[Flashback]
The brothers were speechless.
"This-this is your father?" Dean asked, shocked after finding his voice. After finding out about Adam, he really shouldn't be surprised. Made him wonder how many kids he had out there.
A thought hit him, he had fought about Adam being his brother but with her, it felt like family.
"Yup!" She said beaming with pride, "See that little scrawny little thing next to him? That's me. It was after my first soft pitch game. We won"
Dean studied the picture and looked up at MJ. "The Pistols?" Dean asked. "Not much of a team name"
MJ let out a laugh and smiled at Dean, who forced himself to return it. "I have a fascination with guns, always have. Dad let me pick the name of the team. Some of the other -"
"What the hell." Sam said with anger after a few minutes, glaring at her and stopping her mid sentence. Knowing full well she didn't deserve it but not caring. John had TWO children he had hidden, both he had taken to games and visited and was a normal dad with. "Really? Soft pitch!? He came to YOUR games? Why are you so special?"
Dean shot him a dirty look that said to shut the hell up, but Sam was hurt and filled with hatred anew for John Winchester. First Adam, now this girl!? John Winchester took better care of random women's kids than he did the ones at home.
MJ furrowed her eyebrows at Sam, not sure where the anger is coming from so she took the picture back from Dean. "Look. I don't know what kind of father you have or why you're taking all your obvious childhood trauma out on me, but I'll find Singer on my own."
She hopped down from the bar stool and walked away.
"Dammit Sam" Dean grumbled, jumping down to run after her while Sam looked at Phil and said "I'm gonna need a shot of your strongest"