Chaos Of A Love Potion ch. 4
Disclaimer: I don't own Glee or Caught Up by Usher
Rachel's POV
This week was longer than I expected to be because I had to deal with Quinn and Santana completing for my attention every since what happened on Monday and they were constant on the verge of trading blows with each other over who was walking to me to class or simple things of that nature.
Adding onto the problem ever since I kissed the both of them, there's this hunger in their eye as in the same look that a lioness has right before they make their move on an unsuspecting antelope and I am afraid that I'm the unsuspecting antelope in this case. On top of that, there's the looks and touches that are directed my way and it is making sharing class with them even difficult because it feels like they're undressing me with their eyes, sending shivers down my spine as well as sending pleasurable shock waves to my core.
I never felt this way with any of the boys that I dated and I was sexually attached to them at one point or other but they never made felt like this as the Cheerios are. I have always thought that sexuality was fluid and love is love as being the product of two loving gay Fathers but I have had this idea in my head that I would be married to a man that not I wouldn't ever a woman but it just wasn't part of the plan to be with a woman, let alone two of the most beautiful women in my school.
I'm currently sitting in between said women in AP Literature, watching Merchant of Venice but the cheerleader didn't seem to be interested in the movie at all as they stared loving through hooded eyelids and love struck expressions. I didn't mind the attention but they have been staring at me for a solid fifteen minutes and I don't know much more I can take of this before the teacher made them pay attention to the movie as I let out a quiet sigh of relief.
It didn't seem to last too long as Quinn and Santana had the exact same thing as they scooted their desks impossibly close to my own, leaving no room to move away but that wasn't all that happened. The Head Cheerio decided on placing her hand on my knee as she rubs circles there as her second in command took it a step further by placing her hand on my inner thigh as her fingertips glazes back and forth along my flesh. I had bite my lip to keep myself quiet but it did little to stop the small whimper from escaping as no one seem to notice except for Kurt as he looks back at her as I shoot him a look of desperation.
He furrows his eyebrows when he noticed what was doing on in the back row but turned around with one glare from the raven haired cheerio as she continues her administrations and I wish that she would but not really. Is it wrong that I don't want her to stop? Is it wrong that I'm enjoying what's going a little. Of course it's wrong that I'm enjoying. I mean none of this real, just an effect of the love potion and it's not like they would have feelings for me since they hate my guts.
Quinn is as straight as an arrow and Santana… well Santana is Santana and they have their pick of anyone that they wanted and I can't see either of them choosing to be the school's resident diva. I nearly jumped out of my seat when Ifelt a warm breath as well a pair of lips ghosting over my left ear.
"What's the matter, love? You're really deep in thought" Quinn asked seductively.
"Yeah Estrella, what's going on in that beautiful mind of yours" Santana purrs.
"I-It's n-nothing" I stammered.
"Are you sure? You're stuttering. Are you still up for our date?" Quinn asked sounding more concerned now.
"I'm fine and I appreciate the concern you guy but it isn't necessary. Yes Quinn, I'm more okay for our date" I said evening out my voice.
Everything in that moment went to hell as I feel Santana stiffens as her whole body went rigid as she narrowed her eyes, zeroing in on Quinn as she stands up so quickly that her chair falls over backwards in the process, pointing her finger in the other girl's face yelling and screaming. Shit, this is gonna to end well. The situation quickly escalated into a full blown fight as both Cheerios taking shots at hitting and kicking each other along with a lot of hair pulling to boot and I tried to break them up but I wasn't strong as two football player broke them apart.
The teacher quickly sent them to Friggins' office with me escort them so they wont on the way their way as I put my things as the cheerleaders grumble something under their breaths and glaring at the each other heatedly. They looked me to the principle's office and I knew that I needed to a handle on the fighting now or they'll really hurt each other and I don't want that much bloodshed on my conscious if I could have prevented it so I stopped before turning to face the both of them with my arm crossed. They looked at each other and I can see them nervously gulping as they should be.
"Seriously you guys, I asked the both of you to cut out the fighting and yet you ended up fighting anyways" I said frowning.
"But she started it" Quinn asked pointing at Santana.
"I don't care who start because I'm ending it here now. I don't think that I want to be around either of you if all you're going do to is fighting and argue with each other and I told you that there will consequences if you fought again"
"You're still going on our date tonight?" Quinn asked nervously.
"What about ours tomorrow tonight? Are you bailing on me?" Santana asked fearfully.
