Thanks for checking back!
In this chapter, Will grows jealous upon hearing of his friends' sexual encounters at the Snowball. Mike, Lucas and Dustin come up with a plan to make him feel better. Things escalate from there...
Quick note: I had to frequently refer to the guys by their D&D counterparts to avoid repeating their names in every sentence. You probably know this already but just in case you don't: Mike is the Paladin, Lucas is the Ranger, Dustin is the Bard and Will is the Cleric.
If you're not comfortable with gay stuff, this is your chance to quit while you're ahead. This chapter will contain some pretty intense boy on boy (on boy on boy) smut.
Obligatory *Don't Like, Don't Read* warning.
HEAVY SMUT AHEAD
Chapter 4: First Time for Everything
December 20, 1984
Five days after the Snowball - Wheeler House
Nancy Wheeler appeared at the foot of the basement stairs, clutching in her hands several bags of popcorn and four bowls.
"Ok, Mike, we're going now. Are you sure you guys are gonna be okay on your own?"
"We're not five, Nancy. We know how to stay down here and sleep all night," her younger brother shot back.
Rolling her eyes, the high school girl turned to leave, in doing so accidentally making eye contact with the one person she was deliberately avoiding.
A coy smile formed on Dustin Henderson's face. The boy winked at her, the Wheeler girl's own face reddening as his attempts to get a flustered reaction out of her worked quicker than he'd hoped.
Nancy glared at him with dark eyes and shook her head inconspicuously, at the same time trying desperately to hide her blush from the other boys.
Turning, she raced up the stairs without a word, the basement door slamming shut.
"Umm... what was that about?" Lucas Sinclair questioned his curly-haired friend.
"That?" the boy responded, "Oh... y'know... just..."
He wanted to tell them so badly.
"Just... what?"
"Well, you know how she danced with me at the Snowball?" he began, sounding like what he was about to say wasn't a big deal.
"Yeah?"
"After we finished she..." he paused for effect, his coy smirk now a smug one.
"She...?"
"Well she... let me... y'know... fuck her. I've been wanting to tell you, I was just trying to find the right time," the boy stated, matter-of-factly.
Mike grimaced as Lucas and Will erupted into laughter.
"Do you dream about her, often?" Lucas quipped.
The Henderson boy turned defensive. He'd actually expected them to believe him.
"Ask her your fucking self! Why do you think she blushed?"
The other guys were taken aback by his sudden change of tone.
"You definitely did not fuck my sister." Mike stated, the boy clearly disgusted by the images his friend was putting in his mind.
"Wait, hold on..." Dustin paused for a moment, pretending to think. "Nope, I definitely fucked your sister!"
The sly grin returned.
"Bullshit!" Lucas blurted.
Admittedly, the other boys were growing suspicious. Nancy had clearly blushed when she saw him. What reason could there be for that?
Frustrated, the Wheeler boy was determined to one-up him.
"Well even if you did, which you didn't-"
"I totally did."
Mike began again, "Even if you did, which you didn't, it was probably just because she felt sorry for you. You weren't making love like me and El were."
He wouldn't usually have been so keen to reveal such a thing, but Dustin's claims about his sister had irked him.
"What?!" Sinclair and Henderson sounded at the same time.
"You heard me!"
It was his turn to be smug now.
"While you were off doing whatever the fuck you think you were doing with my sister, I was making love to my girlfriend."
Silence.
"Really?" Lucas asked, surprised by Mike's forwardness.
"Yeah."
"She sucked your dick?" Dustin questioned, prying for lewd details.
Surprisingly, Mike didn't blush. His pride was soaring above his self-respect as he nodded confidently.
"That's great and everything... but did you fuck her ass?" his dark-skinned friend asked.
"What? No! Just her... pussy."
He felt dirty talking about El like that to his friends.
Lucas' quizzical expression turned into a full-on shit-eating grin. He puffed his chest in superiority and began what sounded like some sort of lustful soliloquy.
"Don't get me wrong, pussy's great! But there's nothing like the feeling of being inside a woman's ass."
Mike snorted.
"And just how much experience do you have fucking womens' asses, Sinclair?"
The darker-skinned teen raised an eyebrow in thought.
"About five days."
