For your PLL story book thing I had an idea influenced by the song "Unconditionally" by Katy Perry. Spencer does something bad, but Toby forgives her and he will always love her unconditionally. Submitted by ilovemanyfandoms on Wattpad

Pay attention to the POV switch between Spencer and Toby. It's mostly Spencer's POV but Toby has a little POV.

Spencer's POV

I just finished my first semester of Senior year at U Penn. Toby and I were going out to celebrate tonight.I was 21 and next year I would attending U Penn Law school or so I hoped. Unfortunately I just made the biggest mistake of my life and if anyone finds out I will be in so much trouble. My classes at U Penn were all AP classes and I was always studying. I felt unprepared for one of my finale exams and I did the one thing I didn't think a Hastings was capable of doing. I cheated on a university exam. I feel so awful about it and of course I regret my choices. I cheated because I felt like it was the only way to pass the class.

"It's your night to celebrate so where do you want to go?" Toby asked

"The Brew is fine, I'm not really up for dinner at a fancy place tonight." I said

"Don't you think the Apple Rose Grill would at least be a little bit better?" Toby asked

"What if we just get some carry out and eat here at the loft?" I asked

"If that's what you want but we can have carry out anytime." Toby said

"Fine, we can go out as long as it is just the two of us." I said

Toby's POV

I had a surprise planed for Spencer and so far she had no clue. We wouldn't be going out alone. I invited all of Spencer friend's including Hanna, Caleb, Aria, Jason, Emily, and Alison, her family, and my dad to come celebrate with us at Alfoccino. It was a fancy but not to fancy Italian restaurant. I had it all planed out because tonight I was going to ask Spencer to marry me. No one except Spencer's parents, my dad and Melissa know about my plan. I am worried why Spencer doesn't seem herself. I'm hopeful that this will cheer Spencer up. When we got to the restaurant Spencer seemed happier.

"You wait here while I go inside and see how long of wait it it to get a table." I said

"Fine, but I'm not in the mood to wait very long so we can always go somewhere else." Spencer said

I texted Spencer about two minutes later and told her that the table was ready. When Spencer walked in the restaurant everyone surprised her. Spencer didn't seem to happy and she walked quickly into the bathroom. I asked Melissa to go see if Spencer was alright.

Spencer's POV

I'm happy that Toby set up this surprise party for me but I can't face the people I love not after what I did. It's only going to be a matter of days before I'm kicked out of U Penn.

"Spencer, Talk to me please." Melissa said

I didn't even realize she followed me into the bathroom.

"I did something bad and I can't tell anyone not even Toby." I said

"Spence, you can tell me and I promise I won't tell Toby." Melissa said

"It's so bad I can't tell anyone but don't worry because in a few days the whole world is going to know." I said

"I had a bad week myself and I'm not really ready to talk about it yet but I am here for you Spence." Melissa said

"Did something happen between you and Wren?" I asked

"Yes but tonight is supposed to be about you so try to have fun. Toby didn't plan you a surprise party for you to stay in the bathroom all night." Melissa said

Melissa and I went back to our table. Everything was going alright until just before desert. Toby got up from his seat at the dinner table, walked over to where I was siting, pulled a box out of his pants pocket, and got down on one knee.

"Spencer Hastings, Will you marry me?" Toby asked

I wanted to say yes to Toby so badly but I couldn't, not after what I did. I had ruined my own future and I couldn't let Toby have a ruined future because of of giving Toby a yes or no answer I got up and walked outside. I considered walking back to Toby loft apartment but It was cold and the apartment was 5 miles from here. Before I could even decide were I would go Toby walked outside.

"Spencer will you please tell me what's going on?" Toby asked

"I will but can we go back to the loft first?" I asked

Once we got back to Toby's loft I knew I had to tell Toby what was going on.

"Talk to me Spence." Toby said

"I did something Toby and I'm not sure that you are still going to want to marry me after I tell you." I said

"Spence, If you cheated on me you know I will forgive you. I might be mad at first but what we have is unconditional love." Toby said

"I did cheat Toby but it wasn't on you." I said

"Spence, you are not even making sense right now." Toby said

"I cheated on a U Penn Exam and to make maters worse the person I cheated off of was Andrew Campbell." I said

"Does Andrew know?" Toby asked

"Yes and he sent me a text message saying if I don't turn my self in then he will tell the police." I said

"Spence, Everything will be ok. We will tell your parents together and they will get you a great Lawyer." Toby said

"You don't know that ok and I don't want you getting involved with my mistake." I said

"Since I am a police officer just knowing this could get me in some legal trouble." Toby said

"I know and that is why I didn't want to tell you." I said

"What are you going to do?" Toby asked

"I'm going to turn myself in even if I have to go to jail or something." I said

"Spence, You will almost certiantly get kicked out of U Penn but the most legal trouble you will get in is just a fine." Toby said

"How do you know that?" I asked

"The court doesn't want to waste there time dealing with a case like this. If you physically harmed someone that would be completely different." Toby said

"Goodbye Toby." I said

"Where are you going? Your still welcome to live here Spence even if you get kicked out of school." Toby asked

"I'm going to talk to Melissa and I might end up spending the night somewhere but here." I said

"Don't even think of Spending the night at Melissa and Wren's unless I'm invited to." Toby said

"I wouldn't want to spend the night there unless I had to." I said

I left and drove my car to Melissa and Wren's house. They had bought it and have now been living there for 3 years. As I was about to park my car in front of the house Wren's car pulled up in the driveway. He must have just been getting home from work I figured Melissa's car must have been in the garage. We both walked up to the front door at the same time.

