Author's note: Just keep in mind that this is a first time. Smutty smut will start next chapter.
"Quinn, it's ok."
The blonde instantly tensed, turned further on her side and pulled the covers completely over herself.
Rachel laughed a little. "You can't hide from me forever. Eventually you're oxygen will run out under there and you'll pass out and suffocate. And I don't know about you, but I really don't want that to happen."
"Why wouldn't you want that to happen?"
"Are you kidding? Just because you-"
"Don't! Don't say it, Rachel. I'll just die even more of embarrassment." She groaned in a whiny way, wishing she could just sink and disappear into the bed.
(30 minutes earlier..)
Rachel's father's were out until later which meant her and Quinn were in bed half naked. Quinn had her hand resting on Rachel's thigh as she kissed that beautifully tan neck. "Do you want me to go down on you?" She husked it into Rachel's ear. Ever since they used their mouths for the first time, Quinn couldn't get enough of the way Rachel tasted.
Rachel tilted her head to give more access as she bit her lip. "No."
"No?" Quinn pulled her face back to look at Rachel, trying to hide the hurt in her eyes. "But I thought you had your period two weeks ago?" That had to be the only explanation why she wouldn't want it, right? She was practically dry humping Quinn for the last twenty minutes.
"I'm not on my period. I just don't want your mouth down there."
"Oh. Well did you want my fingers?" If Rachel said no, then Quinn would know it's gotten to the point where Rachel was bored with her.
"No. I don't want your fingers down their either."
Quinn clenched her jaw and went to lower her face again before Rachel stopped her.
"Ask me."
Quinn rolled her eyes. "Ask you what? Ask you why you suddenly seem so disinterested in me touching you?" She couldn't help the bite to her words.
Rachel shook her head before biting her lip to hold back a smile. She wasn't surprised that Quinn reacted like this. "Ask me what it is I want down there instead."
Quinn's entire world stopped. Rachel had to be hinting towards...
"Quinn." Rachel turned to kiss down her cheek and to her ear. "Ask me." Her voice was husky before she nipped at Quinn's lobe.
"Oh god!" She squirmed against the girl. "What do you want down there instead?"
Rachel let the question hang in the air before she slid her hand between their bodies and cupped Quinn through her boxers. "I want your dick, baby. I'm ready." She had been ready for awhile now but just finally had the courage to go for it.
Quinn moaned loudly and bucked her hips into Rachel's hand. She pulled back to look the girl in her darkened brown eyes. "Are you sure? Because I so wasn't trying to pressure you and-" The blonde was quickly silenced with a plump pair of lips.
Rachel pulled back. "I'm sure. I know that you weren't. You were trying to pleasure me with your tongue like you do all the time. And while I love it, I think it's time for us to take it a step further. Don't you agree?"
Quinn nodded. "I do. I'm ready, too." In case that was a question at all. Quinn had been ready for even longer than Rachel had.
She rolled her eyes jokingly. "I figured. Thank you for never being pushy about it. I know I must have made you wait longer than most girls would have."
Quinn shook her head. "That doesn't matter. It doesn't matter who it is or what they offer, I want my first time to be with you." She leaned down to give Rachel a reassuring kiss.
Rachel smiled widely before pushing Quinn back playfully. "Don't you think we've done enough warm up kissing tonight?"
"I'll never have enough of your lips."
Sometimes Rachel couldn't believe how sexy yet sweet Quinn could be. "I feel the same. Now take the rest of your clothes off before I change my mind."
Quinn laughed before standing up to get rid of her boxers. As if Rachel was going to change her mind with that large wet spot soaking through her panties.
Rachel quickly stripped herself of the rest of her clothes as well.
There was kind of an awkward pause where Rachel wasn't sure if she should spread her legs and lay back while Quinn wasn't sure if she should just put a condom on or lay between Rachel's legs for kisses.
"Should I..?" Quinn gestured over to her pants bunched up on the floor and then back to her hardened member.
Rachel giggled a little before nodding. "Yeah." She watched Quinn walk over and pull the wrapper out of her wallet. "You aren't mad are you?"
Quinn's eyebrow arched. "What? You just told me you want to have sex with me. Why would I possibly be mad?"
"Well I've just read that some people get upset about wearing condoms. And it's just that I know we're both clean because we've had every sexual first with each other but-"
"But nothing." Quinn crawled on the bed and kneeled between Rachel's legs. "There's more to worry about than diseases and neither of us is ready for a kid right now. It's not worth the risk. I'd never get mad at you asking me to wear one. It's your body I'm going inside." She ripped the packaging open before tossing it aside.
"Wait... Let me?" Rachel hesitantly took it out of Quinn's hand. She placed the opening on Quinn's tip before slowly rolling it down. "I guess all that practice on bananas in school helped."
