Changeling 2.0

chapter 4

A.N

OK guys, this chapter will move a little fast, and will also be where the sex comes in. There will be some pretty intense scenes, right from the beginning, as well as a little bit of filler. This is set about two days before the end of the actual game the three are playing and will lead to the ultimate parings and subsequent conclusion of this fic. Hope you enjoy and please remember to R&R! :)

~Skittles~

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

It had been almost a week and Lucy still had not succeeded in calming Gray down. He refused to believe that her and Natsu had only shared a bed, and not each other in the process. He was constantly at Natsus throat now and she didn't know how to end it. She knew she would have to make a choice soon. Which boy would she choose? At this point she honestly didn't want either. They were both being so dramatic and it was really wearing on her nerves. Getting up from the table she walked right into the middle of the two fighting teens, grabbed a hand from each, and drug them all the way outside, and up to a practice hill.

"OK STOP FIGHTING!" she yelled, as both boys looked on in shock.

"But he started it! He broke the rules! Its all his fault!" whined Gray pointing to the pinkette.

"NOTHING HAPPENED! For gods sake Gray, i'm not a whore! We just SLEPT in the same bed!" screamed Lucy in frustration. "Stop this stupid fighting or ill leave both of you high and dry. I swear ill do it!" she said walking off to her house to sulk.

Lucy had to come up with a plan, she had to do something to make Gray feel better, as much as she hated to admit it, she was starting to like him just as much as she did Natsu. Seeing him so hurt really made her feel bad and she wanted to fix the pain in his eyes. Suddenly, she had an idea. Putting her plan into action would take finesse, but she thought it would be ultimately worth it, so she sat down to use her writing skills to her advantage.

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

Natsu opened his door to find an envelope attached to it. Grabbing it, he returned inside to sit down and read it.

Dearest Natsu,

I know you and Gray are supposed to be picking the dates, and although I have had fun, there is one thing I would like to do. Meet me at my house tonight around seven. You don't have to wear anything special, or bring anything other than yourself. Ill have everything else we need for tonight ready to go at my house. Cant wait to see you tonight firefly.

p.s. Don't tell Gray, this can be our little secret ;)

xoxo,

Lucy

Natsu smiled as he folded the note up and put it in his back pocket. He was really looking forward to a night alone with Lucy again. Especially at her house. He could hardly wait as he looked at the clock, realizing he had about four hours until time for him to head out, he decided to take a Small nap and then shower and get ready.

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

Gray walked to the door, groggy from his afternoon nap. "Whoever the hell woke me up is in for some serious pain!" he mumbled. Opening the door he looked around, he didn't see anyone right off, so he walked off the porch looking up and down the road. Figuring he imagined the knock he turned to walk back to his house, stopping when he saw the white envelope on his front door. He grabbed it and walked back inside, slamming the door and going to his room to read it.

Dearest Gray,

I want to prove to you that Natsu and I didn't do anything the other night. I want to do something special, just the two of us, so I can ease your worries and make up for the last few days. I really like you Gray, so I was wondering if you would come to my house, around seven tonight, so we can have some quiet alone time. Just the two of us. You don't have to wear anything special, or bring anything. I just want to enjoy a night in with you. Cant wait to see you later!

p.s. Don't tell Natsu!

Xoxo,

Lucy

Gray grinned. Looking at the clock he realized he had about an hour before he would have to leave. He grabbed a shower, taking his time to make sure he was extra clean. Grabbing his clothes he walked out of his house so he could stop by the store and get some flowers on the way to Lucy's house.

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

Meanwhile, at Lucy's house

Lucy was just putting the finishing touches on the table, the only thing left was to light the candles and actually serve the food. She had prepared the meal just for both of the boys. There were three place settings, and she prayed her plan would work out. Moving to her room, she picked up the dress she had gone out and bought just for tonight. It was short, barely covering her butt, and so tight she couldn't wear anything under it for fear of showing lines in the smooth fabric. The dress itself was black, with the middle done in a shear fabric that sparkled. It left her back bare, and barely managed to contain he massive breasts. She had bought it for seduction, and she hoped it would make the boys so speechless they would forget to fight.

She slid into the dress, enjoying the feel of the slinky fabric as it pulled across her otherwise unclothed body. She sat down on the edge of her bed, pulling her shoes from beneath it. These were a last minute purchase the shop keeper had talked her into. She had to admit they looked great with the dress, and elongated her legs. After putting them on she fixed her hair, letting it fall in soft ringlets, then put a little bit of makeup on. She looked at the clock, the boys should be here any minute, she thought returning to the living room.

Lucy jumped at the knock on her front door. Getting up, she cringed as she heard both of the boys outside the door. Oh god, maybe this was a mistake she thought. That is, until she opened the door and everything went quiet.

Both boys looked up in shock.

