapped his arms back around Jennifer and held her close.

"You won't lose us, Jen. We're gonna stay strong, okay?"

"Okay." Jennifer replied, "You promise?"

"Promise." Sam answered.

"Good," Jennifer whispered, pulling back from the embrace, "Because if you don't I'm gonna rip your dicks off and feed them to the ducks, you got it?"

"Got it."

-TBC-