Quinn rolled her eyes. "At least you didn't pull the side too much and snap it on my dick. I might not be able to perform after something like that."
Rachel laughed at the thought, finishing getting it on all the way. "There we go. I promise to never do that to you. Or at least never do it on purpose."
"Mhm.." Quinn slowly lowered herself down on her arm, reaching between them to hold her cock. She wanted to say something special for the moment but words were failing her.
Rachel lifted her legs up and used her heels to press into Quinn's ass. "Come on, Fabray. Don't back out on me now when I'm wet, spread, and waiting."
Quinn shook her head with a smile, leaning down to kiss Rachel once more. She readjusted herself just slightly and put the head of her cock against Rachel's entrance. "I'm nervous about it hurting you."
Rachel loved how honest Quinn's eyes looked in this moment. She wanted to reach over, grab her phone, and take a picture to make the background of her phone. "You won't. That's why I bought the bigger toy."
Quinn gave her a nervous smile. "It doesn't mean that it's going to feel good right away."
"It's ok. Rachel Barbra Berry can handle anything."
"Even Quinn Fabray?"
"Especially Quinn Fabray. Though she does make it difficult at times.."
Quinn rolled her eyes with a smile. "I'm going to let that comment go in respect to the occasion. I'm going to put it in now."
Rachel gave a confirming nod before trying to relax her hole.
"You're beautiful, you know that?"
Rachel blushed and gave her head a small shake.
"Mhm.." Quinn took a deep breath before very slowly pushing herself in a couple inches.
Rachel put her hands on Quinn's back and squeezed a little to deal with the feeling. She saw the hesitance in Quinn's expression. "It's ok. Just a little uncomfortable. Keep going."
Quinn nodded before getting about halfway in. "Rach?"
The brunette was holding her breath while she tried to adjust. "Just- just put it in all the way." Maybe the quicker this part was done, the better.
Quinn wasn't so sure about that strategy but gave Rachel what she wanted anyway. She pushed her hips forward until she was the entire way inside the girl. "Fuck!" Quinn brought her other hand down against the mattress to hold herself up.
While Quinn was going through the most incredible feeling of her life, Rachel was going through what had to be the worst. "God.." Rachel sunk her nails into Quinn's back while closing her eyes and furrowing her brow. How much worse would this have felt if she never attempted to use her toys to stretch?
Quinn began to panic when she saw Rachel's expression. "I-I can pull out."
"No! Just give me a second, Jesus."
Quinn's eyes widened. Rachel never spoke to her like this.
She took a few deep breaths and opened her eyes. She sighed at the look on Quinn's face. "I'm sorry. It- it feels different than I thought it would."
"Different in a bad way?"
"Different in a painful way." She quickly put her hand on Quinn's arm. "But don't move. I'm- I'm stretching to fit you."
Stretching. Quinn had a new love for that word. "Ok. Tell me when you want me to move." Quinn wanted to take the moment to tell Rachel how tight she was. Tell her how good her dick felt inside of her. However, that would have been extremely insensitive to bring up how amazing it was to her while Rachel suffered.
After a few moments of Rachel shifting and Quinn trying not to moan at it, the brunette gave her a nod and a quiet, "you can move."
Quinn pushed herself up on her arms further before beginning to pull out. She didn't want to take it out. She wanted to keep it inside the wet warmth. It belonged there. As soon as it was all out except the tip, she thrusted back in to the girl again. "Baby.."
"Quinn.. Slow still." It felt like she was being rubbed raw down there.
Quinn took down the pace, attempting to find a steady rhythm to fit them both. This was so much harder than it seemed like on television or in the movies. "How's this?"
"Better." It wasn't hurting quite as much. "I'm sorry you can't fuck me as hard as I know you want to right now."
"Don't say that. This is so perfect." Although going faster would certain feel even more amazing...
"Promise?" Rachel spread her legs more as she subtly moved her hips with Quinn's.
"Promise." She leaned down to sloppily kiss the girl. Was she suppose to be getting this close already?
These were the types of kisses that Rachel loved. So unreserved. So needy... Rachel let out a whimper when Quinn's hand worked its way underneath a tanned legged and hiked it higher.
"Can you feel how fucking deep I'm getting in you? How I'm fitting all of myself in your tight, little pussy?"
"Oh, Quinn.."
The blonde sped her hips up. Every sensation to her cock was more intensified than if Rachel used her mouth or hand. She was fucking a girl. She was fucking Rachel. "Y-you're close?"
What? No she wasn't close. Rachel thought they were just getting started. "I-I'm not there yet, Quinn. It's taking me a little while to adjust."
