Duncan asked Courtney that he wanted to talk with her alone. "Excuse us," he told Lance. They got up and she followed him on the front porch. "What did you all talk about?" Duncan asked her as they sat down. She responded by saying that she mentioned her future goals and the kind of high school she attended which was a school for bright kids. "Your father said if you have difficulties in any subject that I should help you," she added. Duncan had been enrolled in an online high school since returning from Total Drama since Tuesday of that same week. She then said she talked about her two older siblings, Stephanie and Jordan and what their occupations were. "And they showed me those photos on the wall of your grandparents' wearing their police uniform. Your dad also told me that his mom was one of the first women admitted to the police academy."
Meanwhile, As Courtney was talking to Duncan about the conversation she had with his parents, Richard and Jason were sitting on the kitchen counter stools eating ice cream. Jason asked his mother that he wanted to carry some of the food home while she was coming out of the dining room with two empty plates. "Sure, dear," she replied. She put down the plates then walked into the living room and noticed that Duncan and Courtney were gone. Lance told her that they went outside to talk. She returned to the kitchen and asked her sons to help clear the table. "You know Ma, I didn't expect that Duncan would have fallen for Courtney," Richard admitted to Karen. "I thought so too, dear," she replied. "Pity she's not Gwen," she thought resentfully.
Outside, Courtney was ending her discussion with Duncan. "…And your dad said that Jason is the one who wants to become a police officer," she said. He then asked her if she wanted to go to a movie later. She replied, "I'll pass, Duncan, after your mom's wonderful dinner I'd prefer to relax at home." Duncan replied, "That's okay." Then she said, "I don't know why you were so anxious about your father embarrassing you, he's very nice." Duncan replied, "Mom probably told him to be nice." Courtney then said he couldn't be that bad. "Have you lived with him for sixteen years?" Duncan said snidely. "He's always telling me why I won't act normal like my brothers, and….." then trailed off. "Forget it, let's not ruin the rest of the day," he said.
Courtney decided to mention his brothers. "Your brothers are very smart and very polite," she told him. Duncan responded by saying they weren't always studious and used to pull pranks at school and on neighborhood kids. "Then one day, there was some hit list going around their school and their names were on it." Courtney responded in shock, "That's terrible." Duncan revealed that it turned out to be a hoax. "But even though the list was fake they decided to change their ways and started getting better grades," he continued. "Have you talked with your guy friends since the show?" she asked him. "DJ gave me his phone number," Duncan said, "But I didn't ask Geoff for his because he was too busy sucking face with his surfer girlfriend." Courtney replied, "Ugh, they're so disgusting!" Duncan replied, "You said it." It was now 5:32 pm.