Disclaimer: Rachel wouldn't be in this position of my deleted scene made-up story if I owned Glee. Just sayin'.
Rachel was the last to leave the building. She was upset about what had happened that day. She remembered when she heard the news of Finn and Santana, and felt even crummier.
That's right, Yental. You're sweetheart? He's been lying to you because he and I totally got it on last year.
The voices replayed in her head. She was tensing up, her lips frowned and open a bit from the anxiety. She was close to tears. The scenes of that week replayed in her head.
Just tell me if it's true. She had started out the confrontation in front of Miss. Pillsbury this way. They were in her office to try to talk it out.
I'm sorry. Okay, I shouldn't have lied to you. I just if I told you the truth, you'd get so mad at me and…you're kinda scary. His response was true, and she couldn't bear it.
Don't you see how it's ten times worse now? Why her? Quinn I understand, but her? Do you…think she's…prettier than me?
Don't answer that. Miss. Pillsbury jumped in.
Why did you do it with her?
Why are you caught up with who it was?
Rachel was forming tears in her eyes. The scene didn't end there.
Sure, she's super hot… It finally came to an abrupt stop. She continued to walk and their breakup replayed in her head.
There's… something I need to tell you. Last week when we were fighting, I was so mad at you and I was so hurt that I wanted to make you feel as bad as I felt. I made out with Puck. I am so sorry and it will never happen again.
I knew you were a lot of things Rachel, but I loved in spite all of them, but I never thought you were mean.
Saying that I'm sorry and doesn't what you did with Santana kinda cancel this out?
We weren't together! I didn't cheat on you! How could you do this to me?
It was a mistake! Maybe we should go to another counseling session with Miss. Pillsbury.
You can't have couples counseling if you're not a couple. These words had hit her hard.
You're breaking up with me? She couldn't believe it.
What you did was really bad Rachel! And you knew how sensitive I'd be about this after what happened with Quinn! She remembered the words he said when she first mentioned breaking up. She was hurt and betrayed.
You said you'd never break up with me!
I never thought you'd make me feel like this.
Now, today, she all the cheerleaders that she was afraid would take him away all hitting on him in the halls. Her heart still beat for him. She was in pain, and couldn't bear to see her loved one flirting with the girls who made her life literally impossible to live. She continued to walk home. She couldn't tell anyone anywhere. No mom to talk to. She didn't even know where her mom was right now. She no longer coached Vocal Adrenaline. She was with Quinn's bastard baby, and starting a family somewhere in the state. She walked home, bitterly torn and depressed to her core.