I don't own any rights to glee… Well you asked and here it is CHAPTER FOUR! I've decided to take it all the way to when Quinn has the baby. However, I will be taking a little bit of a different turn then the show
Chapter Four: Don't trust a- don't trust a Berry
It'd been a week. Puck watched Finn and Quinn from a distance getting more and more annoyed with the two. He didn't know how much longer he could take watching them and knowing Quinn was carrying his baby.
To keep himself busy he'd been hanging around Rachel Berry a lot. She was Jewish and so was he. According to her that meant they should be together.
"Puck don't you think so?" She snapped her fingers in front of him.
"What? Sorry, I wasn't paying attention" Puck admitted and turned his attention away from Quinn at practice to look at Rachel.
"Puck… are you alright?" She asked.
"Yeah… I'm fine" He lied.
"Why do you keep staring at Quinn?" Rachel moved closer to him on the bleachers.
"She's hot… I'm a guy… do the math?" Puck rolled his eyes.
"Oh stop with the whole tough guy act… there's something going on… tell me… I can keep a secret" Rachel looked at him seriously.
"Quinn is pregnant" Puck needed to tell someone and Rachel didn't have anyone to tell. At this point though, he didn't particularly care about the consequences.
"What!" Rachel exploded, "Is it Finn's!" She had a little crush on Finn and was hoping to God it wasn't his.
"Of course not… it's mine!" Puck snapped standing up.
"Wait what? When did this happen?" Rachel asked looking over at the Cheerio's practice, "Are you sure they should be lifting Quinn?" She added.
"A week ago she found out… and they shouldn't be but Quinn knows what she's doing." Puck started walking down the stairs toward the parking lot to drive home.
"Does Finn know it's yours?" Rachel asked trying to catch up with him.
"No… and just don't tell him okay… This is between Quinn and I" Puck hurried down the stairs and over to his car.
Rachel stood on the bleacher for another minute thinking. 'Finn deserves to know… right? He shouldn't have to deal with a baby in high school when it's not his… it's my civil duty to tell Finn it's Puck's baby' Rachel thought with a smile and pulled out her phone to call Kurt.
"Kurt… It's Rachel… I have something really important to tell you. We need to stage an intervention for Finn. Quinn is pregnant and it's not Finn's but Quinn told her it was and it's really Puckerman's" Rachel spoke quickly.
"Alright… I'm with you" Kurt said before hanging up the phone.
…
The next day in glee club everyone was standing around the piano except for Puck who was sulking in a corner. Brittany and Santana were missing as well.
Finn walked into the room. "Hey guys… where's Mr. Shue?" Finn asked.
"He'll be here soon… but Finn we feel that as your friends we need to tell you something… We know about Quinn" Rachel started.
"We also you to know that Quinn lied to you" Kurt added.
"Wait… when did you find out about this? Did Quinn tell you?" Finn asked confused.
"No… someone else did… but the baby isn't yours… its Puck's" Rachel stated.
"What?" Finn felt sick to his stomach. He was, in a way, relieved that the baby wasn't his but why would Quinn lie.
Puck stood up from his corner of the room and began to head for the door but Quinn was already standing in the doorway, tears in her eyes.
"Rachel! How could you? This was none of your business. Why can't you just keep in your own stupid world with rainbows and unicorns pretending that you actually have friends?" Quinn snapped storming over to Rachel.
"No Quinn." Finn stood up and turned to face her, "How could you… how could you lie to me about something like this!" Finn glared at her.
"Finn… you don't understand! If I told you… I would have lost you! I can't lose you" Quinn sobbed.
"Well now you did… and you Puck. I don't understand how you could sleep with my girlfriend. You stabbed me in the back! We were supposed to be best friends!" Finn's face was red.
"Have you looked at your girlfriend lately? She's hot! How could I not sleep with her" Puck smirked. This earned him a dirty look from Quinn and Finn ramming him into the wall.
"Finn stop it!" Quinn hurried over to try and push Finn and Puck apart without much success.
Puck and Finn would have started throwing punches had Mr. Shue not walked in and broke it up.
"What's going on here?" He asked. In response Finn just backed away and walked out of the room. Mr. Shue turned his attention to Quinn for an answer. She too ran out of the room.
"Does anyone know what happened?" He asked again.
"Kurt… can you tell him what happened? I have to talk to Quinn" Rachel rushed out of the room to follow Quinn.
"Quinn?" She asked sitting on a bench next to the blonde girl.
"Go away" Quinn whispered calmly.
"I'm sorry… I shouldn't have said anything… I feel bad" Rachel pushed her hair behind her ears.
"You should" Quinn snapped annoyed.
"Quinn… don't push me away… you're going to need your friends more than ever"
"Yeah… well you aren't much of a friend" Quinn glared.
"I want to be your friend Quinn… don't push. Goodbye" Rachel stood up and left her sitting alone which is exactly how she felt. Alone.
Okay chapter four… what did you think? FEEBACK is my fuel :P
