When Ziva and Tony made it back to Granny's, they found the rest of the team having coffee and hot cocoa with Regina, Robin, Rumple, Belle, Snow, David and Henry. McGee noticed Tony and Ziva holding hands when they joined the group; "So what is up with you two? You seem ready to kill each other or jump each other." Abby exclaimed, "McGee!" as Gibbs head smacked him. Bishop laughed at them when Ziva mumbled that's how she ended up this way. Ducky asked, "you kids ok. We are almost ready to return to DC." Gibbs said they were staying for a quick dinner to discuss the case and tie up loose ends as he looked at Ziva with concern. Ziva said, "We are great. We actually have something to tell you…" but Tony interrupted, "Wait, where's Emma?"

Ziva groaned, "Seriously?" David answered, "She left for a minute to get…" but he was cut off when they thought they heard Henry say 'laid'. Regina choked, "What did you say, Henry?" He didn't realize that she heard him so he back tracked and said, "Mom's outside in the back making out with Killian." At first everyone just sat there not entirely sure they heard Henry right. Then they all went out back and sure enough Emma was sitting on Killian's lap, kissing him passionately as his hands (hand and hook) roamed up her shirt. While Robin and Belle tried not to laugh, David exclaimed, "Hook. I told you to stay AWAY from my daughter" as Emma jumped off Killian's lap. The sudden movement cause Killian's hook to rip Emma's shirt for which he was happy he turned it before so it didn't cut her back.

With Killian kissing Emma quickly as he gave her his jacket (since he cut her shirt and was glad she was safe and he didn't hurt her on accident), David yelled at him again and even Emma this time. But Emma didn't like being yelled at, "Are you kidding me? I have seen you do worse?" Snow couldn't keep quiet while her family started arguing again, "Emma, your father is just concerned about you. I know Killian has been a big help but he is a pirate and has a complicated past to say the least." Emma groaned, "Mom…" but Regina intervened, "She is an adult and can make her own decisions about who to date. Even if she is wrong." At the same time, Tony had to ask, "Wait, are we seriously talking about Hook, as in Captain Hook? Surprised Emma said, "Thank you, Regina. But I am not wrong. And yes, Tony. Killian is Captain Hook Jones." This news left Tony dumbfounded.

However, Regina had plenty to say including, "You may not think you're wrong. Hell, you may have even fallen in love with him. But that doesn't mean that is what is best. You can't just go bringing guys in and out of Henry's life. He needs stability. And if you can't…." At this Killian got angry and had to cut in, "Hey. Emma can do anything. And she is not just bringing guys into Henry's life. Emma's not that type of girl. Henry comes first before anyone or anything. And that is fine with me. It is the way it should be. I LOVE Emma with all my heart and would do anything for her. As for Henry, I look at him as my own son. I love Henry and if I thought my relationship with Emma would ever hurt him I would walk away."

While Ziva thought this was sweet, she still had to ask, "That's great and all but isn't Captain Hook the bad guy in the Pied Pan?" Agent Bishop laughed as she corrected Ziva, "It's Pied Piper. And Peter Pan. To which Hook is the villain." Rumple was the fastest to say that Hook was not the bad guy in that scenario but Tony shared his thoughts too, "Hey, that is my thing. I correct Ziva's idioms. Captain Hook. Pfft. And I can't be the only one that thinks this is weird. David and Mary Margaret can't be Emma's parents. They are younger than me." McGee laughed, "That doesn't mean anything. They could have aged really well. And maybe Emma is younger than you thought." Tony said, "No she is 31 years old. And I don't think that David or Mary Margaret are in their late 40s or 50s, McSmartypants"

Emma giggled at Tony's teasing and then tried to answer seriously, "Ah, I guess they would have been but with everything they are only a few years older than me." Abby said that scientifically that would not be possible but Gibbs said, "Maybe they meant from an emotional standpoint they are her parents. Like I think of you as my children, not just my team." Tony still thought it was delusional and Bishop seemed to agree with him on some level, "Perspective family doesn't make it any less fairy tale like." It was Ziva's turn to agree with the team, "Exactly. I mean who thinks of someone their own age as a parental figure or believes villains are good or their friends are fairy tale characters." While Henry said, "Anything is possible," Emma knew they sounded ridiculous.