Lucas sat back and listened to the clogs turning in their heads.
Initially puzzled by his oddly specific response, they soon pieced together what he was saying.
Mike and El weren't the only couple who had consummated their relationship that night.
In all honestly, they weren't too shocked at the revelation. They all knew that Lucas and Max had a thing for each other and it was only a matter of time before they would do something about it.
"In the AV Room, in case you were wondering."
"We weren't."
"Wait..." Mike interjected. "You're saying you fucked Max's ass?"
"I am saying just that, my friend."
Mike looked down in disappointment, his friend's tale having bested his own.
Lucas was desperate to tell his friends more about his erotic encounter with the redhead. But he had already defeated Mike and so he took the win while he was ahead, however not before adding one last insult to injury.
The Sinclair boy proceeded to proudly inform his friends that he had fucked Max no less than three times since the Snowball.
He didn't, however, tell them about all the filthy things they had done to each other during their intense fucking sessions.
Just two days ago, Lucas had exploded all over Max's face as she jammed two fingers inside him. The day before that, he came just from having her tongue in his ass.
He was saving those glorious details to gloat about later.
Will could feel his pants tightening as the image of Mike and Eleven making love was still racing through his mind. His erection certainly didn't falter when he thought instead about Lucas fucking the newest party member in the ass.
His facing turning a deep red, he suddenly leapt up.
The others, too distracted verbally flaunting their sexual prowesses, had forgotten he was even there, his having not spoken a single word for several minutes.
"I... uh... I have to use the bathroom."
He turned to leave but was stopped by Mike, who grabbed onto his hand.
The Byers boy felt his blush deepen as the other three party members noticed the clear bulge in his jeans.
"Oh... that's... uh... that's nothing to be embarrassed about, Will," his dark-haired friend reassured him.
"Yeah, we all get boners, dude! Lucas pointed out. "It happens."
"It's just..." he began explaining himself. "It's just... you've all had... sex... and I haven't and I just feel kinda left out and I know it's not your fault but I-"
"Will, it's okay," the party's Paladin attempted to ease his friend's obvious jealousy.
Seeing Will's boner had gotten Mike fairly aroused himself. A sudden wave of lust and sympathy for the boy washed over him as an exciting thought entered his mind.
"Maybe we could... cheer you up?"
He emphasized the final three words, intently eyeing the other two, who gawked in response to his suggestive idea, knowing full well what he meant.
All their talk of fucking had gotten Lucas and Dustin too turned on to refuse. They looked at Will and then back to Mike.
"Y-Yeah... sounds good!"
Will felt the weight of being the only virgin in the room begin to lift as his three best friends straight up offered to sexually gratify him, their newfound confidence of everything related to sex urging them on.
The Paladin swiped his hand across the oversized table, flinging its contents onto the floor; D&D pieces now strewn across the Wheeler basement. He looked at Will.
"Why don't you sit on there?"
Swallowing nervously, the Byers boy followed his friend's command, hopping up so he was sitting on the table.
Once the Cleric was in position, Mike wasted no time. He removed Will's pants, leaving his throbbing five inch erection exposed in front of his friends. Getting straight to it, he gently flicked his tongue across the swollen head, eliciting a whimper from the boy.
Looking at Will's cock with lustful eyes, Mike bobbed his head down and swallowed the whole shaft in one suck, his nose resting just above a small patch of hair.
Mike lifted his head, leaving just the tip in his watering mouth before pushing back down, guzzling the hard dick as Will moaned from above.
Lucas and Dustin watched the party's Paladin blowing Will, their own dicks now at full hardness and aching to be released. Sharing a knowing glance, they simultaneously began rubbing their hands over each others' bulging crotches.
Mike, meanwhile, was using one hand to remove his own jeans and the other to tug on Will's balls as he fervently slurped his best friend's cock.
Will ran his hands through Mike's soft hair, moaning as the Wheeler boy gave him his first blowjob. For a second, he looked over to the side and saw the remaining two party members hurriedly removing their clothes, desperate to join the fun.
Out of habit, Lucas kept his camouflaged bandana wrapped around his head. Max had requested, or rather, insisted that he wear it when they were getting intimate, claiming it was "sexy."
