It had been about a week since Marshall and Fionna began to date. They decided to keep it on the down low by Fionna's request since she was shy and dating the hottest boy in school carries a lot of attention. Tho rumors began to spread since they always meet after school and seen together. They were a real match made in heaven tho; her innocent, shy side complemented his bad boy and intense personality. It was about a week since their Fair date and Fionna decided that he needed to know the truth. She decided to Invite him over to her apartment for a movie, She got dressed nicely and cleaned up the house before picking out a scary movie. She didn't like scary movies, but Marshall loved the way she would cuddle up to him.
She sat and waited before hearing a knock at the door, she got up to see Marshall wearing his usual red and black shirt and jeans. "Hey Fi" He smiled floating into her living room before laying on the couch. She shut the door and went over to him laying on his chest before giving him a soft kiss. "I'm glad you could come tonight Marshall." He blushed dark kissing her back softly "It was nothing Fionna..is something wrong?" "Well there is something I need to confess to you Marshall...but I'm scared..." "Why Fionna..?" "W...well I don't want you to hate me" "Fionna..I love you...I could never hate you, your like my dream girl.." "That's just it!" She jumped off him and walked to the door holding back her tears. "I..I can't keep going like this...I love you so much, but I want you to love ME!" "Fionna what the hell is wro-" "My names not Fionna!" "What..?" he floated over near her. "M...my names Finn...I'm not a girl Marshall...I..I just...I just dress like one...I'm a boy..." She held her hands over her mouth as she started to cry. "y..your...what?" "I'm a boy!" She began sobbing before turning and running out her apartment.
"Fi! He floated out only to see her gone as a downpour started. He quickly floated down and began to look all around calling her name. "Finn! Finn!" he looked for two hours everywhere he stood soaking in the rain trying to add all that has happened in his head. "I..I can't believe it...Fi- I mean Finn...a boy..." He slumped down into the sidewalk holding his head "A...am I gay...I mean I like a boy..I've been kissing a boy...AHHHH!" He punched the ground as his knuckle started bleeding. "Oh, mom...what would you do..." "I'd follow my heart" he looked up to see his mom with a blue umbrella carrying groceries. "You know you shouldn't be out in the rain Marshall." "Mom...I...I'm soo confused.." his eyes started to fill with tears. "Marshall...let me ask you something. When you were with her, were you happy?" "O...of course mom...It was the time of my life.." "and when you last saw her before all this did you feel the same?" "yes..." "Well, it sounds to me like you still love him, and I've always told you that love shouldn't have to be bound by genders. Just look at your sister" she gave him a wink as she got up and started home. He got up and thought carefully about where he could be.
Finn sat in the pouring rain swinging slowly on the rusted swing set where he would play as a child. "You know you're gonna get sick out here.." "why did you come after me..? I'm already sick... the way I am... the way I have been lying to you.." He sat down on the swing next to him as he stared down at the ground. "Y...you love me..?" "Y...yes...I've had such a crush on you... I would see you when we were kids, and my heart would race.." "Why do you dress like a girl then?" "I..I feel more comfortable...I get...nervous around woman..as a boy girls are all over me...your sister I don't get nervous around...same with Bonnie...or FP." He swung back and forth a bit before getting up "come on Finn...let's go..." "Go were...? I don't belong anywhere...I'm weird.." He bent down and cupped his cheek lifting his head softly then kissing him deep. His face turned dark red as he kissed back before starting to fall away from his kiss. "F...Finn..?" He lifted him feeling his head "Oh god you're burning up!" He carried him bridal style rushing back to Finn's apartment.
Once there he ran him to his room and started to remove his clothes. He slowly began removing his shirt blushing as he saw Finn in his bra and socks in them to fill them. He soon got down to his skirt as he removed it and then looked away as he removed his panties and put some boxers on him. After he was dried and changed and Marshall, let his Crimson face calm down a bit he undressed and started to dry off. He could hear Finn mumbling and saw him shivering in his bed. He sighed and climbed in holding Finn close to his chest as he stroked his hair. "I don't know if you can hear me Finn...but it's amazing seeing you like this...For a boy, you are cute...I..I didn't mean for all this to happen...and I guess I was just...scared...but I still feel the same about you. "He kissed him softly on his forehead before drifting to sleep."