Tony thought, "It is great for Henry to believe in the possibilities but Emma, you are an adult now and you need to make sure that you both understand the difference between fantasy and reality." Frustrated Emma said, "Shut up Tony. You are not my big brother anymore and you can't tell me what to do…." Everyone was shocked at Emma calling Tony her big brother so Tony clarified, "Emma was my foster sister when I was in high school but when my dad got divorced again she went back into the system." Ziva finally understood, "so you weren't jealous. You were concerned because you still felt like she was family." Emma scoffed, "yeah Tony's an annoying overprotective big brother." Offended Tony responded, "overprotective. You sound delusional…" but Emma continued, "I know it sounds stupid. Peter Pan is actually the villain. Captain Hook is a good man. Red Riding Hood is the wolf. I get it I freaked out to when I found out my parents are Snow White and Prince Charming. I mean come on Regina the Evil Queen is my grandmother well step-grandma and training me. And Robin Hoods true love, which apparently is more powerful than dark magic."

Tony, Ziva, and the rest of Team Gibbs just stared at her before Palmer said maybe she needed to see someone professional. Emma said she didn't lose her mind or need to see someone, while she tried to prove her magical abilities. Rumple told her to stop so Regina stepped in and ripped out Tony's heart; causing Tony to gasp and Ziva to scream as she went into ninja mode. Emma jumped in and said, "See Regina is the 'Evil' Queen (Emma did air quotes as she said Evil) but she isn't all bad. She is going to give Tony back his heart." Regina looked at the heart and at the rest of Team Gibbs before turning to Emma, "I will but you won't ever call me grandma again." As Emma agreed, Rumple told Regina to rip out Emma's heart. Snow told Regina, "Make sure you brace yourself. And be careful." David protested even though Emma only shrugged at the suggestion, "seriously. It is not a good idea." When Regina tried to rip out Emma's heart it didn't come out and a visible wave emitted from Emma knocking everyone over. Regina got up annoyed as Rumple explained that Emma's heart couldn't be ripped out because she was the product of true love.

David thought they were being ridiculous and saying too much when Rumple (or Regina) wasn't going to erase Team Gibbs memories from Storybrooke. With a mock fist up, Emma tried to calm him down, "Tony and the others are not going to say anything to anyone. Or I will beat him up." Palmer laughed, "Ziva would kick your … butt" (changing to child friendly word choice) but before Palmer finished his thought Tony said, "No, my fiancée will not be beating anyone up anytime soon. Emma is more than welcome to hit me if I say something about Storybrooke or its residents that has nothing to do with our case." Ziva smiled at hearing him call her his fiancée and agreed, "It is not like anyone would believe us anyway." Gibbs said, "Congratulations DiNozzo" as Abby squealed and examined Ziva's engagement ring. Palmer said, "how did that happen," causing Ducky to laugh, "When did it happen?" But all McGee could say is "Rule 12."

Emma hugged Tony and wished him well before asking, "what's rule 12?" Gibbs smiled and explained that he had rules for his team to follow so that they didn't get into trouble. He even gave the example of today because when you date a co-worker you relationship competes with your job, like this afternoon when Ziva was frustrated and jealous of how much time Tony spent with Emma. Ziva stepped in, "I apologize if I seemed rude earlier. I am very hormonal right now and I didn't know you were supposed to be a sister figure." Emma said, "it's fine. But I have to ask… are you pregnant?" but when Ziva didn't say anything she felt bad, "it's not that you look pregnant or anything. It's just that you said you were hormonal and…"

Ziva laughed a little but answered, "Yeah, I found out this morning that Tony and I are having a baby so I freaked out a bit before Tony and I talked about it." Tony smirked and complained a little, "she didn't even let me take her home and do a proper proposal." Glaring at Tony, Ziva said, "and your complaining" Tony replied, "No. It's just that I have been carrying your ring around and planning the perfect moment but I slipped up this afternoon and told you beforehand." Emma said it was a good thing and Ziva agreed, "It helped to know you love me and want to marry me before I told you about the baby." Regina asked what difference it made and Emma explained, "If Ziva had told Tony about the baby before he expressed an interest in marrying her, she would probably wonder if he proposed later just because she was pregnant." Ziva agreed with this sentiment, before Gibbs said they should get some dinner and get on the road. At dinner, everyone chatted happily, congratulations were shared, and goodbyes were said because everyone doubted that Team Gibbs and Storybrooke residents would ever cross paths again.