"BOO! There is no way you don't have any juicy secrets! I swear, Lucy, every time we play this game you make it boring! We have heard about Iris and her stupid adventures a bazillion times by now, and it only interests Levy! You party pooper! Even Mira brings more fun to the table, and she's the one with all the juicy secrets about others!" Cana shouted, tugging on Lucy's pajamas to bring her up close. Cana had a nasty snarl on her face, looking more like her Quatro Cerberus drinking pal. Levy tried to calm Cana down, but she was too short to be noticed. Mira and Erza shook their heads, Wendy hid in the pillows, and Juvia went and did her own thing. This was an average "girl's night" at Fairy Hills. Lisanna, Evergreen, and Laki stopped going a while back. Laki got annoyed of hearing Cana yell at Lucy for being boring, Lisanna left because her sister continuously shared embarrassing stories about her, and Evergreen for the same reason as Lisanna. Cana, drunk as ever, dropped Lucy onto the couch and sighed. However, something new happened.

"Fine! I'll tell you! Goodness Cana, you're such a pain sometimes!" Lucy yelled at the top of her lungs. Cana fell backwards, almost crushing Wendy. Mira began to whoop. Erza grinned.

"Whoo! Lucy! Lucy! What's! You're! Secret!" Mira shouted cheerfully. Lucy tried to resist a blush as red as Erza's hair but to no avail. She grit her teeth, but then took a deep breath. Covering her face, Lucy began to mumble.

"My secret… My… secret…" Lucy began, but nobody could hear.

"Speak LOUDER!" Cana shouted enthusiastically. Lucy took another deep breath before shouting,

"My secret is that I like Natsu!" Lucy immediately scurried to Wendy and her pillow hideout. Wendy never thought she'd see the day that she patted Lucy's head for comfort. Lucy, digging her face into pillows, blushed harder than Wendy did when she revealed she liked Mest. To do that is somewhat of an accomplishment.

"AAAAAWWWWWW LUCY LIKES THE FIERY BOY, LUCY LIKES THE FIERY BOY!" Cana screamed, booze in hand. She stood on the tabletop, waving the empty bottle. Mira began ripping apart her "shipping photo albums" that had Lucy without Natsu or vice versa. Juvia gave a big sigh of relief that she had one less love rival. Erza started ordering a wedding cake of her preference. Lucy sighed. She was never going to hear the end of it.

"Alright… Natsu, it's your turn!" Gray shouted across the room. At this moment, Natsu, Gray, Gajeel, Laxus, and a handful of other male Fairy Tail wizards were at Gajeel's house. Since he was formerly a part of the Magic Council, Gajeel had upgraded his house. Currently, they were playing "Ultimate Truth or Dare!"

"Sweet! I"m gonna score the most points on this one for sure! Gajeel, I'm gonna crush ya and you'll be screamin' for your money back!" Natsu shouted, an evil laugh following. Gajeel snorted.

"You? Beat me? When this is over, I'll be takin' your emergency safe!" he responded. Natsu shook his head and pulled out a paper from the Truth and Dare cups. Gray grinned. The whole night, nobody had drawn "the paper". Gray wrote it, and was sure it'd take anybody down. Crossing his fingers, Gray wished the truth paper Natsu had was the one.

"Okay… the dare is to… pretend you're drunk and make out with Max's broom?!" Natsu yelled in astonishment. The guys cracked up. Gray didn't laugh though. He was too busy making extra hands to cross more fingers with.

"And the truth is… say who you like…" Natsu started off enthusiastic, but his voice lowered. Gray's eyes widened, a huge smile on his face.

"YEEEEEEEEEEESSSSS!" Gray shouted. Natsu gave Gray a nasty look. Laxus and Gajeel were already betting whether Natsu would pass it or not. Gray saw the look on Natsu's face. He couldn't afford for him to skip the truth, so Gray threw in a little bit of bait.

"Natsu, you know you're losing, right?" Gray called out to the fire dragon slayer.

"Am not!" Natsu yelled. Gray shook his head.

"Yes you are. If you bothered to check the scoreboard, you'd see you're in last place." Gray explained, pointing to the scoreboard. Indeed, Natsu had the least points.
"Rrrgh… Fine! I'll do both!" Natsu shouted, face getting close to his hair color. Laxus gave a little "yeah!" seeing as he won his bet with Gajeel. However, Gray didn't care. He wanted to hear who Natsu liked. Lisanna? Erza? Either way, Gray would make sure Natsu never heard the end of it.

"I like Lucy!" Natsu shouted quickly, to get it out of the way. All the guys in the room fell silent before bursting into laughter.

"That's one secret you got, flame brain! Ha! Guess it's not a secret anymore though!" Gray shouted cheerfully.

"Natsu likes the blondie! Natsu like the blondie!" Gajeel chanted in between laughs. Natsu had succeeded in blending in with his hair.

"Hey! What about the dare?!" Laxus shouted. Everyone quieted down. That is, except Gray.

"Hey Natsu! 10 extra points if you pretend the broom is Lucy!" he shouted. Chuckles flew around the room. Natsu was so pissed but embarrassed that he began to burst into flames. Laxus and Gajeel bet again if Natsu would do it or not.

"Grrrh… If I win, you all owe me a lot of money! So fine, I'll do it!" Natsu yelled. He walked over to Max, snatched the broom, and began to passionately kiss it. Laxus yelled at Gajeel and gave him a pile of money, and the rest of the guys laughed until they couldn't breathe.

The next day, Natsu and Lucy couldn't even look at each other.