Once they were naked, Dustin seized an opportunity and boldly pressed his lips to Lucas', unsure of how his friend would react. To his surprise, the dark-skinned boy didn't pull away, instead he reciprocated, deepening the kiss.
Will's dick twitched in Mike's mouth when he saw Lucas and Dustin's hard cocks pressed together as they sloppily began to make out.
The Byers boy gasped as Mike began sucking his balls, focusing on them individually before filling his mouth with the whole sack.
A few feet away, Dustin and Lucas were using their tongues to explore each others' mouths, their glans exchanging sticky pre-cum as their erections bumped together.
Lucas slid his hands down Dustin's back and grabbed his ass, squeezing it lightly as his curly-haired friend moaned into his mouth. Dustin returned the favor and gripped Lucas' butt with both hands, the two horny teens increasing the intensity of their homoerotic display.
On the table, Will squirmed as Mike moved back up to his suck on his dick. The Paladin smirked with the Cleric's cock in his mouth, noticing the pleasure he was inflicting on his friend.
Moving his head to the side, Will once again caught sight of the two other boys, their mouths still firmly attached as they kissed, not once stopping to take a breath.
Dustin took things further by slowly pulling on Lucas' asscheeks and tracing his finger over the constricted hole between them. The party's Ranger groaned as he felt something press against his asshole.
But before the Bard could sink his finger into his friend's tight ass, the resounding voice of Mike Wheeler caught his attention.
"I thought this was supposed to be about making Will feel good?" he asked, his hand gently stroking the pulsing dick in front of him. "You know, you guys are more than welcome to join us at any time?" he offered, sounding slightly exasperated and feeling a little guilty that Will wasn't receiving the full party's attention.
Although not wanting their one-on-one make-out session to end, the two boys couldn't refuse Mike's offer.
By the time they reached the table in the center of the Wheeler basement, Mike had embedded a finger in Will's butt, the teen writhing and moaning in pleasure.
Dustin immediately went for Will's hard dick, now left untouched as Mike focused his attention on his ass instead.
Will gripped onto the table as Dustin engulfed his rock-hard cock in his mouth, his tongue licking up and down the shaft.
Lucas could see there wasn't any more room between Will's legs where the Paladin and the Bard were hard at work. Instead, he clambered onto the sturdy table, confident it would take the added weight and crawled over to Will, straddling the moaning teen.
The Ranger leaned down and closed the gap between them, engaging Will in a deep and passionate kiss. Will shivered as Lucas' dick dragged along his skin, leaving a trail of pre-cum on his chest. The Cleric let his hands roam his friend's hot body.
Detaching his mouth from Will's raging boner, Dustin looked up and saw Lucas' upturned butt in front of him. An incredibly hot idea surging through him, the Bard continued to pump Will's spit-covered cock as he leaned forward and tentatively dragged his tongue across Lucas' tight asshole. Immensely turned on by his own daring move, he soon found his wet tongue lashing at the puckered hole.
"Mmm... shit! Fuck!"
Moaning loudly, the dark-skinned boy shuddered as he felt Dustin's tongue lapping at his ass.
Damn, he's almost as good as Max.
Lucas turned to face the Henderson boy, who dislodged his skillful tongue from his butt as their eyes met. Smirking proudly at the moans he elicited from his best friend, Dustin dutifully resumed his task.
Mike's erection throbbed as he watched the curly-haired boy's face disappear between Lucas' asscheeks.
Will was now willing to forgo receiving all the attention. Determined to increase the pleasure, he ducked his head under Lucas' chest and closed his mouth around one of his nipples.
Lucas' pulsating cock twitched wildly between his legs as he was stimulated by two hot tongues, small drops of pre-ejaculate dripping down onto Will.
Noticing Dustin's hands had relocated to the dark flesh of the Ranger's ass, the Wheeler boy took it upon himself to stroke Will, who was busy sucking on Lucas' nipples.
Dustin reached for Lucas' throbbing cock and began jerking it slowly. Every so often, he moved his lips down and sucked on his balls, pulling on the sack until it popped out of his mouth, before returning to sink his tongue into the delicious ass in front of him.
