When Santana was driving away, the only thing that was running through her head was why she hadn't kissed him earlier. Although it was pretty much a peck, Santana felt something. She decided that she would kiss Jeff again. Maybe instead of a good bye hug, she would give him a good bye kiss. She was sure he would like that as well.
"Santana, I need to talk to you." Sam walked up to Santana the next day. "What do you want?" It was the end of the day and she was on her way to Dalton. The Warblers were very familiar with Santana now and they were more than welcoming. "I'm sorry, San. I'm sorry for calling you a slut and all of those mean names." Sam was apologizing. Santana was thinking that he was apologizing because he just missed the company of the twins on her ribcage. "You should be." Santana continued walking, hoping Sam would just walk away. "Are you still mad?" he asked, walking next to her. "Duh. I'm not forgiving you for a long time." she stopped, turning towards him. "Why? I apologized, I know I made a mistake, I just, I love you, San." Sam begged, taking Santana's hands in his. Santana shrugged, making her way to her car. Why wasn't Sam leaving? "Alright. Thanks for apologizing Sam. Have a nice day." she got in her car, starting the engine. "Santana! Don't drive away. We need to talk. We need to make up." Sam was trying to open her door, but Santana had of course locked it. "We can talk another time, I'm going somewhere." Santana drove away quickly, rolling her eyes. "What a baby." she laughed.
When Santana arrived at Dalton, she walked to the spot where she met the boys each day. Nobody was there. Santana tried calling Jeff, but he wouldn't pick up. She got out her phone and decided to message him.
Jeff, where are you?
She sat down on the ground, waiting patiently for a reply.
Warblers practice.
Santana scoffed, getting up to leave.
You can come if you want.
Santana shrugged, picking up her stuff and walking inside the building. Jeff had shown her where the Warblers meet up one time. She walked to the room, quietly opening the door. All eyes were on her when she walked in. "Uh, hi." she said awkwardly. "Oh, Hey Santana." Most of them smiled or waved at her. Jeff motioned her over to an empty space on the couch. She walked over, sitting down next to him. "This is awkward." she whispered in his ear as Wes and the others kept talking. Jeff nodded, half paying attention to her, the other half more focused on Wes, Blaine, Thad and David.
Eventually they took a break and Santana was able to talk to Jeff. "You could have told me you had practice. I wouldn't have come." she told him. "Well, I wanted you to come." he said. "It feels weird to be here, Jeff. I'm your enemy." As outgoing as Santana was, she could be shy at times. "Don't worry, nobody cares." Jeff seemed to be paying attention to everybody but Santana. "Could you pay attention to me once in a while?" Santana snapped. She wasn't really mad, she was just annoyed. She was in desperate need of a coffee. Santana stood up. "Come on, Jeff. I need a coffee." Jeff grabbed her arm, pulling her back down. "No, you can do that later." Santana got up almost immediately. "Okay, Jeff. You're annoying the hell out of me. What's up?" "Sorry, I'm a little distracted." he said. "Can you be less distracted and more fun?" Santana grabbed her stuff, walking to the door. "I'll be back later…maybe." All Santana wanted was her damn coffee.
Jeff watched Santana walk down the hallway until she was out of sight. "Okay, what song are we going to sing for Santana?" he asked. "We don't have much time, it's got to be something we know." Wes said. "I've got an idea." Kurt said. The Warblers talked for the next few minutes until Santana arrived.
Santana walked in, her coffee in hand, going to go sit back down on the couch. All of the boys were huddled in a group. "Oh, something secretive going on? I get it. I'll just sit back down." Santana sat, trying not to look at them. Music started playing and Santana jumped. The warblers started singing background music when Jeff stepped up to the front. This was the first time he had sung in front of Santana.
I lay down. You're the first thing that pops in my mind, I'm stuck on you.
You're all around. I can still see you with the lights out, lights out.
'Cause I can't sleep tonight, when I can't sleep it's like I'm dreaming.
'Cause I can't sleep tonight, No I can't sleep and you're the reason.
Santana was smiling the whole time. Jeff was cute and he could sing. He was quite a catch for Santana. Santana clapped and smiled when the movie was over. "Bravo!" After they were done, Jeff sat next to Santana. "So, what'd you think?" he asked. She smirked, hugging him. "Not too shabby."
