Annabeth's POV

Piper, Jason and Ali all burst out laughing. I probably would've too, if I wasn't included in the dare. I look at Percy. Determination fills his eyes, but underneath his mask I see fear. He is vulnerable. Doesn't want to look weak, but also doesn't want to get fucked up the ass with a marker. Not even a regular marker, a really thick one, like the kind they make kindergartners use. Why he has one of those in his cabin, we'll probably never know.

Percy looks back and forth between me, the marker and Leo. "Fine." He whispers, his voice hoarse. He clears his throat. "Fine. Annabeth, let's go." He grabs my arm, and the marker, and leads us to the master bedroom, which is right off of the main room. We sit on the bed and kiss a little, then he takes his pants off. "Please, just get this over with."

I take the marker and put it in my mouth. I swirl it around a little, wetting it and causing Percy to moan. I grin and wink at him. He spreads his legs slightly and closes his eyes, shoving his face into a pile of pillows. I come up behind him and wrap my hand around his dick. I start pumping it quickly.

"Oh my gods Annabeth, that feels soo good!" He moans.

I take the chance and shove the marker into his waiting hole. He gasps really loudly. I thrust it in and out as I rub his cock. Leo flings the door open and everyone rushes into the room, standing around the bed. I hold my fingers up to my lips, motioning for them to stay quiet. I thrust the marker faster and faster, then I lay down and take Percy in my mouth. I suck his dick until he cums, which I swallow. I usher the other people out of the room and close the door, then I remove the marker.

"That wasn't so bad." He frowns a little and pulls on his clothes.

I just nod and lead him back out. He slowly sits, wincing slightly. "Alright, I guess it's my turn."

No one's POV

All eyes turn to Leo. Since Percy had gotten that dare from him, everyone thought that Perce was going to get revenge. Instead, he turns to Ali.

"Truth or Dare."

"Dare."

"C'mere." He whispers in her ear. She frowns a little but then nods. "Fine." She crawls over to Leo and pulls his pants and boxers down. Quickly, she stuffs his member into her mouth. He moans a little and leans back, letting Ali go to work. She sucks him hard and fondles his balls. Ater a little while, she can feel the telltale signs of him nearing his orgasm.

"Shit Ali, I'm gonna.." He moans softly.

Suddenly, Ali jumps up and walks to the other side of the circle, leaving Leo sitting there, his erect dick just hanging there. "Sorry, Leo."

He frowns and pulls his clothes back on, though his erection is obvious. Ali looks to Annabeth, then Piper.

"Annabeth."

Annabeth grins. "Uh, dare."

"I dare you to get ass-fucked, right here, right now, in front of everyone."

The light in Annabeth's eyes fade and she scowls. "By who?"

Ali picks up the bottle that was used for spin the bottle. Annabeth grabs it angrily and sets it on the ground, flinging it in a fast circle. Everyone watches it, every guy silently praying that it lands on them. The bottle slows and eventually stops, pointing right between Piper and Jason.

Annabeth curses a little and stands. "Let's go, Sparky." She grabs his hand.

Jason's POV

I don't know whether to be happy or angry. I get to do anal, but it's not with Piper, but I get to do anal. I shake my head slightly. I can't back down since it wasn't my dare.

Everyone sits against the wall. Annabeth scowls at me but drops to her knees, pulling down my pants and boxers with her. She runs her hands up my thighs and starts to pump my member, causing it to start getting hard. She sucks on my balls a little, sending little jolts of pleasure through my body. Soon enough, my 8 incher is fully erect.
Annabeth drops down, pulling off her skirt and thong. She gets on her hands and knees, spreading her legs slightly. I drop to my knees and grip her thighs. I dip my tongue into her pussy, causing her to moan and shake a little. I run my tongue up and lick around her asshole, wetting it before I push my tongue inside. It's extremely tight. I wiggle my tongue a little, then pull out, inserting a finger. I run my tongue back over her slit, flicking it up and down over her pussy entrance. I thrust my finger in and out of her ass. She moans and shakes with pleasure.

I slowly insert another finger into her tight ass. With my other hand I reach up and rub her clit. I stop licking her and push my tongue inside her pussy. She relaxes a little and makes it easier for my fingers to explore her anus. I flick my tongue around, trying to find her g-spot. I lick around her walls and curl my tongue slightly. She moans loudly and shakes again. There. I thrust roughly with my fingers and flick my tongue, rubbing her sweet spot. I massage quick, rough circles over her clit.

"Shit!" She yells and shakes uncontrollably. Cum flows over my tongue and leaks out of her pussy. I drink it up and empty her holes. I use my hands and spread her ass cheeks, rubbing the tip of my rock-hard dick against her asshole. I carefully push it inside her. She grunts in pain, my dick pushing into her tight ass. It's tighter than anything I've ever felt before. Once my full 8 inches is pushed inside her, I thrust lightly. I reach back down and push two fingers inside her pussy. She arches her back a little.

"F-faster." She says softly. I obey her orders and thrust into her fast, but not too hard. I bend my fingers in a 'come here' gesture and she shivers. I rub them quickly, wanting her to cum again. I grunt and thrust into her, her tight ass feeling so good against my cock. I thrust quicker and harder and she moans in pleasure. Her pussy walls start to contract around my fingers so I move my hips faster, wanting to cum with her.

I slowly swirl my fingers, rubbing them against her g-spot. My dick thrusts in and out of her, my balls making a loud slapping sound. I start to feel an orgasm coming on. I grunt and thrust harder. I move my fingers faster, swirling them quickly. She screams and cums again, liquids dripping out of her pussy. I remove my hand and grasp her hips. I pull her to me, hard, and moan, releasing my cum inside of her tight asshole.

We break apart, panting heavily. Percy and Piper both glare, obviously pissed. I grab a towel and mop up all the cum. We both put our clothes back on and the circle re forms. This time, though, there is a lot more tension.

Lot's of kinky shit. Now Percy and Piper are pissed, do you think they'll try to get back at them? ~TLOO