A/N: I got a comment regarding whether Tiffany was actually Tris with just a lost memory, I am sorry to say that is not the case fellow initiates.
"I'm Tiffany, Tobias's girlfriend," she smiles as she takes my arm. I can't fathom words at this shock of seeing Caleb. I have a mix of emotions: anger for letting Tris go, sadness knowing he lost the same person he loved that day, and embarrassment of having him look at him like that while he is with Tiffany.
"Tobias, huh? Finally let her call you that? I took Tris what, about a year before that became her name for you. How long have you two been together?" Caleb asks, his Erudite clearly showing.
"Two weeks," I say looking at the ground.
"So, you love her is that it?"
I glance over at Tiffany before saying, "No, not quite yet but I'm learning to love again."
She smirks and holds my arm.
"Two year anniversary is coming up soon... You coming?" Caleb asks
"Maybe, we can talk about this some other time."
"She was your girlfriend! You have to come! You love her."
Tiffany looks at me shocked.
"Yes, I lied, Tiffany. The picture was my ex-girlfriend. Yes, I loved her."
"So you don't anymore? After all that? Should hav known," Caleb says getting up and leaving.
Suddenly I wasn't in the mood to have this date anymore. I wanted to go home, alone, and stare at the picture of Tris. Stare at it then scream at her grave about how stupid she was to go in there.
Eventually, i it home alone. Then there is a knock on the door, it's David. The one person who had shot my happiness but could never remember because his mind was erased, or reset as I like to call it.
"What do you want, David?" I ask less than thrilled to see him.
"Just thought I would stop by to see how you were doing. I mean Two years is coming up since your girlfriend... Bit the dust."
"Yeah, too bad I'll never know who killed her," I say hating the fact that I had to pretend it wasn't him.
"heard you had a new girlfriend too, she's a looker. A lot like Tris."
I just nod as hot tears come to my eyes. To be honest, I had almost forgot about Tris dying two years ago. She is pulling me back to her without even knowing; I hate thinking about her being buried and decaying, so I don't. I think of the could have been sand the what-ifs.
The next night, I tell Tiffany I'm doing something with a couple friends and she gets huffy, no that is an understatement, she throws a tantrum.
"You don't like me anymore is that it, Tobias?" She accuses.
"No, I just have to go visit someone tonight with a few friends."
"Who are you visiting and why can't I come?"
"I'm visiting my dead ex girlfriend. Okay?"
"Fine."
That was probably the worst thing she could have said.