"I don't know if I should because neither of you deserve but yes, I'm going out with the both you" I said as they let out a sigh in relief. "But I want you two to show up at my house after Glee"
"But-"
"No ifs, ands or buts about it. Show up at my house after Glee or I swear that I will not go out with either of you" I said storming away from them
As I was walking away, I did something along the lines of 'that was hot' from Santana but I didn't stop to ask her to repeat that because I have to think of good punishment for the both of them. The rest of the day went well as the touches stopped, much to my dismay, but the looks didn't stop but they were nervous glances instead of the sexual ones that I was receiving earlier. I sat with Kurt at lunch to talk about what to about the Cheerios as I stabbed my salad with my fork but I was still a upset with him not helping me during class.
"I'm sorry about that but the both of them scare the hell out of me" Kurt said shrugging his shoulders.
"They're not all that bad. More like very territorial puppies" I said biting into my salad.
"Puppies, my ass. More like territorial wolves fighting over a female" Kurt snorted.
"Whatever, I need your help to think of a decent punishment for the both of them"
"A punishment?" Kurt asked raising an eyebrow.
"Yes, I told them that I punish them if they fought again but I didn't think that I would have do" I said rubbing my forehead.
"Hmmm you could always spank them" Kurt said laughing slightly.
"Kurt! You're a genius, that's it" I said grinning.
"Thank you but why am I genius? What's it?" Kurt asked raising an eyebrow.
"I'll just spank them and this will be the end of all the fighting. Why didn't I think of it?"
"Rachel, I was only kidding and you can't spank two thirds of the Unholy Trinity. Do you honestly expect them to go along with that?" Kurt asked frowning.
"If they want to go out on a date with me, yes. People do crazy things when they're in love or believe that they are" I said pointing my fork at him.
"Like how you thought that you were in love with Mr. Schue last year and went snooping through his things?" Kurt asked raising an eyebrow.
"Okay, I had a relapse in judgment last year and that only further proves my point as if I remember correctly that you did the same thing with Finn and Puck last year as well" I said challenging him dispute what I had said.
Kurt doesn't say anything but his cheeks says it all as they turn a bright red as he mumbles something under breath before finishing the rest of his salad, leaving me alone with my thoughts of how to execute this plan. I went through the rest of my classes without a problem as I walk to Glee to find Finn already in the choir room with Puck but looks up to see me, standing in the doorway as he glares at me down with every step I took to get to my seat on the other end of the room. The other Glee kids walked in but the only ones not here yet is Santana, Quinn and Mr. Schue until he walks in ten minutes late and he noticed that the two missing cheerleaders.
"Does anyone know where Santana and Quinn are?" Mr. Schue asked confused.
Everyone shook their heads and I couldn't help but feel something is going to happen but I don't know if it's good or bad at the moment but that's when the Cheerio decided to make their presence known. Santana was wearing a black dress shirt, red tie, white slack and white sneakers and as for the head Cheerio, she was wearing a white dress shirt, red suspenders, black slacks, white sneakers as the both of them were wearing matching fedoras. The raven haired Cheerio whispers something to the band and they nodded their agreement as she walks over to her blonde companion.
"Mr. Schue, we have a song that we want to sing" Quinn said looking at me.
"O-Oh okay, take the floor girls" Mr. Schue said confused.
(Side note: Santana's in italics, Quinn's in Bold, both in bold italics)
I'm the kind of brother
Who been doing it my way getting my way for years
In my career
And every lover
In and out my life I've hit, love and left the tears
Without a care
Until I met this girl who turned the tables around
She caught me by surprise
I never thought I'd be the one breaking down
I can't figure it out why
I'm so
Caught up
Got me feeling it
Caught up
I don't know what it is
But it seems she's got me twisted
I'm so
Caught up
Got me feeling it
Caught up
I'm losing control
This girl got a hold on me
Let me go baby
Now listen...
My mama told me
Be careful who you do cause karma comes back around
Same old song
But I was so sure
That it wouldn't happen to me, cause I know how to put it down
But I was so wrong
This girl was mean
She really turned me out
Her body was so tight
I'm lookin' for her in the daytime with a flashlight
My homies say this girl is cramping my style
And I can't figure it out but
I'm so
Caught up
Got me feeling it
Caught up
I don't know what it is
But it seems she's got me twisted
I'm so
Caught up
Got me feeling it
Caught up
I'm losing control
This girl got a hold on me
This girl was mean
She really turned me out
Her body was so tight
I'm lookin' for her in the daytime with a flashlight
My homies say this girl is cramping my style
And I can't figure it out but
I'm so
Caught up
Got me feeling it
Caught up
I don't know what it is
But it seems she's got me twisted
I'm so
Caught up
Got me feeling it
Caught up
I'm losing control
This girl got a hold on me x2
Everyone was on their feet, clapping loudly as my cheeks are bright red by now, I'm sure because I wasn't expecting Quinn and Santana to sing to me or choice this particular song. I don't know if following through on this plan at my house is the best way to go about this anymore as Mr. Schue walks over towards them with proud and impressed smile on his face.
