Me and Dean were going to look more when Lucas ran outside. He went up to a patch of ground which we took as a sign to start digging. We found an old rusty bicycle.
"It must be Peter's." I said.
We turned around and saw the sheriff pointing a gun at us.
"This was Peter Sweeney's bike, wasn't it?" Dean said. Probably not a good idea. "We know that you and Bill Carlton drowned him in the lake."
"Lucas," Andrea said. "Go to the house. Lock all the doors and windows and don't leave until I get back."
"I didn't kill anyone."
"We know it's true, Jake." I said.
"The spirit is going to go after everything you care about and than it will kill you, just like it killed Bill Carlton." Sam added.
"You three are crazy."
"Stop being in denial, Jake!" I yelled. "We need to know where the body it so we can salt and burn it."
Dean looked at me. "Kathy, it would still be in the lake."
"Damn."
"Dad, is this true?" Andrea asked. "Did you kill someone?"
"No!"
"Dad, Christopher died down there and something tried to kill me."
"I... I admit it. It was a game gone wrong and we accidentally killed Peter. But that does not mean that this is Peter trying to get revenge."
"You still need to leave the lake." Sam said.
We were walking back when we saw Lucas at the lake trying to get something in the water.
"Lucas, no!" We ran to to water and saw a disgusting, gray arm pull him in."
"Lucas!" Andrea was freaking out. I jumped into the lake to get Lucas and Sam and Dean followed. When I pulled up my head to breath I saw Jake jump in. He was begging Peter for forgiveness. Funny, how someone needs to get hurt before them to see what's right in front of their eyes...
"Please, take me instead, just don't hurt my grandson!" He shouted. Peter quickly complied and dragged him under.
"No!" I shouted.
Sam and I dove out of the water when we saw Andrea screaming. I calmed her down and was about to go back in when Dean came up with Lucas in his arms.
We were getting into the Impala, ready to leave Lake Manitoc.
"We can't save everyone." Sam tells Dean, who is upset about the death of the sheriff.
Andrea ran over with Lucas.
"We brought you guys lunch." Andrea said.
"Here." Lucas said as he handed us the food. I was surprised, and it was probably written all over my face, because Sam laughed.
Dean takes the plate.
"We're really sorry about your dad." I said.
"It'll be hard." Andrea said. "But you saved my son, and I can't ask for more than that. I know that he loved me and Lucas."
After Dean puts the sandwiches in the car he bent down to Lucas. "Bye kid. Remember what I taught you?"
"Zeppelin rules!" Lucas said. I laughed. I laughed even harder when I saw Dean's embarrassment when Andrea kissed his cheek. Dean gave me a dirty look.
"We need to leave before we run out of daylight."
Lucas and Andrea waved as we drove away.
