Lace, Lucy, and Natsu walked in to Fairy Tail Natsu and Lucy hand in hand.

It was Valentines day and Lace was the only one with out a date.

Her boyfriend from back then was with her sister and she was upset.

Lace thought to her self 'He said he's so in love but why her why not me or even Lisanna where is she any way'

Lace was wondering where her old best friend was.

"Hey Natsu wheres Lise (Lisanna)" Natsu had a sad expression on his face "dead" he walked away.

"How hey Mira how did Lise die" Mira just turned her head and softly said "Elfman."

Lucy's PV

"Hey Levy hows you and Gajeel doing" Levy smiled "good you and Natsu"

I sighed "difficult thats why I wanted to talk to you" I felt like crying.

"Well talk away Lucy-chan" I took a breathe "I think Natsu likes Lace" I sat beside Levy.

Levy looked confused "you to look exactly the same I can hardly tell you to apart."

She giggled "I can't see how Natsu can" I looked away "thats why Levy Natsu might kiss her thinking its me so its confusing for him."

Natsu's PV

"Damn Lucy and Lace is mad at me this is confusing Lace is talking to Mira and Luce is talking to Levy."

Gray felt sorry for Natsu be impressed "talk to Lucy for me, Popsicle."

"Do you want me to die that bad she will get pissed at me to this is on you."

"But I don't know who I love the most my long gone girl or Luce I don't know anymore dude."

While Gray and I were arguing Lucy walked over and kissed me then gave an evil stare to Lace.

I'm still confused "HE'S MINE I DON'T CARE WHAT YOU WANT" Lace and Lucy had a stare down.

"L...Luce c...calm down" she turned to me and stare for a moment she pulled out her whip smacked me then attacked Lace strangle Lace didn't move.

Lace's PV

'Come closer' she gave and evil smile "ICE MAKE CAGE" Gray came up and pushed Lucy out the way.

Lucy fell into Natsu's arms.

Natsu's PV

I don't know any more Lucy my love is strong for you just remember if your ever in pain lost or falling call my name its mine and your destiny.

A tear rolled down my face Lucy looked up at me and though her arms around me.

Suddenly a light appered from us Lace turned and whispered "THE MONSTER IS BACK"

End of chap 4

Lucy and Natsu: Whats going to happen to us

Lace: its not you Natsu its Lucy and you'll find out next time

all 3: Next time Lucy a monster and Natsu