Hey guys, I'm so sorry that it's taken me so long to update, school has been rough and I've just been so busy. But here it is.

...

Rachel's POV

I glance at Quinn who is at a table in front of mine and is sitting next to Sam, I'm next to some boy named Brett who is half asleep. I throw a paper ball with a note inside at Quinn who quickly opens it, reads it, writes something down and throws it back.

I open it and read the note.

Are you choosing cheerios or glee? -Rach

What do you think I should do?-Q

I scribble down a reply List the pros and cons of each -Rach I then chuck it at her and she nods her head at me before looking towards the front so as to not raise suspicion.

...

"You see cheerios is fun, keeps me popular which makes me safe and is what I've always know but it's exhausting both emotionally and physically and Sue is abusive and the other cheerios still call me muma and milf. Glee is warm, inviting, filled with lovely people that are my friends, lets me express myself and Mr Schue is pretty cool but it makes me a loser and a target," Quinn states as we walk to our lockers.

"Well it sounds to me like glee has more pros than cheerios and less cons too," I say "this is your decision Q, you choose whatever you want to do."

She nods her head and we part ways so that she can gather her things and I can continue on to my locker. Once I arrive I see Puck waiting for me and I turn to leave.

"You should hear him out," a voice says to my left.

I turn to see Brittany "What?" I question.

"Puck, you should give Puck a chance, he may be the dad and he cares about you, in a weird Puck way he cares. He didn't get to be there for Beth" Brittany tells me and then disappears into the crowd.

I take a deep breath and head to Puck. "Hello," I say to him and enter the combination.

"Rachel, I really need to talk to you," he pleads.

"Then talk," I look up to him and see his shocked face.

"Really?" he asks and I nod "Maybe somewhere a bit more private."

"Meet me at my place after glee, okay?" I tell him and he nods smiling.

I grab my books, close and lock my locker and then head to my next class.

...

I sigh and sink down onto the couch, it was a rough glee practise, all the footballers kept arguing and grumbling, but they did eventually cooperate and I noticed that some of them enjoyed it.

I jump of the couch when I hear the doorbell, I race to the front door and pull it open.

"Hey Puck, my dads are on a cruise so the house is empty and we can talk," I put emphasis on talk so he knows that's all we'll be doing "do you want anything to eat or drink?" I ask.

"Sure, I'll have whatever," he nods and follows me into the kitchen where I pour us both some V8 juice and grab a plate which i put celery and carrot sticks on as well as a glob of peanut butter. I set it all down at the counter and get up on the stool. Puck sits next to me.

"So what'd you want to talk about?" I ask even though it's obvious.

"We slept together and when I woke up you were gone, then you ignored me for weeks afterwards when I have no clue what I did wrong," Puck answers.

"You didn't do anything wrong, it was me, I cheated on Finn-your best friend- with you and I couldn't look at you because it would mean I had to face what I did," I tell him.

"I get that you're guilty about cheating on him but that's not all of it, there's something else you're not telling me and I want to know what it is," Puck looks at me.

I sigh "I'm pregnant," I blurt out.

"And I'm the dad," he states.

"NO, I don't know, I slept with you and Finn within like a week of each other, it could be either of you. I'm not taking away any of your rights, you can come to ultrasounds and buy teddies and rub my belly and help choose a name but I don't think we should see each other romantically," I tell him "especially because Finn has all these rights too."

Puck looks angry and sad "Well thanks for letting me be a dad, even if I would like more, I'm gonna be there, I won't be like my dad, I'll be a good dad," he promises.

"I believe you," I smile.

"Who else know?" he asks.

"Just me, you, Quinn, Santana and Brittany," I reply "I need to tell Finn and my dads before I start showing." He nods.

"Want me to be there?" he asks and I smile thankfully.

"That's sweet of you to offer but I don't think that'll be wise."

We smile at each other and then finish the snack I laid out.

...

"Quinn, come on, you can tell me," I rub soothing circles on her back.

"I kissed Finn, after he convinced the footballers and Santana and Brittany and I to come back I was reminded of what I loved about him and I kissed him," she sobs. "Now I've cheated twice," she sobs and I pull her closer.

"Hey, hey, hey, shush now. Look Quinn, yes you cheated on Finn with Puck and now you've cheated on Sam with Finn but don't you see the connection," she shakes her head "Puck made you feel special and wanted, Finn made you feel the same, that's all you wanted. Do you know what I think, I think you need to stop dating and take time to be with yourself and to learn to love and want yourself."

"You really think I should do that?" she asks with a tear stained face staring at me.

"Yes," I reply "I really do."

/

Guys quick question, what should happen with her dads? here are options:

-she tells her dads and they accept and help her

-she tells her dads and they kick her out and she goes to live with Quinn

-or puck

-or Finn

-or Sam

-Or Santana

-or Brittany

Please answer, don't forget to vote an endgame