"Because if you kill me, you'll be executed! Now let me go!" pleaded Denkins.
"YOU KILLED BOTH OF MY PARENTS! YOU'RE GETTING EXECUTED!" retorted Scott.
"They was trespassin' and I was protectin' myself! I have my rights!"
"WHAT WERE MY PARENTS GONNA DO TO YOU?"
Denkins pointed at Cartman. "That little monster told me that your parents were violent pony killers!"
"You killed my parents, made me an orphan, over A FUCKING PONY? You better explain to me RIGHT NOW EVERYTHING that happened that night or you're getting this knife straight through your heart!" threatened Scott.
"Well Cartman told me that violent pony killers were on the loose, so I was on the lookout. Your folks came on to the property, and I shot 'em both."
"You didn't fire a warning shot, call out, ANYTHING?" asked Scott.
"Look, I thought they were out to do harm." replied Denkins.
Cartman, silent this whole time, stirred to action. "Gimme that!" he yelled, snatching the knife out of Scott's hand. Cartman stabbed Denkins in the throat.
It was 11:35 pm. As Denkins lay dying in the stable, one of the ponies relieved himself on Denkins' chest. Cartman and Tenorman ran away into the night.
In a final irony, Denkins was laid to rest just 20 feet from the Tenorman parents.
March 3, 1954 – November 22, 2004