Although Mike was still continuing to please Will with his finger, he sensed the tide turning, realizing the others were open to anyone and everyone being pleasured, not just their Cleric. At that, a sexy idea crossed his mind as he returned his mouth to Will's cock, his own neglected dick oozing pre-cum at the sight of Lucas having his ass eaten.
Mike thought his bold plan through and withdrew his finger from inside Will.
"Maybe Will could...?" he called out, causing the others to turn as a noise that wasn't a slurp or a moan sounded. Apprehensively, he gestured to Will's pulsing erection and then to Lucas' butt, hoping they would all approve his erotic idea.
Eyes shifting nervously, Lucas processed what Mike was suggesting.
The Paladin noticed and stammered out a follow-up, "If.. you know... that's okay with everyone?"
Rejecting the idea would no doubt kill the increasingly hot sexual urges bubbling up inside the boys and Lucas had come too far to back out now.
The Ranger cautiously nodded his head, "Y-Yeah..."
Will's eyes were wide with disbelief. He had fantasized about each of them many times. The boy nodded, eagerly, as the thought of fucking one of his best friends entered his dick, a clear drop of pre-cum spilling out as a result.
At his approval, the Wheeler and Henderson boys got to work; Mike using his mouth to get Will's excited cock as slick as possible; Dustin stretching out Lucas' tight hole with first one, then two and finally three fingers.
The Ranger and the Cleric brought their mouths together, their muffled moans sending vibrations across their lips.
Mike gave a few more deep sucks before pulling off and gripping the base of Will's dick, guiding it towards the Sinclair boy's awaiting ass.
Both boys groaned as their bodies touched, the tip of Will's erection gently nudging into the tight hole. Lucas pushed down slowly, allowing his ass to sink down on his friend's rapidly twitching cock. After he adjusted to Will's size, he lifted himself as Byers pushed up, the dick slamming all the way into his butt.
"Mmm... fuck!" the horny teen moaned, as he quickly got used to the feeling of having a thick cock buried in his ass.
He pictured Max squirting as she watched her boyfriend getting assfucked by one of his friends.
Meanwhile, Mike found himself climbing onto the table and positioning his knees either side of Will's shoulders, catching the attention of the two boys currently moaning with great intensity.
Lucas was face to face with Mike's pulsing dick. He eyed it for a second before closing his mouth around it, feeling the hard member throb in his mouth. The Paladin moaned as the Ranger sucked his cock.
Still thrusting in and out of Lucas' butt from below, Will lifted his head off the table, planted it firmly between Mike's asscheeks and began frantically slurping his best friend's asshole.
Slowly stroking his hard dick, Dustin watched intently as Lucas was double-stuffed with cock.
Wanting to get a piece of action, the last boy hurriedly climbed onto the table, its sturdy frame still not bucking under the weight of the four bodies.
Mike, his cock still halfway down Lucas' throat, gestured for Dustin to turn around, his hands pulling on Dustin's hips as his face met with the curly-haired boy's ass.
Not wasting any time, he dove his face in Dustin's butt, tonguefucking the tight hole with the same ferocity as the Henderson boy had been doing to Lucas and as Will was doing to him now.
The intense cocksucking, asslicking and assfucking continued until all four boys were on edge. Not wanting their hot fuck session to end so soon, they detached their mouths and dicks from each other.
As soon as Will pulled his cock from Lucas' ass, Dustin greedily shoved it in his mouth, giving it a few deep sucks, before the horny teens stopped completely to allow their rising climaxes to fade.
Once they were ready to go again, they switched places.
Mike lay with his back on the table, just as Will had been doing. The Paladin groaned as his legs were pushed up and he felt something nudging at his lower end, looking down just in time to see Dustin's thick cock sliding into his ass. Will's saliva shined on Wheeler's opening, sufficiently lubricating the intruding member.
"Shit, Mike! You're so tight!" the Bard observed.
Lucas straddled the grunting Wheeler boy, moaning as his thick pulsing shaft glided down Mike's throat, his balls resting on his friend's face, laden with unreleased cum.
Finally, Will filled the gap and guzzled down on Mike's dick, his own ass inches from Lucas' face. The dark-skinned boy wasted no time and sank two fingers and his tongue into the tight hole, causing the Cleric to hum around Mike's erection.