"That was amazing girls. If you don't mind, I would like to use this as for duet at Sectionals" Mr. Schue said proudly.
"I'm down with that" Santana said smirking.
"I don't have a problem with that" Quinn said shrugging her shoulders.
"Great. Glee's dismissed for now"
Everyone left the room, leaving the three of us alone together as the duo walked over towards me with apologetic and guilty looks on their faces.
"Look Estrella, I know that me and bitch have been acting like a couple of bitch lately but that's because we really like you… a lot and we're extremely completive" Santana said rubbing the back of her neck.
"We promise you from here on out that we won't fight with each other, right San" Quinn asked wrapping her arm around Santana's shoulders.
"Right Q" Santana said wrapping her arm around Quinn.
I look between the two of them and I'm not all that sure that they will be able to keep that promise but I have to take their word for it for now and I will punish the both of them things get too out of hand. I guess that it won't really because after tomorrow tonight this will all end and hopefully won't remember any of this.
"Okay but I will punish you the next time you guys fight" I said narrowing my eyes at them.
"Got it" Santana nods
"Loud and clears" Quinn smiles.
"Okay Quinn, what would be appropriate for our date?" I asked curious.
"Well I was thinking of going swing dance but afterwards is a secret. I'll pick you up for our date at seven" Quinn said kissing me on the cheek.
"I-I be w-waiting" I said blushing.
Santana glares at Quinn's retreating back before looking down at the ground with this sad expression and I was wondering what could possibly be making her sad but before I ask, she quickly fixed her face as she looks at me with a smile on her face. I open my mouth to say something but I was quickly cut off by the raven haired Cheerio pressing her lips against mine and I held onto her hips to steady myself as the kiss ended to soon for my liking.
Santana looks me in the eye as she holds my face in her hands, running her thumbs along my cheeks then turning on her heel out of the choir room and for some reason the kiss felt like for some reason. Why would Santana be telling me goodbye? Where would she be going? Why was she looking so sad just then? Maybe I'm… I'm reading too much into this. I grabbed my backpack leaving the choir to go home and get ready for my date with Quinn which was simple with her giving me a hint as to what we would be doing, making a little excited for it because I never been swing dancing before. I get dressed, applied light makeup to my face as I checked myself in my full length mirror when I hear the doorbell and I walked down the stair to answer it to see Quinn standing there with flowers in her face along with a shy smile on her face.
"Thank you so much Quinn, they're beautiful" I said taking them from her.
"Not as beautiful as you are" Quinn said smiling.
"You're so sweet. Let me put these in some water then we can go" I said walking into the water.
I quickly find a vase to put the flower, running some water into it then placing them into my room before returning to Find Quinn walking at the bottom of the stair, looking up at me like I was the most beautiful person in the world. She shake her head a little as she holds out her arm for me to take which I do then leads me to car and opening the door chivalrously before getting in herself. Where we were going wasn't far as it was a the community center and they were holding a swing dance as lots of people was walking inside, making me even more excited for this then I already was. The head Cheerio opens the door for me then laces our fingers together before leading inside the building to see that it's decorated like it was the 1920's as couple was dancing on the dance floor.
"Dance with me?" Quinn asked holding her hand towards me.
"I'd love too" I said taking her hand.
Quinn leads me onto the dance floor before twirling me around as I follow her movement and I pride myself on being a phenomenal dance but my partner was better than me in this particular dance that I allowed myself to be lead. I have never had this much dancing and having fun with someone before but I found enjoying this immensely as we danced around the dance floor and when the song ended, everyone was clapping for us. We danced to a few more songs before leaving the dance floor to get some punch and that when we got approached by a much older couple who were well into their late fifties, maybe early sixties.
"Wow you two were amazing out there" the elderly woman said smiling.
"Thank you. I'm Rachel and this is Quinn" I said introducing the both of us.
"I'm Ethel and this is my husband Hubert" Ethel said shaking my head.
"Hi" Quinn said smiling.