Fuck. Now what was she suppose to do. She wasn't prepared for something like this because she didn't think it would happen to her. "But-" Quinn licked her lips. "But I need to. Oh god, I'm really about to cum." The slapping of her balls off Rachel's skin and the way the bed was creaking was definitely not helping.
"Can you, I don't know, hold it at all? I'll get there I just need more time." Rachel liked how it felt but it wasn't the same as direct contact to her clit.
"Oh no. I c-can't." Her hips moved faster as she felt her balls begin to tighten. "I h-have to cum. I have to- fuck!" Quinn began pouring herself into Rachel, well, more so the condom.
Rachel's eyes were wide open as she felt Quinn jerking on top of her and into her pussy. "I uh.." she cleared her throat. "That's it Quinn, let it go inside me. Fill me with your cum." If she couldn't contribute by climaxing with her, then Rachel could certainly give her dirty talk.
"I am. I'm giving you everything I fucking have." That was true in more ways than one. After the final tensing of her abs to push the hot liquid out, Quinn groaned loudly and lowered herself on top of Rachel. "Fuck.." She was in a post orgasmic bliss before realizing what just really happened. "Oh my god." Quinn pushed herself back up with an opened mouth, slowly pulling out of the girl. She rolled off of Rachel and turned on her side to face away from her. Quinn tugged the covers over herself before ripping the condom off and throwing it on the floor.
Rachel could barely focus on what just happened. One minute she's giving Quinn her virginity, the next the girl is already cumming, rolling off her, and avoiding her. Usually when Quinn had a moment like this, Rachel just gave her space. She decided to wait a few moments before speaking.
"Quinn, it's ok."
The blonde instantly tensed, turned further on her side and pulled the covers completely over herself.
Rachel laughed a little. "You can't hide from me forever. Eventually you're oxygen will run out under there and you'll pass out and suffocate. And I don't know about you, but I really don't want that to happen."
"Why wouldn't you want that to happen?"
"Are you kidding? Just because you-"
"Don't! Don't say it, Rachel. I'll just die even more of embarrassment." She groaned in a whiny way, wishing she could just sink and disappear into the bed.
Rachel bit her and slid under the covers, putting them over her head just like Quinn. "Hey.. Will you talk to me now that I'm down in your hidden lair? I promise I'll keep everything a secret if you want to share with me." She began running her hand up and down Quinn's side.
"You should have stayed up top. Only losers hang out down here.."
"How can that be? Because I see two smart and sexy girls in here." Rachel added a kiss to Quinn's back.
"I only see one."
"Quinn.."
"What? I mean it. This was so important to both of us and I ruined it."
Rachel rolled her eyes and pulled on Quinn's shoulder so she was laying on her back. "Will you look at me, please?"
Quinn reluctantly turned before connecting her eyes to Rachel's.
"That's better. You didn't ruin anything. Things like this happen and it's nothing to be embarrassed about."
"Yes it is!" Quinn snapped at her before letting out a deep breath.
"Why? Because you couldn't make me-" Rachel couldn't finish her sentence because Quinn covered her mouth with her pale hand.
"Do not finish that sentence."
Rachel peeled the fingers off her mouth before crawling on top of Quinn. She pushed her finger into Quinn's chest. "Now you listen to me, Quinn. Do you have any idea how many times you've made me cum since you showed up at my door?"
Quinn looked away and shrugged her shoulders.
Rachel leaned down and began pressing kisses against her neck. "I used to keep track, but after the first couple of months, it seemed kind of pointless to try to count to infinity minus one."
Quinn smirked a little and bit her cheek to hide it.
"Mmm, did my little math nerd like that one?" Rachel's voice was husky and teasing.
Quinn turned her head back to face the girl. "Maybe.. But you just don't get it."
"Then talk to me. Talk to me and explain it so I can understand."
Quinn sighed before clearing her throat. "It's like- It's like those movies where some dorky kid finally gets to sleep with a hot girl and blows it after two pumps. I used to make fun of those kind of things because I would never be that pathetic. I would be some kind of stud."
Rachel laughed before quieting herself when she got that look from Quinn. "Sorry. Continue."
"Anyway, I was supposed to be someone who could fuck a girl and make her cum five times before I felt like I had to let it go. This is literally my worst nightmare and now you're going to end this whole thing between us because I hurt you and didn't make you cum." She covered her face with her hands. "You should just get off of me so I can go home and sulk in my room."
"Is that what you think? That I'm just some girl who only cares about cumming?" Rachel rested her hands on Quinn's breasts to show she wasn't trying to be defensive.
"..No." Quinn pulled her hands from her face and used them to cover Rachel's. "I don't think that at all. If that was the case then we wouldn't have days where we just go out to eat or watch movies together with no sex whatsoever.
"Exactly. So why would I care about the one time I didn't get off?"