The Paladin was writhing in pleasure as Dustin's twitching hard-on slammed into his butt, Will's hot mouth deepthroated his dick, and Lucas' dripping cock fed into his mouth.
After fingering Will's ass for some time, Lucas pulled his sticky rod from between Mike's wet lips and lined it up behind the butt in front of him.
The Cleric whimpered as his tight asshole was penetrated for the first time. Lucas' dick was the biggest of the boys, standing proudly at a little over six inches.
As such, Will growled when all six inches of his friend's meat were stuffed into his butt, the small patch of dark hair above the cock brushing against his skin.
In an effort to instensify his lover's pleasure, Lucas stroked Will's throbbing cock, the shaft still slick with Mike and Dustin's combined spit.
Lucas' erection now engaged elsewhere, Mike glanced around, desperate for something in his wanting mouth. Looking up, he found a solution. Lifting his head off the hard wood, he buried his entire face in Lucas' ass, now satisfied that he had got to explore all three of his friend's butts with either his fingers or his tongue.
The basement of the Wheeler home was alive with the sounds of slapping flesh, wet slurping and hot moans as the four best friends enjoyed their wild fucking session.
Feeling Dustin's dick wrench itself from his ass, Mike groaned. He found himself unable to look to his friend as Lucas was now riding his face, the dark teen's own cock still sawing into Will's hole.
At this point, Dustin was in possession of the only ass that hadn't been stuffed with a thick cock. Aiming to change that, he spoke up, his booming voice barely cutting through the loud moans coming from his three companions.
"Hey, guys! Any chance I could get some action over here?" he flashed his newly-toothed smile.
Lucas shot him a dirty look before he could end it with a purr.
At that moment, a thought worked its way into Dustin's head that made his cock pulse with excitement.
"I have an idea. Lucas, go sit over there," he pointed to the couch on the other side of the room.
Complying with the Bard's demand, Lucas pulled out of Will and lifted his butt from Mike's face, a few strings of saliva at first still connecting his used hole to his friend's mouth.
Wiping at the sweat from underneath his bandana, the still-horny teen apprehensively relocated to the three-seater, layers of shiny spit and pre-cum clearly visible on his dark cock.
Desperate to be fucked, Dustin practically sprinted over to Lucas. The Henderson boy wasted no time sitting down on Lucas' hard dick, all six inches fitting snugly in his tight asshole. The curly-haired boy released a low, drawn-out groan.
"Fuuuck yeah, that's it! Shit! Mmm. fuck my ass, Lucas!"
As quickly as the words left his mouth, Dustin could feel the cock inside him pulsating rapidly.
Lucas craned his neck upwards and brought his mouth to Dustin's, their tongues thrashing around in their hot, wet caverns.
The two other party members were staring in awe at the incredibly hot display their friends were putting on, before they themselves were invited to join the show.
Dustin motioned to Will, who slowly edged his butt down onto the Bard's throbbing erection.
The Paladin was the last to join, adopting a half-standing, half-crouching position. He pushed down and sank his ass all the way down on Will's sticky cock.
The four best friends were now stacked up on top of each other, fucking and moaning in unison as their cocks twitched inside warm, tight holes.
Lucas fucking Dustin.
Dustin fucking Will.
Will fucking Mike.
All four bodies glistened with sweat as they plowed into each other.
Unfortunately for Mike, being on top meant he didn't have one of his friend's butts to stuff his dick into. Still needing his erection to feel some kind of pleasure, the Paladin desperately reached down to stroke his intensely throbbing dick, his hand catching the arm of the sofa and sending his SuperCom crashing to the floor.
"Shit!"
Mike himself wasn't sure if his cursing was caused by his heavy-handedness or by the dick that was violently twitching inside his ass.
He glanced down at the floor, the walkie-talkie on its side but still seemingly intact, not that he cared at that moment.
The horny teens could feel their orgasms approaching once again as their rapidly tightening balls smacked against each other, the four sacks each filled to the brim with hot cum waiting to be unleashed.
Deciding to take up one more sexy position before ending their erotic exhibition, they unstacked themselves and moved down onto the floor of the Wheeler basement.
The guys had no idea how they'd lasted so long. They figured their sudden lust for each other and their apparent need to do anything and everything had kept them going.
