Hey guys, here is another chapter. I hope you enjoy it and don't forget to review.
Caroline had been debating if she was going to tell Stefan, she knew that she eventually had to especially now since Samuel had been back and she had no idea what he was going to do. She kept imagining the worst of the situation, what if Stefan didn't want to be with her anymore, but as much as it would suck, she knew it was the right thing to do when it came to keeping Stefan safe. All she had to decide now was when and how she was going to tell him. As Caroline debated all that she got ready for school, but when she was about to leave, she saw Elena.
"What are you doing here, Elena? Caroline asked annoyed.
"Can't I come and see my little sister? I just want to make peace with you, okay." Elena said
"Really?" Caroline said not knowing if it was true or not.
"I'm just kidding. Caroline, I promised you an eternity of misery and that's exactly what you'll get. So little sister I'll see you around and I'll see Stefan as well." Elena said leaving Caroline with more worries than she had before.
Caroline got to school and made her way down the halls, when she got to her locker, she saw Stefan standing there waiting for her. She honestly didn't want to see him because she didn't know how she was going to tell him what he needed to know. She just smiled at him not knowing what to say, so she let him do all the talking.
"Hey, how are you?" Stefan asked smiling.
"Good, I'm just tired. I should get going I have practice right now since we have the game tonight. I'll see you later." Caroline said leaving Stefan by her locker not knowing what else to say. Stefan was confused of what had happened.
Throughout the day Caroline did her best to avoid Stefan, she just couldn't lie to him. She was going to tell him the truth, but she was just afraid of his reaction. When arriving to cheer leading practice she tried to focus on what she had to do but she kept thinking about Stefan. She kept thinking about all the possible outcomes after she told him what she really was and why she had come back to Mystic Falls. After getting through a rough day of practice Caroline made her way to the lockers. When she arrived at the locker room, she saw Stefan, or at least she thought it was him.
"Caroline I was looking for you. Why are you avoiding me? Is it because of him?" he asked.
"What are you talking about?" Caroline asked confused.
"I know about Samuel. Look me in the eyes Caroline." He said looking Caroline straight in the eyes. Caroline knew immediately he wasn't Stefan, it was Samuel. She immediately pushed him and realizing he was pretending to be Stefan.
"What are you doing here?" Caroline asked, her heart racing
"What do you mean. I just came to see the girl I love." Samuel said smirking.
"Leave me alone. Why are you in Mystic Falls? You could've left and gone anywhere you wanted but you decided to come back to Mystic Falls. Why?" Caroline asked
"Because I wanted to see you. You are everything to me. You are the one I really love, not your sister. And I know you love me too." Samuel said.
"My love for you wasn't real, you compelled me to love you." Caroline said
"No Caroline, I compelled you so you wouldn't be afraid of me, but your love was real." Samuel said to Caroline.
"It doesn't matter anyways, I'm with Stefan, he is the one I love. You may look the same, but you are nothing alike. Now leave me alone." Caroline said leaving the locker room.
Caroline didn't know what to do anymore, how was she going to keep Samuel from pretending he was Stefan again. She was just so tired of having to hide things from him. The longer she kept the secret the worst it's going to be when he actually finds out the truth. She needed to tell him soon.
Later that day
It was time for the bonfire and Caroline couldn't focus on anything except on what she was going to tell Stefan. Caroline alongside Bonnie started to cheer for the football team, who according to Bonnie they sucked. After cheering, she started to walk around, thinking about how screwed up everything was. She suddenly heard muffling cries, so she decided to see what it was. The sounds lead her to the back of the locker room, where there was nobody around and dark. She saw Elena feeding on Coach Tanner, by the time she got there Elena had killed him.
"What the hell are you doing?" Caroline asked pushing Elena off the lifeless body.
"What does it look like sister, I'm having lunch." Elena said smirking.
"You can't just go around killing people because you are hungry. There are blood bags for that reason." Caroline said not shocked at her sister's behavior.
"You know I don't like them. I prefer straight from the vein. But you have ruined my meal, so I'll go find another one, maybe Stefan. I bet him blood taste delicious." Elena said
"Leave him out of this." Caroline said getting angry. Elena ignored her and started to walk away. But Caroline used her vampire speed to get in front of her.
"I said leave Stefan out of this. Leave him out of this sick game you are playing." Caroline said in a threatening voice. Elena started laughing and threw Caroline across and made her hit her back on the door of the locker room.
"Caroline don't threaten me. You know what I'm capable of." Elena said angry. Caroline was able to stand up, when she did, she stood in front of Elena.
"I may know what you are capable of, but you don't know what I'll do to protect him. So, I'll say it again, touch him and I will hurt you." Caroline said leaving Elena stunned.
What they didn't know was that Stefan saw them use their vampire abilities. What will Stefan do and how will he react?