"If you are here to see Melissa she isn't here." Wren said

"Well Melissa lives here so when is she going to be home?" I asked

"Melissa moved out last week." Wren said

"What?" I asked

"Didn't Melissa tell you. She moved out and the engagement is off ." Wren said

"No, I didn't know about any of this." I said

"Well I'm moving back to the UK soon and once I leave Melissa will be moving back in." Wren said

"So where is Melissa staying at the moment?" I asked

"Melissa temporally moved into your parents barn guest house." Wren said

"Thanks for telling me." I said

"Your welcome." Wren said

Wren and I hugged and then he almost kissed me.

"I should go talk to Melissa now before it get's to late." I said

"Sorry about that. Tell Melissa I miss her." Wren said

"If I didn't have Toby then I could see myself dating you." I said

"Good to know." Wren said

I left and drove to my parents house. I had lived there for 18 years and now I hated it when I had to go back. I knocked on the guest house door and Melissa answered right away. I walked in and sat down on the couch.

"Wren told me I would find you here." I said

"So I guess Wren also told you what happened between us." Melissa said

"Wren just said that's he's moving to the UK for a job and that your engagement with him is off." I said

"Well I guess he wasn't the right guy for me after all." Melissa said

"I think you are giving up on Wren way to easily." I said

"He made the choice to take a job 3,500 miles away." Melissa said

"Do mom and dad know?" I asked

"I told them that Wren and I got in a fight but I didn't tell them we broke off the engagement. I was wearing my engagement ring at dinner tonight because I didn't want mom and dad to find out yet." Melissa said

"Are you sure nothing else is going on Melissa?" I asked

"I'm pregnant." Melissa said

"Congrats, When did this happen?" I asked

"Last week, I found out the same day Wren told me he took a Job in London. I went to the doctors yesterday and I'm 6 weeks along." Melissa said

"Does Wren know that your pregnant." I asked

"No, I was going to tell him but before I could we had a fight. You are the first person I have told. This kid is probably better off being raised by a single mom anyway." Melissa said

"I think you should go to London with Wren." I said

"I have to stay here for you." Melissa said

"I will be fine and Jason is here to watch over me. Don't forget Melissa you are not the only older sibling I have." I said

"Do you want to explain to me what happened earlier at dinner when Toby proposed. Normal Spencer would have said yes to Toby without even thinking about it." Melissa said

"No, I shouldn't bother you with my problems since your dealing with some of your own." I said

"Spence, I will talk to Wren but only if you tell me what is wrong with you." Melissa said

"I don't know how to explain this but I completely ruined my future." I said

"If your pregnant to then our kids can grow up together." Melissa said

"No, I want kids just not for a few more years. I cheated on a U Penn exam and Andrew Campbell wants me to turn myself in or he will tell everyone what I did." I said

"Wow, I thought my problems were bad but this Spencer is really bad." Melissa said

"I know that is why I have to do the right thing and be honest about it no matter what the consequences are." I said

"I promise I won't tell Toby but this is something that Mom and Dad need to know about." Melissa said

"I already told Toby and to be honest he didn't seem to upset by it. I think my guilt is worse then anything at the moment." I said

"Spence, Spend the night and then in the morning you really should talk to mom and dad." Melissa said

"Toby probably wonders were I am so maybe I should just go back to the loft." I said

"Call Toby, he's welcome to spend the night here to if he wants." Melissa said

"Thanks." I said

I called Toby and he was over almost right away. Melissa hasn't always been the best sister but she has only been more accepting of Toby then our parents have.

"I'm sorry about how I acted before." I said

"You don't need to apologize to me." Toby said

"Yes I do, I haven't even given you an answer yet to that amazing marriage proposal earlier." I said

"Don't worry about it Spence. No matter what your answer is I will still love you." Toby said

"Yes, Toby I will Marry you." I said

6 months later

Toby and I were busy planing our wedding. Melissa went to London with Wren and their baby was due in about 6 weeks. I confessed to cheating on the Exam. Surprisingly I got to stay in school as long as I re took the Exam I cheated on. I finished my last semester and got an Undergraduate degree majoring in law. In the fall I will be starting Law School. Toby and I talked about having kids and we decided to start trying right after we get married. Toby and I were well on our way to getting the future we always wanted.

What did you think about this one?

This one has the potential to become a multi chapter story so let me know what you think about writing a Spoby multi chapter story based on this. Reviews help me to write more and stories will be updated quicker.

Next "PLL Story Book" chapter is called "Kiss Me Slowly". It is Hanna/Mike but it will also include some Haleb. I'm not sure if Hanna will end with Mike or Caleb.