Two Puzzle Pieces (Mario X Amy Rose)

by The Afterdreamer

After Peach's decision in Mario Odyssey and Sonic's final straw on Amy, Mario and Amy felt heartbroken. One night, knowing that there is no place to go, the new Hedgehog Plumber Couple venture off in Waluigi and Zazz's Hidden Island Paradise, Whimsic Isle. Join Amy and Mario on an adventure to Whimsic Isle, an adventure like none other before.

4. Chapter 3

Two Puzzle Pieces: Mario X Amy Rose

Chapter 3: Notified

Down at the Baseball Field, the Mario and Sonic teams set up to play. Peach, rather looked a little not to worried about Mario. Sonic had nothing to notice either.

"Alright team!" Sonic cheered. "All we gotta do is win this game! Give it all you got with the power of teamwork!"

"I have a feeling this is going to be so fun!" Cream smiled.

"Um Sonic?" Tails looked around. "Have you seen Amy?"

"Oh. She's probably deciding which athletic outfit to wear. I'm sure it wouldn't be that long." Sonic assumed.

"Oh. I see." Tails also assumed. "Are you afraid of getting her cuz she'll nag on you again?"

"I'm pretty sure it feels like a trap." Sonic expressed with the 'whatever' shoulder pose.

"Amy looked too sad yesterday." Cream said in a worried tone. "She looked like she was never coming back..."

Tails remembered something. "Hey Sonic!"

"Yes, Tails?" Sonic answered.

"Do you ever go to gyms?" Tails asked.

"No. Why?" Sonic asked with a suspicion.

"Amy said you've been working out in a gym. And she asked me to give her your Transport Box." Tails added. "I assumed she was out to take you on an adventure trap."

"Oh no. That couldn't mean-" Cream got worried.

"We gotta get her back!" Sonic ordered. "Tails! You cancel the game! I'll look around for her!" Sonic left off at a high speed.

Meanwhile, at Peach's side.

"Hey, Princess." Luigi asked. "Did Mario said he was gonna be here-a?"

"He said he was." Peach remembered.

"Did he-a say it in a different tone?" Luigi asked.

"Now that you mentioned it..." Peach digs deeper. "He wasn't jumpy at the moment."

"That-a means Mario gone somewhere else-a." Luigi answered.

"At a time like this?!" Peach face palmed, princess style. "Can you get the rest to look for Mario? He couldn't get THAT far."

"I'll cancel the game-a..." Luigi insisted.

And by that, Mario and Sonic crew looked around for the two missing friends.

They met again at the Baseball Field.

"Hey Luigi!" Sonic called.

"Sonic! Have you seen Mario?!" Luigi asked.

"Not a sight of him anywhere!" Sonic answered. "Also must be the same as Amy!"

"This is horrible!" Cream's eyes start to water. "Not only is Amy is gone, but Mr. Mario too!"

"Don't-a worry, Cream!" Luigi said. "We'll find them soon-a!" Luigi begins thinking. "Maybe we can visit a Psychic."

"Good idea, Luigi!" Sonic agreed. "Let's go!"

And with that, the crews left to the Psychic at a Toad Town.

"I see all, I know all." The psychic begins his phrase. "I see you are missing two people."

"That's right!" Sonic responded. "Please tell us where they are gone!"

"Or tell us WHY they are gone!" Peach added.

"You want the good news or bad news first?" The psychic asked.

"Always the good news!" Sonic ordered.

"Well..." The psychic shows Luigi, Sonic, Peach and Tails a vision. It shows Mario and Amy walking happy. "The good news is, they are still alive. And happy!"

"So why were they gone? I don't get it." Peach asked.

The vision shows Amy and Mario crying in sadness and brokenness. Sonic and Peach were facing away. This caught their attention a bit.

"The bad news was, that YOU were the reason they left!" The psychic answered. The vision shows Amy and Mario looking at each other in a bit of relief. Sonic and Peach focused. Mario and Amy hugged each other with a happy feeling.

"Oh! So those two had gone on an adventure I see!" Sonic said in a relief.

"Oh Mario!" Peach giggled as she thought it was cute. "Always there for a friend!"

"Perhaps... Even MORE than a friend." The psychic revealed.

"What?" Sonic and Peach asked.

"Take a closer look." The Psychic commanded.

Amy and Mario, now holding hands in a sweet hug, looked at each other's eyes. Peach and Sonic focused harder on their attention. And the vision shows, the two giving a sweet kiss of romance. Sonic and Peach were shocked. They would be happy if this was a bit easy, or at least, too easy.

"These two have built a love for each other. An inseparable love of two broken pieces. Or perhaps... Two Puzzle Pieces." The vision ends.

"MARIO! HOW COULD YOU?!" Peach grew furious at the vision.

"Amy! Why?!" Sonic shouted.

"It was all made by a mistake you two had made." The psychic revealed. "You two broken them up. But they fixed each other."

"And now they're boyfriend and girlfriend." Tails concluded.

"They will also be married in 3 days." The psychic revealed. "In Whimsic Isle."

"NO!!" Sonic and Peach shouted. They ran outside ignoring the truth.

"I don't see the problem-a." Luigi said to Tails.

"Me neither." Tails responded. "I see that they want someone they can dominate back."

"Ooooooh!" Luigi finally understands. "Sonic would-a be NOTHING without a Damsel in his team! And Princess will lose a bodyguard, KNOWN to stop evil!"

"I guess you can put it that way." Said Tails. "But either way, it was a lose lose for them both."

"TAILS! GET THE TORNADO READY! WE'RE HEADING TO WHIMSIC ISLE!" Sonic shouted.

"LUIGI! PACK SOME POWER-UPS! AND FAST!" Peach demanded.

Both, out of a jump, obeyed.

And soon enough, they left to the Tornado and flew off with a map to Whimsic Isle.

(Note: Sorry if I came unprepared)