Chapter 7: Never Should Have Told You
"What are you doing?" I shouted after he let go.
"Look Quinn, I love you, I know you still love me, I don't know why your bothering with Sam, but I'm the guy you belong with" He said, still holding on to my arms.
He leaned in for another kiss, letting go of my arms, but I slapped him.
"Ow, that the hell was that for?" He shouted.
"Puck, I don't love you anymore, I just... I don't, you had the chance to have me, and you blew it, I can't keep waiting for you to change, and now, as soon as I'm happy, you have to say you love me and break my heart again? Why do you keep doing this to me? I'm not just some toy you can play with till you get sick of, you've hurt me so much, and Sam has been a million times better, you have to let me go" I said, crying.
"I..." Was all he said before I ran.
Sam's POV
I couldn't believe what I'd seen. She was kissing him. Him, the guy she said she didn't love anymore. She said she loved me. Why was I so stupid, she probably just wanted to make him jealous.
I walked back into glee club and took my seat, trying to keep the anger inside until I got home. Quinn walked in, her eyes puffy, probably crying of happiness. She tried to smile at me but I looked away.
"Okay kids, I want you to sing a song this week, which expresses exactly how you feel" Mr Schue said. "Like Sam did"
Fantastic, I knew a song that was perfect for how I felt. When the bell rang I walked past Quinn and she followed me.
"Sam, what's wrong?" She said, still making me love her.
"Nothing, I just need to be alone" I said, I didn't want to do anything until I had sung that song, she needed to know what it felt like to have her heart ripped out.
"Oh" She said, not moving when I walked away.
Quinn's POV
I had no idea what was wrong with him. He hadn't called in days, he didn't say hello, and he ignored me. What the hell was wrong?
I was going to ask him after glee club.
"Okay, well we have Sam singing for us today" Mr Schue said. "Take it away Sam"
Once the song started, I realised what he was singing about.
They're on you like a tattoo You punched my lights out Never should have told you that I fell in love
They're watching every move that you make
Your blue eyes were white lies
I thought you were mine for the taking
Now you're free to be the lonely life of the party
Girl you'll see
Let's get one thing straight
You're gonna regret you left me
Cause you turned me right around and threw me down
and now I can't get up
You'll be sorry just you wait and see
But let's get one thing straight
You're gonna regret you left me
I was crying at this point. You puzzle like a jigsaw But now you're my last call Never should have told you that I fell in love
You love me now we don't fit together
I used up my last shot/straw
I thought I would drink you forever
Now you're free to be the lonely life of the party
Girl you'll see
Let's get one thing straight
You're gonna regret you left me
Cause you turned me right around and threw me down
and now I can't get up
You'll be sorry just you wait and see
But let's get one thing straight
You're gonna regret you left me
"Whoa, whoa, Sam!" Mr Schue said. "We here in Glee club, do not sing songs that hurt other people's feelings, I' m going to ask you to skip this week's assignment"
I ran out of the room, holding my mouth as the tears ran down my face.
"Quinn!" Rachel said, running after me.
"Just go Rachel, this is your fault, you told me to go for Sam! Why is it that every boy I fall in love with breaks my heart?" I said, knowing that I was being horrible.
"Quinn, don't be silly, I'm going to find out why the hell he did that" Rachel said, being too smart to take what I said seriously.
I sat down, letting the tears run out of me.
"Quinn?" For a second I thought the male voice might be Sam, but it was Puck.
"Did you do it, is this your fault?" I said.
"No, I didn't do anything to the kid, maybe he realised you belong with me" Puck said.
"No... He knows I love him" I said. "And I don't belong with you"
Sam's POV
As soon as Puck followed her I knew it was time to confront her.
"No... He knows I love him" She said. "And I don't belong with you"
"But babe, we..." He said
"But babe we nothing, I love Sam, I don't love you anymore" She said. "I'm sorry"
I was shocked. Could I really be wrong? What had I done? She'd probably never take me back now. I'd been so horrible.
"Sam Evans, I told you what would happen if you broke Quinn's heart" I heard Rachel say behind me.
"I know... I'm sorry, how can I make it up to her?" I asked.
"You'll have to come up with that by yourself" She said, walking away.