"Hello, it's good to see new blood. There's a swing dance party here almost every week and you two should come" Herbert said smiling.
"I think that we will. Right Quinn?" I asked turning to face her.
"Of course. I'll more than happy to bring you if you'd be my partner" Quinn said nudging me with her shoulder.
"I would like it" I said wrapping my arms loosely around her arm.
We said goodbye to Ethel and Herbert before returning to the dance floor for a few songs when Quinn says that she has a surprise waiting for me elsewhere, making almost not want to leave but my want to know what the surprise won out. We got in the car and I asked the Cheerio what the surprise but she just giggle, saying that it wouldn't be a surprise if she told and I pout as I sat in the car. It was at least twenty minutes into the drive that we're heading up a hill and that it looks very familiar to me because Finn took me once because it was the hottest spot for teens to come up and make out. When we reached the top, the view was stunning as I could see over the entire town as well as the star twinkling above as the cheerleader opens the door for me and see that set up blanket with a picnic basket.
"W-What is all this?" I asked surprised.
"I want to do something special for you and I thought what would be better than a picnic under the stars" Quinn said smiling. "You like?"
"Like? I love it. This is so sweet, thank you Quinn" I said kissing her on the lips.
"Good" Quinn said blushing profusely.
We sat on the blanket as Quinn pulls out vegan stir fry that she made herself because she remember me saying that I was a vegan and how the vegan lifestyle was healthier. I didn't even know that she was listening to me or remember that I told her and Glee club since no one ever listens to when I talked especially Finn when we were dating because he forgot and fed me meat, causing me feel absolutely horrible. I cried for hours in my room because if it and I swore that it would never happen again as I tasted the stir fry, it absolutely delicious.
"Wow Quinn, this is amazing" I said smiling.
"Thanks. It took me a few tries to get it right but I did and I'm glad that you like it" Quinn said wiping the corner of my mouth with her thumb.
"I do and this is one of the best dates that I've ever had"
"I'm glad…. Rachel?" Quinn said nervously.
"What is it, Quinn?" I asked curious.
"I know that we've only had one date. Would it be too forward of me to ask for a second date?"
"I don't think that it's too forward at all and I would love to go out on another date with you" I said grinning.
"Great" Quinn said excitedly.
The wind came in causing me to shiver a little when Quinn excused herself to get her jacket from the car and this was my opportunity as I quickly pulled the antidote, pulling into her water bottle before quickly hiding it when she returned. The head Cheerio wraps her jacket around my shoulders before taking a quick sip of her water and I hope that this works in the morning as she pulls me in close as I enjoy her warmth, looking up at the stars above us.
I soon feel a pair of lips lightly pressed against the top of my head and shifted in the cheerleader, looking into her hazel eyes and it feels like I'm drawing in the love and adoration in them but I wouldn't mind too and before I knew it, our lips were pressed against each other in a slow dance. One of Quinn's hands was pressed against the small of my back, holding me against her as the other was resting comfortable on my exposed thigh with my hands laced in her long, silky blonde hair.
I breathed through my nose as the kiss slowly got more heated as I let out a small moan as the head Cheerio lightly nibbles on my lower lip before swiping her tongue against the crease of my mouth, seeking entrance which I granted. I parted my lips as the cheerleader's tongue slips into my mouth, seeking out my tongue and pulling it into her mouth, sucking hard making my eyes roll into the back of my head. I pulled away when the oxygen become a requirement with a small sting of saliva connecting between us as my face is set ablaze.
"W-Wow" I said breathlessly.
"I know. I better get you home since it's getting late" Quinn said blushing as well.
"Y-Yeah" I said.
Quinn and I packed everything up and placed it in the car before she drives me home to see that the lights in the house are on, meaning that my Fathers are home now. The head Cheerio walks me up to the porch and I knew that my Fathers are watching from one of the window but I didn't have to consider that when she lifts my chin upwards as she press her lips against mine in a chaste kiss.
"Goodnight my love" Quinn said smiling.
"G-Goodnight Q-Quinn" I said blushing.
I could hear my Fathers' loud squealing as I shake my head in embarrassment as Quinn walks down the porch and getting into her car before waving at me as she pulls out of the driveway. I will remember this forever and hold close to my heart when Quinn reverts back to her normal self, going back to hating me. I sigh to myself as I enter the house to face my Fathers' interrogation.
Next chapter is Rachel's date with Santana then there's one more chapter which will be the final chapter for this fanfic.
~Nicole The Dragon Rider signing off
End of ch. 4