Natsus mouth went dry as he took in Lucy standing before him. He completely forgot about the ice mage next to him as he noticed how short the dress was. She sure was making it hard to keep up the no sex part of this bet. She looked absolutely amazing, and Natsu had drool falling from his mouth in a steady line. Gray was also enamored, catching sight of the heels that encased her legs in some sort of cage that extended until right below her knees. His breaths came out in small puffs as he got immediately aroused.

"Hey guys, go ahead and come in." Lucy said, turning and going back inside. She heard both boys take a deep breath as they got to see just how short the dress actually was. It barely covered her butt, hugging the cheeks tightly, and giving glimpses of more every time she took a step. The boys eagerly followed her to the table.

"Natsu, you go here, Gray over there." she said, positioning them at their respective places at the table. Taking her own seat, she began, "We all need to have a talk... I cant do this anymore guys. Its all too much."

Natsu gave Gray a smug look, figuring Lucy would just let everyone know the two of them were dating so they could be done with Gray.

Gray on the other hand, thought he had finally captured Lucy's heart, and couldn't wait to rub it in Natsus face.

"Don't be so quick to jump to conclusions guys," she said seeing the evil glint in both their eyes. "Now tonight will be the last night of the game, one way or another it will come to an end tonight, but I think I have found a way we can all be happy." Lucy put on a big smile and asked Natsu to light the candles, while gray chilled the bottle of wine she had bought. "I want this to work so please hear me out OK?"

Both boys shook their head in acceptance. Thank you for hearing me out, ill explain everything after our group date tonight OK?" she asked looking at both of them in turn. Nodding they watched as she got up and left to get the food.

"You know shes going to pick me right Gray?"

"Yeah right flame brain, I am clearly the better choice!" Gray said, flexing his now bare chest.

Natsu could do nothing but glare at him as Lucy returned carrying in the food. She gave Natsu his favorite Flaming chicken, while Gray got fried rice. She had roasted chicken. They ate in silence, until the wine started flowing. Lucy had bought five bottles, and one after on they were downed, until the three of them completely forgot about the food and ended up on the couch watching some sappy chick flick while they all giggled. Natsu sat to the left, Gray to the right, and Lucy was in the middle, just how she planned it.

As both boys started drinking more, she started getting more daring. She tentatively reached and grabbed each boys hand under the blanket that had mysteriously appeared in the last hour. Slowly, she pulled each hand to her thighs, respectively and left them there as her hands returned back to their respective guys lap. Both boys tensed, neither knowing the other was mirroring their own actions they just left their hands on her thigh. Slowly they leaned in towards her, still not moving their hands.

Lucy rubbed her hand down Grays bare chest, relishing the way his muscles tensed under her fingers. At the same time she stroked Natsus leg, moving ever upwards in her search for what she really wanted. She spread her legs a bit, almost encouraging the boys to make a move, as both of her hands reached their packages. She quietly slid her hand inside Natsus pants, then Grays, enjoying the feel of them through their boxers. Both boys slid down to give her better access, and she felt her dress roll up some as Grays fingers reached the edge of it.

Lucy stroked the teens through their boxers, feeling each swell up and begin to strain against the thin material. She felt hesitant fingers touching further up her legs. Spreading them more she allowed better access, before withdrawing from both boys and pulling her dress back down.

"That's what I want," she said, looking at the raven headed boy and the pinkette. They both looked confused, until she pulled the blanket back and showed they were both touching her. They immediately pulled away in alarm. "You said you would hear me out, and now is the time boys." she said leaning back into the cushions.

"I really like both of you. The last month has been amazing, other than the two of you fighting more. I enjoy spending time with both of you. Natsu, with his spontaneity, and Gray with his icy calm. I …... I cant choose …... I cant choose between the two of you. So... I …...i want you both. At the same time..." she said, watching for a reaction from either one of the others.

Natsu and Gray looked at each other, then down at their hands, so close yet so far. Looking back up, Natsu thought about how well the three of them had worked together at dinner. Gray thought about how the made a great team on missions. Nodding at each other, they looked at her. Natsu went towards her lips, as Gray headed for her neck. Lucy gasped in shock that the two boys had accepted this so easily, then again in ecstasy as Natsus mouth reached hers.

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

A.N.

OK, I know I said I was going to put a lemon in this chapter, but I feel like it really needs its own chapter to really shine. As you can tell it will be a THREESOME. That means two guys on one girl. If it doesn't interest you, don't read the next chapter. I should have it up later tonight, provided I don't get distracted:)

Lilpurplehood- I want to thank you for reviewing again, I know there will be more chapters, and this might not be the final pairing. Hope you enjoy reading the rest of it!

please read and review, I would love to have some feed back, and the more reviews I get, the more likely ill be to update faster! Hope you enjoyed this little snippet! :)

~Skittles~