Quinn put her hands on Rachel's shoulders and pulled her in to a kiss. "Because it was our first time," she whispered into the lips in front of her.
Rachel smiled. "You know what the keyword in that sentence was?"
"Hm?"
"First. Meaning that we have," kiss "lots," kiss "and lots," kiss "of time." Rachel began moving her hips back and forth, rubbing her still wet pussy on Quinn's abs.
Quinn moaned at the slick streak forming on her stomach. Her hands moved to Rachel's hips to assist in the motion. "P-plenty of time."
"Plenty of time for you to learn how I need your dick to move inside of me to make me cum." Rachel started to grind herself down harder. "Time for you to build up stamina to handle what it's like being inside my pussy."
"Oh god. You know I love when you talk like that." Quinn started moving her own hips in rhythm with Rachel's.
"I do. But if you want me to keep talking like that, I think you owe me something, don't you?"
Quinn nodded. "Do you want to have sex again?"
Rachel shook her head before kissing her. "I don't think I can handle it on the inside right now. I want you to rub my clit. Rub my clit and give me the orgasm you couldn't earlier."
Quinn sat up to push Rachel off before she felt two small hands on her shoving her back down against the mattress.
"Lay down. I'm only teasing."
Quinn arched her eyebrow. "I see Bossy Berry is back."
"Do you only call me that after I let you go to the next level with me? Now touch my fucking clit before I find someone else that will." Rachel would never let anyone else do this to her besides Quinn right now.
The blonde scowled at Rachel before reaching down and putting her thumb on top of Rachel's clit. She took a deep breath before starting to rub.
"Mmm, that's better. You had me so close earlier..." Maybe not that close but she wanted Quinn to feel more confident. "I can't wait for you to learn everything my body needs during sex so I can cum with you."
"I'll learn!" Quinn's voice was desperate. "I swear I'll become an expert on Rachel Berry's anatomy." Honestly, Quinn thought she already was, but if today proved anything..
"I know you will. I don't care how long it takes with your hands on me or your cock in me." Rachel was bucking her hips into Quinn's thumb. "Actually, you're already good with your hands. You make me feel so beautiful and sexy at the same time with the way you touch me."
"That's because you are beautiful and sexy." Quinn lifted her free hand and put it on Rachel's breast, flicking her nipple with her thumb.
"God! That feels amazing." She looked down to meet Quinn's eyes. "How do I look up here? Do you like seeing me on top of you like this?" That was the Rachel Berry sex voice that drove Quinn wild.
"Perfect. I love it. I can't wait to do it like this."
"Yeah? You want me to ride that big cock of yours, Quinn?"
She nodded her head frantically as she saw Rachel's eyes darken even more.
"Say it."
"I-I want you to ride my big cock."
Rachel smirked. "Good. I want it too. If I hadn't already put your dick through so much today, I'd offer to hop on right now." That's a lie. Her insides were still burning from Quinn thrusting in and out earlier. It's what she was expecting though. All her research and common knowledge told her that's how a first time would be.
And if Quinn's body wasn't still in shock from today's events, she would be the first to suggest it. "Maybe next time you can."
"I will. I want to bounce on your fucking cock. Fuck you as hard as I know you can fuck me."
One of Quinn's favorite things about Rachel, was how she so easily transformed from innocent school girl to dirty talking whore. "Me too. Is that what you want in the future? You want me to pound into you like I picture doing in my head on those nights I don't get to see you. When the only way for me to cum is to wrap my hand around my cock and pretend it's you?
"Yeah, baby. That's what I want!" Rachel's hips were moving faster as she got closer and closer to release.
Quinn smirked. "I know what that look on your face means." She knows she didn't see it earlier either... "You're going to cum soon, aren't you? I mean, you're already dripping all over my abs.."
Rachel nodded as she licked her dry lips. "I want your torso to be covered in me. Keep rubbing. It's about t-to happen."
Quinn circled her clit harder and faster. "Do it. Cum all over me like you own me." Hopefully this would make up for the times Quinn came on Rachel's breasts or stomach.
"Oh I do fucking own you." Rachel tilted her head back and began jerking as she finally got the orgasm she needed. "Quinn!"
"That's it. Show me that I know how to touch my girl."
"You so do.." Rachel clenched her pussy around the invisible dick that she wished was inside of her. After a few more moans, she collapsed down on Quinn's body. Her face found the crook of the blonde's neck as she pressed a solid kiss against it.
Quinn wrapped her arms around her, running her hands up Rachel's sweaty back. "Does that make up for earlier?"
Rachel smiled right below Quinn's jaw line. "No."
Quinn furrowed her brow. "It doesn't?"
Rachel shook her head. "No. But you calling me 'your girl' does."