They took their places on the floor, laying on their sides in a row next to each other.
A symphony of moans began to play as, simultaneously, three of the four boys felt their cocks sinking into a tight asshole one last time.
Dustin murmured into Will's ear, his bulging erection gliding into the writhing Cleric's butt.
"Satisfied now?"
Will could almost hear the filthy smirk in his voice. His response came in the form of a deep kiss.
Behind him, Dustin's hole was tightly gripping onto the Sinclair boy's pulsating boner. The Ranger would be moaning loudly if he wasn't engaged in a sloppy make-out session with the Wheeler boy, who was enjoying the feeling of his dick shoveling in and out of Lucas' butt.
They were rutting like animals now, thrusting into each other at an insane speed as their symphony played on, all kinds of dirty phrases being tossed around.
Mike removed his lips from Lucas' and tried something new. He brought his hand down hard, smacking the teen's ass and leaving a faint handprint that blushed against the dark skin.
Lucas groaned in response as Mike teased him, "Yeah... you like that, Lucas?"
Smack.
He did it again.
"You like my dick in your tight ass?"
The dark-haired Wheeler boy wasn't exactly accustomed to dirty talk. Nevertheless, he was still pleased with his attempts.
"Mmm... fuck yeah!" Lucas moaned.
The four boys knew they were at their end now.
Finally reaching the erotic coda, Mike, Lucas and Dustin each pulled their pulsing dicks from the used fuckholes.
Mike leapt to his feet as the three remaining party members took to their knees below him. Furiously stroking his aching cock, it took him only five seconds to explode, firing thick juicy strands of cum across his friends' faces that dripped down into three open mouths. After a seemingly endless ejaculation that drenched the others, he let out a deep groan.
The Paladin dropped to his knees beside Lucas and Dustin as the Cleric jumped up, and without warning, spurted five shots of his creamy load onto the three waiting faces, the hot boycum mixing with Mike's as his cock spasmed wildly.
Dustin was next, several thick strings of cum firing from his engorged tip, only just hitting Will as the boy sank back down onto his knees. Decorating three willing faces with more white, the curly-haired boy groaned as his balls emptied onto his friends.
Cum dripped onto the floor as Dustin resumed his kneeling position, his mouth opening along with Mike and Will's as they prepared to take on one last delicious explosion.
Violently erupting, Lucas' cock shot rope after rope after rope of hot cum onto his friends, his creamy white spunk releasing in eight strong bursts. He moaned intensely as he watched his thick load splatter across their faces, some of it straight into their open mouths.
Feeling his forehead dripping with cum, Lucas dropped back down to his knees.
The boys began to make out fiercely as they enjoyed the salty taste in their mouths, their tongues licking at what remained of the four combined loads of thick teen jizz. They used their mouths one last time to clean the sticky mess from each others' softening dicks.
After they had completely swallowed everything on offer, the four exhausted friends collapsed onto the three-seater, its lack of a fourth seat making for a cramped experience.
As their heavy panting died down, the only sound that could be heard was the faint hissing of static. Mike glanced down at his SuperCom on the floor, still on its side, the push-to-talk button pressed firmly down under its weight.
5 minutes earlier...
In a remote cabin in the woods, El Hopper and Max Mayfield hungrily feasted on each others' dripping pussies, the sound of slapping flesh and their boyfriends' moans blaring through the speaker of the walkie-talkie on the table in front of them...
Huge thanks to brucewaynefan for suggesting this fantastic idea and for hashing out some of the final details. You've probably already read the fantastic stories over there but if you haven't - do it!
Also, it may be quite obvious from this chapter but if not, I feel I should point out that Lucas is my favourite character both on the show and to write about, hence my habit of unintentionally shifting a lot of the focus onto him. Lumax is also my favourite ship ever. Because of that, I tend to go off on random tangents with details about their smutty activities. There are very few Lumax smut stories so I'll definitely be making them a big focus of this story. (If I stick to my current plan, Chapter 8 will be an insanely smutty Lumax chapter!).
The next chapter shouldn't take me as long to write as this one did. Based on that last part, it should be pretty obvious what it's about!
Anyways, thanks for reading and I'll see you for the next chapter!